As an old time gamer I can't agree more. We are in the golden age of old-style games (hollow knight, disco elysium, stardew valley, etc). People are making this old style games with all the hindsight of modernized mechanics, better control schemes, more accessibility, stylized graphics, PC releases.
As the other poster said, plenty of people play Hallow Knight without taking notes. For people who do want notes or use a wiki, it's often for fairly simple things, like trying to remember exactly where a closed door was.
This is quite different from a game like Myst, where most agree note taking is a necessity (I believe the box came with a notebook). For people who haven't played it, imagine 5 or 6 escape rooms linked together, with clues spread throughout, so the first thing you look at in the first room might be something you need to solve a puzzle in the last.
Likewise, the impact of the two games is different. Hollow Knight is a popular indie game, but it's still sold a fraction of the copies that AAA games do. Myst, on the other hand was the top selling computer game for _years_. Often people who never bought any other computer game bought a copy of the game.
Cyan still makes games, but they're niche games that don't have anything like the cultural impact that Myst had.
Likewise, I don't think Majora's Mask should really be compared to games with forward moving time mechanics. It has a time mechanic, but it's basically on a repeating hour schedule. If you miss something, you can just come back to the cycle again.
This is the opposite of games with real time mechanics (time measured in actions - "real action time"?) like The Colonel's Bequest or The Last Express, because the latter games decidedly _don't_ repeat. If you miss an event in the game, it's gone (granted, Titanic isn't quite at that level). Though I suppose such games have always been a bit rare.
I don't really understand most of the other stuff; yes, some games have slightly more punishing implementations of mechanics than others (Dead Rising uses the real-time forward-only approach). I named some high profile examples which are in the approximate orbit of what was discussed. It can't possibly be the article's thesis that minor variation between two games implementing a quasi real-time progression gate constitutes a major arc in the history of narrative gaming.
> The article mentions unnamed youngsters not liking the real-ish time mechanics of Titanic Adventure Out of Time, or the difficulty of the puzzles, feeling that they're too punishing. I doubt it
But none of your examples are particularly recent, except arguably Final Fantasy XIII-3. Recent games with a strict timer are rare, and when they exist -- like the recent indie metroidvania Unsighted -- they get a lot of criticism for it. As for difficult puzzles, well, are there any non-indie games with difficult puzzles in recent history? Sure, such games continue to get made, but they're fairly niche.
> Hollow Knight is maybe the most critically acclaimed indie game of all time and most people play it with a fan wiki open
I don't know how many people play Hollow Knight while constantly consulting a guide, but if they do, it doesn't imply an appetite for taking notes while playing games. If I'd had to take notes while playing Hollow Knight (and I did not, though I did consult a guide a couple times) I wouldn't have enjoyed it nearly as much as I did. I don't know anyone who takes notes playing games. Heck, I don't remember who it was off the top of my head, but recently a journalist caught a bunch of flack when he suggested taking notes while playing Elden Ring.
> Point and click adventures are still quite popular
The graphical point-and-click adventure is nowhere near as popular, in relative terms, as it used to be. They do get made, but mostly by indies with small budgets and small audiences. I also don't think Return of the Obra Dinn is a great example, but maybe I'm too rigid in what I think a point-and-click adventure is.
All that is to say ... it's no surprise that difficult or otherwise challenging games survive to this day; the sheer size of the market means that niche audiences can have their needs met. But a game like Monkey Island couldn't be made today and expect to be the kind of juggernaut it once was.
I'm not saying that these mechanics don't have detractors now, just as they had detractors then. I'm saying there isn't really a generational gap that would make me believe that kids these days wouldn't have a similar reaction to it as people did back then, and the evidence for this is that lots of minor variations of this kind of mechanic exist and mostly it's been in games that do pretty well.
In Hollow Knight, the use of a fan wiki is less about notes in the adventure game sense and more about optimizing builds, reading about lore, checking quest solutions, and looking up boss strategies. It's possible that some unspecified journalist made some unspecified remark about taking notes while playing Elden Ring and some unspecified Twitter demons gave him some unspecified grief about it. And yet, a huge number of people who play Elden Ring do it with a wiki open. Fandom has raised something like $100,000,000 in VC and its primary business model is being a wiki for video games; it's almost entirely supplanted traditional FAQs.
There are of course games that require more traditional "stuff I learned" notes these days, a prime example is The Outer Wilds (> 1 million sales on Steam despite a one year late release, Overwhelmingly Positive reviews, probably my favourite game of the 21st century, Adventure Gamers Game of the Year 2019 so let's sidestep whether you think it's an adventure game please). You might also think about Stardew Valley (20 million+ copies sold, is played almost entirely with Wiki lookups) or Minecraft (300 million copies, has a thriving ecosystem of secondary information and content, including videos, wikis, etc.) What would convince you that there is still a demand for games that require or encourage the use of supplementary information and thinking?
