News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by markstos on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:21PM (#30846452)
IANAL, but if the page is used to opt-out of marketing emails, then yes, Visa is in violation the US CAN-SPAM act, which requires promptly processing opt-out requests.

https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act...

As long as the opt-out page is broken, they should not be sending out marketing emails and could be open to a class-action lawsuit from people they email with no ability to opt-out.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by LukeShu on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:44PM (#30846712)
> could be open to a class-action lawsuit from people they email with no ability to opt-out.

CAN-SPAM does not grant standing to individuals. The only recourse individuals have under CAN-SPAM is to report the violation to the FTC and hope the FTC does something about it.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by manquer on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:29PM (#30847242)
Do individuals have standing against FTC if they don't action ?

Lack of FTC action is causing you material harm , or is there immunity against FTC as well?

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by NaturalPhallacy on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:21PM (#30849598)
Anecdotal, but the FTC has teeth.

I noticed I was getting billed by AT&T for South Carolina taxes when I'd been living in Oregon for 3 years. Literally hadn't left the state of Oregon since I'd arrived.

I added up the fees in a spreadsheet and it came out to $51. I called AT&T and fought with their customer support who offered me "as a one time courtesy refund $25" and escalating to a manager wouldn't change that.

I submitted a complaint to the FTC, and not long after I got multiple calls and voicemails from AT&T "Executive Customer Service" or something, and when I finally took the call they breathlessly offered me a full refund for the exact amount right up front with no haggling.

It was remarkable.

Can you believe they called ME to fix their fuckup? And then paid me?

Could you imagine if that was the level of customer service you always got?

So out of sheer loyalty I immediately switched to Ting and have saved thousands of dollars since.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by jay_kyburz on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:55PM (#30850324)
I was once having problem with my Bank, and instead of going into the branch _again_, I used a form on the website to log a complaint. OMG, I've never seen such good customer service!

My guess is the number of complaints resolved is tied to somebodies bonus.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by ryanhuff on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:48AM (#30851853)
It may be that complaints submitted over the bank website are handled by a different (more responsive) team than complaints made at the branch.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by Meph504 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:00AM (#30852210)
A lot of times, when it comes to business like this, in person complaints go into the ether, but the online complaints are recorded and play a part in performance metrics, or hit corp response team rather than branch.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by andylynch on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:38AM (#30852730)
This is it. Online complaints will go into a system where they are monitored by (very) senior management and reported to regulators.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by jay_kyburz on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @05:18PM (#30860886)
Now if only Google had a similar complaint form.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by rootusrootus on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:56PM (#30847564)
> Do individuals have standing against FTC if they don't action ?

You can petition them, certainly. Individuals and business are not able to sue the FTC.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by iudqnolq on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:35PM (#30848678)
It's complicated, but under certain circumstances you can sue agencies for not doing something. It depends on the specific laws governing the specific agency and how you've been harmed by the inaction. Broadly speaking, the Administrative Procedures Act required agencies to have procedurally fair processes. If you're concretely harmed by an agency's inaction and you can show they didn't follow the correct processes, you can sometimes win.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by tomrod on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:01PM (#30849429)
Why can't you sue the FTC?
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by NaturalPhallacy on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:21PM (#30849604)
Anybody can sue anybody. Winning though...
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by nerdponx on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:38PM (#30849739)
In general you can't sue the federal government.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by epgui on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:26PM (#30850121)
On the contrary, that's what judicial review is for. (And there may be other mechanisms as well.)
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by otterley on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:30PM (#30850534)
The general rule of US and English common law is that the sovereign is immune from liability. The reason you can sue the U.S. Government is because Congress passed laws such as the Tucker Act, the Federal Tort Claims Act, the Administrative Procedures Act, and Section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act allowing plaintiffs to do so.

Judicial review doesn't generally let you sue the Government to obtain redress for injuries; it is for enforcing the people's Constitutional rights where the Government is stepping out of bounds. It doesn't let you, say, sue the FTC to get them to do their job.

(This is second-year Constitutional Law, BTW.)

[dead]
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by georgebarnett on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:09PM (#30847735)
A single email will waste anywhere between 3-30 seconds of my life.

On aggregate, junk email, enabled by disrespecting marketers and ongoing minimisation such as your comment, will waste months.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by tomrod on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:02PM (#30849444)
Yes. My time is highly valuable. As is my ISP pipe and my thought processing. Spam steals that, and you'll find no quarter with most tech folks because this is the societal default.
[dead]
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by tomrod on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:21PM (#30850092)
Oh my. This is a lovely comment. Let us dissect.

> Let’s not confuse being paid a lot of money at work with our time being valuable.

Thanks. I haven't. But I'm glad you reminded people that time being valuable is disconnected from hourly rate. Perhaps unintentionally. It wouldn't matter if my job paid minimum wage or I fund my fifth yacht budget from my latest financial trade, my time is valuable. I get one life to enjoy.

Others may value their time differently. My time, however, I value highly.

> You comment quite a bit on a site that’s the content marketing project of a VC firm after all.

I learn quite a bit from the site, as the weekend projects here become the valuable tech five to ten years down the line.

-----

Spam emails are an unmitigated moral bad, and a tu quoque in their defense, however misplaced and invective, is ultimately meaningless.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by otterley on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:35PM (#30850561)
> Let’s not confuse being paid a lot of money at work with our time being valuable.

