News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by drusepth on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:10PM (#31163238)
Related headline: humans won't tell you they're lying if they think they're telling the truth
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by dragonwriter on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:14PM (#31163252)
> Related headline: humans won't tell you they're lying if they think they're telling the truth

Humans also won't tell you they're lying if they know they're lying, because, well, of the same reason they are lying in the first place.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by Terry_Roll on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @05:50AM (#31165590)
This is what makes science so interesting, I've read plenty of scientific papers where claims or assertions are made cited in another paper and if you dont read that other paper, you dont know if the claim/assertion is correct or not.

Believe it or not, there are quite a few papers pulling that trick!

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by varajelle on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:51AM (#31164036)
Oh, they'll tell you. Unconsciously, using their body language.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by nikanj on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:34AM (#31164638)
"That person seemed really nervous, so clearly they were lying"

Or, you know, that person was really nervous because they might get wrongly deported / jailed / fired / broken up with / etc.

This body language stuff is 50/50 bad cop behaviour and bad relationship advice. See also: lie detectors, which really aren't that accurate.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by isaacfrond on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:54AM (#31165061)
I can really recommend Malcolm Gladwell's book 'Talking to Strangers'. It is a fascinating book in which he tries to explain why it so hard to understand what other people are really thinking.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by DocTomoe on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @07:25AM (#31166099)
Body language is real. Formalistic interpretation of body language ("if subject does this, they are lying") is bogus.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by nikanj on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @09:43AM (#31167356)
I like how we accept the existence of professional actors/actresses, but think body language can’t be controlled with conscious though
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by DocTomoe on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:16PM (#31170230)
And training, which the run-off-the-mill criminal would be unlikely to have.

Just because something does not work 100% of the time, every time, with highly sophisticated criminals does not make it worthless as a tool.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by moron4hire on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:28AM (#31164257)
That's a myth promulgated by the prison industrial complex. There are no reliable body language cues to tell if someone is lying.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by smegsicle on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:48AM (#31164364)
i don't get this meme that just because body language isn't 100% accurate, it is completely meaningless

of course it shouldn't be admissible in court, but it's ridiculous to take that and say that body language tells you nothing

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:58AM (#31164424)
well first off the body language needs to be interpreted, there may be some people who can tell lies and never be caught by body language and there might be some people who will always be caught by body language.

But perhaps the people who will always be caught by body language have issues that cause them not just to be reliably caught when lying but to mislead the interpreters of their body language into thinking they're lying when not.

Given that part of the task of interpreting someone as lying by body language also involves understanding cultural differences, and as a human activity is prone to human bias, it might be beneficial for rational people to discount the use of body language interpretation in determining lies completely as an unmeasurable process.

In short body language may not be completely meaningless, but it is probably best to treat it as if it were.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by robbedpeter on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:28AM (#31164606)
Unless you know someone very well, you'll be missing context when interpreting body language. Even then, sociopaths and con artists can seem extremely well known to you and you won't have a clue that everything you think you know is a lie.

Actors train to control this. You have to wonder if so many Hollywood marriages fail because neither partner can trust that the other isn't just really good at putting on a persona.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by Fnoord on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:04AM (#31164817)
Yes, social engineering, too.

And LE and CIA et al are trained to expose it (see the book Spy The Lie).

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by smegsicle on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:29AM (#31164607)
part of the productive use of heuristics is understanding their limits

by your logic no heuristic should ever be used?

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:01AM (#31164798)
a common heuristic would be

If you are having difficulty understanding a problem, try drawing a picture.

the method of drawing a picture is pretty well understood, thus understanding the limits of the method also are.

However understanding the limits of using body language as a lie detector in any instance where used requires understanding the biases of the person doing the detecting (which may be yourself, and knowing one's self is traditionally a tricky thing), what their current mental state is in, the culture that the person who may be lying is from, do they have any ongoing problems or conditions that might make them appear to be lying when not, is the potential liar able to mask their lying better than most people, and probably a few more things that are hard to pin down that I haven't thought of here.

Getting the heuristic to work in reasonable, measurable way so that one can decide is this giving a good approximation of a correct answer, am I making progress using this, is an important part of having an heuristic. As an example, common heuristics used in construction or software project management.

