News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by Retric on Friday April 15, 2022 @09:50PM (#31048388)
Saying the wrong thing in a private setting and getting fired has been a thing before computers existed.

Cancel culture is just a new name for an ancient practice: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shunning

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by da_chicken on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:03PM (#31048984)
In John Stuart Mill's seminal work On Liberty, he explicitly calls out the tyranny and power of social consequences and their ability to chill free speech. He notes that social consequences for minority opinions can be even more severely chilling than even state consequences. Of course, as I recall he also basically offered no solutions.

Social consequences are both necessary and cause problems. It's really a very complicated thing. People should be free to explore ideas that turn out to be bad without losing their livelihoods. We need to hold people accountable for their actions, but we also need to allow people to make mistakes and learn.

If I think about what happened with Lindsay Ellis, that seems like a gross overreaction. If I think about how people on Twitter sharply criticize Chris Pratt because of the church he attends (which is also attended by other Hollywood stars) then that seems like an overreaction, too. On the other hand, the response to Kevin Spacey seems like it might be more appropriate.

The real issue is that "being cancelled" is only a problem for people who are famous and not powerful. If you're powerful, being cancelled really doesn't do anything at all. Indeed, if you're powerful, being cancelled can just get people to agree with you more even if you have actually done the awful things you are cancelled for.

Nevertheless, there is so much pearl clutching, clout chasing, outrage Olympics, victim identity politics, and manufactured wedge issues on social media that it's just one big rat's nest. Worse, it all overshadows the real problems like actual political issues and misinformation being spread to manipulate opinion.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by utbabya on Saturday April 16, 2022 @05:02PM (#31056065)
Saw this comment before I slept and I think I woke up with a solution!

The problem is incentive based, cancelling others gains one social power. So the solution is simple, use the same weapon, and we are getting at step 1 already.

1) Being "woke" about how cruel cancelling other is, collectively.

2) Cancel the cancellors by naming and shaming every single participant, instead of the cancellee, for reason 1). Script it if necessary.

3) The balance of power is restored, just as Jesus intended, armchair judges get judged. (Doesn't it sound like the beginining of just any other cultural shift?)

4) ...

5) profit!

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Friday April 15, 2022 @09:57PM (#31048444)
See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Brown_(loyalist)

> Brown soon found himself embroiled in the coming revolution. On 2 August 1775 a crowd of 130 Sons of Liberty confronted him at his house and demanded he pledge himself to the Patriot cause. Brown requested the liberty to hold his own opinions, saying that he could "never enter into an Engagement to take up arms against the Country which gave him being", and finally met their demands with pistol and sword. The crowd seized him and struck him with the butt of a musket, fracturing his skull. Taken prisoner, he was tied to a tree where he was roasted by fire and scalped before being tarred and feathered. Brown was then carted through a number of nearby settlements and forced to verbally pledge himself to the Patriot cause before being released. This mistreatment resulted in the loss of two toes and lifelong headaches.

Cancel culture has been with us since the beginning. Hell, other primates kick bad actors out of the social group; it's been a thing before language existed.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by 2muchcoffeeman on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:46AM (#31049851)
I missed the part where they had high speed wireless internet and social media networks in the 18th century.

Technology has enabled us to have artificially wide reach and memory. And then they digitised it, made it searchable and opened it all up to the masses.

Don't like a person and they have Twitter? Guess I'll dig through their Twitter feed and find something objectionable they posted when they were 16. While I'm here I'd better make sure all my like-minded online "friends" from all over the globe pile on and try and coerce their employer to fire them. For good measure, let's find their address and make it easily accessible online.

Technology has a transformative effect on the things we apply it to. Let's not pretend that trying to shame people in the 21st century using freely accessible communication networks that span the globe is the same as monkeys shaming other monkeys.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Saturday April 16, 2022 @09:25AM (#31052130)
The point is it that doesn’t matter as much as you’d think.

If you piss off your monkey tribe, you’re done for. Good chance you’re dead soon without your social group. The news of your being kicked out spread to everyone who matters in life.

