Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by abalaji on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:21PM
(#30760465)
Historia Civilis really is one of the most spectacular YouTube channels out there. Not much other content out there compares to his high quality research coupled with fantastic storytelling.
Once you've exhausted all of his videos, though, I would recommend Mike Duncan's History of Rome, an equally compelling podcast that cover Rome's rise in 753 b.c.e. to it's "fall" in 476 c.e. [1]
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by rkk3 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:21PM
(#30759851)
Too much modern romanticization. Cassius and Brutus chose to assassinate Caesar because his consolidation of power meant they couldn't have grand political careers, it was a fundamentally selfish-act & power grab that we've projected enlightenment reasoning on.
Strongly recommend. 'Caesar, Life of a Colossus' by Adrian Goldsworthy
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by zozbot234 on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:36PM
(#30760032)
It was not really a matter of enlightenment reasoning, but republican traditions that the Romans of their time would have been highly familiar with. Caesar had himself proclaimed "dictator for life for the purpose of reforming the state" only a few months prior to being killed, basically repeating what the by-then hated and vilified Sulla had done roughly a generation earlier (except that even Sulla had not dared to demand a lifetime appointment, this was evidently Caesar's idea). This post on the ACOUP blog goes in more detail wrt. the legal implications of that kind of move, which by that time had become quite clear to the Romans themselves: https://acoup.blog/2022/03/18/collections-the-roman-dictator...
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by vagabund on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:14PM
(#30760406)
Plutarch's nearly contemporaneous account cites republican virtues as Brutus' motive, and Cassius' more personal [0]. It's quite hard to psychoanalyze figures that lived and died two millennia ago, but the political-ethical explanation of the event isn't an enlightenment invention.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by optimalsolver on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:52PM
(#30761250)
Brutus' ancestor had been one of the founders of the Republic. I don't doubt he felt pressure to live up to the family name. Portraying it as a power grab is an unfair simplification, I think.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by droopyEyelids on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:33PM
(#30761097)
Part of Julius Caesar's tyranny was his work to cancel the debt of common people and redistribute land- Debt owed to wealthy (the senate), and land 'owned' (seized from the public) by the wealthy (the senate).
Depending on what aspects of history you learned, there could be good reason to put a flower on his grave.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by 21723 on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:52PM
(#30761245)
Part of Julius Caesar's tyranny was his work to cancel the debt of common people and redistribute land- Debt owed to wealthy (the senate), and land 'owned' (seized from the public) by the wealthy (the senate).
That's not "part of [his] tyranny." That's a good thing that he did. He was also a tyrant in some ways, because people are complicated, and lots of people do a fairly even mix of good and bad.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by monkeycantype on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:04PM
(#30761338)
At risk of over explaining, I think the parent commenter agrees with you.
The word tyranny is likely used because that word conveys the impression most people formed in school history classes of his actions - actions which motivated his peers to to assassinate him. But the comment finishes with : "there could be good reason to put a flower on his grave." Indicating that the actions described as 'tyranny' might in fact be actions we would agree with, and that the assassins may not be the heroes of the story.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by ypzhang2 on Monday March 21, 2022 @10:08PM
(#30762047)
This seems to be the “popular” narrative but the actual truth seems to be much more nuanced. Labeling the senate as a block for example misses a large part of it:
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by whakim on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:51PM
(#30761632)
I don't think the reputation of Caesar as a "man of the people" can survive true interrogation. Caesar was a master propagandist, but perhaps more importantly many of our sources postdate him and come from a world in which he'd been literally deified.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by panick21_ on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @05:44AM
(#30776721)
It depends. If you have strong oligarchy that is trying to be superseded by a strong man that is trying to weaken the oligarchy, that strong man often has intensive to do thing for the people and pull them on his side.
Not sure if we have enough evidence but it makes political sense.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by vagabund on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:23PM
(#30760495)
It sometimes fills me with awe that artifacts like the Eid Mar coins, born out of a history defining moment without equal, two millennia ago, not only persist but can be viewed by the public for a paltry sum. There's just a certain enchantment in having that history and its attendant mythology embodied in a physical object.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by B1FF_PSUVM on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:54PM
(#30760817)
Just this week, I came across this:
"You are afraid of the one — I, of the few. We agree perfectly that the many should have a full fair and perfect Representation. — You are Apprehensive of Monarchy; I, of Aristocracy. I would therefore have given more Power to the
President and less to the Senate."
