News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by roenxi on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:10AM (#30976666)
This may be a mystery best left unsolved. If we insist on figuring it out experimentally, I recommend waiting until I'm dead of some non-nuclear-fireball cause.

There is no reason to escalate tensions in Ukraine to the point where this is an option, anyway. NATO should back off, call it Iraq 2.0 and agree that there are to be no NATO-supported military on Russia's doorstep. The current policies are recklessly provocative.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by iso1210 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:25AM (#30976755)
No, Russia should stop bombing people
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Razengan on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:27AM (#30976774)
And the US, having bombed more people all over the world than literally all other nations combined.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:40AM (#30976844)
А у вас негров линчуют.

Regimes come and go but whataboutism lives forever.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Ancapistani on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:46AM (#30990391)
> А у вас негров линчуют.

Google Translate: "And you have blacks linch"

My assumption as to a more natural translation: "And you have Blacks lynched"

Context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Razengan on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:05AM (#30987544)
> whataboutism lives forever

As does hypocrisy.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by acadapter on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:31AM (#30977193)
Whataboutism is a natural consequence of regarding double standards as something negative
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:39AM (#30977262)
Where do you see a double standard? Did iso1210 say that the US should keep bombing people?

This is just apologism for Russian atrocities masquerading as pointing out a double standard. As we’ve seen in the West for more than one hundred years now.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by IgorPartola on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:35AM (#30976819)
Two wrongs make a right?
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by dotancohen on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:31PM (#30978688)

  > Two wrongs make a right?
No. But when the US normalizes a behaviour and other countries follow suit, why are those other countries criticized but the US is not?

For what it's worth, I'm on neither side of the Ukraine-Russia debate. Both are horribly corrupt states, and NATO has been prodding Russia over the ex-Soviet states for a decade.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by todorus on Sunday April 10, 2022 @03:35PM (#30980848)
Excuse me? Dutchie here, the US have a horrible reputation even among their allies. They are as much criticized as Russia is right now. Maybe even more so considering that we get more imagery from the "exploits" of the US.

Stop with this double standard whataboutism, and maybe find some other circles to hang around in: you'll find the critique you wish for there.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Razengan on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:06AM (#30987559)
Stop with this double standard hypocrisy, and sanction the US as well if you really care about war crimes etc.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by esailija on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:19AM (#30977103)
It's proof by contradiction. Either you are against bombing innocents or you are not. By holding a stance that only Russia bombing innocents is wrong you are not only for bombing innocents you are also a russophobe at the same time.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by kergonath on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:56AM (#30978270)
It’s not a proof. It begs the question and starts from the assumption that the OP is ok with the US bombing people. Then it uses the dodgy premise that the US is worse than Russia when considering the metric “number of people bombed” (which I assume includes things like Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and the Vietnam war, not bothering with details such as the fact that these were actual wars and not unprovoked agressions), ignoring any other metric like “number of killed foreign civilians”, on which Russia, as the proud heir of the USSR, would be vying for the top spot with nazi Germany.

So yeah, faulty premise, cherry picking, and circular logic, as well as putting words into someone else’s mouth. It is just sub-standard trolling.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:41AM (#30977287)
By holding a stance that only Russia bombing innocents

Who is holding that stance? Must every conversation start with a comprehensive list of all unjust things currently occurring anywhere in the world?

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Viliam1234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:08AM (#30977644)
I think the tradition is that only conversations about unjust things done by Russia must start with a comprehensive list of all unjust things done by USA.

Unjust things done by other countries can be discussed freely.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by esailija on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:51AM (#30977381)
> Who is holding that stance?

The one who was willing to risk nuclear war for Russian actions, it's above in this comment thread. I am making pretty reasonable guess that the same person was not wanting nuclear war over similar actions of US.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:00AM (#30977525)
So we’ve gone from proof by contradiction to guess on top of guess.

No agenda, right?

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by simondotau on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:51AM (#30977384)
Hang on, when did anyone in this thread say they were not against bombing innocents? You’re making rather bold assumptions here.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by mads_ravn on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:12PM (#30979184)
One party is currently torturing and murdering civilians, which tends to skew the conversation in a particular direction. Once Russia has withdrawn all troops from Ukraine we can discus behavior of other nations.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by t-3 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:45PM (#30982039)
Most parties are currently torturing and killing civilians, but some have better PR departments. Guantanamo Bay, Iraq, Aafghanistan, Syria, Libya, Yemen, Venezuela, and the list goes on and on. Nobody cares until white people die though.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by kergonath on Monday April 11, 2022 @07:22AM (#30987191)
Guantanamo is a stain on the US and will be for the foreseeable future, just like internment camps for Japanese people during WWII. But comparing either with Grozny, Aleppo (seriously, why mention Syria at all?), or Mariupol is either completely disingenuous, or entirely uninformed. It is also a complete false equivalence to compare them to the neo-gulags, just ask Navalny.

