News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:28PM (#30970625)
It will be hard because India likes to buy from Russia recently and doesn't see a problem with invasion.
Re:Back to India by yumraj on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:08PM (#30971006)
As always the reality is complicated, and yes, India does see a problem with the invasion. India is not like China where the media is openly supporting the Russian narrative. India is merely keeping quiet, with many in the media telling it to take a more open position against Russia.

India has massive dependency on Russian military hardware and spare parts. So what should it do, just break off with Russia over a war in the Europe and get screwed itself when China-Pak nexus comes knocking on the border? No country in the world would do that, none-zero-zilch…

Moreover, Europe itself is buying Russian oil and gas, and wants India to stop - that reeks of double standards..

International politics is much murkier than national politics, so nothing is ever black or white.

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:31PM (#30971221)
Whole Eastern Europe has mostly Russian military hardware and guess what, we are basically enemies with Russia and we manage. We buy new equipment from Western countries now but large majority of equipment is still Soviet made.

Choices.

BTW. Regarding the oil and gas, India started buying when it didn't need to . EU is dependent on that oil and gas (Eastern Europe was forced on that dependency, Westerners stupidly joined) - e.g. cars will stop on streets, people will freeze in houses (ok, maybe not now, fortunately Spring is coming, but we still have 0-8 Celcius here, not fun to be in unheated house in that temperature). And we try to stop it, e.g. in Poland we worked on that and hopefully by the end of the year we can stop importing gas from Russia.

Re:Back to India by yumraj on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:51PM (#30971387)
> Whole Eastern Europe has mostly Russian military hardware and guess what, we are basically enemies with Russia and we manage.

There is a difference: you don’t have a choice, Russia is the enemy as well as from where where you’d sourced hardware. Moreover, per my understanding, a lot of hardware and spares are manufactured in E. Eu, due to Soviet era, so things are slightly better due to that.

India is different, the enemy is China-Pak nexus. Russia has never been India’s enemy, rather has been friendly as a counter against US which for decades was more friendly towards Pak and even China. Kissinger hated India for some reason. Also, India doesn’t manufacture a lot of spares for military hardware. India is trying to reduce dependency on Russian crap by buying from West, note the Rafale deal. So it will happen, it will just take time. Note: India has the 2nd largest army in the world, so things take time.

> India started buying when it didn't need to

India started buying exactly when it needed to, when the price went over $100 a barrel which has a huge economic impact. Just like Eu is still buying Russian oil and gas. It’s not fair to express your own reasons while not understanding the other’s.

No one in India is doing this out of love for Russia, the history is in the past, but out of strategic reasons - which is what countries do.

Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:38PM (#30971281)
India needs cheap oil and gas to make fertilizers to feed its population.

You are free and rich enough to do this, be my guest: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iD_6L_ktkM8

Re:Back to India by 2143 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:12PM (#30973623)
> India started buying when it didn't need to . EU is dependent on that oil and gas (Eastern Europe was forced on that dependency, Westerners stupidly joined) - e.g. cars will stop on streets, people will freeze in houses

Do you think it's only Europe that has cars?

Do you think Indians move around on donkeys and bullock carts?

If the US oil prices match Russian oil prices, then sure, buying oil from US can be considered. [1]

[1] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/Swaminomics/if-us-...

Re:Back to India by thawaya3113 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:07AM (#30974800)
Eastern Europe is the one being attacked. Not India.

It’s pretty obvious that the 2 would have different responses.

Also, if dependence is irrelevant, then why is the EU a continuing to buy Russian gas? To the tune of $35bn since Russia invaded Ukraine, compared to the $1bn they’ve given Ukraine?

I don’t blame them for it. I can understand that it’s pretty much impossible to unravel those decades of dependence in months, and trying to do that immediately will likely be counterproductive.

And India recognizes the same about its own Russian policy. They know they need to move away, but they also recognize the dangers of doing so in a thoughtless and rushed manner.

Further, unlike your conveniently specific black and white thinking, other countries like those in the EU (which haven’t said anything to India), the US (which has tried diplomatic persuasion but has not threatened any negative consequences), Australia, Japan, etc, all understand where India is coming from. And even though it is their duty to at least try to persuade India to shift its stance, they know it’s not gonna happen and understand why it won’t happen at such short notice, which is why they’ve been neutral to supportive.

Re:Back to India by thawaya3113 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @02:11AM (#30974815)
Regd, India buying oil from Russia, while I personally disagree with the decision and think it’s ridiculously short sighted (the long term value of the lost goodwill by doing this will be orders of magnitude greater than any money saved by buying Russian oil), to put it simply, there are no sanctions on Russian oil.