-- John Adams, Letter to Thomas Jefferson, 6 Dec. 1787
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by mannykannot on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:39PM
(#30760680)
I found this engrossing: Edward Watts on the End of the Roman Republic and Lessons for Democracy - episode 37 of Sean Carroll's Mindscape podcast. It is about the Roman Republic's unusual (both in its time and as compared to to today) democratic institutions, and their decline as the republic stumbled towards autocracy.
"Initially, it was a nickname, but lost that purpose when it became hereditary. Hereditary cognomina were used to augment the second name, the gens (the family name, or clan name), in order to identify a particular branch within a family"
Looking over some other articles, it looks like hereditary cognomina were an aristocratic feature. This has the funny side effect of more or less ensuring that aristocrats from the same family are very likely to have exactly the same name.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by xenonite on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @03:12AM
(#30763435)
Well, it was "IULIUS", if you like to start nitpicking ;)
To elaborate: the character "J" was inexistent in Capitalis, which is the then used font face. Hence, the original way to write his name is with an "I".
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by vondur on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:26PM
(#30760540)
I noticed that they mentioned that Caesar's health may have been declining at this point. It should be noted that Ceasar was planning an invasion of the Dacians and the Parthian Empire at the time of his death. Hence the reason to assassinate him before he left Rome. Fairly remarkable for a man of his age to be leading such a long military campaign.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by darrenf on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:42PM
(#30760075)
Honestly my first thought upon seeing the name Julius Caesar is always to think of the English cricketer of the 1800s[0]. I suspect this places me in a minority of one.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by saghm on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:20PM
(#30760459)
I always think of the baseball player Calvin Coolidge Julius Caesar Tuskahoma McLish (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cal_McLish). Apparently his dad wanted to make up for not getting to name his older siblings, so he gave him as many names as possible.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by slg on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:14PM
(#30760955)
Are you by any chance a Jordan Jesse Go listener? I had never heard of McLish before and he just came up on the show yesterday as an example of a fake sounding name for a baseball player.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by saghm on Monday March 21, 2022 @10:27PM
(#30762144)
Nope! I actually haven't heard of that (I assume it's a podcast; I don't listen to any personally). I just grew up a big fan of baseball, and since my dad had always been as well, he shared a bunch of knowledge with me directly and through various books I read as a kid. I'm honestly not sure how exactly I first heard of him, since I was so young when it happened.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by slg on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @12:00AM
(#30762600)
Yes, it is a relatively niche comedy podcast so it isn't that common to run into fans outside of that niche. But on the other hand I'm also a baseball fan and hadn't heard of him until yesterday so it was a little surprising to see his name again immediately. Plus the story of his name is too memorable for this to just be the Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon. Just a funny coincidence I guess.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by darrenf on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:01PM
(#30760293)
I am serious. I live in the town where he lived, walk past his grave frequently, and drink in the pub (The Cricketers, Farncombe) where he worked as landlord. The other Caesar has no such presence in my daily life!
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by B1FF_PSUVM on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:51PM
(#30760785)
> The other Caesar has no such presence in my daily life!
Apart from having set up the modern calendar (slightly adjusted in the XVII century) and having a whole month named after him, and a few other minor things such as the original conquest of Britain ...
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by cardiffspaceman on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:01PM
(#30760860)
"All right, but apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, a fresh water system, and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?”
“Brought peace.”
“Oh. Peace? Shut up"
Are there not vestiges of these things in modern UK today or at least England?
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by abalaji on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:16PM
(#30760418)
It is said that the night before Julius Ceaser's death, he broke bread with Decimus (an original conspirator) and Lepidus. The conversation of "what's the best way to die" was brought up. After some pontificating on the part of Decimus and Lepidus, Ceaser spoke up and said: "It would be best to die suddenly and unexpectedly."
In the end, I guess he was right, we're still talking about his assassination 2000 years later.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by hoten on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:52PM
(#30760801)
Not just derived, but some of these can be seen as a claim to a title (in that, there can only be one). That becomes interesting when multiple people/institutions have claimed it at the same time. For example: the Ottoman Empire and the Catholic Church. When the ottomans sacked Constantinople, the Sultan Mehmed assumed the title Ceaser. Interestingly, although they adopted the title officially and used it a lot internally, for diplomatic purposes they would massage the wording a bit when conversing with western countries under the influence of the Church. [1]
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:53PM
(#30759570)
Not a subscriber so can’t read, but when I see Caesar hit the front page, I upvote.