So I would think heuristics that are well understood and that do not depend on imponderable questions that philosophers have been arguing about for millennia should be used, but ones that are not free of these problems should not.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by dgb23 on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:36AM (#31164961)
Not everything is political BS. Some things are just common sense. People can read body language and sometimes they can tell if someone is lying, especially if they know the liar well.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by sgtnoodle on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:20AM (#31165177)
I can usually tell when my 3 year old daughter is lying because either her speech is quieter, or she acts excessively generous. It also helps that she always blames one of the dogs, typically a stuffed one.

It's funny the stuff she thinks she needs to sneak. A couple weeks ago I stumbled upon her in the back bedroom, shamefully eating a graham cracker. We celebrate her willingly eating anything that isn't pure sucrose...

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:15AM (#31165152)
> Some things are just common sense.

“Common sense” is just a modern positive term for folk mythology; and particularly when it comes to reading “body language” to detect lies, much of that popular wisdom is based on fabrications deliberately popularized by the law enforcement community (not unlike polygraphy, and, until the same fell apart, the FBI’s “fiber science”.)

Relying on body language (not independent knowledge of the facts of the claim) to detect lies is at best barely better than a coin flip and tends to rely (like polygraphy, which is also not reliable) on indicators of arousal and the known false assumption that arousal = deception, but with less accuracy in detecting arousal than a polygraph.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by reshie on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:33AM (#31164943)
sure. unless they lie with that too.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by ssivark on Monday April 25, 2022 @11:18PM (#31163611)
We also don't usually need to raise the question of whether humans are "just statistical models spitting out sequences of words" or whether they "understand the meaning of what they're saying", because we hold it self-evident that the latter applies. Counter to the snark implicit in your comment, that's why the headline regarding AI is more salient than a parallel headline regarding humans.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by iamacyborg on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:23AM (#31164583)
> humans are "just statistical models spitting out sequences of words"

I think a lot of research would suggest that this is actually how the brain works.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by i_like_waiting on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:03AM (#31164807)
Thats pretty much how I learned spanish, for half of stuff I had no idea about exact meaning, I just knew that my girlfriend used those words in similar situations.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by mypastself on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:15AM (#31165150)
That might make you a “Spanish room”:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by iamacyborg on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @05:37AM (#31165532)
I think the general idea is that the human mind is effectively a Chinese room, consciousness is just a by-product of the brain doing it's thing and free will is merely an illusion.

https://www.academia.edu/1502945/The_Last_Magic_Show_A_Blind...

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by IIAOPSW on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:16AM (#31164552)
I have my doubts about the degree of understanding truly existent in a great deal of human speakers.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by Brian_K_White on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:26AM (#31164245)
Then they aren't lying, merely wrong.

Same goes for a AI.

Both of which seem like unremarkable facts.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by devoutsalsa on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:17AM (#31165160)
Doesn’t lying imply an intent to deceive? If I believe the moon is made of cheese and say that, I’m not lying, I’m just wrong.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by _moof on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @06:03AM (#31165639)
It does, which is famously why certain newspapers are/were loathe to use the word "lie" in connection with certain politicians. They knew certain utterances were untrue, but they had no evidence of intent. Without intent it's not a lie; it's just wrong.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by ben_w on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @04:27AM (#31165216)
I’ve seen it used both in that way[0], and in the sense of saying any false thing.

There’s also a gap between the two of lying by omission: on the one hand, “I swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth” is a situation where that clearly counts as a lie; on the other, if I go past a street preacher claiming the world is 6000 years old, I don’t consider failing to stop and tell him and his audience that he’s wrong to be a lie.

[0] I use the word the same way you do; As a further example, if you did believe that the moon is made of cheese, and you said that it wasn’t, that would be a lie.

Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by ajuc on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @02:35AM (#31164639)
It's not lying if you think you're telling the truth.
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by layer8 on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:30PM (#31163350)
The article actually mentions this (“prime ministers”).
Re:AI can't tell you it's lying if it thinks it's telling th... by throwaway787544 on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @12:57AM (#31164072)
Well, they could, but they'd be lying about lying.