News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by esailija on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:19AM (#30977103)
It's proof by contradiction. Either you are against bombing innocents or you are not. By holding a stance that only Russia bombing innocents is wrong you are not only for bombing innocents you are also a russophobe at the same time.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by kergonath on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:56AM (#30978270)
It’s not a proof. It begs the question and starts from the assumption that the OP is ok with the US bombing people. Then it uses the dodgy premise that the US is worse than Russia when considering the metric “number of people bombed” (which I assume includes things like Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and the Vietnam war, not bothering with details such as the fact that these were actual wars and not unprovoked agressions), ignoring any other metric like “number of killed foreign civilians”, on which Russia, as the proud heir of the USSR, would be vying for the top spot with nazi Germany.

So yeah, faulty premise, cherry picking, and circular logic, as well as putting words into someone else’s mouth. It is just sub-standard trolling.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:41AM (#30977287)
By holding a stance that only Russia bombing innocents

Who is holding that stance? Must every conversation start with a comprehensive list of all unjust things currently occurring anywhere in the world?

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by Viliam1234 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:08AM (#30977644)
I think the tradition is that only conversations about unjust things done by Russia must start with a comprehensive list of all unjust things done by USA.

Unjust things done by other countries can be discussed freely.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by esailija on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:51AM (#30977381)
> Who is holding that stance?

The one who was willing to risk nuclear war for Russian actions, it's above in this comment thread. I am making pretty reasonable guess that the same person was not wanting nuclear war over similar actions of US.

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by bradleyjg on Sunday April 10, 2022 @11:00AM (#30977525)
So we’ve gone from proof by contradiction to guess on top of guess.

No agenda, right?

Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by simondotau on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:51AM (#30977384)
Hang on, when did anyone in this thread say they were not against bombing innocents? You’re making rather bold assumptions here.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by mads_ravn on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:12PM (#30979184)
One party is currently torturing and murdering civilians, which tends to skew the conversation in a particular direction. Once Russia has withdrawn all troops from Ukraine we can discus behavior of other nations.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by t-3 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:45PM (#30982039)
Most parties are currently torturing and killing civilians, but some have better PR departments. Guantanamo Bay, Iraq, Aafghanistan, Syria, Libya, Yemen, Venezuela, and the list goes on and on. Nobody cares until white people die though.
Re:What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war bet... by kergonath on Monday April 11, 2022 @07:22AM (#30987191)
Guantanamo is a stain on the US and will be for the foreseeable future, just like internment camps for Japanese people during WWII. But comparing either with Grozny, Aleppo (seriously, why mention Syria at all?), or Mariupol is either completely disingenuous, or entirely uninformed. It is also a complete false equivalence to compare them to the neo-gulags, just ask Navalny.

Which city did the US flatten since Dresden? How many hospitals did they voluntarily bomb? Hell, how many hospitals did the US bomb at all (and no, I don’t assume that number is zero)? Now, compare that to what happened in Karkhiv alone.

Playing chicken when Assad used chemical weapons on Syrian civilians and Putin razed Grozny were stupid mistakes. This is not a reason to let the same thing happen again in Ukraine.