There is absolutely no reason India shouldn’t buy Russian oil. Especially when the EU continues to do so.

The only country that has any standing complaining about Indian purchases of Russian oil is the US. And they haven’t complained about it because they recognize the hypocrisy of criticizing India buying a few millions worth of oil while not saying anything to Europe buying a few billions worth of oil.

Re:Back to India by 1024core on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:27PM (#30971184)
Comments like this make me really mad.

Do you know that Europe is _still_ buying from Russia??

Do you know that the US is also _still_ buying from Russia??

India does about $8Bn/year of trade with Russia. That's peanuts.

And nearly 50% of the tankers carrying Russian oil are Greek; and yet you don't hear a word about Greece.

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:38PM (#30971277)
Issue is that India started new trade with Russia, it is not dependent on it (like Europe, I don't know what the heck US is doing), they just jumped on opportunity. And Europe works hard on stopping that, but it is a bit hard to stop e.g. gas import if your own supply won't be able to heat people homes (it is not India, in Europe we are just starting spring, but still temperatures can hit freezing point).

I didn't know about Greece, I was wondering how in the world was Russia transporting that oil and wheat.

Re:Back to India by ra7 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:10PM (#30971563)
> And Europe works hard on stopping that, but it is a bit hard to stop e.g. gas import if your own supply won't be able to heat people homes

In other words, Europe continues to buy from Russia so as to not to inconvenience its own citizens (need gas to heat people’s homes). But India shouldn’t buy from Russia to keep a check on fuel prices in a poor country.

Seems like you don’t care as long as someone else is inconvenienced.

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:36PM (#30971797)
fuel vs freezing to death, not quite the same.

And Europe is not filled with rich countries.

Re:Back to India by muzaffarpur on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:18PM (#30972153)
It's EU and NATO who fooled Ukraine. Your complains are misplaced.
Re:Back to India by kwere on Saturday April 09, 2022 @06:08PM (#30972603)
like russia didnt keep the nation in a boa constrictor for centuries. Rebellion was inevitable, expecially with access to the internet, outside the good propaganda.
Re:Back to India by ddaalluu2 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:42PM (#30971320)
I don't see a problem in trade with Russia. We certainly don't have the moral high ground, also trade is good for peace and living standards.
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:52PM (#30971402)
Europe also thought that trade is good for peace, but it is not if you trade with some countries with long history of double crossing others.
Re:Back to India by muzaffarpur on Saturday April 09, 2022 @11:52PM (#30974348)
Yeah, expanding NATO everyday post 1989 was a great idea for trade?
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:26AM (#30974677)
Yes, it was, Russians didn't attack NATO members. And countries desperately want to join so they won't be attacked by Russia.

NATO will loose its purpose when Russia disappears.

Re:Back to India by chrischen on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:55PM (#30970884)
The real geopolitics behind this is that Russia is trying to curb NATO influence. So this war is really about hurting NATO. A Russian loss helps NATO and a victory hurts NATO, but the war can be ended if either side makes the requisite concessions. But for unaffiliated parties they don’t necessarily take a pro-NATO stance so anti-war or anti-violence simply means “somebody please give in” rather than “NATO please win.” Asking India, or even China for this matter, to make sacrifices for the benefit of NATO is an unrealistic position to take.
Re:Back to India by oblio on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:31PM (#30971750)
You use a lot of words in your post but none are "Ukraine".

Ukrainians have the right to decide what they want to do and what, if anything, to give up.

Re:Back to India by chrischen on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#30972351)
Ukrainians certainly can, but you can't ignore the fact that a lot of NATO's motivations for helping isn't just altruism. Part of this is also the proxy war being fought, and even if India and China want Ukraine to win, they may not want to be the ones paying for a NATO victory.
Re:Back to India by oblio on Sunday April 10, 2022 @04:48AM (#30975422)
Small wars almost always drag in bigger powers.

But that doesn't change much. The US intervened in Vietnam and Afghanistan and because the locals didn't want them, the US still lost.

Foreign contributions in Ukraine pale in comparison to Vietnam and Afghanistan yet Ukraine is resisting. And this a full blown Russian invasion, not just a Ukrainian civil war, yet Ukraine might even win this war.

That's strictly the merit of the Ukrainians. You can gift weapons, but not the will to fight.

Re:Back to India by Koshkin on Saturday April 09, 2022 @08:59PM (#30973555)
> Ukrainians have the right

Not yet, apparently, but they are fighting for it.

