News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bko on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:32AM (#31528803)
> He worries that they enable illicit activity by making money transactions less transparent. Still, he sees the value in digital payments systems and supports electronic use of government-backed currencies like the dollar.

> “I’ve been a great advocate of moving to an electronic payments mechanism. There are a lot of efficiencies. I think we can actually have a better regulated economy if we had all the data in real time, knowing what people are spending,” he says.

This is almost written like a parody. Government backed electronic money is utterly dystopian to me. Imagine all the "nudges" that could easily be introduced. You're buying too much [bad thing], card declined. You're costing the health care system too much by being overweight so we'll restrict your food allowance. Your carbon emissions are over the limit this month, we'll have to deny your flight purchase. A gas station charges "too much" for gas, payment declined.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by boredumb on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:05AM (#31529139)
I find it alarming how authoritarianism and totalitarianism are perfectly acceptable views if people work in particular academic and political circles and mask it in the 'better regulation', 'better government' or other pro-government sentiment. It feels like a whole section of society is trying to shoehorn in a fully regulated society by playing coy and fooling large portions of society at large into believing it's going to be to their benefit by not being completely honest with the implications and historical outcomes of a totalitarian state.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nine_k on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:50AM (#31529609)
If you are smart, there is a strong temptation to start telling everyone how to behave, because they are, like, less smart, and do stupid and dangerous things. These simpletons should do what we, the smart bunch, say, for their own good!

In some ancient books this is called hubris. It's a very real danger in any human interaction.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by andrew_ on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:26AM (#31529352)
This has been pushed with every hot-button topic, every tragedy, at every opportunity. What boggles my mind even more is how many people seem perfectly willing to step right in line and accept it.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by mushbino on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:44AM (#31529551)
We live in a totalitarian state that's managed by corporations. In true American style, we outsource all of the things you just mentioned to the private sector, but they still very much happen just the same.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_totalitarianism

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by AlanYx on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:50AM (#31529613)
A lot of academics honestly believe in the idea that we're smart enough now to do it better. I work periodically with one academic who wrote a recent book published by Harvard University Press on the history of German censorship prior to 1945 (and she has relatives who were killed in the Holocaust), and yet who is still a firm believer in current initiatives to censor the Internet to address harmful content.

This "we're smarter now" is a kind of perpetual Achilles heel of academics dealing in policy. e.g., Chinese academics thought they were smarter now too just prior to the cultural revolution, and that they'd be able to steer the tiger they created in the students. They weren't, of course, and many of those academics ended up being targets.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by zen_1 on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:13AM (#31530528)
We're smarter now, but apparently not smart enough to realize that "smarts" don't make for a terribly effective countermeasure to being persecuted for disagreeing with those in power.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by imustbeevil on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:28AM (#31530730)
> authoritarianism and totalitarianism are perfectly acceptable views if people work in particular academic and political circles and mask it in the 'better regulation'

Or, just to be devils advocate, maybe people just want better regulation and not authoritarianism or totalitarianism.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by jollybean on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:30PM (#31534505)
Most people are pretty rational about these things I think and can spot 'problems' a mile away A

Private Corps and Legislators tend to sometimes push things too far, or miss the 'dark side' etc..

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by scoopertrooper on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:57AM (#31529060)
99% of retail payments already happen through a tightly regulated electronic payment system today.

I haven't been denied my god given right to murder myself by purchasing tobacco and sugar products so far.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bko on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:30AM (#31529393)
There's already been government attempts in restricting banking services to "undesirables", all under the guise of preventing "high-risk activity". Check out Operation Choke Point. It prevented a lot of legal sex workers from being able to use banking services. It's a kind of extra-judicial regulation where something is "legal" but not really because some agency can arbitrarily tell every banking provider to blacklist you.

Competence is a big part of why you don't see as many nudges as you can, but it'll be considerably easier with a digitized US coin. And of course these departments get more sophisticated over time. Maybe they'll hire consultants from CCP to help them implement a social credit score.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Choke_Point

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by halfmatthalfcat on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:45AM (#31529560)
Reading that wiki, nothing jumped out to me as unreasonable - at least the goal of Choke Point. What's wrong with targeting industries with high risk/incidence of money laundering?

Is there high incidence of money laundering in sex work? If there is, then it's not exempt from being investigated. This isn't a reflection on the act of sex work but the shady characters using it as a laundering mechanism.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bko on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:59AM (#31529723)
It's about the implementation. I believe something should be illegal or legal. If it's legal all the same rights and services should be granted to individuals in this trade. Fraud and charge backs should be handled by the services processors and new services should arise to handle higher risk industries. Better than the state putting their finger on the scales

https://www.vice.com/en/article/4w74jg/how-the-financial-sec...

