News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:57AM (#31133847)
Does anyone love this as music, rather than as an idea? Of composers, there are two schools: those who try to express something interesting musically, and those who produce interesting concepts. Some of Cage's work, especially, takes the second approach to extremes, where it cannot even be experienced as music. I don't think any of that sort of music will survive long, because the concept is no longer clever after it loses its novelty.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:22AM (#31134036)
It's pretty silly IMO. Extreme Concept™ isn't difficult to do, and it's even less difficult to imagine.

It's trivial to make extremely long time-based pieces on the web. You load the page, it works out the time/date, and it plays whatever the algorithm says is right for the time date. With the right algo you can make pieces that last for millions of years.

And so on.

There is a sense in which it's an interesting idea, but it's also a cultural dead end. You can only make it bigger and more extreme, and that's more about spectacle than music.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by NoOneNew on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:34AM (#31134616)
Agreed, extreme concepts are not hard. But I think the fascinating part is the salesmanship involved. Something I've noticed, really high concept artists are fantastic salesmen... and really shitty artists (80% of the time). They can convince people that a duct taped banana on the wall or just splatter paint can emotionally transcend you. Dont get me wrong, I like some abstract art when there is an aesthetic quality to it. But the worship status given to something like this, one incredibly slow note every however months... come on. You could do the same with Vanilla Ice's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2 song from the 90s. Doesnt mean anything... other than that song still slaps :)

I'll take listening to an amateur messing with guitar chords while drunk in a shitty bar over something like this. Because I can actually experience the shitty bar music. You literally cannot experience this "art project".

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by somewhereoutth on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:47AM (#31135282)
The artist as messenger - through inspiration or otherwise to bring us a new way of looking at things; the artist as theoretician - to build on work that has gone on before and progressively expand our horizons; the artist as performer - acting out a role in society.

I'd suggest all three are present in artists across the ages, but in recent times the last seems to have become more prominent.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Bud on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:59AM (#31134333)
No, it's not trivial to make extremely long time-based pieces on the web.

Because you have to keep the computer running continuously. That turns out to be extremely difficult.

So there is no spectacle, here.

Part of the magic of Cage's piece, in this incarnation, is that someone actually built the special organ, in a suitable space that might plausibly remain undisturbed for several centuries. It requires some maintenance and some care and feeding, of course, but not much. So one doesn't have to suspend disbelief too much, here—this performance may actually occur as planned. It's been going for over 20 years so far, after all.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by enduser384729 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:42AM (#31135237)
This is a bad take, but unsurprising when most Western culture still lauds virtuosity playing and "skill" over most other things. If it's a cultural dead end it's because of the culture not the idea.

That aside, John Cage was having these ideas when they weren't as obvious as they are today and we have the benefit of hindsight. Dismissing that is also a pretty ignorant mistake.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by PolygonSheep on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:45PM (#31135883)
> most Western culture still lauds virtuosity playing and "skill" over most other things.

We must be in different Western cultures because I definitely don't see a lot of skill and virtuosity in most popular music.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by CharlesW on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:09PM (#31136709)
> We must be in different Western cultures because I definitely don't see a lot of skill and virtuosity in most popular music.

I think it depends on the lens you use. If you're looking through a "Tom Scholz" lens, that kind of skill and instrumental virtuosity may not exist today (although artists like St. Vincent are an argument that they do). But tech has completely changed music making, production, and distribution since that time, so today's Toms are people like Finneas O'Connell, and making music today is more akin to software design and engineering.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by dahart on Saturday April 23, 2022 @06:37PM (#31139329)
Would you mind elaborating on what you mean? Why is that a bad take? What is culturally relevant about this? I’m not saying it isn’t, but I don’t know what it is, and tearing down others doesn’t help me.

John Cage didn’t intend this piece to last 639 years, right? What ideas of his are you referring to? This long running organ piece was conceived by someone in Germany and is intended to highlight the history of Halberstadt, right?

