They declared something worked one way then silently changed how that thing works without properly announcing the change first and giving people enough time to adapt. Would you still be willing to make these excuses if your emails provider decided to do the same thing?
Even if it's their system, there's a limit where people would rightfully start to object.
It's a free service that they provide - why can they not change how their system works when they want? People can object whenever they want - but it doesn't change the fact that they don't have any 'rights' to show someone elses content via a 3rd party on their website.
Maybe if you paid to embed tweets? Sure ok, they changed the contract - so deal with that.
Is it a bit annoying if you use it? Probably. Is it bad that the docs are out of date? Ok.
Twitter doesn't have any responsibility to you as someone who wants to quote someone else via their platform.
You rightly point out the ridiculous claim, noting people don't use embeds as a favour to twitter - and then make the ten times more ridiculous claim that people are using embeds because of the TOS.
At least try and hide the fact you're being bad faith if you're going to engage like this.
Really? For me this is like saying that just because you stop actively publishing a book, people can never quote it again. That's clearly not true, right?
Edit: or because I didn't distribute recordings of a speech I made, newspapers can't quote me
But also, we could not actually expect anything different. The capitalist/corporate environment in which we operate will systematically compel these companies to choose profits over social obligations. They are accountable to their customers (advertisers), and so whatever moral transgressions we people on the street may perceive -- they don't really play into Twitter's decision-making...
This is a very poor argument. It does not necessarily follow that profit seeking results in this outcome, in fact it could easily be the opposite case, and so your assertion has no footing.
I'm not sure why I (as a 3rd party social media platform) would treat your trust as sacred?
But in the case of not paying for your email, then that is also on you to acknowledge there is a set of terms, and you can adhere or not. I certainly wouldn't expect a free service to owe me anything.
I deliberately chose Twitter's JavaScript because I inspected the design of how it worked and saw that they had deliberately built it in a way that would respect my preferences for how deletion should be handled.
They've changed that on me - without even announcing the change. This is a rug-pull.
Now I have to replace their code with my own implementation, and they've hurt my trust.
You have badly missed the most crucial message of the post.
When you copy the embed link, you are copying the string literal of the tweet too.
You put this text on your site. You are the one retaining it.
The twitter module is hiding the text from the rendered page, rather than loading the local copy.
This isn't tricky at all imo.
Just as if I pasted the text directly, I expect my copying of the content to have the same lifetime as the page I put it on. This is irrespective of anybody's wishes after the fact.
Nobody has the expectation that the text would disappear from my page if copied directly - so why should behavior change in any other case?
The original author of the tweet also has the intent. An unfortunate side effect of having a voice, is that sometimes people will listen and make notes.
Not necessarily. The example VOX article[1] had Trump's tweets embedded in the article, which are now hidden. Trump didn't delete those tweets. He was banned.
[1] https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/13/17233422/d...
And the blog author still has the text as well
But that isn't the exception. Banned users tend to be the ones that have some level of public interest, as evidenced by the VOX quote.
>And the blog author still has the text as well
That's right and maybe in some way this new policy accidentally leads to good things, in that it may incentive sites that embed Twitter's content on their page, to simply bypass that.
Edit: clarified js change
The follow-up discussion then unfortunately is not so much about the grievance or problem, but about the needless hyperbole.
In the end, because the problem no longer feels reasonable or relatable, it seems more like the author has an axe to grind.
There's too many examples to cite, but one could follow any discussion that surrounds a change made by large tech company to find numerous examples.
Even journalists, who really should know better are now quoting tweets.
Talk about a double-edged sword
Why are you not, though? I feel like we have been so co-opted by the system that we forgot we are allowed to criticize it. A giant company with billions of dollars should not be given get out of moral jail free cards. They should absolutely be held to higher standards because of all the power they wield.
One is saying Twitter shouldn’t have done this and should be called out for breaking a promise.
The other group mostly agrees, but is pointing out that problem was giving Twitter so much control over one’s own content in the first place.
I agree with this: Banking on what’s nothing more than a handshake is a bad call.
Having to go to the court of public opinion is largely a failure, not the recourse of choice.
The commercial internet of today works this way, and it’s increasingly becoming fragile for it.
But shouldn't we be striving for a world where it isn't a bad call? Reputation used to mean something, I have read about it in old books. That was back when choice was a thing. Digg got destroyed in a matter of weeks because they did something users didn't like. Now Facebook is openly contributing to destroying democracy and all they get is one bad financial year. These things are way too big and wield way too much power.
And, with all due and undue respect, statements like yours are part of the problem. I don't know what your intent was, but you come off as defending twitter on this as there was no written contract. While everyone is equal under codified law, we shouldn't forget some people have more influence than others over what gets codified.
Reputation isn’t proof. It also carries no context.
If the service is very meaningful to you, then why wouldn’t you want a legal contract?
> I don't know what your intent was, but you come off as defending twitter on this as there was no written contract. While everyone is equal under codified law, we shouldn't forget some people have more influence than others over what gets codified.
Case and point of reputation. You assume I’m defending Twitter, because you can’t imagine that I can agree that it’s a scummy move while also pointing out that it’s bad practice to rely on a company’s word.
As for my intent?
I’m annoyed, dealing with like-minded individuals and engineers.
Having to teach engineers that coding and behavioral contracts get broken, and so code must be written defensively; in a world where pushing out features and adoption is “impact” is quite the uphill battle.
It just took a couple of decades for businesses to realize that “free” has some severe hidden costs.
And appealing on social media hoping to get attention, in a world where there’s too much information and noise?
I’m flabbergasted.
Calling it "altering the public record" is a little hyperbolic imo. If you want to act as a repository for the public record, you better use your own system. Twitter is under no obligation to retain this kind of stuff on your behalf.
I'm not trying to say that this is right or wrong, just that these are the facts of the matter when you engage with a company's code and terms of service.