News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by Animats on Sunday May 22, 2022 @02:50AM (#31465562)
The big question with Tether has been, if they are holding commercial paper, whose commercial paper? Traders who deal in commercial paper of real companies that do real stuff don't see Tether present in that market. The dollar amounts are too big to hide. The suspicion is that their "commercial paper" is high-interest loans to other cryptocurrency companies. With the whole crypto sector in decline, those loans are at risk.

This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market.

About 11% of Tether has been cashed out in the last month.

The real problem for Tether is simple. Why would anyone buy Tether at this point? There's zero upside potential, after all. And the competition, USDC and GUSD, looks better backed. So a steady outflow is to be expected. We're going to find out how strong their backing is.

Watch out for heavily promoted Tether-based "staking" schemes designed to prevent cash-out.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by delusional on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:30AM (#31466373)
> Why would anyone buy Tether at this point? There's zero upside potential, after all.

Tether, and "stablecoins" in general are known as the casino chips of Crypto. A way to exchange more volatile crypto for what is supposed to be essentially dollars without creating a taxable event. Assuming crypto is still something people want to trade, that's still a valuable service. Tether isn't supposed to be an investment. It's a money laundering scheme to facilitate the other investments outside of the taxable economy and outside of KYC regulation. Seen from that vantage point, staking pools and "potential upside" is actually not desirable.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by grey-area on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:38AM (#31466407)
Technically, isn’t selling one asset and buying another precisely the definition of a taxable event?

I don’t see how tether helps you avoid taxes unless you’re going to lie about your transactions and hope nobody notices.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by slyfocks on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:42AM (#31466426)
It is indeed a taxable event. People who exchange crypto for “stable”coins are generally doing so to stay out of the KYC banking realm so they can lie about their transactions to their country’s tax authorities.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by robinduckett on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:51AM (#31466479)
In the UK, it is only a taxable event when the coin is exchanged to a "readily convertible asset", i.e. Bitcoin, Mainnet ETH.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by cmsd2 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:54AM (#31467622)
I don’t know where you got this advice from but this is precisely wrong from my reading of the rules. An asset exchange between two non legal tender assets is treated exactly the same as any other disposal and acquisition and absolutely is a chargeable event.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by grey-area on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:28AM (#31526279)
All currencies are readily convertible assets by definition.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by leereeves on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:49AM (#31467574)
Tether isn't readily convertible?
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by cma on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:34AM (#31468016)
Not if we dont even know what it is backed by, readily convertible one minute, can't dump it for $.01 the next once it happens.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by cmsd2 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:43AM (#31468108)
Please tell me this is a joke. The fact tether trades readily on an exchange is a major factor for it being convertible, even if at a price you don’t like.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by toss1 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:35PM (#31474522)
>>tether trades readily on an exchange is a major factor for it being convertible

... for now

We've seen lots of the crypto exchanges fail to make exchanges for hours to days when things get hot

Official stock exchanges have a standard practice of halting trading in stocks when unusual events happen. Sometimes this cools the market and things get back to normal, sometimes the thing has gone to zero when

If Tether crashes to $0.01, I'd be a bit surprised if it didn't stop being convertible for a significant time.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by mateuszf on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:44AM (#31466435)
Maybe in US, but not in all countries.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dropnerd on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:55AM (#31466508)
i pay my taxes. i make money providing liquidity between eth and usdc.

when i'm not lp'ing, i see no reason to switch to usd so long as us-based attestations continue to be solid. the opportunity cost of being in usd on coinbase is missing lucrative nft deals.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by zht on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:12AM (#31467808)
How solid can an attestation be vs an audit?
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dropnerd on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:20AM (#31468449)
audit is obviously better, am confident that tether will not be the first to introduce an audited stablecoin
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by Jommi on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:40AM (#31467053)
You're on the internet sir, this is not only an American website.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by jallen_dot_dev on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:24AM (#31468491)
I think a lot of Americans are in for a surprise when they finally report their gains, the IRS audits them and does a little digging ("You reported a sale of USDT, where did the USDT come from? You say you traded BTC for it? You never reported a sale of BTC."), and they find out they have owed taxes on trades for years, plus penalties and interest.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by tzs on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:26AM (#31468516)
If you sell something for actual money, and use that actual money to buy something else, that sale would usually be a taxable event (well, it would be a realization event which may or may not be a taxable event, but in casual conversation just saying "taxable event" is fine).