Piss off your town in the 1700s and the same is probably true. People didn’t move far from family and relied heavily on local communities. Again, news spread to everyone who mattered rapidly.

I’d rather today’s flash in the pan outrage over a community shunning - or worse, tarring/feathering or lynching - a couple hundred years ago. It’s a lot more survivable; ask notable cancelee Louis CK about his recent Grammy win.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by 2muchcoffeeman on Saturday April 16, 2022 @09:57AM (#31052358)
If I said something truly moronic as a teenager back in the “good old days”, but only my family heard me, I’d get punished and that could be enough to rethink my views or behaviour. My mistake would likely end there. Or at least your neighbours might never know.

Now some dumb kid can post to Twitter or Facebook and that can be used against them 10 years later by some random person. You could even be saying things that aligns with your communities values (say you have conservative religious views) and then a bunch of strangers who you don’t know will come after you because they disagree with you.

I can literally reach back in time and hold people accountable for things they no longer believe in.

Comparing this to not getting lynched is a really low bar. I would certainly hope in this day and age that we’re at least civil enough not to become pitch fork wielding mobs. That’s the bare minimum.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by Retric on Monday April 18, 2022 @09:49AM (#31070508)
You swapped public vs private, but peoples diaries have caused them problems in the past. It’s an issue with the written word rather than the spoken one that’s adding repercussions years later.

“If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him.”

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:21PM (#31048663)
The new trend of sticking it to the cons by comparing 2022 to 18th century mobs or early 20th century speech codes is something I didn’t have on my bingo card.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:59PM (#31048948)
It's being widely claimed that "cancel culture" is some kind of new and different phenomenon; it hardly takes much historical knowledge to know it's not. Examples abound, in nature, antiquity (go tell Socrates about being "canceled"), etc.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by prepend on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:18AM (#31049713)
I don’t the claim is that cancel culture is new, but the rate and method is new. It happens more frequently for different topics.

That’s what I think of when I hear “cancel culture.” When you present an example from the 18th century, that’s not a very useful rebuttal. It seems like you either don’t understand, are deflecting, or using a “but all lives matter” argument.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:24AM (#31049745)
The method and rate aren’t new.

The method is “people tell others you’re an asshole”.

The rate is “quickly”. For most people in the 1700s, the news only has to go a few miles to spread to basically everyone you know.

Ask Aaron Burr. Not just canceled in short order, but remembered for it in a hit musical centuries later.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by prepend on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:33AM (#31049778)
I remember the pr person fired during her flight to South Africa because of the hundred thousand retweets. Thats new and that’s much faster.

Aaron Burr wasn’t cancelled over a single message within twelve hours.

(Thousands of similar stories)

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:35AM (#31049787)
You remember her nearly a decade later because it’s rare. (She’s also doing fine: https://www.vox.com/2018/1/19/16911074/justine-sacco-iac-mat...)

People have irreparably ruined their reputations in less time than a plane flight. Burr did it in a single instant.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by foldr on Saturday April 16, 2022 @05:10AM (#31050891)
The woman in question was a VP of communications who tweeted the following:

>Going to Africa. Hope I don’t get AIDS. Just kidding. I’m white!

It is not hard to see why a company would fire a VP of communications who tweeted this. In general, you have to be careful about what you do and say in public when you have a senior position within a company. This is nothing new.

In the bad old days, people used to get fired when their employer found out that they were having a gay affair, or had a mixed race child. Now people are more likely to get fired for saying or doing racist or homophobic things. To me this seems like progress.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:21PM (#31049113)
As a conservative I’m not even a big believer in the perfectability of man. I just find it funny that people are copping to being the latest generation of John Ashcroft throwing curtains over naked statues.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by Msw242 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @12:20AM (#31049434)
Is that the comparison you really want to draw?
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:12AM (#31049687)
Yes.

Today’s supposed “cancel culture” is substantially gentler than any time in history. We enjoy rights to free speech broader and stronger than ever.

