News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by Simon_O_Rourke on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:21PM (#31471169)
I lived out in Berlin where basically nobody except the police and the (really) bad guys are armed. Sure, there's burglary, but much more likely was bicycle theft... I had three stolen in one calendar year.

To be honest, I was more comfortable that none of my a-hole neighbors were armed, because they would have pulled a gun on you for leaving out the rubbish an hour too early or talking to loudly after 8pm.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by verdverm on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:34PM (#31471291)
Pointing a gun at someone is generally a crime in the US. No need for the hyperbole around gun ownership and people's behavior
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:30PM (#31472991)
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by wyldfire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31471464)
Unholstering it and holding it down at your waist is still very threatening. And while it's not common, it definitely happens here in the US.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by 3-cheese-sundae on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:00PM (#31471547)
That’s called brandishing and it’s still illegal
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by stevenicr on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:44AM (#31475408)
I have heard some people say this - and I am sure you may find some that wanted to charge it that way.. but I'm not sure that holding a firearm at your waist pointed toward the ground is necessarily brandishing or illegal.

Surely other factors could contribute to make such a situation more or less a threat - things said, or even a particular location compared to another.

I understand the GP comment person feels that such a thing is threatening, but I disagree with the blanket statement there too.. someone holding a firefarm does not mean they intend to, or are threatening to use it, imho..

just like someone pulling a phone out of their pocket and holding towards the ground does not mean they are going to call 911 - now that would be different if they pulled it out and said they were going to call.. but the act of pulling it out of one' pocket and holding it doesn't not imply they are going to use it for nefarious purposes in of itself.

Although I would consider them more ready to - and therefor deserving more acute attention and awareness.

Not a lawyer so I don't know for sure.. I just feel that someone holding a firearm in a downward position is not a direct threat like someone pointing it at a person - which then becomes brandishing / illegal in most circumstances afaik.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by bitcuration on Monday May 23, 2022 @04:55AM (#31476696)
At least in California, just touching holster is considered brandishing. Not sure it's the same in Texas though.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by technothrasher on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:17PM (#31472309)
Depends upon the jurisdiction. For instance, there was a bill in Massachusetts in 2013 that had a provision making brandishing illegal, but the bill did not pass. There are no current statutes that I am aware of making brandishing specifically illegal in the state. Case law does reference brandishing quite a bit (mostly with a knife) and is used most often to show intent or where an assault or other crime has also taken place. (e.g. a perpetrator brandished a knife and then ordered a victim to perform an action against their will, or a perpetrator brandished a firearm to win an argument and was then found not to have a license for it).

Brandishing alone could be considered an assault I suppose, but I don't really see that much in case law. I think because its pretty rare for somebody to brandish a weapon with intent to harm and then not follow up with further criminal actions.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by staticautomatic on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:02PM (#31471568)
Also could be civil assault
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by User23 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:06PM (#31471606)
There’s a wide misconception that assault is an act if violence but legally it’s merely the unlawful threat of violence, which is of course implied by actual unlawful violence.

Unholstering or otherwise displaying a firearm is assault by definition unless there’s a justifiable reason to do so.

Edit: re: assault: https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-charges/assault-an... “In most states, an assault or battery is committed when one person physically strikes or attempts to physically strike another, or when they act in a threatening manner to put another in fear of immediate harm.”

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by staticautomatic on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:25PM (#31471782)
Maybe. Depending on the state I’d bet there’s common law saying otherwise.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by staticautomatic on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:47PM (#31474908)
Re: your edit, point is that doesn’t necessarily mean unholstering a weapon is assault as a matter of law.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by yongjik on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:21PM (#31474162)
> Pointing a gun at someone is generally a crime in the US.

I thought the major pro-gun argument was that criminals don't care for law? You know, the whole "If you outlaw guns only outlaws will have guns" thing. (Which is also patently false, by the way. Criminals in Germany usually don't have guns.)

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by wyldfire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:49PM (#31474602)
> Which is also patently false, by the way. Criminals in Germany usually don't have guns.