If actual money is not involved, for example I trade my X with you for your Y, then it gets quite interesting. In the US there are generally two ways that tax law handles this. I don't know how far along the law is with fitting all the various cryptocurrency things into this.

One way is to treat it for tax purposes as if I sold X at its fair market value and you sold Y at its fair market value, and then I bought Y and you bought X. I'm taxes on my gains from that imputed sale, and take that price as my basis in Y. Similar for you.

The other way to treat it is as a non-realization event, putting off any tax consequences until I actually sell Y or trade it for something that gets handled as an imputed sale. My basis in Y is the same as the basis I had in X.

What determines which of these applies is whether or not the exchange is a "like-kind exchange". If the exchange is a like-kind exchange it gets the "swap basis" approach. If it is not like-kind it gets the "imputed sale" approach.

Sometimes this is clear cut. Suppose I bought an old guitar at garage sale 50 years ago for a couple dollars that is nowadays a valuable vintage guitar worth $100k, and 50 years ago you bought a new comic book that is now worth $100k to collectors.

If we trade, that would be an imputed sale because guitars and comic books are not like-kind.

When things are in the same category it gets much harder, and the case law is full of courts having to go deeply into philosophical questions of what makes things like-kind.

Say we trade paintings. Are all paintings like-kind? Or would a Monet not be like-kind with a Picasso because they are different artists and/or different styles? Is a male horse like kind with a female horse? Is an electric guitar like kind with an acoustic guitar? Is a comic book that is valuable because of the first appearance of a character like-kind with a comic book that is valuable because of who inked it?

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:26AM (#31467374)
You don't report income on every item you shuffle.

In the spirit of US law (since crypto is t precisely classified), if you are a professional trader, you only pay taxes on your overall annual trading profits, not each individual trade. Same as how a a retail store doesn't have gains and losses on every individual item in inventory.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dubswithus on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:25AM (#31467925)
No, that’s not true. The IRS has given guidance on this.

> explaining that virtual currency is treated as property for Federal income tax purposes and providing examples of how longstanding tax principles applicable to transactions involving property apply to virtual currency.[0]

Also, every crypto tax software does exactly what you say is not required. A bit of signal there.

[0] https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/freq...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by amluto on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:30AM (#31468553)
I am not a tax expert, but you should read this:

https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc429

If you use one of the various mark-to-market rules, then you may well “only pay taxes on your overall annual trading profits”, but you pay it every year on unrealized gains too. Choose your poison.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by thallium205 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:03AM (#31467713)
Don't you have to have some special tax license to treat earnings that way?
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by jallen_dot_dev on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:20AM (#31468444)
You've never heard of a 8949, have you?
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by nikanj on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:39AM (#31466414)
You answered your own question
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by somewhereoutth on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:50AM (#31467120)
Casino chips is right. Imagine you are in a casino happily playing, and then rumors go around that the house can't cover the dollar value of the chips in everyone's hands. Pandemonium ensues.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by puranjay on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:19AM (#31466638)
I think what OP meant was why would anyone hold Tether at this point instead of a more transparent and less fudded stabelcoin like USDC
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by jimmydorry on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:13AM (#31467826)
The temptation is too great. If the stablecoin has a non-zero administrative cost, someone has to pay it. And if no-one wants to pay it, then it is going to have to invest a portion of the dollars it holds to make up the difference (and to ultimately reward the creators / seed investors).

There are probably no 100% cash-backed stablecoins.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:37AM (#31468054)
This is the breakdown for USDC. Luckily for crypto, USDC keeps climbing the charts and USDT will be a memory soon. Bad money is always exchanged out for good.

>Jeremy Allaire @jerallaire 3/ As of 12:00pm EST Friday, May 13, 2022, the USDC reserve consisted of $11.6 billion cash (22.9%), $39.0 billion U.S. Treasuries (77.1%), for a total of $50.6 billion (100%), and there were 50.6 billion USDC in circulation

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by kgwgk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:25AM (#31469161)
> $39.0 billion U.S. Treasuries

Par value or market value? If it’s the former the current value is surely less.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by ac29 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:39PM (#31471925)
Why? Treasury bills are the appropriate choice here and are always bought at a discount to par.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by kgwgk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:24PM (#31472360)
If you bought $1000 worth of 1-year treasury bills (maturing in 12m) six months ago you have less than $1000 worth of treasury bills (maturing in 6m) today. That could be a problem if you need to recover today at least the $1000 that you put. (There may be no problem with much shorter maturities - or could be worse with bonds with longer maturity. The quote didn’t give any details.)
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dalbasal on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:14AM (#31465990)
Either way, unless they are fully backed by USD... stablecoin is just an unregulated bank and it can run.