Re:Back to India by sidibe on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:48PM (#30972395)
The recent tension kicked off in 2013 and was based on Ukraine approaching the EU. Over time Putin has sold the NATO story well since then but he started trying to directly control Ukraine politics in 2013 when they said they wanted to move forward with their EU candidacy. Ukrainians didn't accept this "veto" from Moscow hence Euromaidan and that led Putin to do what he did in Crimea and Donbass. None of that was about NATO

Ukraine becoming a more successful county like all the other countries that have joined the EU would have made Russians wonder if Putin was holding them back given their closeness to Ukraine and more advantageous starting point.

Re:Back to India by chrischen on Saturday April 09, 2022 @06:18PM (#30972669)
> Ukraine becoming a more successful county like all the other countries that have joined the EU would have made Russians wonder if Putin was holding them back given their closeness to Ukraine and more advantageous starting point.

Yes but this furthers the goals of Western Europe and The USA, regardless of how Ukraine behaves. It just so happens to be an aligned interest with Ukraine. If Ukraine wants to fight off Russia it certainly has the right to, but asking China/India to sanction Russia is like telling them to pay and actively contribute to the war. Maybe they should do that, but that payment is at their cost, for the benefit of Ukraine and NATO.

I'm sure there are plenty of civil wars and atrocities such that the US probably should have interfered more, such as in Myanmar, so one has to wonder why in certain cases (Iraq, Afghanistan, Ukraine) that the US decides to intervene slightly more.

I'm not saying that's what they should be doing or not be doing, I'm just helping laypeople rationalize why the self-interested approach of certain countries is rational... for their self interest. But then countries aren't people, but they are beholden to the interests of their own people first. The US just so happens to be aligned with the interests of Ukraine, but our interference definitely has self interest motivations too. We just can't go around pretending like China and India not "helping" for our self-interests as some kind of atrocity.

Re:Back to India by mama123 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:53PM (#30971411)
It is more like India doesn't trust that the west actually has an intent of stopping the conflict.

Or that Europe would in anyway want to give up on its Russian gas and oil, while pointing fingers at India which buys less than 1%.

In fact they fear it might go the same way as the sanctions on Iran, where India had to go through Germany banks to pay its Iranian dues, where Indian banks were expected to abide by sanctions while German banks were not.

Re:Back to India by zaptheimpaler on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:59PM (#30970926)
Germany continues to buy oil from Russia too, but I never see them being criticized for it. They bought oil for decades from Russia, arguably funding the current invasion, yet that was held up as a shining example of how interdepenence via trading can maintain peace between nations.

There's always a double standard at play. For EU, buying oil is a necessary evil. For India, it's "supporting" the enemy.

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:26PM (#30971164)
You didn't see Germany criticized for buying oil from Russia? Boy, they are the most criticized country for doing that (and oil and gas) - they basically enabled Russia to do the invasion. Nord Stream 1 and 2 come to mind. They made themselves (and few other countries) dependent on that bloody import.

India received Lawrow recently, he is not allowed in any EU country.

But there is a difference in long dependency and completely new buy. India is not dependent on Russian oil, Germany is (I mean, if they stop, cars will stop, people will freeze in houses because of lack of gas to heat their houses).

Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:40PM (#30971304)
> India received Lawrow recently, he is not allowed in any EU country.

And? Your point? Speaking to diplomats is suddenly taboo?

> India is not dependent on Russian oil

No. But, it is dependent on oil and gas being cheap enough to make basic inputs with. It is a region and country on the brink of poverty in many ways. What did you expect?

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#30971451)
> And? Your point? Speaking to diplomats is suddenly taboo?

You can speak on phone, receiving one from countries killing civilians on purpose is making a statement. If you make a statement you will be heard, and I don't think many EU countries will be happy. Not to mention, you know humanitarian aspects - you can buy your oil without blood.

Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:05PM (#30971524)
Not everyone shares those sentiments -- and that's all they are, just sentiments.

And, why hasn't the EU shut off all oil and gas purchases from Russia immediately?

Why should a poor country support this sanctions regime and then witness massive internal disruption?

Most of the countries and populations of the world have in fact NOT imposed sanctions.

Re:Back to India by josephcsible on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:22PM (#30971671)
> And, why hasn't the EU shut off all oil and gas purchases from Russia immediately?

Because they let themselves get too dependent on foreign energy, so doing so would have meant letting their own people freeze.

Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:47PM (#30971897)
And, India needs cheap oil and gas to make fertilizers to feed its population.

You are free and rich enough to do this, be my guest: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iD_6L_ktkM8

Re:Back to India by foolinaround on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#30971453)
> India is not dependent on Russian oil,

Is oil the only thing a country can be dependent on?