Which city did the US flatten since Dresden? How many hospitals did they voluntarily bomb? Hell, how many hospitals did the US bomb at all (and no, I don’t assume that number is zero)? Now, compare that to what happened in Karkhiv alone.

Playing chicken when Assad used chemical weapons on Syrian civilians and Putin razed Grozny were stupid mistakes. This is not a reason to let the same thing happen again in Ukraine.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by FpUser on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:09AM (#30977664)
No. But one definitely gets punishment and rightly so. The other never will. They just say fuck you. We are the good guys, we are exceptional and we have the biggest dick. Look what they promised to ICC should they ever try to indict their nationals.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by gambiting on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:22AM (#30976739)
I imagine it must feel great to be able to say something like this if you don't live in the region. Some of us don't have such comfort though.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bobthechef on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:01AM (#30976966)
The Poles, the Baltic states, etc. know Russia all too well and have an fear of Russian power that is justified. However, NATO is not some simple fix as current events demonstrate. Central Europe is a region between a rock and a hard place. On the one hand, Russian imperial propensities are not appeased. On the other, NATO (vel American) incursion and regime change has provided a pretext for grievance and military action.

The only long term stable geopolitical option for the region is the historic option: a powerful regional state and/or bloc that can simultaneously dampen Russian imperialism as well as "Western" ambition, like this one[0] which is a nascent project that I suspect can lead to a high degree of regional solidarity that will stabilize all of Europe and therefore contribute to the stability of the Eurasian landmass.

[0] https://3seas.eu/

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by qwytw on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:25PM (#30978628)
Except that almost every single Central and Eastern European country benefit tremendously from interference by the West. The region was mostly left alone after WW1 so we ended up with a bunch of isolated states run by quasi fascist regimes 1930's. And guess how that turned out?
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by seba_dos1 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:04PM (#30979809)
It's a very poor pretext. NATO doesn't threaten European countries to join it and doesn't invade them if they don't. It's the countries themselves who choose to associate with the West, Russian aggression being one of the contributing factors.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by randomname93857 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:12PM (#30981757)
Disagree. russia forces puppet dictatorships on its neoghbours , but when that fails they spread lies and invading / annex them. Haven't this happened multiple times already?
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by happytoexplain on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:46AM (#30976881)
NATO has a moral quandary on their hands. It's reasonable to argue that a given decision is the wrong one, but it seems ridiculous to lay the label of "recklessly provocative" on anybody but Putin, who threatened to nuke Europe over "offenses" for which a nuclear holocaust is, to put it lightly, not commensurate.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Zanfa on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:41AM (#30977288)
Putin’s been threatening to nuke or invade its neighbors about once a week for the past two decades already. Nothing but hot air, just a brand new audience who aren’t used to hearing it all the time.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by lolc on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:00PM (#30978332)
How I wish it was just hot air.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by NoOn3 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:01PM (#30978339)
Prior to recent events , he stated that no first nuke strike...
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by peoplefromibiza on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:07AM (#30977627)
two things are clear:

- Putin has been left in charge by the same people that now are surprised Putin is being Putin. also US were too busy in Afghanistan and trying to make China look like the biggest threat to international peace.

- NATO should never ever intervene in areas that do not belong to NATO. When it happened it didn't go well (Bosnia and Herzegovina 1995, Kosovo 1999)

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by sgc on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:10PM (#30978459)
Neither of those things are clear at all.

I don't think anybody in Russia is surprised by Putin. They are, far and away, primarily responsible for him being in power.

NATO stopped some pretty horrific atrocities from spiraling even further out of control during those interventions. The not going well part mainly happened before they intervened. And yes, nothing is ever perfect.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by peoplefromibiza on Sunday April 10, 2022 @12:52PM (#30978937)
> I don't think anybody in Russia is surprised by Putin.

who ever said anything about Russians?

You should also aknowledge that Russians don't know as much as we do about what's really happening in Ukraine right now.

> They are, far and away, primarily responsible for him being in power.

ridiculous.

Now it's clear why things are unclear to you, you don't even know how Putin got in charge in the first place.

> NATO stopped some pretty horrific atrocities from spiraling even further out of control during those interventions

No, it didn't.

Nothing NATO did prevented any atrocity, the atrocities had already happened, they could be stopped in many other ways, NATO chose bombings because bombing was the easier option and the one that assured that as little men as possible would be killed on NATO side.