If that's not the case, they have as much rope as they have ability to liquidate. IE they can keep buying their own coin to defend the price for as long as they can.

Imo, stablecoins are a good example of everyone knowing the score but systemic risk accrues regardless. Stabkecoins just the worst kind of risk. Low risk/reward on a daily basis. Risk of catastrophic collapse on a bad day. It's the type of risk that gets financial companies/complexes into trouble.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by eru on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:37AM (#31467482)
Properly unregulated banks are actually less likely to experience runs.

Backing by USD is not required. As you say, anything they can liquidate is good. Doesn't have to be USD. This works best when you are over-capitalised, ie when you have a thick equity cushion, so that when your assets go down in terms of USD, you still have enough balance sheet assets left to cover all your USD obligations.

You are right that trying to be stable makes things more systematically risky. If Tesla stock drops by 20% over night, some people are going to lose money, but the finance system won't collapse. If supposedly stable assets drop by 20%, everything can go wrong.

That's part of why government backed deposit insurance for banks and too-big-to-fail are problems.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dalbasal on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:36AM (#31469289)
Being stable just gives it a certain risk profile: regular profits, with a chance of occasional apocalypse. Modest, of course, relative to the sum "under management." Two-and-twenty. The kind of game we've been known to lose.

I don't think it really matters what the underlying assets are. Once the bank runs, it'll probably run dry. "Equity cushions" don't work. The banks own shares suck as a hedge against a run. Assets do hedge against a run. But, once a run is truly happening... it's unlikely to stop. Eventually reserves run out. Assets, credit, etc. I don't buy the idea of assets "calming" a run. In a collapse, the assets are only good as a currency to literally pay out exiting holders.

That said, it's possible to keep the game going a long time. Decades even, depending on the levels of greed and luck.

Stablecoins are still new. The derivatives death star is still not fully operational.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by eru on Monday May 23, 2022 @12:24AM (#31475339)
I'm not sure you understand how an equity cushion works.

Suppose you start a company with 1,000 kg of gold. No other assets, no liabilities. Currently, that gold is worth about 60 million USD.

Now you issue 1,000,000 'stable' tokens. Each can be redeemed for one USD. For simplicity, assume that you just give them away.

At current gold prices, your tokens are 60x over-capitalised. If the gold price collapses 90%, your tokens are still 6x over-capitalised. That's what I mean by an equity cushion.

A 'run' is everyone trying to redeem their tokens. If that happens, you just sell one million dollars worth of gold, and pay that obligation. You are not running out of anything here.

In historical practice in eg Scotland, the banks that issued private bank notes there kept an equity cushion of about 30% around. That means for every 70 pounds in liabilities, they had 100 pounds of assets on their balance sheet. (For comparison, in our example of 60x over-capitalisation, that's an equity cushion of 59/60 = ~98%. Or for the 6x over-capitalisation, it's 5/6 = ~83%.)

It's called an equity cushion, because on a balance sheet the excess of assets shows up at equity.

That equity on the books is very different from the banks shares. It's the difference between 'book value' and 'market value'. See https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile... for a table with price-to-book-values (PBV). You can also look up that value for any specific firm online.

> I don't think it really matters what the underlying assets are. Once the bank runs, it'll probably run dry.

That might be true in the most trivial sense: if a bank has plenty of underlying assets, like our example that was 6-60x over-capitalised, there will never be a run. So the 'once the bank runs' condition would never happen.

---

Technical detail: I completely avoided the question of reserves here. Mostly, because it's not actually very interesting. The bank will keep some reserves on hand, so that they can pay out routine redemptions immediately. They would be well advanced to follow the role model of the Scottish banks: their notes came with an 'option clause'.

The 'option clause' says that the bank can either redeem notes right away at par, or they can opt to 'pay' with a super-senior IOU that accumulates a punitive interest rate but that the bank can choose to pay back any time.