Um, that doesn't invalidate "If you outlaw guns only outlaws will have guns".

   ∀ gun-holder | gun-holder ∈ criminals
But you're suggesting that:

   ∃ criminal | criminal ∉ gun-holder
... and that is not in conflict with the above. Your evidence only invalidates:

   ∀ criminal | criminal ∈ gun-holder
... which no one has claimed.

BTW in general I think we should have some saner restrictions on firearms in the US even if we have to amend the BOR to do it. But I will concede that the abundance of legal firearms will be challenging to suddenly prohibit and could certainly flourish among criminals. I'd like to consider your argument but "Criminals in Germany usually don't have guns" doesn't help much.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by stevenicr on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:19AM (#31475320)
you actually made the point of it.. when the populace is unarmed, the thugs can bully / rob / coerce just using muscle and knives, which makes the law abiding citenzry less safe imho.. but of course some will see it that way and some will not - much of individuals view point depends on where live / work.. people in nice places, surrounded by other nice places are more insulated from the more prevalent daily violence of the less nice places - the people who live and work in thos different places often see it differently.

anyway the saying is still true - outlaw X and only outlaws will have X - just like we outlawed drugs and have had a big expensive war on them for a long time - they are outlawed and wow, outlaws have them.

Sure you'd see some street crews using guns less if very few people had them, but you'd defeinely have gangs that had guns, there's just too much money in the game, and you already have supply chains getting kilos of other things to you that are not supposed to exist in the country.

Also if the criminal groups in Germany had Honduras, Mexico, El Salvador and their neighbors a train ride away, they would absolutely be using guns more imho.

Every place on earth is apples to oranges when trying to compare the situation in the US in regards to these interconnected issues.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by soco on Monday May 23, 2022 @08:45AM (#31478284)
When the thugs actually use their muscle to rob you, you get a twisted arm. When the thugs actually use their gun, you get dead. One is less healthy than the other.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by stevenicr on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:45PM (#31481401)
Well for me that twisted arm would likely lead to a slow painful death (maybe 70/30 chances).

There is a chance I could beg for charity at Vanderbilt to donate $10,000 hemophilia treatments (of which it may take several for days) to keep me from nonstop internally bleeding to death - and there is a chance it would prevent death and just keep me in excruciating pain physically, mentally and emotionally instead of complete death.

There is a chance I could get charity to live through it, although I put the chances at less than 50%. There are other possible outcomes - partial treatment, and lawsuits over the hospital bills, and doctor bill. I would likely try to skip the hospital, apply ice every other 10 minutes and try to meditate my blood to flow slower. This could lead to nerve damage, and PTSD plus, but maybe not death.

Frankly I'd rather them have a gun or knife and let things get decided faster.

Many of the women I know would rather have the option to be armed to prevent twisted arms, and threats of severe violence.

However I can understand that there are people int he world who would rather be at risk of mugging via force to prevent their neighbors from having firearms. I do think this varies much depending on the amount of localized violence and is likely different for the folks living in nice parts of the world then people who live in cheaper parts of the world / cities.

I've also never thought when walking through New Orleans, SE D.C., or Memphis or St Louis that if one was to engage in a physical altercation with 'thugs' - that a simple 'twisted arm' would be the result.

Wish I had the resources to poll the locals to know how many of them think that would be a common result.

I understand things are different in different places, maybe parts of Germany and Russia have strong guys that twist arms and they get compliance. I would not expect that around here.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by darksaints on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:23PM (#31472947)
What about your neighbors in Austria, Finland, Iceland, Czech Republic, Switzerland, or Norway? Because tons of those neighbors also own guns, but you aren't really any more likely to get shot there than you are in Germany (all of those countries have less than 3 deaths by firearms per 100k people). And if you're just looking at crime that is not intentionally self-inflicted, you're looking at less than 1 death per 100k.

Almost all international statistics on gun ownership and gun violence in developed countries show a direct relationship between the two...at least until you take out the largest outlier, the United States. Then that relationship completely disappears.

