The biggest declines in enrollments are at community colleges and state schools. Also counter intuitively when a college lowers their listed tuition to offer more transparent pricing they almost see an enrollment decline.
The difference between 50k, 60k, 70k, 80k per year is almost irrelevant to the students if they are able to secure a gurnanteed government loan.
Schools and loan folks have skin in the game so I can understand why they are pushing for more high priced loans.
Why aren't school guidance counselors and school programs better preparing people? We should be taking a hard look at that.
It's no wonder many young people have no idea what a burden debt can be.
No, I didn't went to military college, sadly, and now that I am properly independent and could do that in theory, I am over the age limit.
I am now debt free, but paying debts took a huge chunk of my life and set me back a lot, I married way later than I planned, got back to my sport way later than planned too and so on. (it took me 16 years to be able to rejoin my old team! now I am horribly out of shape and struggling to get back in shape).
in any market, there are broadly only two competitive strategies, cost or differentiation, and cost no longer matters when money is "free".
Are you only speaking of public universities? I worked at an expensive, private, liberal arts, non-profit college, where I witnessed revolting inefficiency. Do such schools receive _significant_ state funding? Any?
One example of the waste I witnessed: at the end of the financial year, the student services departments where I worked would blow whatever money remained in their budget on frivolous, needless things, because if they didn't spend it, it went back into the college's budget. This mostly changed after the 2008 financial crisis, (I think?) but that's how it was for a long, long time. All staff were complicit, and knew what they were doing. These departments were given executive privileges with very little oversight of expenditure or outcomes. The corruption was surreal.
Another dynamic that I never see mentioned: in a small college town, the hiring pool is challenging, and the college jobs are the high-status local jobs. I witnessed, on several occasions, needless positions being opened for people who were basically friends of staff, so they could have one of the "college jobs".
When I hear students discussing college debt, and I remember these and other examples, it makes me a bit sick.
The problem is that in an effort to avoid being wasteful, the bureaucracy aggressively tracks money spent, and forces a return of unused funds. This in turn disincentivizes saving because there is literally no benefit to spending efficiently or saving money for rough times, because those short term savings are immediately vacuumed back up by the higher level bureacracy.
Blaming student services departments for overspending is missing the root of the problem. I've seen the exact same issues in STEM research institutions.
I worked in a Student Services office for 15 years, but I suspect this happens all over the place.
I also suspect that much of this changed after the 2008 financial crisis, as universities suddenly had to match their programs with career outcomes. Then the worst thing happened: administrations expanded even more, while the essential liberal arts are being suffocated and squeezed out.
We lost the best part of the college concept, and kept all the worst parts.
If only they hired an inspector general or auditor to keep tabs on these sort of shenanigans! /s
Decreased (per capita, inflation-adjusted) state (and federal) funding for schools (mostly state) and student grants (state and federal) effects both public and private schools.
This often means we pull money out of our own pockets for super basic tooling and materials. Students simply cannot learn in such a restricted environment and often burn out because they have to spend days working around a problem that a $10 component is meant to solve. Those students are also required to work to even afford tuition. They have to take on a second external job to have any "extra" money to buy their own hardware with.
Yet the uni absolutely preaches equality and opportunity. Again, democrat talking points. They do nothing to actually make that happen.
We need to defund unis, and we should have done it 20 years ago. Across the board no more public funding, if it's worthwhile then private industry will fund it like they do for any other trade.
Projects that just "align with political talking points" tend to be much more challenging to fund because there's significantly less money available in those domains.
Economically, an educated populace produces positive externalities on society. As such it makes sense for the government to fund and subsidize it to some extent because it produces a good ROI for both the society and the individuals.
Sure, but we tried that, and tuitions are sky high and everyone is in tons of debt, right? Cutting all public funding may be extreme, but something obviously needs to change.
Fun fact with many of the external programs is you are actually paying them to do it. Though it's a "grant" the institution wants you to fundraise to pay them. Yeah, no.
Because of this most students never touch a project outside of classes.
