News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Nextgrid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @02:52PM (#31551732)
> The majority of browsers that were commercially closed software didn’t make it

Keep in mind that the last time this was tried, free/open-source alternatives were on-par if not better and the web was much less hostile.

Nowadays, not only is the web teeming with hostility that can best be addressed by a browser, but the closest free/open-source solution (Firefox) is half-baked and doesn't actually solve many of these issues nor is it incentivized to due to murky funding (most of it comes from Google, a big advertising provider) and a dysfunctional company.

A browser whose funding comes directly from its users wouldn't have these misaligned incentives and wouldn't be afraid of doing bold moves that piss off adtech.

The Enterprise™ spends a lot of money on (often dubious) security products and given that the browser is often on the front-line for various threats, a browser with built-in security features (both against malware and other features such as DLP, blocking/filtering/monitoring without middleboxes) with a paid enterprise plan subsidizing a free version for personal use could become a sustainable business.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by irrational on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:10PM (#31552896)
Firefox is half baked? What does that mean? I’ve used Firefox as my primary browser for many years, including for my full time job as a web developer, and have never had any issues. The only time I ever use Chrome is when I need to put in my PTO at work since their time-off web app doesn’t work with Firefox.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by ushakov on Sunday May 29, 2022 @02:53PM (#31551742)
how is Firefox half-baked?

i'm using it every day along with Safari and don't see any significant differences

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by zamadatix on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:22PM (#31552542)
With something as wide scoped as a browser this inevitably comes down to "well the 200 things I think are relevant do/don't work the same in favor of a/b" out of tens of thousands, if not more, of things implemented.

For me Firefox is about as good as any. Upsides here, downsides there, and nothing truly outstanding overall. It seems severely far behind in modern color (e.g. HDR videos or all of the wide gamut CSS specifications coming out), ahead in terms of single profile compartmentalization (containers), but behind in profile management (the profile manager sucks if you even know how to get to it). For as much as it champions being the last bastion of the free web it comes default with a decent amount of crapware (pocket, vpn) and has lost its way in terms of power user flexibility (UI customization, mobile extension limits, removal of power user flags). That said it's still better than the alternatives in those spaces, just not as good as it used to be.

For another none of these might matter but a lot of other reasons I don't even think about might. In the end even Firefox's own usage statistic point to the vast majority seeming to agree it doesn't have anything compelling enough to be worth switching to/evangelizing for anymore though.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by shkkmo on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:19PM (#31552970)
Firefox on desktop is pertty solid, despite some controversial decisions.

Firedox on android has a lot of issues.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by iamcurious on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:28PM (#31553039)
Which ones? On principle, I never use chrome on android. Am I missing some killer feature?
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by maskros on Monday May 30, 2022 @09:39AM (#31558826)
Firefox has image rescaling that doesn't blow chunks at non-integer scales.

For example scaling up the page 120% to be able to more easily read text that the designer made too small doesn't turn all the images on the page into a blurry mess like it does on Chrome.

I've tried reporting bug reports to the Chromium project, but they can't seem to understand the concept and keep misfiling the reports as duplicates of irrelevant bugs and closing them as fixed without having fixed the problem.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by shkkmo on Sunday May 29, 2022 @09:09PM (#31554521)
Constant crashes that lose open tabs, layout glitches where display gets offset from ui trigger points (including on this site), downloads that just fail / don't work.

You'd think that this would have me stop using it, but I really don't want to use Chrome/Brave/DDG so have just been putting up with it.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by TingPing on Monday May 30, 2022 @12:10AM (#31555399)
Anecdotally I've never experienced a single one of those bugs in Firefox on Android as a heavy user.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by pleb_nz on Monday May 30, 2022 @06:22AM (#31557408)
I second this.

Only use ff mobile and never have any issues

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by iamcurious on Monday May 30, 2022 @01:46PM (#31561553)
I rarely find any of those things. I mean, it does crash, but once every six months, which I don't see as constant.

Hehe, we are on the same boat about not using other browsers. I have been use firefox for the last 18 years, I will continue to do so.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by dicknuckle on Sunday May 29, 2022 @09:17PM (#31554572)
why not Kiwi Browser? uses chromium under the hood. allows chrome extensions to be installed, but most don't work.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by zamadatix on Sunday May 29, 2022 @09:41PM (#31554705)
Like most small-backing Chromium clones it's usually ~2 months behind on patches (normal and security) and the published source is about ~10 months behind. Being effectively closed for the release version and very small from a development side it does wonky things like redirect your "Google" searches through their servers since they don't have proper search agreements.

I.e. it's basically "an interesting Chromium clone maintained by a couple of folks out of Estonia". If you're cool with that it can be a nifty browser, for many that just makes it to unproven to dump access to their entire online world into.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by dicknuckle on Sunday May 29, 2022 @09:18PM (#31554574)
try Kiwi Browser.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by sosull on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:19PM (#31552518)
+1, it’s a great piece of software.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:18PM (#31553429)
"Half-baked" means Firefox adopts slogans like "protecting the open web" and it purports to represent the interests of web users, however its true goals are to generally to match Chrome feature-for-feature and preserve the status quo on the web which is that it provides an optimal medium for advertising. It gets over 90% of its financial support from Google, not web users.

From the comments some people's idea of a fully baked Firefox is a browser that generally works exactly like Chrome and Safari on the surface but is somehow better, e.g., because it does not overtly sell advertising services. An enormously complex program with a gazillion knobs and dials that no average web user would ever touch. Sending all search queries of these users to Google by default. Perfect.

