Surely other factors could contribute to make such a situation more or less a threat - things said, or even a particular location compared to another.
I understand the GP comment person feels that such a thing is threatening, but I disagree with the blanket statement there too.. someone holding a firefarm does not mean they intend to, or are threatening to use it, imho..
just like someone pulling a phone out of their pocket and holding towards the ground does not mean they are going to call 911 - now that would be different if they pulled it out and said they were going to call.. but the act of pulling it out of one' pocket and holding it doesn't not imply they are going to use it for nefarious purposes in of itself.
Although I would consider them more ready to - and therefor deserving more acute attention and awareness.
Not a lawyer so I don't know for sure.. I just feel that someone holding a firearm in a downward position is not a direct threat like someone pointing it at a person - which then becomes brandishing / illegal in most circumstances afaik.
Brandishing alone could be considered an assault I suppose, but I don't really see that much in case law. I think because its pretty rare for somebody to brandish a weapon with intent to harm and then not follow up with further criminal actions.
Unholstering or otherwise displaying a firearm is assault by definition unless there’s a justifiable reason to do so.
Edit: re: assault: https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-charges/assault-an... “In most states, an assault or battery is committed when one person physically strikes or attempts to physically strike another, or when they act in a threatening manner to put another in fear of immediate harm.”