Our government needs to make it easier to switch to a different bank. Tons of people would leave these awful banks for credit unions and such if it was easy to do. I mean it's possible to switch banks, it's a big headache though. People just have too many other things to worry about right now to deal with headaches like that.
I was originally going to get a Wells Fargo account, but that changed when I decided to go to uni in Florida - before the wachovia merger happened. My father decided that not being able to keep tabs on my account was a dealbreaker, so I ended up getting a USAA account.
Worked out for the best, because USAA has some of the best customer service in the industry.
For instance, if the father wasn't a custodial on the account he can't deposit money in the event he needs it. My parents would have to mail me a check or pay a $25 bank transfer fee because they bank elsewhere. With student privacy laws, the father can't directly see school bills. Those have to go to the student, even if the parents are paying. My school also had a student account where you could pay for food, vending, and laundry. This is a separate account that requires replenishing, so the guys I knew would sometimes call their folks asking them to deposit some money for expenditures (freshman/sophomore year, everyone pretty much had some side income by then).
When did that start? I've deposited money many times into other people's accounts without problems; you don't even have to show ID -- just fill out a deposit slip with their account number and hand over cash.
When I was younger I had a joint custodial account with my father, for a similar purpose, though it wasn't my primary checking account. It's much, much easier to move money between two accounts you control.
as caw[1] said, it's really more so that he can easily transfer money to the account in the event I need it.
If you open an investment account with them, and keep at least $1500 in there, you get a nice checking account -- refunds ATM fees, free rental car insurance, good customer service.
For what it's worth, my brother (Air Force) sold me on USAA after he signed up with them. I worked at Wells Fargo at the time, so I had the best accounts. I'm happy I made the switch. Also, their web interface and iOS apps are excellent. By far the best I've seen.
They also have a deal with UPS that allows you to go to a UPS store where they swipe your ATM card, scan the check and process the deposit. It's free. I believe the UPS method is the only one available to USAA bank customers that are not eligible for the insurance products. It's not too bad. There are a lot of UPS stores and their hours are at least as good as most banks.
PS: The first half of this happened to me costing me close to 300$ in 2 weeks and it's only me double checking that everything was fine that I got informed. At no point in this process did they attempt to contact me and they would have gladly let this grow into the thousands before contacting me for payment etc. O and the debt card had been canceled for over 3 months before that transaction happened.
In that case they either have to react or, if they dream up some fantasy fees later, you have at least something in writing (and maybe grounds for a complaint about fraud with the DAs office) ?
I'm amazed with what US banks can get away:
Selling your private data to some sleazy marketing organization, unless you opt out? A criminal offense here
Charging more the 15% annual interest on any credit granted (including cards)? A criminal offense here
Threatening you because some scumbag used your "pre-approved credit card" scamogram (for which you never asked) to defraud you? They'd be laughed out of court
While I don't believe that it should be the governments role to protect consumers from their own stupidity it should crack down hard on this sort of outright fraud. Good faith is a basis of contract law and contracts designed to defraud one party should be outright illegal (and are actually unenforceable in a lot of countries)
"Could you write that down for me, sign and stamp it, please?"
If you have bill pay setup then you have to copy all those accounts to the new account.
You have to keep track of which checks you have outstanding, and especially if you have some people who take their time to cash them you may have to wait 6 months before you can close the account.
Yes, it's possible, but it's a pain in the ass. I should be able to export my entire account from Bank A and login to Bank B and import it in a matter of minutes. They know that it is difficult, that's why they are doing these fee raises and getting away with it.
In each such story online, I've heard a claim that they specifically have algorithms to maximize the penalty fees on these mistakes.
Its another instance of a practice that disproportionately affects the poor. Unless you're living paycheque to paycheque, you would never even bother looking into such niggling details.
Their precious human capital could be used to create further knowledge and advance progress, instead it's used to exploit.
As an engineer myself, it's even scarier when the problems are challenging and exciting, but the application scares me. Oh man, would I ever like to try and put together advanced intercept/listening systems (think cell phones, over the air)! I get excited thinking about all the technical challenges, so if someone wanted to pay and support me to do it, wow that'd be interesting! It takes me a moment to stop and think to realize that I don't want to be involved in giving that kind of power to the people who would want it.
[1] http://philosecurity.org/2009/01/12/interview-with-an-adware...
You'll be the one signing the paycheque, yes?
You've just described the entire history of finance and nearly all of modern economics.
I understand that some people work multiple jobs, take care of kids, etc. Those people barely have time to breathe, let alone manage finances. Even so, managing finances is a fact of life.
Time, more money or whatever else you can think of will not break the cycle of living paycheck to paycheck. It requires a change in attitude and habits. The first simple fact is you have to spend less than you earn. It's a basic concept that so many people fail to grasp. If it's payday and you have leftover money from the last check you have savings. Don't go out and spend it like it's found money. Set it aside. Do this over and over again and you have an "emergency fund". Guess what? Now you are not living paycheck to paycheck. The second is that you have to take on an active role in managing finances in order to accomplish this. That means planning, budgeting, tracking and adjusting. The most difficult part is making the decision to start and then taking the first step.