That option gives the bank time to liquidate assets, if they ever ran out of reserves. The punitive interest rate re-assures customers that the bank would not abuse that privilege it willy-nilly.

(Of course, that mechanism only helps with illiquidity. It does not protect against insolvency. But that's fine: it's better for the economy when insolvent companies cease operations.)

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:29AM (#31467402)
Stablecoin is only risky while you hold it. You can convert to Bitcoin or Eth to adjust your risk profile, and take profits occasionally in national currency.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by oneoff786 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:42AM (#31467531)
Russian roulette is only dangerous while you’re playing. In fact, it’s honestly risk free unless it’s your turn.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by wallaBBB on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:08AM (#31465669)
Oh it’s even worse. For a while now some[0] have suggested part of the backing is in bonds issues by Chinese real estate companies

[0] https://twitter.com/thelastbearsta1/status/14690072004965908...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by kgc on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:36AM (#31465828)
It could be worse than that. It could be commercial paper from Bitfinex or one of their other related party holdings.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by zby on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:41AM (#31467063)
Bitfinex seems like a very good business. I mean at least since 2016 - but 8 years is enough. It is possible that they still mismanaged it catastrophically - but fees are really good in crypto exchanges and margin loses are socialized - so they are not a risk factor for the exchange.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by darawk on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:32AM (#31466078)
Chinese real estate would be considerably better than crypto company loans, tbh.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by wallaBBB on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:48AM (#31466157)
Chinese real estate companies are defaulting on their international bonds en masse and CN government has shown no interest in bailing them on that end.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by thematrixturtle on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:33AM (#31467437)
Better to be backed by overvalued, sketchy physical real estate than nothing at all (see also: TerraUSD).
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by jimmydorry on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:16AM (#31467850)
They are backed by companies with near-zero or less than zero valuation (liabilities > assets). Many of these companies that are defaulting have no money on hand but have already sold apartments that they have not even started building yet.

They are equivalent to a crypto that the market has lost faith in (both are worth nothing).

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dubswithus on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:27AM (#31467950)
According to Advchina, the underlying asset is of such poor quality that they will be torn down or abandoned. And from my understanding owning a property doesn’t mean you own it forever. It’s time limited by the government.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by CTDOCodebases on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:23AM (#31467358)
This comes from the rumor that the commercial paper is from China.

What I find more believable is the commercial paper is actually from crypto hedge funds and exchanges incorporated in Hong Kong.[0]

[0] - https://protos.com/tether-papers-crypto-stablecoin-usdt-inve...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by dehrmann on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:08PM (#31474703)
So tether could be theoretically backed by...bitcoin?
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by CTDOCodebases on Monday May 23, 2022 @10:26AM (#31479437)
Possibly somewhat. There is typically a differentiation between commercial paper and asset backed commercial paper so who knows. It might depend on the individual lending USDT.

I believe that these exchanges/crypto funds are borrowing USDT with interest payable in USD and principle payable in USDT. This would incentivise borrowers to buy USDT when the peg breaks to the down side thus keeping USDT pegged to the dollar.

I think it would be more accurate to say that USDT is not backed by anything. The loans are backed by commercial paper but if the borrowers are not fulfilling these debts in USD in reality there is no backing.

I presume the incentives that stop the peg breaking to the down side will only hold as long as the exchanges/crypto funds stay liquid. If there is a sustained mass exodus out of USDT I predict things will get ugly.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by NelsonMinar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:51AM (#31468811)
No the big questions with Tether are: do they have backing assets? How much? And where are they? Whose commercial paper is a second tier question.

In August 2021 The Economist estimated Tether to be leveraged 383-to-1. That's incredibly unstable. https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/08/07/why-regulators-...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by unityByFreedom on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:36AM (#31466102)
> This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market.

How does this happen again 15 years later? Is it because we ineffectively dealt with 2008? A result of the repeal of Glass-Steagall? Or have we over regulated banking to the point the miscreants went underground to build things like crypto?