Socrates would be jealous.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by Tao331 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:57AM (#31049916)
Socrates wasn't cancelled. Insofar as we can trust Plato and Xenophon, we know who he was and the things he said. Athens may have executed him, but they didn't deplatform him.

> Socrates would be jealous.

I doubt that very much. Your examples are bad enough to be considered trolling.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ceejayoz on Saturday April 16, 2022 @08:56AM (#31051935)
Execution for pissing everyone off doesn’t count as cancellation?

We know who Alex Jones is. Louis CK is out there getting awards. If “we know who he was and the things he said” means you’re not canceled, we’re in very good shape.

> Athens may have executed him, but they didn't deplatform him.

You get what a hilariously scary and silly statement this is, right?

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by Tao331 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @10:07AM (#31052433)
;)
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by skinnymuch on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:19AM (#31049716)
Why wouldn’t they?
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by skinnymuch on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:04AM (#31049647)
What do either of your example trends mean? What 18th century mob has been brought up? What in 2022? What speech codes are you referring to?

It appears as if this is your way of saying “cancel culture” is different than it was before in terms of “cancelling” happening?

If so, then your examples would make sense as parroting the weak concept of “cancel culture” being anything but another moral panic and made up culture war in the long line of things to keep the status quo going.

Why do any of these cancel trends matter? Even if they do exist. Why not eliminate the possibility of the worst fears of cancel culture so that becomes moot and society is improved? That would require people not being able to go homeless if they suddenly lose their job and/or can’t work for some time. It doesn’t come across that being able to be homeless because of work and income issues is a horrible outcome no matter what. Not only when it is because of “cancel” culture.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ModernMech on Saturday April 16, 2022 @09:01AM (#31051967)
> Why not eliminate the possibility of the worst fears of cancel culture so that becomes moot and society is improved?

Indeed why not? It’s glaring to me that when I read these arguments, the solution to cancel culture never seems to be to limit the ability of employers to fire at will.

The only reason cancelling works at all is that you can be fired for any reason or no reason at the drop of a hat, with little to no recourse, and at great financial loss to yourself with the potential of losing your food, shelter, and medical care in an instant. People have been begging to change this system for a long time for this very reason.

But why does this system continue to exist if it has the potential to be so destructive? As far as I can tell it serves wealthy elites like large corporations very well. They enjoy having this ability to ruin your life by firing you. It’s the best leverage they have!

This is why the whole cancel culture debate is so fascinating to me. Generally speaking the people who are so upset about cancel culture are the very people who are standing in the way of eliminating the worst consequences of it. Instead they ground their position in the idea of free speech, but paradoxically the principles of free speech preclude any solution to cancel culture, because such a solution would restrict free speech!

I’m really waiting for the day that cancel culture warriors recognize the root problem here: that we built our society in a way, on purpose, to give people (business owners) this great power over others (employees) as a means to control them. If I can be fired tomorrow and still have food, housing, and healthcare then getting fired isn’t going to ruin my life. The flip side of that is employers won’t be able to fire their employees for any reason or no reason, and that seems to be a bridge too far for some of even the most ardent anti cancel culture warriors (see if Musk would ever advocate to curb his own ability to fire his employees).

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ripe on Saturday April 16, 2022 @02:07PM (#31054572)
Very much this. The enormous arbitrary power that employers wield and have always wielded, is one of the sacred cows of capitalism. Underprivileged people have had to deal with being fired (or never even being hired) for irrelevant reasons or in fact without any reason being given at all. But now that this same hammer is coming down on white people's offensive tweets, suddenly it's a "free speech" issue.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by armchairhacker on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:05PM (#31048518)
Yes, people have been much worse than "cancelled" for much more "borderline" taboo opinions.

But spread of information today is definitely an issue. Back then you could be more comfortable saying stuff in private. Now with a lot of communications online, proof* of private conversations can affect you in public.

* There's also the issue of people framing things out of context but that's a separate topic.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by elpakal on Friday April 15, 2022 @09:59PM (#31048455)
Yes but it wasnt as easy to find out about and there weren’t as many companies who profited from making these kind of things easy to hear about.