The fact that it (kinda) worked doesn't imply that it did go well, it went very bad indeed.

NATO bombings worked same way they worked in Afghanistan, Iraq, Lybia, middle east in general: they didn't.

They just killed a lot of people for no real gain, what actually stopped those wars was the capture of the dictator of the day, not the bombs.

Milošević survived all of that and was also running for presidency in 2000.

He was arrested on suspicion of corruption, abuse of power, and embezzlement. The international tribunal could not charge him with anything, he died of heart attack in his cell in 2006 without a verdict under very unclear circumstances.

Ask William Perry (former Secretary of defense) what he thinks of those actions in retrospect.

Also the legality of the operation is still unclear.

You knew if your country was 30kms of sea away from former Yugoslavia and you could see the sky turning bright and red at night or fishermen kept digging up unused bomb flushed into the Adriatic sea by NATO bombers, together with a lot of toxic and dangerous chemicals.

Just a few pointers to shed some light on the whole fiasco

- United States bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade (bombed because allegation that proved to be false)

- Niš cluster bombing (cluster bombs were already illegal in 1999)

- A Perfect Failure: NATO's War against Yugoslavia - Michael Mandelbaum: Kosovo's consequences were just the opposite of what NATO intended: suffering Kosovar civilians, regional instability, and a fuming Russia and China.

But yeah, I guess American propaganda worked if there are people that still believe 23 years later that bombing the Balkans was "good". The Mandela effect is stronger than I thought.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by sgc on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:25PM (#30981868)
How Putin came to power and how he is now in power are two distinct things. I was talking about the present, with 20 years of many/most Russians just basking in Putin's killer tough guy shtick while he had his soldiers massacre and rape people indiscriminately, and invade countries around the region. Many Russians know exactly what is going on and still support it. And they all have a responsibility to attempt to overcome their media blackouts and find out.

I am intimately aware of the Kosovo situation, and not from US sources. I had to do a fair amount of reading to understand since I was constantly exposed to both Serbian and Albanian perspectives. This always turns into a flame war whenever it is mentioned online, but suffice to say there are many people who think they would not be alive today if it were not for NATO's actions. And that war was 23 years ago. The same thing could be more precisely done today of course. Again, I do not claim they were perfect at all. However, exponentially more innocent people were killed by the Serbs than those bombings ever killed. And civilian deaths were never the intention.

As for Milošević, let me pull out my tiney tiny violin. Whatever we might disagree on, I do think we can agree he was a war criminal, full stop. Whether he was convicted is irrelevant.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by peoplefromibiza on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:54AM (#30985874)
> How Putin came to power and how he is now in power are two distinct things

They are not.

> I was talking about the present, with 20 years of many/most Russians just basking in Putin's killer tough guy shtick while he had his soldiers massacre and rape people indiscriminately, and invade countries around the region

Not differently from what US has done in the past 20 years.

Russians are responsible for Putin's actions no more than Americans are for what their DOD does.

> but suffice to say there are many people who think they would not be alive today if it were not for NATO's actions.

That doesn't imply, __again__, that it wasn't bad.

Many people would not be alive if Stalin hadn't defeat Hitler, that doesn't mean it was good.

> However, exponentially more innocent people were killed by the Serbs than those bombings ever killed. And civilian deaths were never the intention.

Arithmetic is the weapon of dictators, not of democracies.

> Whatever we might disagree on, I do think we can agree he was a war criminal, full stop. Whether he was convicted is irrelevant.

Failure to bring criminals to justice is the reason why the death of civilians is unacceptable.

In our democracies nobody is a criminal, unless convicted.

Even war criminals such as Milošević.

It's not enough to know they are criminals to kill them in a prison's cell, that's what people like Putin do.

But most of all, democracies should __protect prisoners at all costs__, not kill them (if your country hasn't abolished death penalty, it's not a real modern democracy and can't be taken seriously when talking about "freedom rights") not let them die in prison and not discard their deaths because they were enemies.

I call myself a democrat because I would never do to them what they would probably do to me.

If we go around bombing civilians and keep doing things like this, covering up the atrocities[1] with lies and false myths[2], we are in no position to believe we are better.

That's why NATO should not intervene outside of NATO territories, because that's what NATO pact is about.

Protecting its members, not policing the World, especially those parts of the World that we kept unstable with our bombs.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/13/us/us-airstrikes-civilian...

[2] https://www.jstor.org/stable/2538830

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by astine on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:46AM (#30989526)
Many people would not be alive if Stalin hadn't defeat Hitler, that doesn't mean it was good.

The defeat of Nazi Germany wasn't good? The fuck?