I think we can’t stress the story of Caesar enough in our era of demagoguery. A look into Rome at the time paints a picture of Caesar, like a lot of populists we’ve seen since 2015, wasn’t actually wrong about a lot of his complaints. The senate was a corrupt, spoiled, bunch who only cared so much for the Republican because it provided them a ton of power within a very powerful polity; and it was there’s the way a child thinks his parents back yard is theirs.
They believed themselves entitled to enrichment on the backs of plebs and to top that off it was still a very real political idea (and movement) that Rome allowing the peasants both political power bringing them into the legions was a grave mistake that desperately needed undone (similar, but to a much greater extent, than the ultraconservatives who think giving the vote to women and African Americans is a grave mistake.)
So it was easy for Caesar to point at these senators and say all of these things, because they were true. It’s analogous to the way someone like Trump or Bernie Sanders used sound byte rhetoric to play up peoples emotions. The promises they made (whether or not they believe in them is irrelevant) are second to emotions running high.
That Caesar may not have cared about the plebs is irrelevant, indeed it could have all been a personal vendetta dating back to the prescriptions imposed on him and his mother after Sulla took power.
Sorry for this rant, I’ve spent the last few years thinking about this and how to better tell the story in a way that fits nicely with current times and trends. I believe when the story of Caesar is told it usually plays up the tragedy of Brutus or Caesar, both of whom were what were consider tyrants today, when there’s a very real political message that is very important we understand today.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by mishftw on Monday March 21, 2022 @05:36PM
(#30760035)
I was listening to Dan Snow's History Hit podcast [0] where there was a guest episode on oligarchs & oligarchy in general. They mentioned Caesar because he was also an oligarch, like most of the other generals/Senators of Rome. Jeff Winters also wrote a book on this topic [1].
Caesar threatened the oligarchs of Rome by crossing the Rubicon with his legions which was heavily frowned upon by the others. Caesar threatened their power structure for sure and likely led to his death.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:21PM
(#30760467)
I’d say it takes two to tango. Caesar didn’t cross the Rubicon with his legions because he was a mustache twirling villain. He did so because the Roman senators (rightly) feared any man who commanded the respect of a large portion of the legions. Caesar has just pacified one Romes oldest fears, the Gauls, and the people loved him for it. He was told to disband his legions and return to face the senate, a move which certainly mean death, so he did what anyone who wanted to keep living: he invaded.
I really wouldn’t say Caesar’s death had anything to do with oligarchs. Sure he threaten their business interests but what he did was so much worse in their eyes. Remember Rome was built on overthrowing a tyrant, the Senators believed any man who refused to disband his army was an aspiring King and aspiring kings can’t be allowed to live.
Of course Caesar was an aspiring king after the Rubicon, whether he was before will be debates too the end of time, having triumphs where he tested how king like he could act to his subjects (Mike Duncan has an episode on this where he says, “the Roman’s could learn to love autoarchy, but they wouldn’t accept monarchy.)
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by hoten on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:16PM
(#30760430)
> That Caesar may not have cared about the plebs is irrelevant, indeed it could have all been a personal vendetta dating back to the prescriptions imposed on him and his mother after Sulla took power.
No doubt he rode the waves of populism, but I wouldn't write off entirely that he actually did care, on some level, about the poorer class. He did grow up in that world himself (of course he came from a rich family, but his mother raised him in Subura, a poor part of Rome, where her business was), and when he first returned to Rome after Sulla was out of the picture he chose (well, probably had to, not having money) to live in the same place he grew up. I'm speculating, but it seems likely that rubbing shoulders with the lower class for most of his formative years suggests his later advocacy for their advancement in society may be somewhat genuine.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:56PM
(#30761664)
Yeah that’s why I said it was irrelevant. I think he did have sympathies with the plebs. Maybe not born out of a wholesome desire to make their lives better (although he probably thought it couldn’t hurt) I’d say it was born out of the fact that he related to them.
