News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by nathanvanfleet on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:34PM (#31300713)
Sad to think that investing in the stock market, which I have only been able to financially over the last 5 years might have been much riskier than I might have previously thought. What I previously thought as "okay I just leave it in the stock market for a bit of time to recoup" is something I am now realizing would likely have to be 10+ years.

It's kind of funny because I was getting shaky about having money in the stock market back in December, and I held onto investing some of my money there. But I ultimately relented 4 months later to lose 10% within about two weeks (and after just index funds). Now it's much worse, and I guess I'll just leave it all there.

And in 15 years I'll be back to where I was when I originally invested it.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by anonporridge on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:21PM (#31300968)
Are you ignoring dividend reinvestment creating compounding growth?

Even god couldn't beat dollar cost averaging, https://ofdollarsanddata.com/even-god-couldnt-beat-dollar-co...

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by qznc on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:08AM (#31304104)
There is an inverse question: If you have a cash windfall you want to invest, all-at-once or split it up?

I have seen a similar analysis (but can’t find it right now). Even if you invest at the all time highs, so the market drops right after you buy, you still win with the all-at-once strategy.

The general lesson: Get your money into the market as soon as possible. Maybe more memorable: Time in the market beats timing the market.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by layer8 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:15AM (#31304185)
Investing in the stock market has the general assumption that, a priori, stocks are more likely to rise than to fall at any given point in time. Under that assumption, the all-at-once strategy has the better expected outcome. Of course, you can be unlucky and end up buying the all-time-high just before a crash. You can avoid that risk by splitting up the investment, at the cost of lowering the overall expected value. So it’s more about how you feel about that risk, and whether you feel avoiding it is worth having a somewhat lower expected return.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by doopy1 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:43PM (#31305661)
Peter Lynch had a pretty interesting talk where he said that on average the stock market has a sizable dip every few 2-3 years, meaning it's lower at the end of that year than it was at the beginning. Generally though, it goes up over time.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by layer8 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:12PM (#31306538)
Right, up to now the maximum interval where the market didn’t go up to a new all-time-high is about 15 years, but so far it always ended up reaching a new all-time-high in the end.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by DantesKite on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:55AM (#31301426)
Damn thanks for the great read. This is just what I was looking for.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by mberning on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:47PM (#31301101)
Buy all the time. Only reliable way to win.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by slaw on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:09AM (#31301210)
Past performance is not indicative of future results. Japan stock market JP225 didn't recover yet from 1990 crash.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by astrange on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:51AM (#31301687)
Do Japanese people have to buy Japanese stocks just because it's the same country?
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by SapporoChris on Sunday May 08, 2022 @03:27AM (#31302017)
No, Japanese can invest in other markets using international brokers. I don't know details on the fees and currency conversions. Investing in a foreign exchange is always at a slight disadvantage because of currency conversions and fees.

For a US centric view: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/032615/how-t...

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by id on Sunday May 08, 2022 @04:26AM (#31302257)
US stocks are traded on foreign exchanges. Even if you insist on buying on a US exchange, the currency conversion is not very expensive. If you're a buy and hold investor, it won't matter at all.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by tasuki on Sunday May 08, 2022 @04:44AM (#31302321)
And yet you often see US people recommending to buy US stocks. There are risks and benefits to buying both domestic and international stocks.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by christophilus on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:58AM (#31304669)
If you invested only in the Nikkei on the way up and on the way down, you still came out fine. The only person who didn’t is the person who put all of their savings in at the very top and never bought again.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by rubidium on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:29AM (#31301310)
Yea so buy land if you’re so paranoid about becoming Japan. It’s an island nation with a very unique history. Not a great counterpoint to current US and global economics.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by scrivna on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:57AM (#31301437)
The UK is at more or less the same price as it was in 2000. France same as 2008. Meanwhile SPY is up 2.75x in that period. The US seems to be the anomaly. Value doesn’t always go higher. Maybe the USA is special, maybe not.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by nly on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:35AM (#31302547)
The UK FTSE all share total return index, which accounts for reinvested dividends, is at 8430 today and was at 2870 in May 2000. That's an annualized return of exactly 5%/year
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by lordnacho on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:09AM (#31302435)
Is that with dividends? Watch out because the German DAX actually does have reinvestment in it iirc. Most of the others don't.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by qznc on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:16AM (#31304193)
An index never includes dividends. An index fond might (accumulating) or might not (distributing).
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by lordnacho on Sunday May 08, 2022 @10:22AM (#31304273)
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by qznc on Sunday May 08, 2022 @11:16AM (#31304802)
Thanks. Learned something today.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by digitalnatives on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:47AM (#31301892)
SPY is differently weighted than for example FTSE. Most indexes do not factor in dividends, if you look at the total return data where dividends are reinvested you will see there are gains in Europe, but less than the US.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by scrivna on Monday May 09, 2022 @02:56PM (#31318268)
Thanks, I hadn’t realised the “obvious” indexes were measuring different things
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by scrivna on Monday May 09, 2022 @03:04PM (#31318356)
Thanks for pointing out dividend adjustments work differently on some indexes