Because you aren't more likely to die because more people own guns. You're more likely to die when your neighbors are poor. A more rigorous approach, which keeps the US "outlier" but also doesn't discard developing countries shows an extremely strong relationship with crime: poverty. Specifically the number of people living below the poverty line. The US, despite it's level of wealth and development, has a huge poverty problem, and that poverty problem turns into violent crime problems in the US just like it does literally everywhere else in the world.

Your neighbors in Austria, Finland, Iceland, Czech Republic, Switzerland, and Norway have figured it out: actual functioning gun regulation that still liberally allows for gun ownership (even scary assault weapons!), but stronger emphasis on a well functioning economic society. It's quite a bit ironic that the gun control policies that the US left so vigorously pushes for won't really have a measurable effect, but the poverty-reduction measures that they have all but abandoned actually would. I really wish they could be steered in the right direction, but I've given up hope.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by em-bee on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:24PM (#31474175)
gun laws across the EU are pretty similar because they are all based on the same EU laws. switzerland is actually the most liberal and it doesn't have more guns either.

there are no more guns in austrian cities than there are in germany, or as far as i could tell, anywhere else in europe. maybe more people in the country side have guns because they use them for hunting. a lot of guns are also used for sport. you would only see those on shooting ranges. otherwise they are locked away.

i do agree with the idea about poverty. that makes a lot of sense and is sometimes that can and should be addressed.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by em-bee on Monday May 23, 2022 @04:40AM (#31476604)
"sometimes" was meant to be "something". i blame a slip on the word suggestions from my keyboard
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by soco on Monday May 23, 2022 @09:03AM (#31478470)
Just so I understand: while those countries you named try to solve poverty (and thus protect the richer) on the state level, the US leaves this responsibility to the riches themselves - which will have to stock on weaponry obviously. So basically pushing for more personal freedom brings as a collateral those street wars. Another example where applied philosophy fails (thinking about communism as well)
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:15PM (#31471679)
Eh. I live in a state where a lot of people own firearms, myself included, and have open carry laws as well as concealed carry permits. It really isn't a big deal. Unfortunately humans are humans and, worse, Americans are Americans, and crazy people go crazy and do crazy person shit with a lot more regularity than we'd like, which is only compounded by easy access to firearms. But I'm willing to bet most of my neighbors own guns, including the right-wing troll[0] living up the street. I have no real fear that any of them are going to pull a gun on me.

[0] No seriously, this guy puts up intentionally inflammatory yard signs.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by giraffe_lady on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:56PM (#31472087)
I grew up in a place where gun ownership was the norm, and I have had a gun pulled on me in anger following a mutual fault car accident. People fuck up and get mad, confrontation happens. It is better for everyone if having firearms at hand is not the norm.

Aside from that I also caught a stray bullet in the hand when I was 15. I was in the woods, it was hunting season, I should have known better, etc etc. Hundreds of miles of beautiful nature that it was my fault I was injured while exploring.

The rural american attitude towards guns is indefensible. It just is. I'm as much a product of that culture as anyone, and in some ways as country as they come. But the problem isn't "crazy people" it is the guns.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by kcplate on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:15PM (#31473345)
>I grew up in a place where gun ownership was the norm

Same here, rural America Deep South: Most people I know are armed and concealed carry almost all the time. In over 4 decades here, I have never seen a person even brandish a weapon.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by giraffe_lady on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:10AM (#31505678)
How's this comment sitting for you a couple days later?
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by jonhohle on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:18PM (#31472315)
I know you’re being sarcastic, but it most definitely was the fault of the shooter who did not follow basic firearm safety rules (either not knowing what they were shooting at or what was beyond what they were shooting at). Firearm ownership is a right, but also must be taken seriously and responsibly. Regardless of the “mistake”, the offender should have been charged (hopefully with a felony).
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by soco on Monday May 23, 2022 @09:07AM (#31478512)
If there are say 1% stupid people who won't follow safety rules, the sheer amount of personal danger is quite different if you have 100 gun owners or 10.000.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by jonhohle on Monday May 23, 2022 @10:26AM (#31479445)
And thankfully that number is far, far below 1%, more like 0.04%. The US has by far the highest number of guns per capita, but no where near the highest number of gun deaths.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by giraffe_lady on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:10AM (#31505679)
Like where you stand on this one this morning?
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by jcims on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:05PM (#31472185)
>The rural american attitude towards guns is indefensible. It just is.