The Senators looked down on him too and thought he was an annoying upstart and the nephew of a “radical” who had the audacity to want to win wars more than he cared about who’s grandfather was supposedly one of Romulus’ initial men. I think he did care, for sure, like I think a lot of populists actually care.
But I don’t think he, nor a majority of populists, are honest to the masses they get to do their beck and call.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by crate_barre on Monday March 21, 2022 @04:58PM
(#30759622)
If we want to go full throttle with the analogues to today, Ceasers journal entries would be read out loud in the public forum where large crowds gathered to hear it (as good a tweet as you can get). He specifically tried to reach the plebs.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:14PM
(#30760405)
Of course. Plebs are focused on working the land etc they don’t have time for a full education into the political machinery of Rome they would need to understand in order to grasp the nuances of the problems of their day. So they outsource their grievances to a guy from that world who says he knows how to fix all their problems, it’s easy even, if it weren’t for the pesky Senators.
This is exactly like what we’ve seen in recent years (really it’s been seen time and time again.) I tried to leave out any names or obvious events other than to explain the rhetorical behavior they usually share.
I will say that it doesn’t take an ignorant person to fall victim to populism. I initially went head first into Bernie as “my guy” (not that I’m some genius, mind you.) Coming from a lower middle class white family he basically told me everything I wanted to hear in 2016.
It’s easy identifying a given problem but one thing I’ve come to try and understand is that if I ever have an idea that seems simple, it’s best to try and figure out why it is it hasn’t been solved yet. For any given issue (be it enterprise or political) there have probably been incredibly intelligent people, smarter than me for sure, who’ve tried to solve it and were unable to.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by crate_barre on Monday March 21, 2022 @07:44PM
(#30761189)
The implication is that it’s easy to say universal healthcare, student loan amnesty, and stimulus checks for all. It’s harder to say ‘but if we give stimulus checks, we might cause inflation’, or ‘universal healthcare might cost a few trillion a year, and I’m not sure how we can finance that’.
Stroking the plebs is not a new thing. Trump exists for this reason, AOC literally strokes the left with every tweet, so does Bernie.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @09:02PM
(#30761704)
Also, it’s easy to say free college for everyone. Especially when you know that the students who will actually need their college paid for won’t be going because the price of tuition is only one factor in why people decide against college. I would say Bernie definitely understands this nuance, but it doesn’t make for a nice soundbite and kinda seems like subsidizing college for those who would have went regardless.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by edgyquant on Monday March 21, 2022 @08:59PM
(#30761686)
No I definitely added a clause stating their true desires were irrelevant. Just that’s it’s easy to get yourself a powerbase by making sweeping promises that play at emotions. It’s not so easy to actually enact the needed change and occasionally it is impossible. If they’re the especially ugly type Populists can then use them as proof that the engrained powers are working against the people.
The only reason I mentioned my own believes was because I used to consider myself fairly well educated, having been a huge history nerd my entire life alongside the CS stuff we all do here, and yet I didn’t even realize Bernie was a populist until after Trump was president and the election was over.
It’s easy to get sweeper up in emotions, that’s my point.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by andrekandre on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @05:44PM
(#30771976)
i see, thanks for explaining
i think i agree, populist messaging can be a dangerous weapon in the wrong hands... on the other hand, i wonder how else politics of change can work without it?
it seems very hard to get a message through when theres such a huge low-pass filter... maybe there are other ways?
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by reducesuffering on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:27PM
(#30760559)
> The senate was a corrupt, spoiled, bunch who only cared so much for the Republican because it provided them a ton of power within a very powerful polity; and it was there’s the way a child thinks his parents back yard is theirs.
It's a story as old as time. 1,500 years later down the road it's the Medici, nobility, and Signoria of the "Republic" of Florence.
Re:The conspiracy to kill Julius Caesar
by walkhour on Monday March 21, 2022 @09:30PM
(#30761862)
Fascination with Caesar is only slightly better than fascination with any other mass murderer in history.
He himself boasted about having killed over a million Celts, probably exaggerated, but nevertheless had no problem in slaying tends of thousands, burning whole towns to the ground, and then selling whoever was unfortunate to still be alive to slavery.
He was a genocidal maniac that had no problem in doing the unthinkable to further his power in Rome. Whether he was a tyrant or a man of the people is largely irrelevant to who he was and should be a footnote in any text about him.