Adjusted for dividends since 2012

VUKE - Vanguard UK 100 up 100% VUSA - Vanguard S&P500 up 350%

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by weberer on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:38PM (#31306797)
I'd wager most of that difference is due to the USA's tech industry growth.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by argomo on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:17AM (#31301527)
As the saying goes, there are four types of economies: developed, undeveloped, Argentina, and Japan.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by hanniabu on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:43AM (#31301660)
Why Argentina?
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by astrange on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:48AM (#31301678)
Argentina's economy is a series of endless crises from the government choosing the worst possible ways to intervene in it at every opportunity. Like a reverse South Korea.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by rwmj on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:23AM (#31302793)
Buying land in Japan isn't a great idea (except to live on it). You have to pay a hefty annual tax on it. Land even with property on it is so often abandoned they have a word for it and many marketplaces where you can buy abandoned land from the tax office.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by jrumbut on Sunday May 08, 2022 @04:07AM (#31302182)
> What I previously thought as "okay I just leave it in the stock market for a bit of time to recoup" is something I am now realizing would likely have to be 10+ years.

I am wondering where you previously got your information?

At one point ten years was considered about the minimum time window for investing in stocks.

To give an example, an old rule of thumb was to have 100 minus your age percent of your retirement savings in stocks and the rest in less volatile investments such as bonds (so a 50 year old would be half and half between stocks and bonds).

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by nly on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:31AM (#31302523)
It's been easy to promote bonds when we've been in 40 year bond bull run
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:12PM (#31300913)
My grandfather had $3M invested in the market in 2007. Lost $1M at the bottom in 2008, but didn't do anything other than rebalance. Now worth $8M.

Either you fret over every price move and likely buy/sell at the worst times, or you invest with a long-term vision and stop tracking the price moves everyday.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by bagacrap on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:42PM (#31301068)
yes but in that case the Fed rode to the rescue and delivered the greatest bull market in US history. There's absolutely no way the next decade looks like the last so this is a poor comparison.

As far as rebalancing --- you may have noticed stocks and bonds falling in unison this year, so rebalancing is not much help.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:08AM (#31301206)
Take a gander at the PE ratio for the S&P500 over time. A substantial amount of those gains are backed by increased profitability.

https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio/table/by-year

And not sure what your comment on rebalancing not being much "help" is. Rebalancing is not about "help" it's about sticking to an investing approach.

And I can recall back in the early 2000's when people said "Equity growth will never be like it was the 90's".

Glad I never listened to them.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by bushbaba on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:04AM (#31301185)
Why not l? If the market returns don’t keep up at 6-7% annualized government pensions will run out of cash.

If rates go up drastically, government debt payments go up.

The game must go on! *until the us empire collapses, taking down with it the western world

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by landemva on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:11AM (#31301222)
Yes, pensions and Illinois are cooked.

But EU has had negative interest rates for years, and will collapse (break up the eu monetary union) before USA goes under. Dollar strength confirms capital is moving into USA.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by landemva on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:06AM (#31301196)
>>> Now worth $8M.

That is the price. Worth and value are different than price.

If that $8M now buys about the same amount of blueberries or house as $3M in 2007, then it kept pace. Except for paying the capital gains on $5M.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by ramblerman on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:38AM (#31301866)
Are you suggesting in 15 years, the $ devalued by more than 250%?
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by antisthenes on Sunday May 08, 2022 @03:06AM (#31301946)
Something can't devalue by over 100% of itself.