I don't get it. Crashing over and over doesn't seem good for anyone.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by cormacrelf on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:04AM (#31466223)
The powers that be aren't trying to crash it all on purpose, nobody wants another 2008. They have produced a pretty hands-off response, because of a number of factors. Crypto has an explicit project to escape US regulation, so lots of money is in e.g. the Bahamas and difficult to target. Many companies are trying really hard to avoid even having US customers, so that's a hands-off win for regulation as the feds have nobody to protect from e.g. Binance directly. The big companies that do operate in the US have led a mostly successful campaign to position themselves as innovators and deserving of a long leash, IMO too successfully as only now is the SEC feeling the pressure to clamp down. There is a long tail of complex regulatory actions to take against really quite small individual operations. Finally I think a lot of this has been influenced to a huge degree by the cheapness of cash, and increasing interest rates will do a lot of the work people want to see from regulation by forcing people to make better investments and making bonds/deposits more appealing as people look for an alternative to the apparent huge risk that they're discovering they've been given a premium for taking on until now.

The answer on regulation is a mix, then. Some of it has been effective (if only at scaring off potential investor dangers completely), some of it is difficult, some of the response is underwhelming. So far there hasn't been a 2008-scale meltdown because it hasn't been a big enough market to have a domino effect, and I still don't think it is yet, so really now's the time to take preventive measures but it's not too late for that. It is too late to protect all the people who've lost big so far, but that is a much smaller number than those who suffered in 2008. In my opinion the movers and shakers who care about worldwide financial stability are tuning in around the right time and are overwhelmingly accepting that regulation is going to be necessary. I predict the EU and the US will both push some pretty solid efforts soon; EU through explicit regulation, US through maybe some legislation but definitely through better enforcement.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by pvarangot on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:03AM (#31467201)
Wouldn't regulating crypto need an influx of dollars from the exchanges or other liquidity providers back into the government? If that money doesn't exist or is hidden well enough regulation is only going to crash down liquidity providers and screw this people you are saying it should be designed to help.

The US is already very much ahead of most countries in regulating but not outright banning crypto. It's closer to banning it than let's say Switzerland. With the way they consider any sale a taxable event if US regulations were better for let's say the retail crypto trader as a whole they would all massively move to US regulated exchanges like Coinbase but that would remove a lot of "natural" circuit breakers like bots or manual arbits.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by cormacrelf on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#31469260)
A lot of what people are talking about is the 90% of securities regulation that lives in the information space, regulating what must be disclosed when & to whom, and ensuring people are not deceived en masse by those running an enterprise on their behalf. 2008 was largely one of these crises -- there was fraud in the creation and marketing of mortgage-backed securities, about what was in them and what the risks were. If you have enough of those, and enough big institutions dressing up these terrible securities in even more incomprehensible instruments, big ribbons & glossy materials, and marketing them to retail, then the original fraud is compounded in effect and more and more people start being exposed to it. Imagine there are 200 active Ponzi schemes and you sell a financial product offering 10-20% returns against a background Fed cash rate of effectively zero, and you manage to keep it up by investing in Ponzi after Ponzi, reaping the yield they give and propping them up with VC money when they teeter. If enough of them fail, so do you.

If you think that sounds a lot like 2008, well, yes it is. Fortunately this time it's not gone even close to under the radar. Remember 2008 was built on a much safer financial product. Like, there were a lot of good mortgages in America, and for a while there was a healthy market for packaging them up in bonds, it just turned very sour when the bad mortgages started making up the bulk of new bonds issued to meet huge demand and more was wrung from the sponge in derivative products at the same time. The idea of a collapse was unheard-of; the market had quietly undergone huge changes with only a dozen or something people worldwide really taking notice. We're in here with a thread every few days on HN talking about the possibility of a 2008. That's a difference.

Some of the discussion of crypto regulation is more about the "prudential" side i.e. talking about some crypto entities as if they're deposit-taking institutions (like retail aka commercial banks). That's quite recent, I think it's what you're referring to by "influx of dollars ... back into government" i.e. getting them on the Federal Reserve system, getting deposit insurance, and having to be so heavily scrutinised any crypto CEO would have a heart attack in the first 20 minutes. In 2008, some commercial banks got too far into mortgage securities, failed and got bailed out. Some commercial banks doing deposits & loans got bailed out, and some even got nationalised. That protection mostly just worked as planned. Given the fact of bailouts, the risk of bailouts had to be readjusted, of course, so the new laws were about what commercial banks couldn't invest in. Lehmann was of course an investment bank. The main message is that the root causes of the crisis were not perpetrated by commercial banks, so all the new regulation around them was about trimming the risk of bad securities turning into systemic meltdowns. That's a relevant thing to worry about today but note that actual banks are pretty well protected and not really allowed to freewheel like some did in 2008. If your normal bank is investing your deposits in crypto, I would be surprised.

