We have the technology, we need the political will. These scooters are nice but few people will brave riding them in a busy American street, not to even mention a highway.
This makes roads safer for bikes and scooters, but the NEV gives a car-like option for someone who can't (or won't) ride a bike.
Even a NEV-plus standard that allows up to 35mph would be an improvement, that would already cover almost all of my commute.
There are some solutions that can slow cars but still allow emergency vehicles through, but they aren't perfect, and still need sign off from the fire department. And that signoff can be hard to get, years ago, my neighborhood wanted to install speed humps to slow traffic -- the fire department vetoed it since the road was the main access from the neighhood firestation.
The main thing is: how bad are speed bumps for vehicle maintenance, really? Fire trucks, for example, only need to go full throttle when they leave the fire station.
When they come back they can just go over the speed bump slowly, like everyone else.
Why would going over 1 speed bump every bunch of days be such a major issue? Does that mean that a fire truck going over a pothole will do a barrel roll? :-p
But even for ambulances, if you couple traffic calming measures with bike lanes, better public transport, etc, car traffic goes way down, which means that ambulances aren't stuck in traffic. So even ambulances can slow down a bit before speed bumps and they would still arrive faster than otherwise.
That way you can avoid passthrough traffic.
Which is another way of saying 'willing voters.' Who all own cars already, for the most part. And rarely vote to reduce their own quality of life even if there is a possibility that in the longer run it will be higher.
The costs are more than likely paid by others, which is why they're oblivious.
Far easier than convincing them would be to stop subsidizing them, sprawling car dependent suburbs are a giant money sink that the people living in them rarely pay for.
You're likely reading this on a device that was invented while plenty of ignorant people were still not enlightened.
(I admit I may have worded my comment a bit better with a "that" - 'If innovation can't happen until the ignorant are enlightened we're never going to see that innovation.')
I can't imagine any developed city having the collective willpower to retrofit these sorts of paths into their city, though.
A lot of city centers in Europe have been closed to cars during the last decades but special trafic is still allowed.
It just works and it’s better for everybody.
And now I hope this will be extended outside of city centers.
In Granada Spain I noticed that certain parts of the old city had physical barriers that could only be passed by a vehicle with the right NFC pass. Generally taxis, busses, and a few private cars that seemed to belong to people with property in the area. It made it very pleasant to walk around the old streets without having to suck down exhaust fumes of idling cars.
As you noted, Uber is a newer service, plenty of people happily lived their lives before it existed.
The international symbols show it's a pedestrian zone, and there's a rule of no stopping from 11-04 (no stopping meaning not even any loading/unloading, a stronger restriction than no parking.)
The text says "Residents excepted" (under the graffiti/sticker) and "Goods vehicles excepted 04-11" (so deliveries and rubbish collection in the morning) on all days including Sundays and public holidays.
50m down the cross-street on which the StreetView car is driving, there's the standard sign for no motor vehicles [2], and the text underneath says "Except for business" -- so this street can be used all day for delivery vehicles etc.
Both signs are enforced similar to parking: get caught, and you'll be fined. I'm sure you're less likely to be challenged if you're driving a van with "Plumber" written on the side, but it shouldn't matter.
No doubt it's more complicated in cities where this is enforced by cameras.
(In addition, the pedestrian streets are mostly conflicting one-way streets [3, and do a 360°]. No problem for a delivery, but useless as a shortcut.)
[1] https://www.google.com/maps/@55.6779772,12.5729422,3a,25.5y,...
[2] https://www.google.com/maps/@55.6772541,12.5737765,3a,23.2y,...
[3] https://www.google.com/maps/@55.6814522,12.5751944,3a,75y,12...
RIP Europe, you will be sorely missed.
On a more serious note, ride sharing services are considered as taxis which are considered public transport and public transport is generally allowed at least on designated roads.
You walk or take transit within that area? In my experience European cities are super walkable within the core, never bothered with taxis or ride-sharing.
I see you live in an area with significantly more days of good weather than bad!
If your solution to this problem doesn't account for the disabled, elderly, physically unfit, or requires that some or all people be unable to drive in weather that personal vehicles right now handle without issue, like freezing rain, you're not gonna get much buy-in.
A vehicke that can survive a crash at 60 km/h and reach 200km/h and handle properly at that speed is going to weigh accordingly.
