So instantly any proposed changes would get resistance from housing, charity, education, parent groups, medical industry, ESG among others. Think about how many times politicians say "we should encourage [good thing] and discourage [bad thing]". What do you think they're talking about? Changing the tax code.
And if you think the US government knows if you installed solar panels on your roof this year or something, then you're sorely mistaken
I use to wait with filling out a form until the absolute latest moment. I knew they [often] couldn't process the forms until they had all of them. I would get reminders and sometimes a phone call.
I explain my sabotage: If you already have access to these numbers. Why are you asking me for it? If it is up to me I will exercise my right to make a mess of it.
Same for paying taxes: You present it like I have a choice I can pay it or I can not pay it? But if I don't pay it you will give me a 5 euro fine and then a 50 euro fine and then the 800 euro fine and then you take the money out of my account or seize my income. So they choices are: 1) PAY or 2) PAY. Just take it out of my account? Why would you invite millions of people to make a mess from your administration?
I give the employee an example. I can request a form, it is send to my house, at the top of the form it asks for my name and address. As if I have nothing better to do? Then I return the form and someone has to check my name and address???? As if they too have nothing better to do. Multiply the effort by many millions and by dozens of forms and it becomes a horrific waste of of time.
Why are we doing this?
Now it is just a web page that shows the data they have on me. I click accept, even if it is slightly inaccurate and I'm done. Wonderful!
They have my bank accounts, they have my brokerage accounts, they have my W-2s. There's no reason I can't just ask them to do my taxes for me.
Adjusted Gross Income, Audit rate
0 8.9%
$1- $25,000 0.7%
$25,000-$50,000 0.4%
$50,000-$75,000 0.4%
$75,000-$100,000 0.4%
$100,000-$200,000 0.4%
$200,000-$500,000 0.6%
$500,000-$1,000,000 1.1%
1,000,000-$5,000,000 2.5%
$5,000,000-$10,000,000 5.1%
over $10,000,000 8.6%
Please don't make stuff up
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/what-are-the-odds-be...
But those brackets are very different sizes. What I'd find more interesting is "do they focus on minimizing the amount of money stolen from other tax payers?" That would be more like the absolute number of audits in each bracket, divided by the total number of audits. (or audit hours, if you want to go for a "bang for buck" type analysis)
I read there's a secret formula that screens out cases that can be considered for audit and auto-approves the refund. It's secret because if you knew it, you could obviously exploit it.
Even the numbers for lower incomes are a little misleading because fraudsters know the probability of audit and know they can exploit the system by using fake identities to file claims for relatively small amounts. Bret Johnson spoke about this in an interview with Lex Fridman [0] and said 3 days a week for 8 months out of the year he was filing a tax return every 6 minutes using fake or stolen identities. Then he spent the rest of the week driving to ATMs around the state to withdraw the returns. Fun fact, a standard briefcase can hold $150,000 in 20s. So obviously the IRS needs to go after absolute fraud as a deterrent as well as the large tax filings where the money is.
If you're $100 off on your taxes, they are going to tell you that you're off, give you the reasons why they think you are off, and ask you to pay them.
Now, if you keep refusing to pay, and refuse to provide a reason why, eventually, some point a long way down the line, jail becomes an option.
On the other hand, self-employed individuals do need to file, which is not simple.
I feel like its all to keep accountant and lawyer jobs
Americans have been programmed to assume anything the government can do, a company can do better.
This is somewhat hyperbolic. Reporting income to the IRS is pretty easy. Dealing with deductions and credits is not hard, but is hard to get right. The whole process ought to be much, much easier than it currently is, but it is not "all but impossible". I even managed to teach all 3 of my kids how to handle 1099s and other stuff, and if they were a bit intimidated (they were), they didn't find it actually hard.
1. "simplified tax reform" as in "change the tax code to eliminate a bunch of complexity that we think adversely affects the people who vote of us"
2. "simplified tax reform" as in "enable the IRS to precompute the tax forms for 80% of the US population, since they can"
Sure, #1 is bipartisan (even if the things to be eliminated are not).
#2 is opposed almost entirely by Republicans only, just as they are the only party to consistently oppose realistic funding levels for the IRS given the current tax code and legal requirements.
I might or might not support 1., but 2. is doable regardless.
You can already efile for free. Implementation and options could be better though.
https://www.irs.gov/filing/free-file-do-your-federal-taxes-f...
And yes, i use FreeFileFillableForms and have done for many years now. It works, but it's a bit clunky.
My taxes were pretty simple, admittedly. But the government website already had all of my income information pre-filled out. I entered a bank account, entered my health insurance details (hey, hey, affordable universal healthcare), and submitted. I was literally done in 15 mins.
The Australian government practically fell all over themselves to promise me they would get me my refund as soon as possible. They sent a text within hours that promised something like five business days. It was done in three. I never had to deal with them again.
WTF America.