1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhutanese_refugees
2. https://worldhappiness.report/ed/2022/happiness-benevolence-...
Here's a very troubling example that is happening right now:
Denmark is currently deporting back to syria all of its syrian refugees. They revoked their residency almost overnight and declared that Syria is now safe even if the Civil war is far from over. Considering that the groups that those refugees originally escaped from are still in power (whether it's Assad or the islamists), it basically means certain death for a lot of them (even those lucky enough to avoid reprisals will probably end up forcibly conscripted). They also argue that Damascus is completely safe for refugees who specifically escaped the syrian government security services (gestapo lite)... because that same government is now fully in control and has pacified the entire region.
>In 2019, the Danish prime minister declared that Denmark wanted ‘zero asylum seekers’. That was a really strong signal* >That's really good news," Mr Tesfaye said in February. "Corona, of course, plays a role, but I think first and foremost, it's because of our strict foreign policy. Many of those who come here do not need protection at all." >The government has set a target of zero, arguing that the money saved can go towards welfare[0]
The most troubling part is that all of this is happening under a "moderate" left wing government with pretty wide support and little to no actual backlash. So yeah, I'd be hesitant to use nordic countries as a model for everything. It's a lot of tradeoffs and the welfare state can be sweet for some, but I know that personally as a muslim I'd much rather live elsewhere
This is silly. The US didn't take remotely close to the same amount of refugees per capita in the first place. They just let them die at the border instead.
> all of its syrian refugees.
I'm glad you brought up this topic, but saying "all" is quite an exaggeration, although that doesn't make it any less horrible.
It’s hard to communicate bad stuff can be bad without it being WWIII kinds of bad. Imagine time traveling before the pandemic to your younger self in say late 2018 and describing what’s going to happen in detail, in such a way that your younger self feels the same way about it as you do right now.
It will be a serious problem that will take big efforts to solve, but on a civilizational level, it will be much more of an inconvenience than a disaster.
>"Everything seems to say..."
What I just wrote above doesn't go viral or generate millions of clicks. For that you need predictions of epic disaster. So epic disaster stories are what go viral, show up everywhere, makes it easy to conclude that "everything seems to say" that.
If you’re thinking of nukes, we had New START, SALT, NPT, etc. and a shit ton of activism which significantly reduced the threat.
If you’re thinking of past claims that we’re “past the point of no return” for climate change, those claims were correct. We passed the point of no return for avoiding extreme weather due to climate change. Then we passed the point of no return for 1C of warming. Now we are nearing the point of no return for 1.5C of warming. Things are getting worse for the climate, which is why people keep saying that things are getting worse for the climate.
That said, apathy is counterproductive. We need hopeful children and adults to drive political and technological change. Therapy or other tools for reducing anxiety (e.g. exercise) could help people be hopeful.
That is not to say that ALL predictions are necessarily wrong, but enough to be wary of the fear mongering. Especially since dramatic predictions probably yield more government money.
Uh, really? There are any number of natural disasters that have been made many times worse by climate change, but ignorance is bliss I guess...
It can be compared to, "How many times can we change the solar system model before it's reasonable to be doubtful of the message? I think there have been at least 4 changes in what we believe to be the center of our universe in my rather short lifetime and there's always a new proposed center after each one is proven false."
It is a science. It is scientifically proven that the damage we have done to our climate is going to eventually cause very bad consequences. The only question is when, which is very difficult to pin down with constantly changing conditions. It's like trying to identify when the next tornado will hit. You don't know precisely when, you might have some false positives, but you know it will happen. You don't get to say, "Well this is the fifth time the meteorologist has told me to evacuate, I have reason to believe this is politically motivated".
The house is made of cards, and there are people running around trying collect more cards than everyone else - even when those are at the base. Meanwhile, someones turned up the AC at one end of the house and the heater at the other, and we've got weird air currents blowing every which way.
On top of all that, we're stuck in a two party system where one does nothing, and one is actively malicious, and has the Supreme Court on the verge of tearing down a ruling which has been the basis of a massive number of other extremely important rulings.
Don't tell me everything is fine.
> So you don’t remember 9/11
Correct, I don't remember the actual event. Just observed the trauma and fear that it inflicted, as most people of voting age at the time rallied to work together and... decrease our rights and blow up brown people.
And the terror, on everyone's face when they talked about it.
The videos in school where we watched clips of it happen, again and again, each year.
So no, I don't remember it live, but that was in response to the "you've _lived_ through" portion of the above comment, or I would've skipped it anyways.
> and were being raised in a two parent household during the housing crash
Ha. I'm not going into detail here on that aspect of my life, but you're laughable here.
> while a “war” (actually an occupation of two countries) you were totally disconnected from went on overseas?
Legally still a war, resulting in perpetuation of PATRIOT et al.
> And you were going to school all through this after when school shootings actually shocked the nation?
