News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by teachrdan on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:03PM (#30757536)
From a practical perspective, I believe the whole point is that an idiom is fundamentally different. If you are a non-native speaker, you can look up a word you don't know. But if it's an idiomatic phrase, like "waiting for the other shoe to drop," looking up each word in the phrase does you no good. Studying fables etc. is a great way to learn them.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by faitswulff on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:08PM (#30757594)
I'm a native English speaker and I actually have no idea where "waiting for the other shoe to drop" comes from, but I know its idiomatic meaning.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by BitwiseFool on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:58PM (#30758954)
Same here, and another one that irritates me is "being left high and dry", which is a bad thing. But I envision high and dry as a good thing, isn't that where you would want to be in a storm or at sea?

Truth be told I never actually looked up where a lot of these idioms come from. I just heard other people using them and then I started to use them too.

Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by martyvis on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:38PM (#30759403)
But not if you tied your boat up in a harbour, and then when the tide went out, you can't sail it because it is high and dry sitting on it's hull instead of floating.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by morsch on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:00PM (#30758261)
These days, you can easily look them up. To viz: https://dict.leo.org/german-english/waiting%20for%20the%20ot...

Interestingly, the first given translation is itself an idiom (lit. "to wait for the thick/fat end"). An idiom I understand, even though I had no idea where it's from; I looked it up, it relates to corporal punishment. The second translation is a more generic one.

Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by FearNotDaniel on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @01:58AM (#30763133)
The second translation is a biblical reference, where a "Hiobsbotschaft" implies receiving news of a further tragedy, invoking the Old Testament character Job (Hiob), whose faith was tested by suffering great losses.

Unfortunately neither of these help to understand the English shoe idiom which I, as a native English speaker, have no clue about.

Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by jquery on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:13PM (#30757653)
You can look up the entire phrase or just ask someone. There’s no need to know where it came from, although it might make retention easier, or comprehension better. Nothing beats time spent immersed in the language and just asking questions or looking at context when something seems odd. Living languages aren’t static targets either, you’ll sound formal or just plain strange if you elevate dictionary definitions over experience and practice with common usage.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by int_19h on Monday March 21, 2022 @03:17PM (#30758481)
In some cases, there's an equivalent idiom in the native language, and while the scenario may be very different, the underlying similarity is readily apparent.
Re:Sumerian dog jokes, or the difficulty of translating dead... by guelo on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:10PM (#30760927)
These idioms are basically compound words, the meaning is barely related to the component words.