https://www.washingtonpost.com/crime-law/2018/09/21/you-pull...
https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/national/artic...
https://www.pnj.com/story/news/crime/2022/03/04/three-charge...
https://www.fox35orlando.com/news/lake-county-man-shot-kille...
https://www.waaytv.com/news/update-man-shot-accidentally-in-...
Etc.
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saQ72NZtrS0
Never ending:
Surely other factors could contribute to make such a situation more or less a threat - things said, or even a particular location compared to another.
I understand the GP comment person feels that such a thing is threatening, but I disagree with the blanket statement there too.. someone holding a firefarm does not mean they intend to, or are threatening to use it, imho..
just like someone pulling a phone out of their pocket and holding towards the ground does not mean they are going to call 911 - now that would be different if they pulled it out and said they were going to call.. but the act of pulling it out of one' pocket and holding it doesn't not imply they are going to use it for nefarious purposes in of itself.
Although I would consider them more ready to - and therefor deserving more acute attention and awareness.
Not a lawyer so I don't know for sure.. I just feel that someone holding a firearm in a downward position is not a direct threat like someone pointing it at a person - which then becomes brandishing / illegal in most circumstances afaik.
Brandishing alone could be considered an assault I suppose, but I don't really see that much in case law. I think because its pretty rare for somebody to brandish a weapon with intent to harm and then not follow up with further criminal actions.
Unholstering or otherwise displaying a firearm is assault by definition unless there’s a justifiable reason to do so.
Edit: re: assault: https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-charges/assault-an... “In most states, an assault or battery is committed when one person physically strikes or attempts to physically strike another, or when they act in a threatening manner to put another in fear of immediate harm.”
I thought the major pro-gun argument was that criminals don't care for law? You know, the whole "If you outlaw guns only outlaws will have guns" thing. (Which is also patently false, by the way. Criminals in Germany usually don't have guns.)
Um, that doesn't invalidate "If you outlaw guns only outlaws will have guns".
∀ gun-holder | gun-holder ∈ criminals
But you're suggesting that: ∃ criminal | criminal ∉ gun-holder
... and that is not in conflict with the above. Your evidence only invalidates: ∀ criminal | criminal ∈ gun-holder
... which no one has claimed.BTW in general I think we should have some saner restrictions on firearms in the US even if we have to amend the BOR to do it. But I will concede that the abundance of legal firearms will be challenging to suddenly prohibit and could certainly flourish among criminals. I'd like to consider your argument but "Criminals in Germany usually don't have guns" doesn't help much.
anyway the saying is still true - outlaw X and only outlaws will have X - just like we outlawed drugs and have had a big expensive war on them for a long time - they are outlawed and wow, outlaws have them.
Sure you'd see some street crews using guns less if very few people had them, but you'd defeinely have gangs that had guns, there's just too much money in the game, and you already have supply chains getting kilos of other things to you that are not supposed to exist in the country.
Also if the criminal groups in Germany had Honduras, Mexico, El Salvador and their neighbors a train ride away, they would absolutely be using guns more imho.
Every place on earth is apples to oranges when trying to compare the situation in the US in regards to these interconnected issues.
There is a chance I could beg for charity at Vanderbilt to donate $10,000 hemophilia treatments (of which it may take several for days) to keep me from nonstop internally bleeding to death - and there is a chance it would prevent death and just keep me in excruciating pain physically, mentally and emotionally instead of complete death.
There is a chance I could get charity to live through it, although I put the chances at less than 50%. There are other possible outcomes - partial treatment, and lawsuits over the hospital bills, and doctor bill. I would likely try to skip the hospital, apply ice every other 10 minutes and try to meditate my blood to flow slower. This could lead to nerve damage, and PTSD plus, but maybe not death.
Frankly I'd rather them have a gun or knife and let things get decided faster.
Many of the women I know would rather have the option to be armed to prevent twisted arms, and threats of severe violence.
However I can understand that there are people int he world who would rather be at risk of mugging via force to prevent their neighbors from having firearms. I do think this varies much depending on the amount of localized violence and is likely different for the folks living in nice parts of the world then people who live in cheaper parts of the world / cities.
I've also never thought when walking through New Orleans, SE D.C., or Memphis or St Louis that if one was to engage in a physical altercation with 'thugs' - that a simple 'twisted arm' would be the result.
Wish I had the resources to poll the locals to know how many of them think that would be a common result.
I understand things are different in different places, maybe parts of Germany and Russia have strong guys that twist arms and they get compliance. I would not expect that around here.