News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by zozbot234 on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:32AM (#31366080)
It's not that uncommon among people with Asperger-like traits, which Musk has publicly acknowledged in 2021.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by KaiserPro on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:53AM (#31366326)
> not that uncommon among people with Asperger-like traits

Lets get one thing straight. If you are on the spectrum, the reason you act like this is because you don't understand that you are doing something wrong. Its a spectrum, normally around social interaction, and not understanding, or being able to pick up on the slow of social information.

However for most high functioning people it is possible, with work, to mitigate those "negative" qualities.

It is not an excuse to be a dick. What Elon is doing is a choice. He is perfectly capable of interacting with people enough to have a series of relationships with people without making them feel like shit. I would therefore postulate that whilst he might be on the spectrum, he has worked hard to mitigate it.

What Elon is, is a rich school boy.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by kortex on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:11AM (#31366514)
> Lets get one thing straight. If you are on the spectrum, the reason you act like this is because you don't understand that you are doing something wrong.

This might be a nitpick, I wouldn't describe it as an "understanding" problem. Usually we understand that there are social cues and what they mean (at least in the mild cases). The difference is in the strength of that signal.

It's like as if people have a warning indicator when doing things socially inept. Most folks seem to have a loud klaxon "You are being an ass! Stop that!". With ASD, it's more like a quiet "check engine" light that's easy to overlook.

If you never experience the social pressure to actively look for that indicator light (see exhibit E.), you never really build strong social graces. Or, maybe you just don't give a damn about masking, too tired, just not interested.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:59AM (#31367693)
> Or, maybe you just don't give a damn about masking, too tired, just not interested.

I strongly feel this is the case with not only Musk, but a lot of high ranking "leaders"; I believe that you need an amount of ruthlessness, of indifference, an ability to turn off your morals to be in that position and get even richer. I mean just look at how he fucks his staff over and expects them to work ridiculous hours, bragging about how much he works (the difference being he gets paid for every second he is alive, while staff only gets paid for contract hours).

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by vidanay on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:11AM (#31366500)
My 13 year old child reached this epiphany just this week (ADHD, not Aspergers). They told me "whenever I think about something, I am really interested in it but then I simply stop thinking about it and do something else." They were a little upset because they wanted to continue with those interesting activities. We had a nice long talk about reaching a maturity point where their active thoughts can control their impulses.

Yes, it is more complex than simply "mind over matter", but it's still an important development milestone.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by chasd00 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:02AM (#31368560)
(total tangent but i've had a couple moments like this with my kids. It's amazing to see, i love it)
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Starlevel001 on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:22AM (#31367245)
> If you are on the spectrum, the reason you act like this is because you don't understand that you are doing something wrong.

completely untrue, nearly all autistic people I know including me are hyper-aware of social situations and specifically act in ways to avoid being a dick. this is a pop-psychology notion of autism.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by NoGravitas on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:37AM (#31367428)
Yeah, but that's because we spent our childhoods and young adulthoods dealing with the consequences of not understanding what we were doing wrong, and put effort into figuring out what we were doing wrong and fixing it.

Now, I don't think Musk never faced consequences when he was young, and never learned this stuff, but I do think he faces absolutely no consequences today, and is happy to not put in any effort.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by freeopinion on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:36AM (#31368216)
Your last sentence resonates with me. I would add that he might consider different efforts he might make and determine that it wouldn't change the results. He might offend a different 2/3 of the audience and please a different 1/3 of the audience. So why exhaust yourself all the time when the outcome is arguably indistinguishable?

Somebody on the outside might see a big difference in result, say a 50% approval rating vs a 35% approval rating. But from the inside it can all look the same: "everybody hates me anyway" or "most people love me anyway".

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by chasd00 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#31368606)
> Now, I don't think Musk never faced consequences when he was young, and never learned this stuff, but I do think he faces absolutely no consequences today, and is happy to not put in any effort.

my late step-father would say this person needs an "ass-whoopin"

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by tomp on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:08AM (#31366475)
> the reason you act like this is because you don't understand that you are doing something wrong

No, it's actually because you don't think it's wrong in the first place.