The question @TheOtherHobbes is raising seems relevant: how does this performance contribute to musical culture, or even to Cage’s work? It can’t be enjoyed as music, it’s more of a logistical piece intended to create a mythology. In that sense, this performance is, in a way, very much lauding a sort of skill over most other things about the music - the skill of pure perseverance. Like other conceptual art, it’s the story of this work that is interesting, but not really the work itself. You seem to suggest otherwise, would you mind coloring that in for me, so I can appreciate it more?

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Bud on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:56PM (#31140255)
The best guide is probably Cage's book, "Silence". Contains a lot of Cage's interaction with Zen, random change procedures, silence, form and time in music, and all the ideas that are contained within his various experiments.

It would be hard to explain in an easy sentence or two on here. If I thought I could do it, I'd try. It might end up looking like a Zen koan. :)

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by dahart on Sunday April 24, 2022 @09:48AM (#31143964)
That ignores the fact that this Halberstadt project wasn’t designed by Cage, and the timing is for reasons specific to Halberstadt. Do you feel like Cage’s ideas call for a piece to last hundreds of years? It seems like all the ideas you just mentioned are thrown out the window when a single note lasts for years at a time, and zero people are present to witness the full performance, or even the full playing of a single note. This isn’t being done for music reasons, it’s being done explicitly for spectacle reasons, as described by the project page.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Bud on Sunday April 24, 2022 @11:49PM (#31150577)
I think Cage might ask why you are so very certain why a "spectacle" can't be art, too. Especially one like this.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by dahart on Monday April 25, 2022 @05:51PM (#31161181)
Oh that’s totally fair. A spectacle absolutely can be art. This is a bit of a different goal post than above though, isn’t it? And while we can speculate that Cage might say this, it’s (speculating) also possible that he wouldn’t approve of his music being used as a town attraction, or that he wouldn’t approve of music that can’t physically be experienced by humans, right? Either way, isn’t it equally fair to question whether a spectacle is musically and culturally relevant, like @TheOtherHobbes did?
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by enduser384729 on Monday April 25, 2022 @10:10AM (#31155003)
I don't believe you are arguing in good faith so I will not be coloring anything in for you.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by dahart on Monday April 25, 2022 @06:02PM (#31161310)
You’re wrong, I’m genuinely curious, and like many here fascinated by experimental and generative arts. You may be lashing out at the very people most likely to agree with your point of view. Sorry to hear that you’re unable to engage.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by rnd0 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:00PM (#31136605)
>This is a bad take, but unsurprising when most Western culture still lauds virtuosity playing and "skill" over most other things

Why is that a bad thing?

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by enduser384729 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:44PM (#31137099)
If you think music and art are entirely about skill that's fine, but I personally am not interested in hearing anything further about your opinions in that case.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by rnd0 on Saturday April 23, 2022 @03:33PM (#31137642)
> but I personally am not interested in hearing anything further about your opinions in that case.

Fuck me, you say? No, fuck YOU.

Feel free to mute me (edit: assuming HN has that feature) if you're unwilling to engage in an exchange of opinions and perspectives like a reasonable adult.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by DonBarredora on Monday April 25, 2022 @07:54AM (#31153245)
Wow, tone it down with the pretentiousness.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by rufus_foreman on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:50PM (#31135926)
>> Western culture still lauds virtuosity playing and "skill" over most other things

It was my understanding that everyone had heard.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Honga on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:33AM (#31134113)
The work doesn't necessarily argue against you. It may have been the intention, or it may be the effect of the work that ideas like yours come into existence. One idea of conceptual art is that the work plays out in your mind, and the physical creation is secondary, utilitarian even.

The authenticity of the piece and it's validity is reinforced by our conversation and replay.

On this measure the timeline is arbitrary, and trumping it is a second work all together, creating a new conversation.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by blenderdt on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:22AM (#31134502)
What good does this work of Cage bring the world?

Most people think it is uninteresting and a total waste of time.

I can also understand the aggression a lot of Cage's work got in the past. It's very destructive for people to listen a long time to a man who is only speaking letters. Almost like torture.

Is a waste of time art?