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by Ancapistani on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:02AM (#31530432)
A ton of gun stores lost their banking access as a result of this. Bank of America, IIRC, dropped a bunch of retailers with no notice.

It’s definitely seen in that community as a back-door attempt to abrogate access to firearms.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by collegeburner on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:20AM (#31530617)
It's really screwed up, most of the people I know who go fucked over were LGS owners and employees, like they weren't already having a hard enough time staying in business. You know, the kind of people who can actually help create a community of safe, responsible firearms use with their trainings outreach efforts etc.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by BiteCode_dev on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:21AM (#31529291)
Because you can still use cash.

But once you can't, then the temptation to coerce people into "the right way" is going to be too big.

Then you need to hope you don't need to go to a gay bar in an anti gay state, pay for an abortion without your parent knowing, or give financial support to a controversial political group.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by thawaya3113 on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:27AM (#31529376)
So the problem isn’t the existence of a USD digital system.

The issue would only arise if cash was eliminated.

I completely agree on the need for cash, but as long as we’re also keeping cash a digital USD would solve every problem crypto claims to solve while still allowing for a non dystopian future.

In fact, crypto is completely dystopian because there is absolutely no space for cash in it, and further, by being distributed and therefore pseudonymous at best, it actually opens massive privacy and security pandora boxes.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by BiteCode_dev on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:34AM (#31529446)
Oh, I though it was the idea to go full electronic.

Then yes, a perfect ledger for all monetary transactions would be great, espacially for big sums.

Appart from that, the current financial system is mostly digital and satisfactory for day to day payments.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by exo762 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:54AM (#31538740)
> In fact, crypto is completely dystopian because there is absolutely no space for cash in it, and further, by being distributed and therefore pseudonymous at best, it actually opens massive privacy and security pandora boxes.

I don't think crypto positions itself as the only option (Bitcoin maxis aside). So there is definitely space for cash, space for tokenized USD, space for collateralized algo stablecoins.

Why distributed implies "pseudonimous at best"? Have you looked into what can be done with zero-knowledge proofs? With MPC?

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ridgered4 on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:48AM (#31530278)
> In fact, crypto is completely dystopian because there is absolutely no space for cash in it, and further, by being distributed and therefore pseudonymous at best, it actually opens massive privacy and security pandora boxes.

Is this true of all coins though? I know little about crypto, but I gather from reading on here while the privacy of bitcoin was greatly exaggerated/false other coins use actually privacy respecting schemes. Of course, that would assume that the schemes they use work perfectly which is probably a ridiculous assumption.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by WillPostForFood on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:17AM (#31529239)
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ekianjo on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:03AM (#31529125)
> I haven't been denied my god given right to murder myself by purchasing tobacco and sugar products so far.

The past does not predict the future

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ceejayoz on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:11AM (#31529191)
Sure, but that doesn't mean the past doesn't have any predictive value.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ekianjo on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:43PM (#31536546)
The past has absolutely no predictive value. Thats why we have a news business in the first place.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bennysomething on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:04AM (#31529129)
Yes but that data is fragmented, not on a giant immutable ledger.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ceejayoz on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:08AM (#31529813)
It's not that fragmented. Visa, Mastercard, and if you're being completionist, Amex and Discover. Four taps gets you virtually every credit card transaction in the Western world. Direct bank transfers are even more susceptible.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bennysomething on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:29PM (#31532287)
And cash! :)
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nverno on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:17AM (#31529248)
The future for tobacco products is looking pretty bleak. In MA, now I can only buy juul 3%, no menthol or any other flavor, even worse than in CA. Besides, it costs as much as groceries now.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by toomuchtodo on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:41AM (#31529529)
Good! I know more people who desperately want to quit and can’t due to addiction than I do people who love tobacco and can quit anytime.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by yucky on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:04PM (#31535454)
Do you think prohibition has a particularly effective track record?

Also, since obesity is the biggest health problem in the US, we can easily use this argument to limit caloric intake "for the greater good™". After all, what is the argument against limiting caloric intake if we should all be policing what humans put into their bodies?

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by thatguy0900 on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:57AM (#31530376)
Hopefully you have the same attitude when the sin tax comes for your vices, I suppose
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by eganist on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:59AM (#31529082)
> Imagine all the "nudges" that could easily be introduced. You're buying too much [bad thing], card declined. You're costing the health care system too much by being overweight so we'll restrict your food allowance. Your carbon emissions are over the limit this month, we'll have to deny your flight purchase. A gas station charges "too much" for gas, payment declined.

Why would they do this when they can (and already do) use taxes and tax breaks to dis/incentivize behavior?

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ekianjo on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:02AM (#31529112)
> Why would they do this when they can (and already do) use taxes and tax breaks to dis/incentivize behavior?

Because they can. You have never heard of government abuse before?

