News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by gamblor956 on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @07:19PM (#31576103)
I work at a well known public uni. We can get state and federal funding for anything that aligns with democrat political talking points. We cannot get funding for basic tech and projects.

Uh huh. Totally believe you. Convenient of you to leave out the name of your school while trying to make a ideological point so that nobody can refute your claims.

Apparently your school's tech program must be quite bad, if it's alumni are unwilling to donate to fund student's basic tooling requirements. However, it means your school can't be located in the Pac12 or California.

Across the board no more public funding, if it's worthwhile then private industry will fund it like they do for any other trade.

If you think that publicly funded schools are bad, you should look into how much worse privately funded schools are. (Here's a tip: you won't just be paying for your own tooling. The school will charge you for it at a huge markup.)

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by devwastaken on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @08:24PM (#31576563)
Too bad, I don't want to be fired. The tech program is bad, it's bad because there is not funding and instructors are a revolving door due in part to that. We have private industry instructors hire on, look at the state of the institution, and run. The only things that can be even partially funded are classes and dedicated individual student projects. There is 0 budget outside of that.

Alumni don't make enough to be contributing any significant amount of money. Programmers outside of Cali bubble economy are not making that kind of bank.

I'm telling you the facts of what I've personally worked with and how students are being scammed by this system for political gain.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by gamblor956 on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @09:43PM (#31577100)
And I'm telling you that if your school was for-profit, it would be even worse.

For-profit schools are significantly worse than non-profit schools in every way. And it seems that your real beef is that the taxpayers have decided not to provide adequate funding to the school for basic supplies. You should take that up with your fellow taxpayers, not the school.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by devwastaken on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @10:19AM (#31582130)
Public schools are for profit, that profit comes out of tax payers against their will. Just because they have a tax free status doesn't mean they're not lining their pockets with money. Given the massive artificial increases in costs - they are. I've seen it happen in realtime.

This doesn't even approach the problem that industry and academics are seperated worlds. Unis lie and tell you everything is "in demand" yet students graduate and no one will even look at them.

The most funding for effective programs comes from private industry. Companies will spend far more than state or federal on real programs as long as they're not attached to universities. That tells you something right off the bat. High schools get far more money than us.

Private industry should be the one footing the bill and are the most knowleable about what industry wants. We do not yet have a system of this so you don't have any examples to base your claim from. For this to happen we need to first remove all higher public education funding to force companies to build their own.

Before you make bogus claims about "general education" there is nothing learned about humanities or general knowledge at a uni that isn't better done with a YouTube video. The instructors don't know how to teach and can't engage students with effective knowledge.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by bumby on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @11:03AM (#31582841)
>profit comes out of tax payers against their will.

And there we have it. The "taxation is theft" heuristic that snaps your perspective into focus.

>Private industry should be the one footing the bill and are the most knowleable about what industry wants.

Are there any instances where you think this breaks down? There are some industries that very likely would not exist without initial government support because the initial risk was too great or the payoff too vague. I'm not sure aerospace would exist, for example, without the public shouldering the bulk of the initial risk. (That shouldn't be conflated with the stance those industries can't mature to a point where privatization is better).

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by devwastaken on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @07:26PM (#31589443)
Taxation is theft. That's a fact. In some circumstances that's a necessary evil. However that does not make it always proper to do. You're looking for a way to strawman this instead of addressing the argument.

There is little done in modern academics that legitimately drives innovation. Only select institutions, with significant ties to private industry, generate papers and innovation. Largely these are still already done in R&D at a company somewhere.

Public funding for education that works is effectively subsidizing costs for private industry. Public funding that doesnt work is incompetence that benefits no one other then government employees, and that makes it equal to theft.

Therefore, we remove the subsidy, and students that are worth investing in will be paid for by the billions that companies have sitting around collecting dust.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by bumby on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @09:34PM (#31590296)
Taxation without representation is theft. If you live in a modern western democratic society, that is not the case.

In my experience, in both academia and industry, industry often gets the better deal. They can effectively socialize the risks to the public sphere and then when there's a clear path to make profits, take the reins. I think that hybrid system tends to work the best to mitigate the evils of both sides.

A good example is SpaceX. There would be no SpaceX without NASA and most of the earliest flights were self-insured by the govt. Their SpaceAct agreement allows them to have access to all the support and expertise of NASA as long as they share their data. In exchange, the dinosaur of NASA has some new innovation led by the private sector. Once they proved themselves competent, their customer base expanded to private companies because the risk was now lower. I don't think any of that was likely to happen in a non-hybrid approach.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by gamblor956 on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:38PM (#31586217)
You seem to be ideologically opposed to the very idea of public schools, and yet apparently have no problem working for one for years even though there are for-profit private schools or programs that you could be working for.

Something doesn't add up. I'm going to assume you are trolling and leave this conversation now.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by bumby on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @02:45PM (#31586310)
>You seem to be ideologically opposed to the very idea of public schools, and yet apparently have no problem working for one

The Ron Swanson Effect

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by devwastaken on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @07:36PM (#31589510)
That philosophy right there is why nothing changes. I'm pointing out the problem square in the face and you choose to ignore it for a fantasy. Address the merits, don't strawman.

I can infact get a government paycheck and also criticize it, knowing where it comes from and how it's obtained. Infact that makes me one of the most knowledgeable people on it.

Re:High tuition costs mostly stem from the Omnibus Budget Re... by bumby on Thursday June 02, 2022 @04:31PM (#31600144)
You can, but it does seem to point to some questionable ethics.

Either you are personally benefitting from an institution you are actively undermining or you are perpetuating an organization that you think deserves to go away. Neither of those actions are ethically admirable. (See: your post about how illogical humans are)

Now I'll grant that your personal ethics are distinct from the issue, but I'm sure you can see why that might raise some eyebrows.