"Haha, your generation and everyone else has become desensitized to the fact that every few months some lunatic shoots up a school/nightclub/party/$EVENT"
... yes, that's literally the point.
> And you still didn’t learn that it’s spelled Capitol?
That one's on me. Guess I shouldn't HN late at night after work/school.
> And you think that we’re closer to nuclear war now than we were in the 00s and 90s (sorry, that’s unfair: you don’t even remember the 90s)?
Based on my analysis of everyone's reactions around me? Yes. Based on the fact that there's a cancer-ridden egomaniac in charge of one of the worlds largest nuclear arsenals, and he seems determined to win at all costs? Yes.
If I'm wrong I'd love to be corrected, but the only evidence you've provided are ad hominem attacks.
> All while living in an era of expanded “human rights” from the very political establishments that you apparently now think are going to destroy society?
/me facepalms
That's the point. That's the freaking point. People made progress, and now there are people in positions of power actively trying to undo said progress.
I have listened to some of these talking heads call me a demon, ask "when do we start using the guns?", say I deserve to die.
And yet they keep getting more powerful.
> Sorry, but your generation has never known adversity until 2020 and you grew up in one of the most peaceful times in human history. You’re part of the touchscreen generation. You’re a Zoomer. Even your generation’s name is soft.
Ad hominem, [citation required], ad hominem, ad hominem.
> The “once in a lifetime” events you hear about are clickbait.
Tell me, was 9/11 not once in a lifetime? (again, remember that this was in response to events that people my age and older have lived through). Has Covid not been "reasonably" described as "once in a lifetime"? I know a lot of people described the 2008 recession as "once in a lifetime"? Was the mob on Jan 6 not "Once in a lifetime"? Would the Ukraine war not have qualified as "once in a lifetime" two decades ago? People have finally stopped using the term except as a "lol, yet another 'once in a lifetime' experience".
The point is as much when my generation is coming of age as when we're raised. Half of us see no possible way to improve our standard of living - self improvement is hard when you need two or three full time jobs to survive.
The Jan 6 riot and BLM riots were not very deadly. In the old days, riotous mobs would literally go around murdering people. A few hours of rioting would mean hundreds dead. The 2020 riots were nothing like that. In the 60s, radical leftist groups were regularly bombing American cities. Get some perspective.
The Ukraine war is notable, but only because Europe has been relatively peaceful as a whole. But don’t forget the Yugoslav wars, the Soviet occupation of Eastern Europe, and that war in Europe has historically been a very common thing. What’s unusual is the relative peace that Europe is still enjoying due to post-WW2 American hegemony.
Mass shootings, as in a gunman mowing down multiple random people, are rounding errors in terms of total murders. (Beware of stats, which include gang executions and such in the mass shooting number). Murder rates in some of the big cities are nearing historic highs, but unless you’re involved in gang life or live in the hood, you’re very unlikely to be affected. The overall murder rate is still lower than the 70s and 80s.
I think there’s plenty to worry about still. One way our time is exceptional is how eagerly we are discarding traditional morality and social hierarchy. And pop culture promotes awful decisions around sex and drugs and family. Racial and sexual resentment are reaching fever pitch. Crime is trending up. American hegemony is waning.
But please, remember that the news on tv or twitter can’t literally jump out of the screen and kill you. People have survived and even thrived in much harder times than now. You are among the most fortunate people in history, with access to education and information that people couldn’t even dream about a century ago. Skilled workers are still in high demand. Engineers and doctors and lawyers are paid more than ever. Even the poor have access to better food and creature comforts than a king in times of old. The state will watch your kids five days a week for seven to nine hours a day, for free. If you’re frugal, you can eat enough to get fat for less than $5 a day.
This Reddit hivemind woe-is-us stuff is the result of tunnel vision for whatever the media hyped current thing is.
>>Tell me, was 9/11 not once in a lifetime? (again, remember that this was in response to events that people my age and older have lived through). Has Covid not been "reasonably" described as "once in a lifetime"? I know a lot of people described the 2008 recession as "once in a lifetime"? Was the mob on Jan 6 not "Once in a lifetime"? Would the Ukraine war not have qualified as "once in a lifetime" two decades ago? People have finally stopped using the term except as a "lol, yet another 'once in a lifetime' experience". The point is as much when my generation is coming of age as when we're raised. Half of us see no possible way to improve our standard of living - self improvement is hard when you need two or three full time jobs to survive.
9/11 was not a once in a lifetime event. Oklahoma City was bombed just 6 years prior by a domestic terrorist, so terrorism isn’t new. Someone flew a plane into an NYC skyscraper back in the 40s. The combination of planes and terrorism may have been novel, but hardly “once in a lifetime.” People probably died in the 9/11 attacks that had perpetrated their own version of terrorism overseas (recognizing that “terrorism” is subjective) in Vietnam, Korea, Iraq, or any other number of other countries.