People worry about Coinbase because it's seen as a kind of commercial bank but not regulated as one, so it (1) gets to freewheel on investments & capital requirements like no other commercial bank in the country, and (2) has no deposit protection for those who use it. So risky twice over. Frankly I don't think Coinbase could survive with its current business model as a regulated bank, same way Uber wouldn't survive if it were forced to compete without favour & VC dried up, so forcing Coinbase to to be might trigger the very collapse being protected against (by stopping it investing in all the schemes that make it money, killing those schemes and causing knock-on), and look kinda bad. It's a tricky one. Maybe if there's enough securities enforcement against the things that are keeping the party going, the fraudulent portions can gracefully collapse on their own and the government won't have to cop the blame for bringing on the death of a pretty popular industry by prudential regulation.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by unityByFreedom on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:40AM (#31468670)
> So far there hasn't been a 2008-scale meltdown because it hasn't been a big enough market to have a domino effect

Isn't it more that the crypto + companies with cult followings + chinese real estate bubbles simply have not yet popped? These assets are big enough to cause a sell-off in other areas. Maybe they haven't dipped low enough yet, or maybe the dips are gradual enough to be absorbed.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by KaiserPro on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:11AM (#31466262)
Its an unregulated market.

People are convinced that since its cryto, it won't be vulnerable to the same old issues that every other traded instrument has had since the south sea bubble/tulip mania.

the 2008 market crash was similar as you pointed out, in that it involved wholesale fraud (using a subset of good mortgages to market worthless ones) that were "validated" by ratings agencies.

Here, there were no real third parties to provide ratings. Just people saying "Look its crypto, you can loose because its backed by real something or other"

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by nickelpro on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:39AM (#31466119)
Technologically distinct market, even if economically parallel, Glass-Steagall wouldn't have prevented this. The crypto companies have operated almost entirely outside of regulatory oversight prior to the last 18 months or so.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by LatteLazy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:39AM (#31466121)
In this case the damage will be limited to a bunch crypto companies. The issue before was it hit companies we relied on for things like mortgages and current accounts. Crypto companies can just be allowed to fail and no one except their users will be effected.

Hence they are not regulated.

So even keeping GS (which was limited to big banks and a few similar institutions) wouldn't have made any difference. Not that keeping it would necessarily have been a bad ide...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by unityByFreedom on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:49AM (#31468794)
> In this case the damage will be limited to a bunch crypto companies. The issue before was it hit companies we relied on for things like mortgages and current accounts. Crypto companies can just be allowed to fail and no one except their users will be effected.

I don't buy the argument that crypto lives in a vacuum. People valuing that asset are part of the global economy.

The question is, is crypto really as valuable as the crypto exchange markets claim, and do companies assign face value to these assets, or do they account for the amount of risk they deserve?

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by LatteLazy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#31469253)
At the risk of getting semantic...

Value is not a single concept. The value of something to me is different to to you. And for both of us it changes over time. Value cannot really be defined, let alone measured.

So we are stuck with prices. And prices are sort of connected to value. But the connection is very non linear.

We can know the price of crypto (or gold or shares or credit default swaps). But it's value is purely a matter of personal taste...

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by hericium on Sunday May 22, 2022 @07:50AM (#31467117)
> How does this happen again 15 years later?

It didn't stop. Lehmans were thrown under the bus and business continued like there's no tomorrow with more and more financial instruments created and investment bankers putting their clients money in crap positions.

> I don't get it. Crashing over and over doesn't seem good for anyone.

There's money to be made on crashes, too. And if someone got rich before, they can patiently wait. There'll be money to be made before next crash, too. I doubt the pattern bothers them. Have you heared how Buffet assigns blame[1]?

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k2VSSNECLTQ

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by Paradigma11 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @06:43AM (#31466766)
In my very uninformed opinion the financial system is a big correlation machine. People buy stuff that is mechanically and logically unrelated to their other assets. Everybody does this, but when the crash hits they have to sell those assets too, to satisfy margin calls or other obligations.