I understand why people prefer to lie to protect other's emotions, or why people prefer being high-status rather than being right, but I disagree with that, I think it's wrong.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by danparsonson on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:24AM (#31366630)
That's a false dichotomy - there is a whole range of options between 'lying to save someones feelings' and 'being rude'.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by alasdair_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:11AM (#31366512)
> If you are on the spectrum, the reason you act like this is because you don't understand that you are doing something wrong.

Sometimes, you know it’s wrong, at least at some level, but are so fucking tired of masking all the time you just do it anyway.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by HWR_14 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:02AM (#31367743)
> but are so fucking tired of masking all the time you just do it anyway.

I feel like "masking" is being used for "be polite". I didn't decide to be rude, I decided not to mask my disability.

That is bullshit.

People on the spectrum may have a harder time understanding what is rude, and that may give some passes when you don't realize it. But if you decide to ignore what you've learned is rude, you're just an ass.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by zozbot234 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:25AM (#31368058)
"Being polite" is emotional labor, whether or not that labor takes the form of "masking" a disability. While of course we should be respectful of those we engage with, avoidance of emotional labor should always take precedence over shallow notions of politeness that have nothing to do with actual respect for others.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by HWR_14 on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:30PM (#31369640)
> "Being polite" is emotional labor,

And "going to bathroom and not pissing on the floor" is physical labor. Even more so if you are on crutches.

I completely disagree with your artificial distinction between "being respectful to others" and "politeness". Politeness is defined as being respectful to others

We all benefit from a more polite interaction. To refuse to be polite because it requires effort is just taking advantage of the system without paying it back.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by marricks on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:40AM (#31366178)
That’s the thing though, you don’t have to seek attention or power. That’s not an Asperger trait. That’s the thing which really makes it inexcusable.

You can also be rich and relatively unknown, most rich people are. He chooses to be super public.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by wongarsu on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:52AM (#31366311)
I don't think being rich is his end goal. His goal is to do great things, to advance humanity (in very specific ways), maybe having a great legacy. Being rich helps him achieve these goals, but so does building hype and being present in the media. Being rich and unknown isn't a great strategy to achieve his goals.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by lapcat on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:23AM (#31366627)
> Being rich helps him achieve these goals, but so does building hype and being present in the media.

Does it? I know literally nothing about the personality of the Wright brothers. Or Henry Ford. Or Thomas Edison. Their legacy is their inventions. Hype and media coverage are temporary at best. And unfortunately, Musk's hype and media presence tends to show him at his worst. I'm not sure whether Musk fans realize how many non-fans actually despise the guy. If anything, he's wrecking his legacy. Shut up and build stuff.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:05AM (#31367781)
Alternative take, things like the space program; while there are some prominent names in there like Wernher von Braun and Louis Armstrong, the endeavour which changed human history was an endeavour by many people, not just a few individuals with Personalities. Same with other current endeavours like nuclear fusion and the LHC; I can't name any individual person behind those projects. They are a lot more selfless.

Meanwhile, there's great engineers working at both Tesla and SpaceX, but the only person you know is Elon.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by phil21 on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:56AM (#31366974)
I mean, Thomas Edison may as well be a 200 year old Elon Musk. Practically all he did was be a hype man.

Ford was pretty similar from my reading.

Both men had early career success and worked harder than most at achieving their goals. But their ongoing successes were very much political and public perception. Ford especially was incredibly politically active and noisy about it.

I imagine Elon's legacy (should he be remembered) will not be his twitter shitposting, but electric cars and rocketry.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by lapcat on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:13AM (#31367142)
> But their ongoing successes were very much political and public perception. Ford especially was incredibly politically active and noisy about it.