On the contrary, that's exactly what "being paid a lot of money at work" implies.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by noizejoy on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:36PM (#30850951)
“My time being valuable” can legitimately be meant in a fully subjective way. In the sense of: I would like to cram a long list of activities (including thinking about certain things) into my remaining lifetime. If that list is a lot longer than my remaining life allows for, the value of my time is arguably pretty high for me - even if it isn’t for others.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by otterley on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:42PM (#30850991)
I think both can be true!
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by noizejoy on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:57PM (#30851100)
I just meant they are pretty much independent dimensions, and I interpreted your comment to mean they are highly correlated. Or did I misunderstand what you were trying to say?
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by otterley on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:09PM (#30851164)
I think it depends on the frame of reference: one reflects how others value you; the other reflects how you value yourself. (And as most of us know, these are not necessarily correlated...)
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by sumedh on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:14PM (#30849553)
That is like saying if I steal a dollar from your pocket do you really care about that but I can steal a dollar from millions of people and get rich.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by drdaeman on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:02PM (#30847645)
A single one - barely any. Although you have to be a Superman to be able to entirely process it in 1ms.

At scale, it might take up to a few minutes off your day and under certain circumstances (heavy spam) even start contributing to a mental fatigue. It's a minor nuisance but a nuisance nonetheless.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by convolvatron on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:28PM (#30849172)
don't forget that that the presence of spam makes it quite a bit more difficult to manage your own email

regardless, it introduces a non-zero chance that legitimate email might be misclassified

it seems like everyone in the ad industry has this opinion - if you don't like it, just delete it and move on. but there are thousands of them, and somewhere in there is that job offer I really need.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by paskozdilar on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:02PM (#30848318)
So just because the harm "feels small" to you personally, that means it's not really harm?
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by charcircuit on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:09PM (#30848397)
When you go to sue Visa to get them to pay for the harm they caused you I imagine a $0.01 of harm is not worth the trouble.

Edit: I forgot the context. I should have said the FTC.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by tobyjsullivan on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:16PM (#30848474)
From the URL in the root comment:

> Each separate email in violation of the law is subject to penalties of up to $46,517

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by autoexec on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:48PM (#30851307)
The economic harm spam causes is in the billions every year. Plenty of articles and reports on the negative impacts of spam. It's no small thing.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by charcircuit on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:23AM (#30852050)
We are talking about the "Lack of FTC action is causing you material harm." It's not causing you specifically billions of dollars.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by na85 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @12:52AM (#30851603)
>How much harm does a marketing email even do. Waste 0.001 seconds of your time?

I can't get myself into a frame of mind where I'd find myself defending spam. I'm genuinely fascinated. Why are you taking this angle?

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by behringer on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:19PM (#30848513)
If you don't like it perhaps you can petition the government to get rid of the can spam act?
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by hoppyhoppy2 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:40PM (#30846660)
>if the page is used to opt-out of marketing emails

Though I can't access it, I don't think that's what it's for. I believe it's for opting out of having your credit-card purchase history used for marketing purposes (i.e. sold to other companies, not for Visa itself to send you marketing emails).

>U.S. cardholders may opt out of Visa using their card transaction data for VAS, a suite of aggregated data products in the US.

(from the first result on https://www.google.com/search?channel=fs&q=visa+marketing+re... , which points to the same subdomain on visa.com)

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by JacobThreeThree on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:18PM (#30847825)
Yeah, this opt-out is clearly not related to the sending of marketing emails.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by codingdave on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:59PM (#30846898)
> with no ability to opt-out.

That is the key. Does the web page being down mean that there is no way to opt out? Or is it just more difficult? The page you linked says: "Give a return email address or another easy Internet-based way to allow people to communicate their choice to you." Take note of the "or" in that statement.

So as long as they check replies within 10 days, they seem to be OK. If they fail to do so, maybe there is a problem. FWIW, I'm in agreement that this link being down is not good. But there is not enough info to hazard even guessing whether this is a violation of law.

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by playpause on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @04:18AM (#30852613)
Seems unlikely every marketing email Visa sent during this outage was sent from an actual, valid email address with an inbox. Isn’t that pretty unusual for marketing emails? They’re usually from something like no-spam@domain.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by codingdave on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @07:01AM (#30853567)
Agreed. I'm not saying they are in the clear, I'm saying that neither do we have enough information to declare that they definitely broke laws - the law being cited contained both flexibility and ambiguity and it would take some legal research and knowledge to know more.

(And now that I think of it, we aren't even citing the law, we are talking about a summary of the law that is posted online.)

Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by aidenn0 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:35PM (#30846617)
IANAL as well; #6 says that no information other than an e-mail address is required to opt-out, but when I was presented with a login-page for an unsubscribe, my research indicated that it's not cut-and-dry that requiring a login is banned by CAN-SPAM.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by fay59 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:29AM (#30852071)
CAN-SPAM does not create a private right of action. I have generally no idea what I’m talking about when it comes to legal stuff but I think this means only the government can sue them over it.
Re:Visa's marketing opt-out has been down for over a week. I... by dillondoyle on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:30PM (#30850165)
I think the CA law might have more teeth to allow for individual action? e.g. if they don't respond to data deletion requests.