As to team size, point and click adventures don't require the budget of an open world game like Red Dead Redemption 2. About 15 people are credited on Myst. About 20-25 on Secret of Monkey Island. Tons of PnCs today have much larger budgets and larger team sizes than they ever did. The fact that the market also sustains an Asssassin's Creed game made by 2500 people over 3 years doesn't take away from the space for creative adventure games. The relative terms framing is just bonkers. James Cameron has half-billion dollar budget films, but Parasite still exists.
Monkey Island was never a juggernaut. The US sales in the first two years were about 100,000 copies. You don't think Monkey Island could be made today and sell 100,000 copies in the US? Thimbleweed Park (2017, Ron Gilbert) is well over 100,000 copies in the US across platforms. Broken Age is around 100,000 copies on Steam. The Witness over 500k on Steam. Inscryption is over a million on Steam, and that just launched 9 months ago. Papers Please around 2 million on Steam. Agent A, which is I think 3 people in a flash-style animation, is coming up on 100k on Steam. The Grim Fandango re-release is coming on the game's entire original sales run. Phoenix Wright in the 500k range. Gorogoa in the 500k range. The Room around a million units. Granted you can play with the numbers -- lifetime versus first few years sales, discounting, countries of availability, upfront MSRP, availability of console ports versus just PC, whatever. My point isn't to prove all these games outsold Monkey Island, it's to suggest I don't see the apparently cavernous collapsed alleged in demand for PnCs.
It's true that nothing is Myst anymore, but nothing was Myst back then either. PnCs are alive and well.
The loop version of the time mechanic, where you're intended to loop back around and not expected to win the game in a certain amount of time, is much more forgiving than a strict timer mechanic. I guess I don't see the existence of looping games as an indication that younger gamers have an appetite for difficult or obtuse mechanics that used to be more common.
Further, all of those games except Deathloop are not particularly mainstream. Yes, they may have sold a million copies, but it's important to keep in mind that the size of the prize is much greater than it was thirty years ago. There are 160M total gamers in the US alone right now; whereas when I was a kid in the 80s basically no adults played video games, and not every kid did, either. It's not surprising to me that a million people enjoyed a weird mechanic when the number of gamers in the world might number in the billions.
> You don't think Monkey Island could be made today and sell 100,000 copies in the US?
You're selling 100,000 copies short -- that's a fairly large number that many indies would be more than happy with. Regardless, I'm not sure Monkey Island could sell as well, if it were a new property and not backed by an established company. Can you give me examples of point-and-clicks released recently that sold so well? And I mean true point-and-clicks -- Lucas Arts or Sierra style inventory puzzle games. Double Fine released one in 2014 (Broken Age), which I think barely broke even sales-wise. That's the closest I can think of off the top of my head. All the others I've played in the past few years haven't been mainstream games.
> PnCs are alive and well.
I never said they weren't. They're just not mainstream in any way. Most younger people aren't going to be playing them. My nieces and nephews wouldn't know what to do with one, frankly.
> In Hollow Knight, the use of a fan wiki is less about notes in the adventure game sense and more about optimizing builds, reading about lore, checking quest solutions, and looking up boss strategies.
I'm not sure how important this is. It doesn't necessarily comport with my experience with Hollow Knight in particular, but regardless, the fact that people are willing to look things up doesn't seem to say anything important about how likely younger people are to engage with difficult or unforgiving mechanics. When things are difficult people might have to look something up, sure, but that doesn't mean they want to have to look things up. When I did look something up for Hollow Knight it was because I was stuck; I would've hated having to alt-tab out to a fan wiki every ninety seconds to look up tips and tricks and walkthroughs.
Nintendo had mostly gotten away with not needing it up until then because of the flat shading of their 3D cartoon look for most games. Goldeneye and later Turok suffered from this especially in the level design mapping.
Overall though, you nailed it.
Also, one of the best point and click puzzle games of all time, Myst, was kinda a UX disaster. Kids would spend hours just staring at some 3D rendered scene without knowing what was going on. People figured it out. Puzzles with difficulty have been a part of gaming ever since.
The blurriness on the N64 was down to the hardware requiring each texture fit into a 4KB cache (and games using low resolution video output to control pixel fill-rate).
The texture unit on the N64 is really powerful but the 4KB size limit and additional usage restrictions leads to its signature look:
- If you want texture repeats/wraps/clamps the texture dimensions must be power of 2.
- If you want mip-maps then you halve the size of the most detailed texture mip.
- If you want detail textures then you halve again (I think, bit fuzzy on that mode).
- If you want to use a color lookup (from 4 or 8bit pixel values) then the LUT takes 2 of your 4KB, even for 4bit pixels.
Most of the pixel formats have options for 1 or 4 bits of transparency, but transparent pixels render at half speed (and the alpha bits further eat into your 4KB limit).
For something like Goldeneye you are likely going to use as many 4 or 8bit mip-mapped, repeating, greyscale textures as possible (64x64 or 64x32) and use vertex tinting to add color. Everything will look a little monochromatic but you will be controlling blurriness as best you can!
On early 3d games the art team would spend enormous amounts of time hand tweaking individual pixels and carefully specifying texture formats per texture in order to get the most detail out of the available resolution. It wasn't all bad though, they had a couple orders of magnitude fewer textures to produce (than a current generation game) and their polygon counts were 2-3 orders of magnitude lower too!