It's a bandwagon culture that believes they have a responsibility to be activists and force that upon students. There is no fixing that by just replacing leadership. The whole boat must go.
In other words, the "burn it to the ground and start over" approach.
Refactor. Don't rebuild. The bigger the system, the more true that is.
Code is logical, people are not. Cultures can only be removed, you will never convince a 40 year old woman working in education their whole life that their entire philosophy is wrong. They will continue to push their beliefs under the table. That's the poison that is naturally bred in public institutions. It's all politically motivated.
Not that I vote for them but you can see how little of a dent Trump made because the institutions around them were actively undoing their work. Perhaps for good reason, however they were voted in by half the population. What we see for support in education is largely confirmation bias. If you put it to a public vote higher education would be defunded.
If you think university is solely vocational training, then this makes sense. However, that leaves a lot, including fundamental research unfunded. Research seems to suggest that reductions in public funding is the single most important variable in increases in tuition. I'd be worried that your proposal either exacerbates the problem or creates a whole new set of problems.
You can't fix the ship. The political culture is far too ingrained. This makes perfect sense when you realize that public means government controlled and funded. Of course it's going to be largely politically motivated.
As an example there are now new required classes that preach about equality and white privilege with dubious accreditation. Not as a concept, but as a requirement of students. That's a real thing, I wish I were making it up.
Be a fly on the wall in your admins offices and you'll want to scorch earth that system too.
Uh huh. Totally believe you. Convenient of you to leave out the name of your school while trying to make a ideological point so that nobody can refute your claims.
Apparently your school's tech program must be quite bad, if it's alumni are unwilling to donate to fund student's basic tooling requirements. However, it means your school can't be located in the Pac12 or California.
Across the board no more public funding, if it's worthwhile then private industry will fund it like they do for any other trade.
If you think that publicly funded schools are bad, you should look into how much worse privately funded schools are. (Here's a tip: you won't just be paying for your own tooling. The school will charge you for it at a huge markup.)
Alumni don't make enough to be contributing any significant amount of money. Programmers outside of Cali bubble economy are not making that kind of bank.
I'm telling you the facts of what I've personally worked with and how students are being scammed by this system for political gain.
For-profit schools are significantly worse than non-profit schools in every way. And it seems that your real beef is that the taxpayers have decided not to provide adequate funding to the school for basic supplies. You should take that up with your fellow taxpayers, not the school.
This doesn't even approach the problem that industry and academics are seperated worlds. Unis lie and tell you everything is "in demand" yet students graduate and no one will even look at them.
The most funding for effective programs comes from private industry. Companies will spend far more than state or federal on real programs as long as they're not attached to universities. That tells you something right off the bat. High schools get far more money than us.
Private industry should be the one footing the bill and are the most knowleable about what industry wants. We do not yet have a system of this so you don't have any examples to base your claim from. For this to happen we need to first remove all higher public education funding to force companies to build their own.
Before you make bogus claims about "general education" there is nothing learned about humanities or general knowledge at a uni that isn't better done with a YouTube video. The instructors don't know how to teach and can't engage students with effective knowledge.
And there we have it. The "taxation is theft" heuristic that snaps your perspective into focus.
>Private industry should be the one footing the bill and are the most knowleable about what industry wants.
Are there any instances where you think this breaks down? There are some industries that very likely would not exist without initial government support because the initial risk was too great or the payoff too vague. I'm not sure aerospace would exist, for example, without the public shouldering the bulk of the initial risk. (That shouldn't be conflated with the stance those industries can't mature to a point where privatization is better).
There is little done in modern academics that legitimately drives innovation. Only select institutions, with significant ties to private industry, generate papers and innovation. Largely these are still already done in R&D at a company somewhere.
Public funding for education that works is effectively subsidizing costs for private industry. Public funding that doesnt work is incompetence that benefits no one other then government employees, and that makes it equal to theft.
Therefore, we remove the subsidy, and students that are worth investing in will be paid for by the billions that companies have sitting around collecting dust.