If you're asking about inflation, it is usually measured as an increase in prices.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by danielmarkbruce on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:20PM (#31300961)
Unfortunately for every one of these folks, there are a handful of folks who panic sold and still haven't made it back...
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by galaxyLogic on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:57AM (#31301711)
Problem with "long term investing" as I see it is that to realize the gains you must get out of the market at approximately the correct time. That is difficult psychologically because if you have been able to increase your worth by doing what you have been doing so far you are likely to keep on doing it. Then one day the next crash comes. All of a sudden having been a long term investor does not help so much any more.

You need to be a long-term investor for a limited term. But hard to know when that term is over.

So I think when markets go up you should seriously consider taking some money out and using it for leisure and travel and education investing in yourself. But taking money out and spending it is not usually considered prudent investing. Especially because taking money out means you must pay taxes on it. So you stay in the market and soon most of your long-term gains are wiped out, and you have to be a "long term investor" all over again.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @04:39AM (#31302304)
You should clearly have a purpose for your investing goals and adjust your investing style based on risk.

So if your goal is retirement and you're 30, you can tolerate higher risk because if the market crashes, you've got 30 years to wait for it to recover. If you're 60 and retiring in a few years, your risk tolerance is low. And you can slowly adjust your portfolio in between.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by srean on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:30AM (#31302516)
This a very popular idea but I don't fully accept it. Goals and desires are not static. They are path dependent and adaptive. I want a funding scheme that's able to fund that.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:34AM (#31302542)
So you want high returns with little to no risk?

Doesn’t exist. Sorry bud.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by srean on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:39AM (#31302562)
You think you are entitled to returns just because you took a risk ? Sorry bud, sad to break it to you but it does not work that way.

That's the idea that I am criticizing. Risk might be necessary, but never sufficient.

BTW I don't think, you think that way, but neither should you. Gratuitous condescension poisons the well.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:07AM (#31302680)
I never said I "think [I am] entitled to returns just because [I] took a risk". There is no entitled, it's simply a trade-off.

It's a basic precept of investing. In a very simplified way - higher returns require higher risk of invested capital - why else would you invest in something higher risk unless the return justifies it? And likewise, people will accept lower returns if they know the risk is low.

Nobody is doing payday loans at prime because the risk isn't justified by the return.

When you start looking at portfolio allocation across multiple investments, it gets more complicated because you can actually achieve the same return at lower risk through diversification across classes of assets.

But to answer your original question - the only way to guarantee short-term and long-term positive returns (as you put it "if my goals change, I don't want to lose money") is to invest in low risk investments. Low risk investments mean low returns.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by srean on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:11AM (#31302705)
> I never said I "think [I am] entitled to returns just because

Exactly! Why did you think I said anything about not taking risks. I didn't say that either. I was misinterpreting on purpose to show yours.

> "if my goals change, I don't want to lose money"

I did not say that either. I vehemently agree with everything else that you said.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:44AM (#31302902)
Ok, then I misunderstood and am very confused.

You said "This a very popular idea but I don't fully accept it. Goals and desires are not static. They are path dependent and adaptive. I want a funding scheme that's able to fund that."

Which I interpret as "I reject the idea of setting some financial goal decades into the future. I want a scheme that is flexible and can accommodate changes to how I want to use my money."

How is that different than "If my goals change, I don't want to lose money."?

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by srean on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:15PM (#31305391)
The best sort of discussions are those where each is happy with the other's rewording of their position. I certainly do not reject setting financial goals decades into the future. I do not like ('like' and 'reject' aren't synonyms) investment discipline that are strictly fixated on some goal I had in the past. I would rather have an adaptive trade off of risk to return depending on where I am right now financially. Some goal I had ten years ago may not be as relevant in my current state. I wouldn't want to let go of a favorable opportunity by pulling out the money, just because a goal that I had set in the past has been met.

> How is that different than "If my goals change, I don't want to lose money."?

… and I don't see at all how they are equivalent. I might be willing accept the possibility of losing some money if there is a notable increase in the possibility of meeting my updated goal.