Case closed! Damn, all that time wasted arguing. lol

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by giraffe_lady on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:09AM (#31505672)
How you feeling about this one today?
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by burner556 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:28PM (#31471235)
If you were armed too they probably would think twice.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by andrewstuart2 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:31PM (#31471253)
I really doubt the narrative that someone who would pull out a gun over trash would spare the time to think twice.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by prepend on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:57PM (#31472697)
The pull a gun over trash scenario is kind of ridiculous because the gun puller would be arrested. And it just doesn’t happen.

It would go like this: 1) I leave trash out 2) Neighbor yells and pulls out gun 3) I put up trash 4) I call police, neighbor is arrested and gun is taken away forever.

I think there’s a perception of “crazy people owning guns” means they are just randomly doing things. Gun owners are typically pretty responsible or self-destructive.

Half the US owns guns and there aren’t many crimes percentage wise. So the vast, vast majority just never do stuff with their gun.

The actual argument is about the extreme outliers who murder people and commit mass shootings. There’s 20M firearm homicides [0] so that’s still super rare as a rate but the impact of each event is super impactful.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/homicide.htm

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by soco on Monday May 23, 2022 @09:09AM (#31478529)
They would get arrested maybe - but only after I was already shot.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by throw0101a on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:41PM (#31473098)
> The pull a gun over trash scenario is kind of ridiculous because the gun puller would be arrested. And it just doesn’t happen.

"Doesn't" is a strong word:

* https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/colorado-cop-who-pulled...

* https://www.fox4now.com/news/local-news/cape-coral-resident-...

> I think there’s a perception of “crazy people owning guns” means they are just randomly doing things. Gun owners are typically pretty responsible or self-destructive.

The problem is there is no filter in the US for the people that are not "pretty responsible or self-destructive." Just about any rando can get a gun in many states.

> The actual argument is about the extreme outliers who murder people and commit mass shootings.

No, it's about the 'background noise' of destruction that is on proverbial page 17 of the newspaper:

> A member of our well regulated militia allows a juvenile access to a loaded gun. The juvenile brings the gun to the home of a 14 year old friend, who shoots himself in the head unintentionally. He doesn’t survive.

* https://twitter.com/Well_Regulated_/status/15183659425894113...

> A member of our well regulated militia moves a loaded gun from a bedroom to a bathroom, then leaves it there. Her 6 year old son finds the gun when he goes to take a shower and shoots himself in the head. He does not survive.

* https://twitter.com/Well_Regulated_/status/15229931050662502...

> A (drunk) member of our well regulated militia spots her neighbor grilling burgers, so she walks over and points a handgun at his face and says "bang bang." When police arrive at her home, she points a cane at them and pretends it's a long gun.

* https://twitter.com/Well_Regulated_/status/15158166918082273...

See also:

* https://www.gunviolencearchive.org/reports/mass-shooting

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by menacingly on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:40PM (#31471348)
so we can speculate far enough to imagine this person into existence, but no further
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by Simon_O_Rourke on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:38PM (#31471333)
That sort of thinking directly brought about WW1 as well as the Cuban missile crisis.

If everyone was armed then society's short-fused lunatics are the ones most likely to misjudge a situation and start shooting first over something trivial.

Goes a long way to explaining most shootings by the police too.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by therealjumbo on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:59PM (#31471543)
CCW is very common in the US now, CCW holders are less likely to commit crimes than police officers. In general CCW or constitutional carry states don't see big wild west shoutouts at grocery stores so no. People are generally good and honest. Criminals are the exception to that, except they don't really care about whether or not carrying a weapon is illegal.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by nadavwr on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:22PM (#31471742)
A quick google search brought up a statistic from Pittsburgh 2008 where roughly 1/5 of perpetrators were the legal owners of the gun used in a crime.