Also, what are you? Some Eastern European, who has some emotional ties to the region? 99% of Indians have never heard of Ukraine, and yet, Indians should sacrifice their one steady ally who has stood with India all these decades?

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:41PM (#30971840)
It is not a economic war where you can easily sacrifice.

I assume India politicians heard what Russia targets in Ukraine (and it is not military). Bucha is just one example.

Would India buy cheap soap from Germany during WWII (of course if it wasn't under Britains rule)?

Re:Back to India by foolinaround on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:03PM (#30972040)
India without Russian fertizer is like Germany without Russian energy.

Do you really understand or know more about these concerns?

Re:Back to India by ra7 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:46PM (#30970796)
Huh? They’ve repeatedly said they don’t support violence and has offered to mediate between Russia and Ukraine. Just because they’re looking out for their economic needs — which are wildly different than developed nations — doesn’t mean they support the invasion.
Re:Back to India by chrischen on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:51PM (#30970855)
If you asked the Russians they’d probably also tell you they don’t support the violence.
Re:Back to India by mongol on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:52PM (#30970861)
If they don't support it, they have had plenty of opportunities to voice against it. But they have abstained. It is really disappointing.
Re:Back to India by ra7 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:59PM (#30970921)
Yes, but that doesn’t come close to supporting the war. On the other hand, they’ve provided considerable humanitarian assistance to Ukraine. For better or worse, that’s just the situation — economic and geopolitical — India is in. They don’t have the luxury of looking at things black and white like most western nations.
Re:Back to India by mongol on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:28PM (#30971195)
The situation in Ukraine is more black and white than most others. That India can't recognize that both surprised me and disappointed me. It would make a big difference if they dared to speak out against Russian agression. Even if they would like to remain on friendly terms with Russia they should recognize the atrociousy which Russia displays in Ukraine. Putin needs to hear it also from India.
Re:Back to India by ra7 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:06PM (#30971534)
> The situation in Ukraine is more black and white than most others.

Not for India’s economy and defense. Surely, you recognize they are not a rich country and in an unstable region?

Re:Back to India by mongol on Sunday April 10, 2022 @05:51AM (#30975689)
In the long run, it would benefit them if they align with western values. How many Indian IT specialists are working for Russian companies? There is a new cold war brewing and India will need to choose a side.
Re:Back to India by ra7 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @09:14AM (#30976694)
This comment reeks of not knowing Indian history or geopolitics.
[dead]
Re:Back to India by wiseowise on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:59PM (#30971465)
Azov is less than thousand men. Stop this straw man.
Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#30971271)
Wow. The manufactured consent generating machine is still working as expected.
Re:Back to India by narrator on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:30PM (#30972258)
You never ever oppose "the current thing."
Re:Back to India by warner_of_doom on Saturday April 09, 2022 @07:10PM (#30973026)
Exactly. 0 consideration that the media may be constructing narratives and feeding them to us, instead of being objective.
Re:Back to India by mama123 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#30971458)
And did you consult India before you orchestrated the regime changes and laid the seeds for conflict.

India isn't a colony, and India is capable of and willing to be a mediator to bring peace, the west isn't or won't.

Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:12PM (#30971574)
> And did you consult India before you orchestrated the regime changes and laid the seeds for conflict.

What regime changes, what orchestration?

Re:Back to India by throwaway_1928 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @02:47PM (#30970813)
This is a simplistic assessment of India's strategic situation.
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:34PM (#30971251)
Your point being?

They literally hosted Russia Foreign Minister week or two ago. They abstained in votes against Russia for that invasion in UN. US warned them no to go in bed with Russia. Do you think EU or US will look kindly to support India now?

Re:Back to India by throwaway_1928 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @03:55PM (#30971429)
The US and EU governments have a much deeper understanding of India's strategic position than your comment gives them credit for.
Re:Back to India by mama123 on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:01PM (#30971489)
So your point is let the conflict brew and let us isolate Russia but let us not help negotiate peace.
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @04:09PM (#30971548)
My point it let Russia loose. Let it be beaten by smaller country. Let it be beaten by a country (some) they say shouldn't exist. Let this Soviet imperialism die once and for all. Split it up into smaller countries, there are too many nationalities in there and most of the resources sit in Asian part, let the people there take the fruits.

This country needs to be cleaned from the head, just like Germany after WWII. If not it will always be a danger to world peace.

Re:Back to India by muzaffarpur on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:16PM (#30972141)
NATO/EU and US are allies/friends and West never been friend or kind to India/Indians.
Re:Back to India by krzyk on Saturday April 09, 2022 @05:19PM (#30972167)
I was referring to this part from grandparent: > The US, Europe, and allies should be doing whatever we can to support this.