In my experience, in both academia and industry, industry often gets the better deal. They can effectively socialize the risks to the public sphere and then when there's a clear path to make profits, take the reins. I think that hybrid system tends to work the best to mitigate the evils of both sides.
A good example is SpaceX. There would be no SpaceX without NASA and most of the earliest flights were self-insured by the govt. Their SpaceAct agreement allows them to have access to all the support and expertise of NASA as long as they share their data. In exchange, the dinosaur of NASA has some new innovation led by the private sector. Once they proved themselves competent, their customer base expanded to private companies because the risk was now lower. I don't think any of that was likely to happen in a non-hybrid approach.
Something doesn't add up. I'm going to assume you are trolling and leave this conversation now.
The Ron Swanson Effect
I can infact get a government paycheck and also criticize it, knowing where it comes from and how it's obtained. Infact that makes me one of the most knowledgeable people on it.
Either you are personally benefitting from an institution you are actively undermining or you are perpetuating an organization that you think deserves to go away. Neither of those actions are ethically admirable. (See: your post about how illogical humans are)
Now I'll grant that your personal ethics are distinct from the issue, but I'm sure you can see why that might raise some eyebrows.
I hate that now, when I’m more mature, more experienced, and know exactly what I want from it is the time it’s the most difficult for me to go back.
For things like swimming pools and gyms, sure.
But some of the new services are things like 'mental health support' - it would be problematic if you'd opted out of mental health support to save $50/month, then you committed suicide.
Schools try so very hard to be the entirety of their students' lives. They want students socialisation to be within their bounds, they want students to go to their hospital, exercise at their gym, be policed by their police force, work at their on-campus jobs, eat at their cafeteria, live in their dorms, cheer for their sports teams, and so on and so on. And society mostly caters to this desire, which the students and parents are also more-or-less on board with. But even as these integrations individually benefit the students, the net effect is to bubble students away from the rest of the world while also creating a bloated administrative entity that is both too powerful for its own good and completely unable to get things done.
This sort of desire to tell people what's good for them is why we can't have nice things. You think you're being reasonable here but there's another well-meaning moron insisting they're being reasonable by preventing students from opting out of the the $50 gym fee, and another well-meaning moron that thinks they're being reasonable by requiring the dining hall have X Y and Z, etc, etc, etc.
In reality what you people are doing is the institutional policy equivalent of littering. One or two people do it and it's fine, we can tolerate that. But everyone does it and the park turns into a dump and the college turns into a flaming pile of money that society cannot afford to keep feeding.
The least crappy outcome is achieved when none of you get your way.
BTW, you could get a lot of fees removed or reduced by dropping to part-time commuter student. But they probably got rid of that exclusion since a lot of colleges are chasing money.
I was also an online student that only attended on campus class for 1 weekend per semester. It made no sense to make everyone pay the fee that included significant amounts of benefits that weren't needed by online students (the online MBA program was structured toward those currently working). This was on top of the $41 fee that I paid for the "Rec Center"...which again would never be used by me since I was an online student.
Like many first in their family college students I soon discovered a lot of scholarships only covered tuition (and books) and I was left to make up the difference in housing, meals, and fees. I felt the fees were a sly way for the college to scam money out of students. I was required to pay an athletic fee but they weren't required to give me tickets to every football game.
For schools, MBA programs are such a money pump if they were entitled to charge more they would. A lot cases the employer pays for the MBA program and they don't have the wherewithal to scrutinize excess fees. So, you end up with online students paying student health, rec, bus, and athletic fees.
I think all online degrees are over the top also because many companies will pay for them. I'm doing a CS degree right now that is online and it's more expensive (per credit hour vs. on campus). Not sure what the on campus fees are, but it seems crazy that not requiring anything more than some server hosting space to charge ~$2,000 for a 4 credit class. Luckily my employer is picking up 90%+ of the tab (maxing out at $5,250/yr).
Having worked for one such office for ~15 years, the most appalling part was that they are largely antagonistic toward the faculty and mission of the schools. The waste is dizzying."
I made the above comment on another thread with a similar topic: "Boston University Undergraduate Cost Reach $80K" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31309700