Gun crimes are so much more prevalent in the US vs practically any other developed country. Usually by leaps and bounds. Australia used to have around 20% of US gun death rate for years. In 1996 they introduced strict gun control laws. Decline in gun deaths was gradual, but over some 15 years they went down by some 70%.

Gun control can work.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by Glyptodon on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:00PM (#31472133)
Legal owner is not the same thing as CC permit holder, and CC permit holders to seem to be safer than other gun owning or carrying categories and rarely involved in altercations or crimes.

Australia is a highly ambiguous example of gun control success for numerous reasons.

It's also worth noting that the funding and law enforcement capacity to disarm the US were stringent gun control legal is borderline impossible, if not just impossible, from a purely mathematical perspective when compared to things the like the war on drugs and considering the sheer number of guns owned.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by yucky on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:32PM (#31471860)
>In 1996 they introduced strict gun control laws. Decline in gun deaths was gradual, but over some 15 years they went down by some 70%.

Gun deaths worldwide fell precipitously during that same time frame, including in the US. 1994 was the peak of gun violence, and fell almost every years since then until the BLM riots and the ACAB crowd scared cops out of doing their job.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by stevenicr on Monday May 23, 2022 @01:03AM (#31475481)
correlation does not equal causation. Economy, pop culture, social safety nets, offline-social networks, and so many other things are factors in all this.

the 90's were not the same at 2009 and not the same as 2021 by many means.

I just searched : https://www.startpage.com/do/dsearch?query=Pittsburgh+2008+w... - and even the left wing news is saying that gun rights folks are accurate in that most gun crime is committed by non-legal-firearms owners, like 8 out of 10.

It's a weird stat to consider anyhow. In my experiences, many crimes are not officially reported, and many are not reported completely - so all that is screwed anyhow. There is no way to know how many crimes are committed in each city with illegal gun possessors.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by jka on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:10PM (#31471632)
That may be true, although it doesn't really address the parent commentor's line of argument: in environments where few (if any) people are allowed to have guns, concealed carry isn't necessary, and gun crime is rare.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by therealjumbo on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:55AM (#31475448)
His argument was that a lot of people being armed leads to regular standoffs. CCW being very common and leading to almost no standoffs over stupid arguments absolutely does address it. I'm ignoring comparing individuals to nation states, which is just silly.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by CalChris on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:51PM (#31472030)
Are they less likely than non-CCW permit holders?
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by JKCalhoun on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:19PM (#31471713)
Reading a lot lately about "criminals" then brandishing during road rage incidents.
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by Arubis on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:08PM (#31471612)
> CCW holders are less likely to commit crimes than police officers.

What’s “commit” here? Accusation, conviction, something else?

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by nadavwr on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:06PM (#31471604)
What makes you think they'd think even once?
Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by User23 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:05PM (#31471588)
I literally can’t imagine Germans pulling a gun without just cause. We’re talking about people who won’t even jaywalk. I suppose most Berliners aren’t German anymore though.

Edit: If I’m somehow wrong I respectfully ask that you please correct me.

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by Simon_O_Rourke on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:36PM (#31472482)
You asked respectfully, so I'll respond with total respect.

I found some of the Berliners/Germans near where I lived (less affluent part of the city) to be very quick to extreme anger over any perceived social slight, amplified more so if done by an obvious foreigner like myself.

Mostly it's these older guys, who grew up in a totally different culture, and absolutely it's only a tiny fraction overall.

For example, I read this only today, and it really resonated with what I (very very occasionally) experienced.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/22/in-no-city-hav...

Re:Guns, Privacy, and Crime by cf141q5325 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:13PM (#31472854)
>We’re talking about people who won’t even jaywalk.

Come on man. This is a stupid stereotype.

To relate to the initial post, it is also very wrong that only police and the most dangerous parts of organized crime are armed. Germany has masses of inherited guns. They are just not visible. Breaking and entering are also a very real and common thing, although focused on when the owners are (presumed) away.