Another idea of a fully-baked "Firefox" is one that has options to allow mere mortals to compile it from source on modest hardware in a reasonable amount of time. There could be multiple versions of Firefox, that could all be built from the same source tree, each a different compile time option, or a set of compile-time options. Some of these might exclude support for features that make the web optimal for advertising or commerce, i.e., essential features of Chrome or other "modern" web browsers. Scaled-down versions might be optimised for different experiences. Not all them driven by Javascript. For example, fast consumption of noncommercial content with minimal surveillance, and no advertising. Essentially "Reader Mode" as the default.

What is the point of having Firefox be open source if almost no one can download the source and start creating new and different web clients with it. Instead it is a project that only tries to keep pace with Chrome, getting larger and larger, more and more complex. It appears to have no other purpose. Tunnel vision. Follow the leader.

Make no mistake, I am not suggesting there should be no Firefox version that does almost everything that Chrome does, as there is now. Mozilla has supported use of the web for advertising and commerce. They have supported Yahoo, Inc. and Google, LLC. That's wonderful. Great job.

What I am suggesting is that Firefox should also have smaller, simpler versions that deliberately do not do all the things that Chrome does. Mozilla should also work to support noncommercial web use. Compile-time options to remove Javascript, telemetry and a host of other things some users may prefer to do without. Give people choice.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by NetOpWibby on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @03:21AM (#31566929)
An Electron-like framework using Servo would be great! I opened an issue on that repo and Mozilla said no.

Then they fired a bunch of people so…welp.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by brundolf on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:47PM (#31552254)
> The Enterprise™ spends a lot of money on (often dubious) security products

> a browser with built-in security features (both against malware and other features such as DLP, blocking/filtering/monitoring without middleboxes)

It'll be hard to outdo Google at security research and hardening

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Nextgrid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:59PM (#31552353)
Vulnerabilities in the browser engine is only part of the issue. Plenty of malicious activity involves tricking the user or silently spying on them - blocking advertising/spyware/etc domains will greatly help with that.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Retric on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:52PM (#31552305)
Last month Google announced 30 new security including critical vulnerabilities in chrome.

They might be doing a great job at hardening, but they don’t have a great reputation.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by meibo on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:56PM (#31552334)
What is that supposed to say about reputation?

It's the most popular browser by far, and they actually do have a very publicized team that reports bugs to not just Chrome, but Apple and Mozilla as well. In my circles this is well respected, and personally, it inspires more confidence in the infrastructure around Chrome to me. I'd be wary of any "new" browser engines in unsafe languages.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Retric on Sunday May 29, 2022 @05:29PM (#31553048)
> What is that supposed to say about reputation?

Just that people don’t consider chrome extremely secure, it may be acceptable 99% of the time, but it doesn’t get a free pass in extreme security environments.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by pvg on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:10PM (#31553367)
What is the 'extreme security environment' you have in mind? Very little end-user software operates in an environment and with operational parameters as adversarial as a modern web browser's.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by imajoredinecon on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:02PM (#31552389)
Do you mean “30 security vulnerabilities, 1 of which was critical”? Because that seems to be the reality: https://chromereleases.googleblog.com/2022/05/stable-channel...
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by georgemcbay on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:24PM (#31553482)
> Last month Google announced 30 new security including critical vulnerabilities in chrome.

This doesn't mean chrome is less secure than other options, it means people are heavily incentivized to find and report security problems and google is open about issues that are found.

This makes me feel better about chrome's security, not worse, and I say this as someone who is overall kind of iffy on google these days.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Taywee on Sunday May 29, 2022 @02:55PM (#31551754)
Which issues do Firefox fail to solve?
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by tux3 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:08PM (#31551885)
I frequently cannot log in to my bank with Firefox.

The problem is that my bank's website was made by a bank, but as a Firefox user this impacts me in my daily life.

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by skinnymuch on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:16PM (#31551962)
How would this be solved by an up and coming browser that isn’t based off Blink/Chromium and why can’t Firefox do the solution?
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Nextgrid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:19PM (#31551986)
Firefox's problem is the company behind it, not the rendering engine. Firefox is actually a pretty fine browser if you pair it with uBlock Origin and neuter its wide range of user-hostile "features" and keep maintaining that as updates often introduce new "features" you'll need to disable.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by djbusby on Sunday May 29, 2022 @04:56PM (#31552799)
What's your top three user hostile feature? Have you looked at LibreFox?

Edit: I see there is a LibreWolf and a LibreFox

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Nextgrid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @06:07PM (#31553344)
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Barrin92 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#31552219)
at least according to this article from last year Arc is chromium based.

https://www.protocol.com/browser-company

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by ushakov on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:19PM (#31551989)
have you considered telling your bank about the issue?

it's not like they did this maliciously to worsen your experience as Firefox user?

Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by tux3 on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:47PM (#31552252)
Sure. This has happened before and they do eventually fix it. Then a different problem might happen on another page a few months later, and this'll last a few weeks.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by sigio on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:54PM (#31552322)
Probably best solved by changing banks... firefox works just fine with the ~4 banks I currently use. Though the situation is probably worse on the usa-side of the pond.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by DakotaR on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:40PM (#31552191)
Conversely, one of my banks returns a server error if you visit from Chrome. Their "solution" was to put a banner at the top advising an alternate browser.
Re:Arc Browser Company: Chrome and Safari face a new challenger by Nextgrid on Sunday May 29, 2022 @03:15PM (#31551947)
Not only Mozilla's privacy claims are smoke and mirrors (you need uBlock Origin to get any reasonable privacy on the web today - why is it not included by default despite being permissively licensed?), they have opt-out telemetry (in breach of the GDPR), the browser will load a page with Google Analytics on first run and will nag you with bullshit on nearly every update (and it updates often) not to mention change the UI all the time for no good reason.

Firefox is the most user-hostile free & open-source software that I know of, and more hostile than a lot of paid, proprietary software.