Nobody remembers Ford's political activism. Apparently he ran for US Senate once and lost. Is there any reason to think that Ford's political activism had anything to do with the success of the Ford Motor Company?

Ford hyping cars is fine and expected. Ford hyping politics doesn't really seem to add anything. In fact, it appears that there were some antisemitic writings associated with Ford, there was a lawsuit and a consumer boycott, and he was forced to apologize.

A common fallacy is to assume that everything a successful person does in life contributes to their success. OJ Simpson was one of the greatest football running backs ever, and he was also a murderer. You might say, "if he wasn't a violent person, then he wouldn't have been a great running back", but somehow Barry Sanders managed not to murder anyone.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Bubble_Pop_22 on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:19AM (#31367218)
Edison and Ford had the small detail that the product they sold became widespread among the population very quickly.

They represented the last effort after standing on the shoulders of giants, basically being the person who got to sign off the quality of life improvement and reap the financial reward. It happens, could have been somebody else but in the end it was them.

mr.Musk has been at the helm of Tesla for 20 years and his product is nor widespread (only 1% of total number of global vehicles sold in FY21) nor revolutionary from a quality of life standpoint (at the end of the day it's a car and you can hardly tell the difference between Tesla EVs and MercedesEQS, iBMW, Toyota EVs etc....if anything the Quality Of life gap is towards the other automakers)

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by freeopinion on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:57AM (#31368504)
That's like saying a 1930 Ford Model A is not that different from a 1930 Cadillac. That doesn't mean that Ford didn't change the automobile industry in a historic way before 1930.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Bubble_Pop_22 on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#31368596)
Where is Tesla's equivalent of the Model T, or Windows 95 or the Wright Brothers biplane, or the Montgolfier brothers hot air baloon?

The paradigm shift that gets to 95% marketshare before getting copied? Nowhere to be seen.

Tesla changed the way people feel about Tesla.

When people say they are not a car company they are right. They are a cult company. They sell cult. Of the techno-utopian kind.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by freeopinion on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:08PM (#31369377)
Yes. Tesla changed the way people feel about Tesla.

Importantly, some of those people were in positions of influence at other auto manufacturers. So Tesla didn't have to capture 95% marketshare to change the industry.

I think that the blinding glamour of a Tesla has faded quite a bit. I think, 20 years on, we expect to see strong competition to them. The lane assist, the adaptive cruise control, the touch screen console... these are a bit boring now. Others have had them for a long time. Some probably had them before Tesla. Hopefully, several competitors will start offering 500 km range EVs. Tesla can still cult that advantage.

But the cult of Tesla scared established players. Everyone has scrambled to adapt since. And the public has been persuaded to keep the pressure on. Tesla represents an historic shift. I don't have to like them or buy them. But I recognize their place in history.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by HWR_14 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:09AM (#31367850)
> at the end of the day it's a car and you can hardly tell the difference between Tesla EVs and MercedesEQS, iBMW, Toyota EVs etc..

I'll go a step further and I can hardly tell the difference between a Tesla and a used ICE car.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Bubble_Pop_22 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:35AM (#31368200)
I have not enough karma to make the point above and not risking ending up underwater.

But the hell with it...I can always delete it.

I think people are taking crazy pills, they religiously follow this guy and his delusions about becoming a multiplanetary specie before the Sun becomes a red giant....5 billions years from now.

As they have such thoughts they have to walk through human feces and scenes from the Walking Dead...only with the homeless instead of zombies.

Stuff that would scare them to death if they saw it in a movie or compel them to pity if they happened in the background of a live news reportage from Ukraine.

Instead it's happening under their nose as they wonder if Mars is ambitious enough or we should aim directly for the Andromeda Galaxy.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by MockObject on Friday May 13, 2022 @11:24AM (#31368838)
“We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.”
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by g_sch on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:29AM (#31368124)
I can't buy this. He very clearly seems to relish public attention for its own sake. Otherwise we'd have to accept that his hyping of random crypto tokens (e.g. DOGE) is somehow indirectly connected to saving the world or advancing humanity.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by PaulHoule on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:27AM (#31367304)
Musk's bullshit endangers the valuable things he's doing.