What would've happened hadn't he been murdered is that he would've continued his genocidal dreams, now in East Europe, just to feed his ego and increase his "glory".
https://youtu.be/9XBxMk_plhA
Once you've exhausted all of his videos, though, I would recommend Mike Duncan's History of Rome, an equally compelling podcast that cover Rome's rise in 753 b.c.e. to it's "fall" in 476 c.e. [1]
[1] https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-history-of-rome/id...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SU1Ej9Yqt68
Strongly recommend. 'Caesar, Life of a Colossus' by Adrian Goldsworthy
[0] https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/e/roman/texts/plutarch/...
Depending on what aspects of history you learned, there could be good reason to put a flower on his grave.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/292075
here's a bit on Lex Agraria, though focused on the earlier one from Tiberius https://www.britannica.com/topic/land-reform/History-of-land...
That's not "part of [his] tyranny." That's a good thing that he did. He was also a tyrant in some ways, because people are complicated, and lots of people do a fairly even mix of good and bad.
The word tyranny is likely used because that word conveys the impression most people formed in school history classes of his actions - actions which motivated his peers to to assassinate him. But the comment finishes with : "there could be good reason to put a flower on his grave." Indicating that the actions described as 'tyranny' might in fact be actions we would agree with, and that the assassins may not be the heroes of the story.
Nonetheless, i'm sure the people who had their property redistributed were pretty unammused.
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/s7p2dk/how_m...
Feels like you could do a better 'medium' just by locating angry rants left by enthusiasts and experts on reddit.
Or the thing where you scrape HN for all links to a book/site.
Not sure if we have enough evidence but it makes political sense.
"You are afraid of the one — I, of the few. We agree perfectly that the many should have a full fair and perfect Representation. — You are Apprehensive of Monarchy; I, of Aristocracy. I would therefore have given more Power to the President and less to the Senate."
-- John Adams, Letter to Thomas Jefferson, 6 Dec. 1787
https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2019/03/11/epis...
Huh? The cognomen is the individual part of a Roman name. Nothing "family" about it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Praenomen
"The praenomen was a personal name chosen by the parents of a Roman child."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomen_(Roman_name)
"The nomen gentilicium (or simply nomen) was a hereditary name borne by the peoples of ancient Italy"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognomen
"Initially, it was a nickname, but lost that purpose when it became hereditary. Hereditary cognomina were used to augment the second name, the gens (the family name, or clan name), in order to identify a particular branch within a family"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Julius_Caesar_(governor_...
But this is not a general feature of cognomina; compare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ovidia_gens#Members
Looking over some other articles, it looks like hereditary cognomina were an aristocratic feature. This has the funny side effect of more or less ensuring that aristocrats from the same family are very likely to have exactly the same name.
To elaborate: the character "J" was inexistent in Capitalis, which is the then used font face. Hence, the original way to write his name is with an "I".
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_Caesar_(cricketer)
Apart from having set up the modern calendar (slightly adjusted in the XVII century) and having a whole month named after him, and a few other minor things such as the original conquest of Britain ...
"... what have the Romans done for us?"
“Brought peace.”
“Oh. Peace? Shut up"
Are there not vestiges of these things in modern UK today or at least England?
In the end, I guess he was right, we're still talking about his assassination 2000 years later.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottoman_claim_to_Roman_success...
https://www.amazon.com/Roman-Revolution-Oxford-Paperbacks-No...
I think we can’t stress the story of Caesar enough in our era of demagoguery. A look into Rome at the time paints a picture of Caesar, like a lot of populists we’ve seen since 2015, wasn’t actually wrong about a lot of his complaints. The senate was a corrupt, spoiled, bunch who only cared so much for the Republican because it provided them a ton of power within a very powerful polity; and it was there’s the way a child thinks his parents back yard is theirs.
They believed themselves entitled to enrichment on the backs of plebs and to top that off it was still a very real political idea (and movement) that Rome allowing the peasants both political power bringing them into the legions was a grave mistake that desperately needed undone (similar, but to a much greater extent, than the ultraconservatives who think giving the vote to women and African Americans is a grave mistake.)