The war in Ukraine is hardly once in a lifetime. There is almost always a war going on in Europe historically, and prior the the Ukraine war there was the annexation of Crimea, the fallout from the USSR’s dissolution, the constant problems in the Near East, the Bosnian-Serbian problems, etc etc etc etc.
Even Covid the disease was not a once in a lifetime event. The once in a lifetime event with Covid is our response and collective hysteria. Prior to Covid there was SARS, AIDS, avian flu, swine flu, etc etc etc. but we didn’t freak out about these problems.
January 6 is also not a once in a lifetime event. The country rumbles on in spite of a bunch of morons protesting. That’s happened constantly for our country’s history: people get mad, people protest, sometimes people burn stuff down, and the country moves on. Sometimes we use these types of events to take away people’s civil liberties, and it looks like this will be another one of them if certain political parties get their way.
And yeah, people have stopped using the term except as a joke because that’s what it is. It’s clickbait. It must be tough to realize you’ve been manipulated by advanced clickbait algorithms for most of your adult life into thinking that the world is The Worst It’s Ever Been and that you’re in The Most Important Time of All Time.
PS - you post on hn, so I find it statistically unlikely that you see no possible way to improve your standard of living in one of the most juiced job markets of all time for intellectual white collar jobs. If you can’t improve your standard of living on a tech salary then it’s because you’re already living at a standard so high above everyone else in the world’s that you’ve lost perspective.
> you post on hn, so I find it statistically unlikely that you see no possible way to improve your standard of living in one of the most juiced job markets of all time for intellectual white collar jobs.
Is correct. I was referring to many other people I went to high-school with, as well as others I know in my age group. You'll note that I stated half of us, I should've noted that I was not included in that half.
The Great Depression happened during the interwar period.
I have seen it a lot more of "why even try because our quality of life is going into the toilet" and less of "we are all going to die"
Not sure how active for example "Fridays For Future" is in your country?
Relentless propaganda: if you have kids in school, odds are any event they plan will be littered with climate change stuff, for example. My kids school decided cakes for the next event will have to be vegan because it is better for the climate, for example. Science projects will be about climate something. And that is just school, media is on a whole other level.
The only thing more popular atm is the transgender craze.
I didn't even make such references, but your snark claiming renewable energy couldn't possibly have ulterior motives makes no sense.
It is also not a given that it reduces pollution. Until very recently, solar panels cost more energy to make than they would yield. I've hear claims it is different now, but I can not yet buy a solar panel for my house that would make economic sense. That seems odd, because if they would yield a net win in energy, it should be available to buy.
In my country they will now also cut down a historic wood to make space for wind power.
Hydrological dams are also famous for wrecking havoc with ecosystems.
Most ecological issues that are attributed to climate change these days are actually caused by humans destroying nature directly - cutting down woods, eliminating safe spaces for animals and insects, messing with rivers, building cities that let the ground sack into the see, stuff like that.
As for economic development I think the past few years have shown us very well (though whether or not people want to hear the message will remain to be seen) is that optimizing for economic growth and development (namely GDP) means you're not optimizing for things like redundancy and resilience and stability. Growth for growth's sake is the ideology of a cancer cell; it doesn't have to be ours. How many more "once in a lifetime" economic crisis do we get before we take that to heart?
If 10% to 21% of kids had some sort of minor physical aliment we wouldn't be content to just treat it and not question why it is happening.
It's almost like the article should highlight the need for prevention as well as screening which (checks) it does.
Teenagers are supposed to be awkward and feel anxiety, amongst endless other emotions in excess. It's a normal part of growing into an adult.
Take away the act of learning how to deal with all this new emotion, and emotional intensity, and a human's growth will be stunted.
Most children are not teenagers.
> Teenagers are supposed to be awkward and feel anxiety
Diagnosable anxiety is not “feeling anxiety” in the common sense any more than diagnosable depression is “feeling sad”.
> Take away the act of learning how to deal with all this new emotion
No one, ever, has argued for that. Where treatment is required for childhood anxiety, talk therapy — often CBT — seems to me the first-line treatment. Which is exactly learning how to recognize and deal with problematic feelings.
However, space needs to be provided to do that growth safely, and in order to that there would need to be massive changes in Sign-up-for-everything parenting culture, A's-or-die school culture, and a myriad of other things in order for this to work. As it is, this culture takes the fire and throws gasoline on it, preventing healthy growth.
Even outside of that, there is a balance to be struck - while some amount of anxiety/awkwardness is expected, if it leads to suicidal thoughts, self harm, lashing out at others, or other destructive behavior, it has gone to far.
bhutan's an absolute autocratic kingdom, it's just that the king is oxford-educated and does a lot of the usual enlightened monarchy stuff and seems a decent enough man. if his son is a little shit or he gets a stroke or something, that all goes down the toilet
I envy countries that focus on Gross National Happiness vs GDP.