They can do whatever they want with Twitter, but I don't have to use it. Which is exactly what everyone complaining about "censorship" on Twitter was told as well. If Musk wants to make Twitter more hospitable to trolls and harassers, then they're welcome to go annoy each other in their new paradise.
Thanks for the idea
your threads are more so focused on the threat of more bigoted stuff
I’m focused on how it would be a hilarious meme factory, amplifying the amusement park that twitter already is to 4chan levels of entertainment, while inheriting a much better more modern interface than 4chan if they tweak twitter just a little more
Yeah that comes with crazy, I’m looking forward to it. I really like that “but muh advertisers dictate what I do” goes away when reducing the options for advertisers. This could be a big and lulzworthy shakeup for the overton window.
I'd like to buy an Internet Experience without memes.
I always find myself laughing at the speed and meme preparedness of the respondents though. Twitter has some of that but it really pales in comparison.
People will just have to find a different forum if they want something else shrug
I really like the potential for Elon to tell advertisers to pound sand since he wouldnt need to impress shareholders with the idea of ad revenue growth, and many people and organizations will still see the value of advertising there.
There's no world in which Musk is going to be anti-trolling. The dude literally started this whole thing BY TROLLING.
I'm mostly unsure if I trust Musk, someone I associate with unfiltered mental garbage intended to en(r|g)age on Twitter to lead the vanguard to moderate out any of that.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/04/08/musk-twitt...
"Musk’s appointment to Twitter’s board shows that we need regulation of social-media platforms to prevent rich people from controlling our channels of communication."
...said a multi-millionaire in a newspaper owned by a multibillionaire.
There were also hundreds of notable comments and dozens of articles to that end across the usual websites. People should stop doubling down on their lies and just admit that their past positions weren't based on any real principles.
I don't think that was ever Ellen Pao's position. What you've done is taken two groups of people:
* People think that twitter is private and should do whatever it wants (hence can moderate if they like),
* People that think twitter has a big public influence and therefore has a responsibility to act in a certain way (ie, moderate a certain amount)
And claimed that these two positions are in opposition and therefore hypocritical. But there is no hypocrisy because they're not the same people, they just disagree.
A straightforward reading of that tweet is "It's a private company, they can remove hate and harassment if they want."
Her WaPo editorial from 2.5 weeks ago argues that even though the First Amendment exists, the government should force Twitter to remove hate from their platform.
One could simply turn the charge of hypocrisy back on Ellen Pao - if she cares so much about the first Amendment (see the tweet that preceded the one I linked), why does she want the government to regulate speech on social media?
All of these channels are controlled by rich people. Who is controlling the lobbyists? Who is financing political parties/campaigns. This is the cost of oligarchy. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. I don't know how we get out of this spiral. I think a huge tax on digital ad revenue would help make these channels more organic and less contentious but I really don't know.
Why is everybody assuming we are all hypocrites who are 100% in support of the status quo?
It guess it is like Media Literacy where a person is able to contextualize the info they read about in a bigger picture sense.
The second someone — especially a kid — opens TikTok / social media, they are essentially granting access and unlocking their mind for someone else to cram as much information as possible into it.
The Clockwork Orange example is just a reference of mixing that concept with emotional videos and high screen time. The whole idea is not new and it has serious impact on your behavior and sense of self.
Social media is easy to blame for problems but it would be better if people learned to guard themselves a bit.
I haven't used TikTok myself but I have observed others using it and it certainly feels a lot more fast-paced and saturated compared to Instagram (which for me already feels like that anyway).
I often am told certain things that might or might not be true, but are often couched in true things. The one i heard the other day was a long list of mandela effects, now some of them were true, but often had context around them that wasn't given ... e.g. Pikachu not having the black stripe on its tail, that could easily have context with regards to time that picture was used, lore in pokemon..etc. but it's reduced to a far more simple "fact"
"it's a private company they can do what they want" is a response to the right-wing claim that moderation is somehow illegal. It isn't, and it still isn't. Online forums are allowed to moderate as much or as little as they want to.
Moderation isn't illegal. Reduced moderation also isn't illegal. I hold the the opinion that some moderation is preferable to no moderation, and I am disappointed that this move may lead to a reduction in moderation and an increase in spam and trolling on the platform. That's not hypocrisy.
Noone was saying what they were doing was illegal, they were saying they didn't like what was happening and perhaps it should be illegal.
So people said "it's a private company, go make your own Twitter".
Turns out the network effect is hard to overcome, so the solution is new management.
It is not a violation of your first amendment rights for me to refuse to lend you a megaphone. In fact the opposite is true, if the government compelled me to give you my megaphone, that would be a violation of my free speech rights by compelling association.
People who used to say "increasing moderation on twitter is good and legal" now say "decreasing moderation on twitter is bad, but legal". Those are not contradictory.
Every dispute of Twitter's moderation you read was claiming it was illegal?
Like every single comment? Would you like to link to those comments on here? I can go to a thread and find plenty of arguments of people saying it should be illegal.
I have to think that you aren't arguing in good faith because that's such a ridiculous statement.
edit: I picked a random thread and found this exchange immediately:
And having seen the arc of many social media sites with "libertarian" moderation, I'm firmly in that camp.
I mean, Hacker News would not be what it is today without firm-handed moderation.
However, I see similar commentary of "anybody who supports inclusive language is just giving stupid prizes to weenies" or something like that. This, by contrast, is fine.
It may be just that dang disagreed with my tone, or never saw the latter, or just thinks this is "my bias", or simply the large number of comments posted (which is kind of a natural effect of being heavily opposed -- agreement with the consensus on this site is intrinsically quieter than disagreement). I don't know.
Either way, their site, their prerogative. Either way, I'm trying not to get into politics on this site anymore.
I thought you were gonna say when Americans are the ones doing it. (I think you mean the opposite, when non-Americans are flaming the US - let me know if I misunderstood you.)
I see far more toxicity allowed about China and (recently) Russia than about the US. I've even seen misinformation allowed in the titles of posts (which are usually heavily moderated to remove even hyperbole, much less misinformation), when the target is Russia.
This only reinforces your "Dang is not without his biases" point though. As a (presumed) political leftie, he's probably more inclined than the average US-ian to allow self-criticism of the US. But as an American in the first place, he's inevitably imbibed some of the caricature of places like China and Russia, and likely doesn't even see the toxic flaming of them for what it is. You see the first bias as the one stands out, while for me the latter is the one that seems visible and obvious.
Full 180 and probably shouldn’t use an argument you don’t believe in to help make your point if you are on the receiving end of that joke.
Just trying to enjoy the ride on by this one…
I’m still much more concerned with the on-demand Ludovico Technique / aversion therapy device TikTok is using on kids.
If anything comes from this Twitter mix up and supposed transparency — hopefully some algo literacy. Just not a healthy way to be informed through a click bait anger machine designed for engagement.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4woPg0-xyAA&t=3m10s
Aka, don’t ever tune in and tune out!