It reminds me of the mortgage backed securities fraud. "You cannot criticize these complex financial derivatives, they were created by MIT PhDs."
Wealth isn’t denominated in currency - price is an exchange rate to another system of faith.
Value is the length people will go to acquire an asset. Utility is only one dimension. And true utility is arguably far less important than perceived utility. Being convinced something like gold has intrinsic utility that justifies its current exchange rate is sufficient to carry the current price regardless of whether that belief is based in reality.
For an otherwise useless digital token which can only be held or exchanged, its price would seem to be pretty relevant when discussing its value as it literally only has exchange value and no utility.
I would agree that perceived value is more important than real value, but it is risky to place bets on there being a big difference between the two for a long time.
I’m saying it’s a rhetorical crutch that doesn’t lead to meaningful discussion or insight.
If people acknowledged in these threads that “value” is way more complex and nebulous than these facile comparisons make it out to be, we’d have more interesting discussion.