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Honga on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:39AM (#31135202)
It's not the job of the work to bring good to the world, nor to interest people in the slightest, as can be said for yourself, or myself. Though you're right that the success of the work is probably intrinsically tied to it's interest.

Art, and media in general are productions of culture which celebrate our humanity. That is, they rejoice in all of our abilities to perceive, conceive and enact upon the world. Wasting people's time in this light makes people aware of their time, and allows for further interrogations of our humanities to arise. Just as we're doing now.

It's good to remember that art only gains it's status through a production being named art by an exhibitor. IMO there's no special purpose to the term. Consuming art is just another form of recreation, and people are right to hate it for any reason, just that tyranny of what is useful is usually not in the human spirits best interest.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by vlunkr on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:39AM (#31134653)
IMO the point is to question the limits of what can be considered music. There's precedent (way too much in fact) in visual arts. Is a signed toilet art? Mona Lisa with a mustache? Banana taped to a wall?

None of these things are meant to be enjoyed in the traditional sense. But they might make you think, or make you angry.

So what good do these things bring the world? I don't know, probably none.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Bud on Saturday April 23, 2022 @08:59PM (#31140265)
I think the best response to your claim that "most people" find Cage uninteresting is this book intro that e. e. cummings wrote. He had a few things to say about "mostpeople":

https://www.americanpoems.com/poets/eecummings/introduction-...

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by rerx on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:27AM (#31134068)
This is all concept, of course. But walking around the dishevelled old church, listening to the constant humm in the background is an experience that grows from knowing that this tone will last for years until it will change as prescribed. A tone change is a small event that draws some attention from wider circles. There are people who have cared for the project for more than 20 years and it's not only folks who initiated it. It will be fascinating to see how long there will be interest and resources to keep it up.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by chki on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:37AM (#31134150)
Maybe that's part of his art? To show where music and experiencing something as music "ends" and where art "begins". Exploring the boundaries of what constitutes music or art is interesting to me.

> I don't think any of that sort of music will survive long, because the concept is no longer clever after it loses its novelty.

At some point it stops being a novelty and becomes a historical event, where a piece of music has already been playing for 400 years. Wouldn't it be interesting to visit a place where you know that people hundreds of years ago have listened not only to the same piece of music but to the same performance as you are experiencing right now. That listenership spans centuries?

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:16AM (#31134461)
I believe we're agreeing, except in our value judgments. You say:

> Exploring the boundaries of what constitutes music or art is interesting to me.

Interesting, yes, as a concept, and perhaps even as a cultural event, but we certainly agree that it's a different kind of experience than a musical performance.

> Wouldn't it be interesting to visit a place where you know that people hundreds of years ago have listened not only to the same piece of music but to the same performance as you are experiencing right now. That listenership spans centuries?

I honestly have no interest in visiting such a place to hear a note, or even the change from one note to another. And recognize that what interests you in such a visit is not musical interest, but conceptual interest.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by klelatti on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:51PM (#31137172)
I think that there are several issues with this perspective.

Firstly, it presupposes that the music and the ‘concept’ are distinct. I love say Mahler 2 and the Rite of Spring but I love those pieces as a collection of notes and a concept together and trying to separate the ‘concept’ from the notes is impossible - when I listen to them the concept is an essential part of the experience.

In this case I can imagine listening to the notes in the knowledge of the wider context and being profoundly moved by the experience. I don’t see this as any different to music that is highly repetitive (and so not ‘interesting’ musically), for example, but still elicits an emotional response from many listeners.

Finally, if the classification is of composers into two camps, with Cage being in the wrong camp, then I’m afraid that the idea that Cage’s music won’t survive long isn’t backed up by the evidence as most of it is still doing really well many years after it was composed.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by UncleMeat on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:41AM (#31134675)
Is it wrong to explore the boundaries of the art form for reasons other than enjoyment? Formal experimentation is powerful and gives ideas to later composers. By constraining oneself to the goal of enjoyable performance, one can't be as free to experiment formally.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:37AM (#31135181)
Wrong? I don't see it as a moral issue. I see it as an abandonment of music, but not a moral wrong.