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by bko on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:35AM (#31529468)
A lot already happens, from a super complicated tax code and things like cities banning fountain drinks above a certain size. But a lot of these things are not practical. I don't know if we have the legal infrastructure to mandate gas may not be sold above a certain amount. Now do that with millions of business, many of them too small.

Digital currency is a general solution for absolute control. It's much easier to control and impose and change arbitrary rules on spending or target individuals solely through the administrative state. No laws have to be passed, no congressional hearings, no one you can vote out of office. Just a single bureaucrat you've never heard of flipping a switch and upending your life.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nverno on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:24AM (#31529322)
The dis/incentive aspect is already abused, imo. If a small percentage of society participates in one activity, eg. smoking, it's too easy for the majority to tax the crap out of them to fund whatever activities they want.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by danaris on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:19AM (#31529933)
I'm really not sure invoking smoking as your boogeyman here is making the point you want it to. It's already very well known that the reason it remained unrestricted for so long is because the tobacco giants actively suppressed the studies that clearly showed how deadly it was, both for smokers and for the people around them.

I don't think using something like sin taxes to discourage doing something that actively harms both you and anyone who has to share your air can reasonably be called an abuse of government power, unless you're one of the people who thinks that anything (besides maybe enforcing property rights) is an abuse of government power.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nverno on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:28AM (#31530049)
You're missing the point. It's too easy for the majority to support taxing the minority over anything like this, cause it's no skin off their back. [Not to mention there are already laws pretty much everywhere restricting smoking to places where secondhand smoke isn't an issue- people can smoke at home you know. If you are worried about air quality, then driving in the city should be taxed, but it wouldn't be b/c the majority does it regularly]
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by danaris on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#31530085)
There's a massive difference between taxing something like "being black" or "renting an apartment", where it's either an immutable part of who you are or something very difficult for many to change due to something like socioeconomic status, and something like smoking, which, while yes, it's addictive, is still a choice.

And, again, it's a choice that is actively harmful to the smoker and everyone around them. So if you really want to make a point, I strongly encourage you to find a different example, because this one just sounds like you're a smoker who's angry that they have to pay more in taxes to continue to be able to pollute the air with carcinogens.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nverno on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:39AM (#31530193)
The point is people support taxing whatever is convenient for them. Another of the many conforming effects of overgrown democracy.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by danaris on Friday May 27, 2022 @04:14PM (#31534370)
If you can show an actual example of that, rather than an example of people taxing objectively negative behaviour in an attempt to reduce it, then I might take your point more seriously.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by Majestic121 on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:55PM (#31531839)
In countries with socialized health care, the high tax on tobacco does not cover the costs of treating cancer patients : https://www.science-environnement.com/modes-de-vie/les-taxes...

It's a mistake to believe the tax is here to fund "whatever activities"

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by nverno on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:59PM (#31531900)
I've seen reports like this from anti-smoking campaigns before. It's hilarious they don't account for the estimated costs of treating those dead patients had they lived to old age. Calling BS on that one.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by robotjosh on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:25AM (#31529330)
This just sounds like punishing people, not incentivizing. People just want to see others punished, they would never want to use such a system themselves.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by lootsauce on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:55PM (#31534150)
Still, why wouldn’t they?
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by Tenoke on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:57AM (#31529068)
I agree but I actually wouldn't mind if carbon emissions and offsets were tracked and ensured to be not too negative. There are easier ways to do that though - e.g. just include money for offseting in the flight price.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ericd on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:17AM (#31529237)
It’s even simpler than that - slap the carbon tax on the carbon source at time of extraction if it’s domestic, or at import time if it’s from a country that doesn’t do that itself at the same rate. The price changes will all flow downstream from there, and we don’t have a hairball of exemptions for eg jet fuel. And very pessimistic taxation estimates for materials and finished products from countries that don’t follow suit.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:27AM (#31529369)
Yeah, but everything has to be progressive. We can't reduce emissions by taxing EVERYONE to reduce emissions. We have to try to squeeze 76% of the reductions from the top 1%.

The problem is - if you ACTUALLY want to do something about emissions - they aren't as unevenly distributed as wealth. Everyone needs to cut back. And just like taxes - everyone is willing to raise taxes on someone else. Everyone is willing to force everyone else to cut their emissions. Hardly anyone wants their own taxes to go up, or reduce their own emissions.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ericd on Friday May 27, 2022 @11:49AM (#31531001)
Is that first sentence sarcastic? Anyway, these tax proposals are usually accompanied by an evenly distributed dividend that makes them revenue neutral. The net effect is that people who live close to work, don't fly, don't eat lots of produce from the other hemisphere, etc should be net gainers, and everyone else will pay more. In most categories, the rich will probably end up paying more on average, since they consume more.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday May 27, 2022 @05:01PM (#31534830)
No - that's the one it seems economists recommend.

