https://erikhoel.substack.com/p/why-we-stopped-making-einste...
Teachers are criminally underpaid, unsupported, and overworked, while parents are not engaged with their children's learning. It's a bad mix. Not to mention the politicization of teacher unions.
My impression is that public school teachers have been un-empowered to fail out kids, or punish them for bad behavior in class.
As if the only way a person can be overworked is by not being effective at their job.
And thus it is the teacher's failing that they cannot keep up with the workload, not the people assigning the workload.
It seems you have had a very rare and fortunate life. I am happy for you, though I wish you had more respect for others.
You took this a little far with the personal attack.
If you threw out all the context switching and review and catch-up, you could probably teach most year-long high school subject curricula in a week.
I hear some tech workers complain that their days are made ineffective by lots of pointless meetings.
What?
Your teachers not understanding material doesn’t matter if their role is prompting you to ask the right questions and find areas of interest.
I highly recommend that anyone else who feels the same way look into Acton Academy. The model is based on project based work, self guided learning, and Socratic discussions. There are locations all throughout the U.S. My six year old may not recognize all the material for a standardized test, but he’s fascinated by laws of physics, engineering for space, growing plants, and conservation. At home he wanted to start a project on simulating landing a Mars rover with a small programmable robot. He’s playing around with the idea of cushioning the landing versus building a parachute. And all of this is something we can tie back together to make interesting for him — because he has interests! How could we collect a plant seed after landing for example.
His approach to his other interests is similarly curious. He doesn’t want to be told how to fish by an authority, he wants to experiment with different techniques and think about how he can improve iteratively.
We stomp curiosity out of children in public schools. We need to stop.
I wonder if this is the sort of thing that could be fixed by paying teachers more. Why would a smart person become a teacher if a professional industry job will pay $300-500k and a teaching job will pay $100k? Is paying teachers so much even palatable to the general public?
salaries top out around 70K. That's ending salary, not starting salary.
And yes, this could be fixed by paying teachers more. And treating the profession with some respect.
I wanted to go into teaching but stopped after I realized what that would mean for my long term earnings. Even with time taken off as a stay at home parent and time spent working in the developing world, I’m getting close to the lifetime earnings for teachers who progress in their careers. In less than a decade of working.
1. Students with chronic behavior problems are easier to throw out
2. Parents are less likely to go on idiotic crusades about the content of the curriculum
3. The school board (or, more likely, the state legislature) isn't going to make irrelevant changes to appease voters
Private schools are more likely to treat their teachers as independent professionals rather than glorified babysitters or McEducation employees.
Here's the HS math sequence options from my local school district in VA. Can't speak to many other places but this is what my above comment is based on.
I probably could've specialized better if I had done that in school, but who knows. My attention was trash and still getting worse.
Of course you're learning about others' crown achievements, there's no need to reinvent the wheel. And things got way more complicated, there's so much to know that it's hard to remember. Especially if you use social media, always some shit there that you'll shove in your memory instead of useful things heh.
Most new things are a spin on the old, it might've been easier to discover/stumble upon something genuinely new 100+ years ago.
Without it folks might end up pigeonholed into whatever their family does or a narrow selection of trades within the local community.
All of which is usually covered by 8th grade in the US.
HS is a waste for most people attending.
1) The baseline is extremely low, and getting lower by the year
I will take math as an example. High school, at the best possible setting, leaves you knowing single variable calculus.
Is this enough? no, it's nearly zero. To be able to understand anything about math in the modern age, you have to know :
- Formal logic
- Linear Algebra and Differential Equations at 4x courses or more level
- Probability and statistics, 2 or 3 courses.
So all in all, in order to even think intelligently about a field like math, in order to have any chance at all of even comprehending the slightest inkling of what all those scientists and engineers and ML practitioners who impact your life massively even do, you have to know easily 10x of what high school, in the best possible scenario, teaches you.
Then one year passes, science, math and engineering get more complex, and high school curriculum and budgets get lower and lower, and the race to the bottom continues.
You can repeat this exercise for any subject : Ask a specialist what's the bare, absolute minimum for anyone to think or reason effectively about their subject, compare their answer to the K12 curricula for that subject, and laugh at the sheer mismatch of the two.
2) The baseline is redundant and wasteful
The sheer waste is mind boggling, all of my K12 education could be easily compressed in 6 years of study. Lessons are repeated over and over again each year, irrelevant subjects like the agricultural policy of Brazil and Nigeria are stuffed in overweight geography curriculums for no apparent reason (my country is neither of those 2), the English language's way of annotating verbs with tenses is rehashed for the 7th time this year.
There is no concept of opportunity cost, there is no awareness of a notion of "What could I teach this kid this year instead of yet another rehashing of the names of the world's most popular rivers and mountains?".
3) The baseline is low quality, low relevance and low impact
Programming is memorizing visual basic's or php's basic syntax, math is learning a formula and repeatedly applying it over and over again to questions with parameters varied, biology is memorizing the reasons of why various phenomena happen.
It's not only that what gets teached is a pathetically small subset of what needs to be teached, and not only that it's teached in 2x the time needed with metric tons of mindless repetition and rehashing. It's that even this small subset that is teached and re-teached, is teached in the most boring, unmemorable, uninspiring, useless and actively harmful way possible.
It's not a good baseline, people leave it not knowing a single worthwhile thing about anything or - even worse - actively thinking those subjects are useless pontifications and navel-gazing. It does an awful lot of harm and virtually 0 good, when you divide by the time and resources it consume .
I'm not saying US K12 is perfect. Rather that it isn't trying to cater to 90th percentile, independent learners. For those hopefully the parents will recognize greatness and seek a more fitting alternative.
Granted, children are not necessarily trustable to figure it all out on their own. It’s more the bullying, anti-intellectualism, and generally not considering their needs that needs checking.
Maybe now people have to spend their 20s learning about the discoveries because our modern pre-post-secondary education has become so watered down and unambitious.
Personally, I get the sense that could have learned 5x to 20x as much in my teenage years if I hadn't been in an excessively mediocre public education system. And I'm not a genius :)