I think there's a value distinction to be drawn between boundary explorations that expand the art form and those that simply depart from any definition of it separate from the other arts. That leaves a broad scope for innovation: the composers of the ars subtilior, Carlo Gesualdo, Hector Berlioz, Debussy and Satie, Harry Partch, Antheil and Edgard Varese, and the progression of serialism from Schoenberg through Webern to Boulez — all of them explored and expanded the boundaries of music, but you can still experience their works as music, even if some have argued that it's bad music. It all can be, and has been, accepted as music.

But some of Cage's works (of those which he presented as musical) depart from musical material and musical experience to play with the nonmusical culture that surrounds music and musicians, or, abandoning that, the idea of performance itself. Obviously 4'33", with its formalities of opening and closing a piano, is an example of the former, but his lesser-known 0'00" runs simply, "In a situation provided with maximum amplification, perform a disciplined action." In that case, the performer is as justified in a disciplined soiling of their pants as any musical act. I refuse to countenance such wanking. (Cage was by no means alone in this, but he's probably the most famous.)

I'm glad to see that even academic composers seem to have retreated from this dissolution.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by fipar on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:53PM (#31135944)
I enjoy reading Cage a lot more than listening to his music (for that matter, he was fine with not being called a musician if people deemed his work not worthy of that, I can’t recall exactly but I believe sound architect is the alternative job description he proposed).

I don’t relate to most of his music but I do think he was on an honest quest for something. In fact, I think it could even be fair to say he was a philosopher using sound as his medium, instead of a musician.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:56PM (#31135981)
I agree with everything you wrote there.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by klelatti on Saturday April 23, 2022 @03:14PM (#31137438)
4’33” isn’t about about non musical culture although some have mistakenly construed it as such. Cage made it absolutely clear what it was about in his comments about the piece.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @03:32PM (#31137637)
I could have worded that better: to make its point about sounds and, if you please, music, it depends on nonmusical cultural expectations that surround musical performance. Its adherence to the outward trappings of musical performance in the 20th century prompt the audience to perceive what occurs during it as part of a "performance". Apart from that, there's nothing more musical about it than sitting alone in a meadow — which I think was essentially Cage's point.

That I find myself using the word "point" so often here emphasizes, to me, that Cage was engaging in philosophy rather than musical composition.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by klelatti on Saturday April 23, 2022 @03:45PM (#31137759)
Your last sentence is very interesting and probably captures our different perspectives. I see Cage’s work as pointing towards an experience that I might enjoy and be enriched by in practice (not always but then I don’t always enjoy performances of my favourite works) and the concept is part but only a part of that.

Messiaen found sitting in a meadow quite a musical experience!

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:26PM (#31140745)
That's why I chose the sitting in a meadow comparison: it's an experience you could also choose to interpret as musical even though it is not organized sound. An aside: I think an awareness of and exposure to the sounds of nature is beneficial to a composer, even if I don't think it's intrinsically musical.
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by swayvil on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:49AM (#31135306)
Well you're trading music for a story about music.

It's a matter of taste, of course.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by ogogmad on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:21AM (#31134999)
plausible but [citation needed]
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by jeegsy on Saturday April 23, 2022 @09:11AM (#31133951)
Its an excellent point. You really cant get a sense of the whole thing since its mostly one tone stretched out most of the time. Hopefully it survives the stated 639 years
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by Bud on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:00AM (#31134348)
You could listen to one of the versions out there that only lasts an hour. That would give you a good sense of the full piece.

Then you could go listen to a snippet of it, in this extremely slow version, and get a sense of that.

Then combine the two.

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by swayvil on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:47AM (#31135284)
Artists are generally in the first camp. Nonartists in second.

Go to a gallery full of abstract expressionism. Hear people asking, "what does it mean?"

Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt by tomcam on Saturday April 23, 2022 @11:49AM (#31135309)
The first 15 years weren’t so catchy, but the chorus starting in easily 2016 is catchy as hell