Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt
by klelatti on Saturday April 23, 2022 @03:45PM
(#31137759)
Your last sentence is very interesting and probably captures our different perspectives. I see Cage’s work as pointing towards an experience that I might enjoy and be enriched by in practice (not always but then I don’t always enjoy performances of my favourite works) and the concept is part but only a part of that.
Messiaen found sitting in a meadow quite a musical experience!
Re:John Cage Organ Project in Halberstadt
by JasonFruit on Saturday April 23, 2022 @10:26PM
(#31140745)
That's why I chose the sitting in a meadow comparison: it's an experience you could also choose to interpret as musical even though it is not organized sound. An aside: I think an awareness of and exposure to the sounds of nature is beneficial to a composer, even if I don't think it's intrinsically musical.
That I find myself using the word "point" so often here emphasizes, to me, that Cage was engaging in philosophy rather than musical composition.