So it was easy for Caesar to point at these senators and say all of these things, because they were true. It’s analogous to the way someone like Trump or Bernie Sanders used sound byte rhetoric to play up peoples emotions. The promises they made (whether or not they believe in them is irrelevant) are second to emotions running high.
That Caesar may not have cared about the plebs is irrelevant, indeed it could have all been a personal vendetta dating back to the prescriptions imposed on him and his mother after Sulla took power.
Sorry for this rant, I’ve spent the last few years thinking about this and how to better tell the story in a way that fits nicely with current times and trends. I believe when the story of Caesar is told it usually plays up the tragedy of Brutus or Caesar, both of whom were what were consider tyrants today, when there’s a very real political message that is very important we understand today.
Caesar threatened the oligarchs of Rome by crossing the Rubicon with his legions which was heavily frowned upon by the others. Caesar threatened their power structure for sure and likely led to his death.
[0] https://podfollow.com/dan-snows-history-hit/episode/94f58a73... [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11598740-oligarchy
I really wouldn’t say Caesar’s death had anything to do with oligarchs. Sure he threaten their business interests but what he did was so much worse in their eyes. Remember Rome was built on overthrowing a tyrant, the Senators believed any man who refused to disband his army was an aspiring King and aspiring kings can’t be allowed to live.
Of course Caesar was an aspiring king after the Rubicon, whether he was before will be debates too the end of time, having triumphs where he tested how king like he could act to his subjects (Mike Duncan has an episode on this where he says, “the Roman’s could learn to love autoarchy, but they wouldn’t accept monarchy.)
No doubt he rode the waves of populism, but I wouldn't write off entirely that he actually did care, on some level, about the poorer class. He did grow up in that world himself (of course he came from a rich family, but his mother raised him in Subura, a poor part of Rome, where her business was), and when he first returned to Rome after Sulla was out of the picture he chose (well, probably had to, not having money) to live in the same place he grew up. I'm speculating, but it seems likely that rubbing shoulders with the lower class for most of his formative years suggests his later advocacy for their advancement in society may be somewhat genuine.
The Senators looked down on him too and thought he was an annoying upstart and the nephew of a “radical” who had the audacity to want to win wars more than he cared about who’s grandfather was supposedly one of Romulus’ initial men. I think he did care, for sure, like I think a lot of populists actually care.
But I don’t think he, nor a majority of populists, are honest to the masses they get to do their beck and call.
This is exactly like what we’ve seen in recent years (really it’s been seen time and time again.) I tried to leave out any names or obvious events other than to explain the rhetorical behavior they usually share.
I will say that it doesn’t take an ignorant person to fall victim to populism. I initially went head first into Bernie as “my guy” (not that I’m some genius, mind you.) Coming from a lower middle class white family he basically told me everything I wanted to hear in 2016.
It’s easy identifying a given problem but one thing I’ve come to try and understand is that if I ever have an idea that seems simple, it’s best to try and figure out why it is it hasn’t been solved yet. For any given issue (be it enterprise or political) there have probably been incredibly intelligent people, smarter than me for sure, who’ve tried to solve it and were unable to.
Stroking the plebs is not a new thing. Trump exists for this reason, AOC literally strokes the left with every tweet, so does Bernie.
The only reason I mentioned my own believes was because I used to consider myself fairly well educated, having been a huge history nerd my entire life alongside the CS stuff we all do here, and yet I didn’t even realize Bernie was a populist until after Trump was president and the election was over.
It’s easy to get sweeper up in emotions, that’s my point.
i think i agree, populist messaging can be a dangerous weapon in the wrong hands... on the other hand, i wonder how else politics of change can work without it?
it seems very hard to get a message through when theres such a huge low-pass filter... maybe there are other ways?
It's a story as old as time. 1,500 years later down the road it's the Medici, nobility, and Signoria of the "Republic" of Florence.
He himself boasted about having killed over a million Celts, probably exaggerated, but nevertheless had no problem in slaying tends of thousands, burning whole towns to the ground, and then selling whoever was unfortunate to still be alive to slavery.
He was a genocidal maniac that had no problem in doing the unthinkable to further his power in Rome. Whether he was a tyrant or a man of the people is largely irrelevant to who he was and should be a footnote in any text about him.
What would've happened hadn't he been murdered is that he would've continued his genocidal dreams, now in East Europe, just to feed his ego and increase his "glory".
You too, Nat Geo?