Politicians go with what panders to their base, not with what economists recommend.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ericd on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:16PM (#31535567)
Yeah, fair enough, I see what you meant in your other comment.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by adrianN on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:09AM (#31546581)
Give everyone a fixed amount of money if you want to make this more progressive than it is naturally (poor people emit less carbon already).
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by ekianjo on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:03AM (#31529120)
> carbon emissions and offsets were tracked and ensured to be not too negative

including big exceptions for politicians who have no problem taking a plane every 2 days for no reason.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by freemint on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:15AM (#31529223)
No, no, no need for that. It is an expense the tax payer pays for anyway. So no reason for exception for politicians
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by igorkraw on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:57AM (#31529056)
With natural monopolies like those promoted by the network effects crypto projects pin their hopes on the stable point is the same, minus democratic institutions ensuring some semblance of justice and equity.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by _ZeD_ on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:57AM (#31529058)
I'm pretty sure is more about money laundering than that.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by xtracto on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:02AM (#31529110)
And the security theatre in airports is more about terrorism. And not letting you pass that sunscreen bottle is about liquid bombs... There will always be a "reason" for the government to gain control over citizens.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by npc12345 on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:56AM (#31529693)
They'll never get it man.

They want to government up their a$$.

That's why I no longer argue with them, not as much as I used to.

Every successful, cool and relaxed person Ive known in real life is against all of this shit.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by Maf1 on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:51AM (#31529617)
Davos have been pushing individual carbon trackers. "reached carbon quota.. access to flight/bus/car..denied!
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by alkonaut on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:12PM (#31535530)
Government backed and transparent doesn’t mean all my purchases are exposed. It’s (technically) possible to have a system of tokens where it’s only known how much I spend for example, but not where. Having (say) transactions under $1000 or $10000 anonymous would make a lot of sense as a cash replacement.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by moistly on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:55PM (#31532616)
You have declined to get a credit or debit card, I suppose? If not, you may want to check out the data a “Level 3” transactor provides regarding your purchases. Data the card company subsequently sells to insurance companies, etc. Tip: pay for your “sin” purchases with cash.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by adrianN on Sunday May 29, 2022 @01:07AM (#31546575)
I would prefer something like GNU Taler over any cryptocurrency.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by andrenth on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:15PM (#31533664)
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by dpweb on Friday May 27, 2022 @09:51AM (#31529624)
There’s 141 trillion of wealth in the US. 2 trillion is in currency. We already have digital money it’s called the US Dollar.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by outime on Friday May 27, 2022 @08:54AM (#31529033)
I'm afraid that's exactly how it's gonna turn out.
Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by jollybean on Friday May 27, 2022 @10:05AM (#31529776)
"Economists want real time data" --> "They are controlling our toughts!"

1) Please - enough with they hyperbole.

Data is not the same as control.

Yes - we should be wary, we don't want the government using our money to nudge us.

At the same time we definitely want our governments using data to help us.

There was a story in Canada about the government buying anonymoized cell tower data to understand our behaviours during a pandemic, misrepresented as 'they are trying to control us' - which is a disingenuous lie.

Literally we're faced with a pandemic, we want to get rid of restrictions, the best way to do that is to know where and how COVID is spreading. We wouldn't bat an eye if some garbage advertising company bought that data.

2) "Government backed electronic money is utterly dystopian to me. I"

Hyerbole.

You already use 'Government Backed Electronic Money' - that the way it works and it works fine.

It's 1000% better than 'Ponzi Scheme Money 80% Owned by Elon Musk' or 'Google Controlled Money'.

And FYI - the 'Government Backed Money' we use today flows through VISA network and they are 100% selling every bit of your data to anyone who will buy.

What you probably want is even stronger regulation of 'Gov Money' so that private entities cannot trace, transact or sell, i.e. even better privacy laws.

And maybe some kind of legislation that forbids the Central Bank from doing anything other than targeting inflation/employment.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by yucky on Friday May 27, 2022 @06:10PM (#31535505)
>At the same time we definitely want our governments using data to help us.

Speak for yourself, until the government shows it can be trusted. Their track record is awful, no thanks.

Re:Joseph Stiglitz: 'We should shut down the cryptocurrencies' by jollybean on Wednesday June 01, 2022 @04:18PM (#31587473)
Again, hyperbolic nonsense.

Your government has millions of people working for it that do innumerable things from water works, electricity distribution and regulation, policing, defence.

You already depend on them intimately.

The naive, glib view that somehow 'we can't trust government' is blatantly contradicted by your very existed.

We want to make sure oversight and controls are there, but it's bonkers to suggest we don't want health officials to understand how this pandemic played out, so that they can figure out how to deal with the next one.