And that's in ideal conditions - real world could easily have multiple passengers and a full load of luggage/cargo that'll slow things down.
Likewise with going 120mph - highway speeds are anything from 60 to 85mph. Most vehicles aren't at 100% engine load when cruising on the highway.
And with the 120 on the other end, sure, maybe the engines are good for that, but why even allow the car to go that fast? Why not just put in a speed limiter? Doesn't make much sense why we have all this power imo when the driving rules and laws were written around cars that probably took 20 seconds to reach 60mph and might have needed to go downhill with a tailwind to breach 75mph. And what do you know, the laws always have to account for these anemic vehicles thanks to just old vehicles and stuff like commercial equipment that is going to be heavy and slow no matter what, so you won't find yourself ever needing more performance to keep up with faster interchanges or anything like that since things are always going to built to these meager performance expectations. It's like buying a $4000 gaming PC to run microsoft word 98; wrong tool for the job.
FWIW, the Aptera three-wheel EV design gets IIRC 10X better distance/kWhr than most EVs, and has a US classification as a motorcycle.
It's impossible to use anything but cars in places with bad weather. Science has proved it!
For a rare few places in the world, open air transportation could work year round. For the rest, you'll need an equally sized fleet of cars for the bad days, and scooters for the good days, than can be easily swapped.
1. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15389588.2020.17...
> During the observation period, a total of 875 GC-related crashes occurred, representing an average of 136 crashes, 65 hospitalizations, and 9 dead or disabled annually. Of all crashes, 48% resulted in hospitalization, severe trauma, or death. Of these, ejection occurred in 27%, hospitalization in 55%, and death or disability in 15% of crashes.
2. Random YouTube for scale: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/xHh1vAGd8Uk/hqdefault.jpg
Nice personal attack.
You have 0 info about me to say anything. You know what they say: "if you have nothing to say, just shut up". Your mom should have taught you that ;-)
> For a rare few places in the world, open air transportation could work year round. For the rest, you'll need an equally sized fleet of cars for the bad days, and scooters for the good days, than can be easily swapped.
A rare few places?
Bikes are common in South East Asia (hot, wet).
Bikes are common in the Netherlands (wet, windy).
Bikes are common in Finland (icy).
Electric bikes are starting to make even hilly terrain bikeable.
Unless population density is low, bikes + scooters + public transport can cover everything.
People just don't want to do that. That's a different story to "it can't be done!!!11!!".
The path I was on wasn't really maintained with winter bikers in mind, and I never even thought of researching winter tires, and I wasn't a particularly skilled cyclist (I don't think I cleaned the chain once in several years).
So I did what any stubborn-minded fool who had to bike to their job rain or shine would do: I simply fell over repeatedly until I started getting the hang of things (pro-tip: just don't turn at all and you won't fall over)
Nowadays I'm too old to consider regularly crashing during my commute to be a particularly sane idea; though I still don't have a car and wish cycling infrastructure would get even a fraction of the attention that car infrastructure does.
However there is a strong lack of will for it in many places.
In many others the population density doesn't really allow it.
As usual, it's a mix of things, just that the current default of "cars everywhere" should be turned on its head. It should be: "no cars everywhere, and then introduce cars where they are actually needed".
See this[1]. Quote:
" the excessive noise of these vehicles annoyed residents of some of the wealthier areas of the town and so the company ordered 4 battery-powered buses, which entered service in June 1909; ... [buildings] held charging equipment, so that during the day buses could swiftly exchange spent batteries for ones that were fully charged, a change-over which took about ten minutes. "
[1] https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1...
So the main battery is fixed as current standard, but you can throw in a few of these to extend range or if you run out of power for a ~50km type extension.
For example, if you tried to launch Squarespace in 1993, most people wouldn't care; they'd wonder who would want it and why. (The World Wide Web was a niche thing at that time.)
These are the things that start becoming possible if we let our idea of an EV move beyond a 4000lb automobile to move your maybe 200lb self. You would have to use a technician to service a car sized EV and swap out the batteries even if they dropped right out easily, just due to the to weight of them. An entire infrastructure that would have to be built just to move around 3800 unnecessary lbs anytime you wanted to go anywhere at all. Meanwhile, if people were merely happy with something the size of an e scooter, converting the population to EVs starts getting a lot simpler just in terms of the physics of it all, and simple low hanging fruit innovations like this are possible.