If he wants to make Starship a reality, he needs permits and government contracts.

I met an African-American man about ten years ago who owned an excellent patent portfolio covering technology like this

https://patents.google.com/patent/US6695260

but he was the only black person I've ever met who hated Barack Obama. He was an extreme Republican, thought Democrats all worked for the anti-Christ, etc.

I figured there was no way he'd succeed at what he was trying to do because he'd need to make nice with the government no matter who the administration was. I haven't heard from him again.

I see Musk going down the same road. I can only imagine the last man is dying on Earth 1000 years from now and cursing: "If only Elon Musk didn't have to post that tweet we would have made it to Mars."

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by yehBut0 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:18AM (#31367968)
There’s absolutely no reason to believe he’s on the right track

No science says “yes rockets and spreading through the stars is definitely the future for humans.”

The odds he’s just exacerbating damaging industrial feedback loops and a worse mess for the future are much higher than successful Mars colonies and extrasolar expansion coming from his efforts

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by weego on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:37AM (#31366757)
As with all outputs from any neurodiversity or personality disorder, it's a reason not an excuse
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by zozbot234 on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:44AM (#31366223)
He uses that attention and focus in ways that benefit the world at large. Like helping build more ethical AI's, or getting people to Mars. There's nothing wrong with that IMHO.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by martyvis on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:53AM (#31366323)
My concern is he losing his focus. I know I get distracted from the work I am supposed to be doing (sometimes my paid job but even more so at home). I really should be finishing some home renovation work but there is that mail box I need to finish, and the 3D printed lid for a mouse trap, and the synthesizer I am thinking of building, oh wait there is an nice branch from the plum tree we trimmed that I could turn into a flute on the lathe...

Elon really needs to focus on the energy and transportation thing that he really is good at.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by foxhill on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:59AM (#31366395)
sorry to pick you up on this, and i’m unable to phrase this in such a way as to not sound inflammatory (again, apologies):

* which ethical AI would that be?

* how many people has elon sent to mars now?

elon has marketed an image to people, one of a tony stark-like figure, that might do or say the wrong thing at the time, but who truly wants to make everything better.

the reality is that, whilst perhaps not a conman (although i find my opinion of him leaning to that end more each day), he’s definitely just another profit-driven business man, with little to no regard of the people around him. and probably a sociopath.

bill gates has done (a lot) more for humanity. and i’m not particularly fond of him, either.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by hammyhavoc on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:16AM (#31367182)
Can you elaborate on Musk being a conman? I don't follow the news these days.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:06AM (#31367794)
Well there was that incident where he committed securities fraud by saying he's taking Tesla private at a certain amount.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by yehBut0 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:23AM (#31368032)
There is something wrong instigating further extreme resource exhaustion to serve boyish Star Trek pipe dreams.

There’s absolutely no guarantee he’s on the right track. Humans expanding away from Earth is as likely as us being able to rewrite the speed of light.

There’s no rewriting the fundamentals of reality. One really bad day and Mars colony is wiped out. How much damage we do here before getting there is a real concern.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by g_sch on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:32AM (#31368167)
It never ceases to amaze me how many people consider some problems here on earth to be hopelessly intractable, but simultaneously consider a livable human colony on Mars to be not only achievable, but also not subject to the same supposedly intractable problems of today.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by MockObject on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:06PM (#31369349)
A Mars colony is merely an engineering problem. The intractable problems on Earth are stuck because millions of dollars don't want them solved.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by g_sch on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:36PM (#31369732)
What is it about Mars that would cause those same problems to collapse into mere engineering problems over there?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by MockObject on Friday May 13, 2022 @12:51PM (#31369919)
There really isn't a comparison between engineers figuring out how to build a sustainable biosphere on Mars, and the problems that we're presumably discussing on Earth, like climate change and pollution, which are political problems inasmuch as billion dollar business models are benefiting from them, and actively fighting your efforts to interfere.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by yehBut0 on Friday May 13, 2022 @01:19PM (#31370265)
I like how you try to extricate getting to Mars as it’s own thing despite the industrial effort to do so exacerbating climate problems that are political problems.