Voila, instant correlation.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by nikanj on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:40AM (#31466419)
Crashes are a huge wealth transfer from the optimistic to the opportunistic. They’re very good for the few
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by thelamest on Sunday May 22, 2022 @05:53AM (#31466492)
True, but they’re still a negative sum event. (Putting aside libertarian-ish arguments, ironically overrepresented in crypto, that in the long term a crash is a healthy garbage-collection event.)
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by zaphar on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:34AM (#31467454)
Crashing early is better than crashing later because it limits the damage and moderately frequent crashes creates some level of caution in the market. Propping up a market because it's too big to fail can in some cases create worse fallout. It's a judgement call though and I'm not entirely sure we have a really good rule of thumb here.

If there were a way to have enough transparency that we had smaller crashes more frequently it would probably help to limit the damage to those who can afford to lose it.

The truth is that you can only push a correction so far out. It will happen eventually and the farther out you push it the worse it will be.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by unityByFreedom on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:53AM (#31468834)
Also, I doubt you can predict a crash and make bank on it without having a whole bunch of people point in your direction. You'd have to have been speaking about it publicly prior to and have had zero inside information on some too-big-to-fail organization failing. I know people feel the US justice system doesn't hold the wealthy accountable, but I also think the wealthy are pretty good at knowing where the line is drawn. You can have all the money in the world but it's no fun if everyone's out to get you.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by lupire on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:32AM (#31467428)
Negative-sum events are extremely popular with the winning side, and the winnings are momey, which converts to power.
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by marvin on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:09AM (#31468339)
> How does this happen again 15 years later?

It's human nature to create and participate in systems that are untenable over time but are tempting for short-term speculation.

Normally, in advanced economies, we try to use regulation to prevent or limit these events. But crypto explicitly avoids regulation, so of course it's going to pop up there. It's got nothing to do with not cleaning up after 2008.

Cryptocurrency is a new asset class, of course it's going to go through some of the painful learning experiences that traditional finance has. I've been saying since 2013 that we're going to see the exact mistakes of finance repeated with cryptocurrency.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by unityByFreedom on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:43AM (#31468711)
> Normally, in advanced economies, we try to use regulation to prevent or limit these events. But crypto explicitly avoids regulation, so of course it's going to pop up there. It's got nothing to do with not cleaning up after 2008.

The point I wanted to make is when you regulate too much you may encourage the growth of things that are unregulatable. Gambling and alcohol come to mind. I don't know that that's what happened, hence the question. Phrasing it another way, are we post-WW I (over regulated) or post-WW II (got it right, but you'll never be perfect)?

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by funstuff007 on Sunday May 22, 2022 @09:33AM (#31468003)
> Traders who deal in commercial paper of real companies that do real stuff don't see Tether present in that market. The dollar amounts are too big to hide.

Very similar to Madoff's derivatives transactions. He was so big, but there little evidence of him transacting his main "strategy" in the market.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by eru on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:32AM (#31467434)
> This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market.

Eh, the problems in 2008 were ultimately caused by (many) central banks around the globe letting nominal gdp drop. All loans (and dividends etc) are ultimately paid out of aggregate nominal income; so obviously they are all correlated with nominal gdp: it's basically the same as aggregate nominal income.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by LatteLazy on Sunday May 22, 2022 @04:41AM (#31466128)
Of course, if they have been making a profit for however long they've been open, they should have a rainy day fund to cover those risks...
Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by timoth3y on Sunday May 22, 2022 @12:42PM (#31470091)
> whose commercial paper?

Perhaps it's in the form of debt from exchanges. Tether could buy short-term notes from the exchanges paying them in Tether -- maybe at a slight premium to make sure the exchanges go along. The terms would stipulate that Tether could call the loan at any time allowing them to quickly pull Tether off the market as needed to maintain their peg.

How long the dance can go on would depend on the premium they've offered the exchanges and how much free Tether they've minted for themselves.

Obviously, this is all pure speculation.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by CTDOCodebases on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:06AM (#31467230)
Why would anyone buy Tether?

Because the most liquid trading pairs and futures use USDT. The same companies who borrow USDT from Tether happen to be the same people who run exchanges or act as market makers.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by aaaaaaaaata on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:24AM (#31468484)
They did — is that still true?

Will it still be true next month or next year?

Seems to me the slow abandonment of Tether has become faster.

Re:Top stablecoins shed $7B in May as traders redeem tokens ... by CTDOCodebases on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:18AM (#31469084)
Maybe. Or maybe the exchanges/market makers are buying back USDT in order to pay back their loans to Tether.