There a hundred excuses one could come up with for living paycheck to paycheck, having debt or some other financial mess. Predatory banks, too little money (when still earning more than a reasonable amount), not enough time. None of it changes the fact that you are still living paycheck to paycheck. The only thing that changes that is planning your own finances instead of letting these other things plan for you.
It's For Your Benefit, citizen.
(Also, the cash advance interest differential for credit-cards, which is higher, and only paid off after all other charges are covered, rather than any sort of temporal ordering)
I take exception to using “citizen”, here, since it implies the gov't is somehow at fault…
In reality, the banks had indeed devised such a scheme, and for the obvious reasons, but it's since been disallowed by government intervention, along with a few other things sucha as actually being able to opt out of overdraft “protection” (this was just a few years ago but fortunately I don't have to care about what US banks do anymore).
FWIW, in Canada credit card issuers are required to apply payments to whichever balances you're paying the highest interest rate on -- it's not even temporally ordered.
UK banks used to have a god racket (don't know if they still do, don't read the relevant blogs) where they'd offer 0% balance transfer cards but with expensive purchase interest. Then, any payments you made went to paying off the oldest debt first (on which you were paying 0% interest) leaving the purchases quickly gaining high interest payments.
Several banks are being sued at the moment in class action suits for this behavior if I recall correctly. It's an unfair tactic that takes advantage of customers.
So you can end up with overdraft fees despite having enough money in your account!
Go to a bank machine, inquire about your current balance, and then extract cash to make your purchases with.
Banks may be predatory with fees, but really it's your own responsibility to avoid this trap, and it's not even that hard to do. You can also join a credit union.
I used to suffer the same mentality until I finally woke up and started to take responsibility for my own future.
Things happen to victims. Victors make things happen.
Yes, by all means, make the banks stop gouging people like that (especially maximizing fee collection by ordering largest-to-smallest). But really, once you've suffered overdraft fees once, there's no excuse for suffering it again and again; especially not when there's such a simple solution as cash. As George W. Bush once said, "fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — You can't get fooled again."
It's happened to me. Once. Never again.
http://www.fdic.gov/bank/analytical/overdraft/
They state that the sampling wasn't random and shouldn't be extrapolated, but for the banks with automated overdraft protection that they studied closely, 4.9% of customers had 20 or more overdrafts per year and paid 68% of all non sufficient funds fees collected by the banks. An additional 4% of customers had between 10 and 19 overdrafts and paid about 16% of the fees (so as a group, people with more than 10 overdrafts a year paid 84% of overdraft fees).
The people with 20 or more overdrafts averaged about $1,500 a year in overdraft fees.
All I'm hearing are excuses to make changing your situation someone else's responsibility.
But I think it's worth noting, because I'm not sure if I got the point across: I was intending to overdraft on the final, large fee. The insane overdraft fees only affected me in an unexpected way because they go out of their was to also screw people on the order of withdrawals.
relying on undefined system behavior is dangerous.
The closing date was set to the day that the last scheduled charge was going to hit, and so they gave me my cashier's check with all the funds except the $25 for the last scheduled charge. But there was also going to be a credit for $0.10 in interest on the account (which was necessary to pay the $25 charge.)
Apparently the system was able to calculate all of that properly so that the debit matched up to the funds left in the account on the closing date, but on that day the debit was processed before the 10-cent credit. So they wanted to charge me $75 in fees because of a 10-cent overdraft that their system created!
There are no limits like that because that wouldn't make sense.
I really wish we threw managers like that in jail though. They know they're enough of a roadblock that their denial to help will squash most legitimate complaint, letting them keep most of their stolen money. A 5-8 years sentence for fraud for them and coworkers who aided and abetted this would do wonders to stopping this kind of thing.
(1) They agreed, or
(2) You promptly closed your account.
I've not overdrafted since.
Credit unions are the only banking institutions I will deal with now.
I greatly admire that.
It took me two and a half hours to get the charges reversed, 30 minutes of which were spent in the nearest BoFA location until I learned I had to commute around town to go back to the original place I opened my account to even discuss the situation.
Should I move, I now know two banks I should not dream of doing business with.
Somebody in the marketing and PR department got a bonus for making that shit up. It is like they slap you in the face, then smile at you and ask you how your day is going.
One day I had had a few small charges, and realizing it was a week intl payday, I figured I'd run to the grocery store and make a large precise of groceries, to ensure I had food taken care of, expecting to make s single overdraft.
Suntrust had other plans. They took out the large grocery bill first, meaning a quick lunch at Taco Bell cost over $40, shipping a small box cost over $50, and a Slim Jim and cream soda cost almost $40. In addition to the overdraft on the groceries.
It's a very easy trap to fall into if you're living check to check and make even the slightest mistake.