Please, go on. I want to hear more about how thermodynamics can be waved away for “just an engineering project.”

This is what I mean. Obsession and success with engineering has titillated people to the point of blind faith. Externalities do not exist in their conceptual void. It’s become akin to unfalsifiable religious belief.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by MockObject on Friday May 13, 2022 @01:59PM (#31370678)
> I like how you try to extricate getting to Mars as it’s own thing despite the industrial effort to do so exacerbating climate problems that are political problems.

If humanity doesn't spend the resources on spreading humanity throughout the universe, then the resources will be spent on disposable plastic toys that fill landfills. It's not as if an edenic utopia is being despoiled for this boondoggle. Our environment isn't in its precarious state because of too much space travel. We're debating over the disposition of a tiny fraction of our dwindling material resources, negligible in the grand scheme.

> I want to hear more about how thermodynamics can be waved away for “just an engineering project.”

If we have a limited period before climate doomsday, then we'd better get cracking on space travel before it's too late.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:57AM (#31367669)
I don't take anyone that uses the Asperger moniker seriously anymore; the guy was - in all likelihood - an eugenicist who picked out the "good" kind of autistic children and sent the "bad" ones off to get "euthanized"; see e.g. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5907291/.

Plus, it's often used as an excuse or a mark of honor; an excuse for unacceptable behaviour, and a mark of honor for being super smart and not like those Other Autists who struggle in their day to day.

The word has been besmirched by its namesake and the behaviour of those using it to distinguish themselves from "other" people with autism.

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by croes on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:36AM (#31366118)
Acknowledged or claimed?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by lazyeye on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:37AM (#31366120)
Elon would be completely forgiven if his politics were more left-wing than they currently are.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by ben_w on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:03AM (#31366432)
I think it would just be different people complaining in that case.

(My impression of his politics is more that they’re anarchic then left/right, but I’m not excited enough by his words to listen beyond the presentations and random support for e.g. UBI).

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by rasfincher on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:40AM (#31366170)
Like Michael Avenatti?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Bud on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:57AM (#31366368)
Please cite examples to support this, er, rather extraordinary assertion. Which prominent left-wing figures have acted like Elon Musk and have been "completely forgiven"?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by lazyeye on Friday May 13, 2022 @07:39PM (#31373680)
I'm struggling to understand what Elon Musk's crime actually is? Being successful? Having influence on the internet? Not following the narrow railroad tracks of a particular ideology?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by wowokay on Friday May 13, 2022 @08:56AM (#31366969)
I don’t think they were stating it as in they had examples, they were extrapolating from other left leaning activities like BLM vs Insurrection. Similar aggressive approaches but only insurrection gets attention as bad.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by hef19898 on Friday May 13, 2022 @09:24AM (#31367271)
BLM protested police brutality. Jan 6th wanted to stop / prevent a democratic election process. Seems like different things to me.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:09AM (#31367842)
> Jan 6th wanted to stop / prevent a democratic election process.

And possibly abduct or murder congresspeople (thinking of the guy with clearly visible tie wrap restraints, or the republican that was telling where to find democrat members of congress)

Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by mikeyouse on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:16AM (#31367928)
And the violent parts of both were pretty roundly condemned?
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by Cthulhu_ on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:08AM (#31367818)
These two are not comparable; you're trying to push an indefensible equivalence.
Re:Twitter Deal Temporarily on Hold by yehBut0 on Friday May 13, 2022 @10:14AM (#31367902)
Musk has publicly said a lot of things that were BS for attention and sympathy

Let’s not act like our air gapped view of him through screens can provide an accurate diagnosis of real medical conditions