I doubt that we have any fundamental disagreement. You have a good day.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by UncleMeat on Monday May 09, 2022 @09:03AM (#31313524)
The core problem here is that nobody understood your original comment or the follow ups. It isn't clear what you are criticizing or what alternative you want.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by refurb on Sunday May 08, 2022 @09:20PM (#31309530)
I'm still confused as hell.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by throwaway898989 on Sunday May 08, 2022 @03:50AM (#31302108)
if you have a large enough sum of money (i.e., $50m USD ) you can stay invested all the time and withdraw a small sum of money each year like $300k

With $50m if your portfolio averages 4% a year you would be clearing $2m then pulling out $300k for 1.7 gain. You only pay tax on the income withdrawn

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by matwood on Sunday May 08, 2022 @08:53AM (#31303577)
The real baller move for someone worth 50M+ with rates as low as they have been, is take out loans against the 50M to live off of. Pay back the loans with rates less than the annualized market returns. Also limits/pushes out cap gain taxes.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by galaxyLogic on Monday May 09, 2022 @04:25PM (#31319260)
Right, take out a mortgage. That is tax deductible
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by newshorts on Sunday May 08, 2022 @12:14AM (#31301240)
Don’t worry friend, it’s about the savings rate, not the savings return.

Just keep putting a little in here and there. Don’t put in anything you can’t afford to lose and it’ll turn out alright

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by qeternity on Sunday May 08, 2022 @01:48PM (#31306298)
> Don’t worry friend, it’s about the savings rate, not the savings return.

Yikes, please reconsider your advocacy of this.

As Einstein said: "Compound interest is the eighth wonder of the world."

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by nly on Sunday May 08, 2022 @06:00AM (#31302646)
If person A invests monthly and achieves a 7%/yr return, how much more does person B have to invest every month to get the same pot after 30 years?

50% more

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by chii on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:44PM (#31300767)
you have to take risk to earn returns. Sometimes that risk actually eventuates, and you have to either keep going, or take the loss.

That's why you must know the time horizon for your investments - if you know you need the money "soon", you cannot actually invest in the stock market.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by bequanna on Saturday May 07, 2022 @10:55PM (#31300829)
You have to take calculated risks to earn returns. FOMO at your own risk.

If you are 30 and don’t need the money you put in SPY until 70, don’t sweat it. You’ll be fine.

But let’s not pretend blindly taking risk is OK because some return is expected. Time horizon and some relative valuation context is important.

Buying into the stock or housing market at extreme historic levels of valuations like those in late 2021 and now GREATLY reduces your expected return over 5/10 years.

If you don’t have the (extremely) long view, expect to lose some sleep watching your net worth over the next couple years.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by srean on Sunday May 08, 2022 @05:27AM (#31302502)
> But let’s not pretend blindly taking risk is OK because some return is expected.

Exactly. I have seen this idea float around that just because they have taken a risky position they will be able get better rewards. Risk may be necessary for above market rate returns, but it is not sufficient. A proportionate amount of those taking the risk will be cleaned off the amount that was risked. Why do you think its not going to be you ! Of course when you use time effectively or use other hedges one can reduce the exposure.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by thathndude on Sunday May 08, 2022 @07:32AM (#31303119)
This is a large part of why I’m feeling so negative about this draw down. In the last 5ish years I paid off my student loans and started banking real cash. I put it in the market and now am down tremendously. Crap timing.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by jokethrowaway on Sunday May 08, 2022 @02:03AM (#31301732)
I was pissed because I didn't invest in my portfolio to buy a house during the pandemic and missed out on pandemic gains - but checking how much money my portfolio lost, I made more money to keep those in cash.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by SturgeonsLaw on Sunday May 08, 2022 @03:22AM (#31301991)
It was hard to predict that real estate would see pandemic gains. It's an asset that people need to leave their homes to inspect, and comes with face-to-face time with multiple parties. In a locked down society, there were plausible reasons to assume that the real estate market would be dampened.
Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by matwood on Sunday May 08, 2022 @08:59AM (#31303604)
Predictions are always hard. I bought my house during the last housing 'crash'. It was my first house so I didn't have one to sell, so it was easier. But, I was being told by friends and online that things could drop more, wait, etc... At the end of the day, I needed a place to live, I could afford it, and my job was reasonably secure.

Now people ask how I timed it perfectly and the fact is I didn't. I simply made personal financial decisions based on my situation at the time.

Re:When buying the dip doesn’t work: An analysis of the dot-... by ProjectArcturis on Sunday May 08, 2022 @09:25AM (#31303765)
What are you buying that you've lost "much worse" than 10%? There's no guarantee each individual stock will go up over time.