I dunno, I think the Langoliers are still creepy. Yeah, a little low poly—but they got it where it counts.
Uncanny CG kinda fits the mood of Steven King anyway. I feel the technical limitations played to the advantage of the movie. Could you make an even creepier langolier today? Sure, but I feel like this train criticizes art because of the tools available.
1930s films did "shoot in HD". Most films were either 16mm or 35mm, both of which have more than enough fidelity to represent video at 1080p or higher without loss of quality. Here's a copy of Wizard of Oz on 4K UHD: https://www.amazon.com/Wizard-Oz-Limited-Anniversary-Collect...
A more realistic take is could you criticize 1920s films for not shooting with sound, and the answer is yes, absolutely. Films went from almost entirely silent to almost entirely talkies in roughly 3 years because of massive, unprecedented, and immediate commercial pressure to do so. Audiences ate up even mediocre talkies and shunned silent works now considered classics. The only reason colour film adoption wasn't similarly fast was because of Technicolor's monopoly.
Flash forward to the 1990s, where cinema as a medium was very sophisticated. Now look at blockbusters beginning to use CG rather than animatronics. The airplane in Air Force One. Jar Jar Binks in Phantom Menace. Hell, take the 1997 re-releases of the Star Wars trilogy which inexplicably added garbage like CG Jabba the Hutt. The purple stuff in The Langoliers. Even going back to Lord of the Rings, even going back to the Hobbit, even going back to "early" Marvel films there are tons of moments where CG is jarring. The Polar Express -- an excellent and heartwarming Zemeckis film -- is mostly known because no one likes the dead-eye CG. Yes, absolutely, technical barriers have affected peoples enjoyment of film and still do!
In video games the most obvious period of time that is conspicuously a donut hole is the Playstation 1 / early 3D era. The PS1s 3d games featured really quite nauseating affine texture warping due to a lack of hardware correction support. Here's one video of many talking about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8TO-nrUtSI Early 3d controls are atrocious -- the "tank controls" of Resident Evil are famous for this -- because controllers initially didn't have analogue sticks and when they did, they didn't yet have basic paradigms around how to best use them. The Nintendo 64 was built around analogue control, which is why Mario 64 works so well, and yet it has a completely rotten camera system because there's only a single analogue stick and the c-buttons aren't a good substitute. And that's the PS1/N64. If you go back to the earlier era of 3D, especially on the Super Nintendo, you find low framerate, awkward controlling messes with flat polygon shading. Try playing an unmodified copy of StarFox or Stunt Race FX, I dare you.
No one is saying to throw Casablanca out with the bathwater, just as no one is going to throw Super Mario Bros, out with the bathwater. I'm not saying that technical issues mean we should never play old games or watch old movies. I'm saying that it shouldn't be surprising that people do count technical issues as part of the reason why they prefer newer stuff.
I also think the article misses widely when it pretends that "old ways" of making games don't exist today. Games are made in now-dead genres, with now-dead mechanics, all the time. They have commercial budgets at least as large as they ever did and large, warm communities. In many cases, the original teams working on games in the 1980s and 1990s still make games. I can't find an example in the article where you can't find similar games to play today.
The article mentions that isometric games would be anathema today. Disco Elysium is one of the most acclaimed games of the last few years. Wasteland has two recent sequels, both well liked. Hades is also one of the most acclaimed games of the last few years. Age of Empires IV retains a basically isometric perspective for an RTS. Diablo Immortal just launched and Diablo 4 is coming. Huh?
The article mentions unnamed youngsters not liking the real-ish time mechanics of Titanic Adventure Out of Time, or the difficulty of the puzzles, feeling that they're too punishing. I doubt it. Majora's Mask (1999) is considered an excellent Zelda because of its time mechanics. Dead Rising (2006) was one of the first major hits of the HD era of video games and it's on a fixed timer. Final Fantasy XIII-3 (2013) uses a similar mechanic, and while the game is often criticized for being terribly written nonsense, it's not because of the mechanic.
Or if not the time mechanic, then needing to take notes? Hollow Knight is maybe the most critically acclaimed indie game of all time and most people play it with a fan wiki open, to say nothing of From Software (Dark Souls, Elden Ring) suddenly becoming the apex of prestige developer. Point and click adventures are still quite popular: The Return of the Obra Dinn is widely considered among the best games of the 2010s.
The article claims unnamed gamers today are reacting negatively to the visual choices of the new Monkey Island. This just seems entirely untrue. The reaction across the internet, including on gaming forums, reddit, and here, was overwhelmingly positive. A few people said "okay, this style reminds me a bit of the not-great LucasArts Singapore modernizations of the first few Monkey Islands". This does not presage a great backlash against the game, it's just people shooting from the hip, the vast majority of anyone who cares to comment is excited even if they have concerns about the visuals. And anyway, 99% of the people commenting are greybeards like the rest of us, not young people.
Overall I can't find much here that resonates with me.