News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by simonh on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:28AM (#30720816)
To be fair to Joe he wasn't giving medical advice, but licensed doctors on his show were.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by HL33tibCe7 on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:33AM (#30720849)
This sounds reasonable, until you realise that his opinions massively skew which licensed doctors he lets on the show. So effectively you’re ending up with him pushing his opinion anyway.

If you cherry-pick your experts enough, you’ll be able to find one that agrees with you, no matter how absurd your position.

I’ll also note that much of the time the licensed doctors he invites on aren’t actually in relevant specialties at all. And in many cases they are grifters in some way or another.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by moonchrome on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:42AM (#30720903)
>This sounds reasonable, until you realise that his opinions massively skew which licensed doctors he lets on the show.

Don't like to defend Joe Rogan, but he literally had the guy that laughed him off at CNN (Sanjay Gupta).

While he is often pushy with dumb ideas he will often have guests that contradict him. I stopped listening to him regularly because hearing his opinion along so many guests gets kind of old, and he isn't the smartest guy in the world so it gets boring even faster. But I wouldn't characterize him as closeminded.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by eggy on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:23AM (#30721263)
So tired of people attacking Joe Rogan. He's a pod caster. How come people don't push more on the 'experts' like Wolensky or Fauci or the main stream media? Ignoring natural immunity, not releasing publicly funded data to scientists and citizens to do science, openly lying in the name of 'for your own good', or tweeting a statistic that is way off from the data they released - the list goes on, and these are the highly-paid experts who have pushed for science as a belief rather than a method or system for examining phenomenon. How many people have they harmed (children being masked while old farts in government hug and talk face-to-face; pushing vaccines on 5-11 year-olds with a 12% efficacy after only 30 days, on and on). I think people just like to dog pile on people like Rogan; they should be turning some of that scrutiny upon the people they listen to or extol as experts. CNN calling Ivermectin "horse dewormer" or "horse medicine" was blatant propaganda, and not journalism, yet people rely on CNN for their information, too much I fear.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by strken on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:52AM (#30721536)
For the past two years I've been telling anyone who'll listen that the WHO screwed up by telling people not to wear masks, by claiming transmission wasn't via aerosol particles, and by opposing border closures. I spent a long time getting into arguments about the lab leak theory being almost impossible to disprove. In my comments on HN there's one calling out an article about mask-wearing for drawing the exact wrong conclusion from a study of cloth masks.

I reserve the same right to call out Joe Rogan when he's wrong. He is not special.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by simonh on Saturday March 19, 2022 @12:56PM (#30735391)
They did screw up, that’s true. Almost everyone everywhere has been wrong about this virus, mostly several if not many times. That’s because for a long time we were working with very limited and sometimes contradictory or misleading information. I do not believe that the WHO did this for nefarious reasons, or knowingly lied, although they did make some mistakes as a result of leverage and coercion by various states. I blame those states more than I do the WHO.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by strken on Sunday March 27, 2022 @08:03PM (#30825462)
Screwing up disaster response for non-nefarious reasons doesn't bring back the dead.

The WHO screwed up for systemic reasons that commentators, at the time and without the benefit of hindsight, were able to call out. Specifically, they repeatedly claimed there was "no evidence" for cloth masks and "no evidence" for aerosol transmission. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and the organisation meant to coordinate a global medical response should know that. Many respiratory viruses spread by aerosol transmission, and it would have been responsible to say "we do not have enough evidence to say how COVID spreads yet." Additionally, there was evidence for the efficacy of cloth masks, but the papers were studying whether cloth masks were adequate replacements for surgical masks and N95 respirators in hospital settings, and they (rightly) concluded that cloth masks weren't as effective as actual PPE, from which the WHO (wrongly) concluded that cloth masks weren't effective at all.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by eggy on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:06PM (#30743833)
Not denying your right, never have, but choice of where to apply your scrutiny and time spent on it says a lot. A very popular fight commentator, comedian, pod caster, or the people actually creating the guidelines you and your family will live under, right or wrong, is another. Choose your battles kind of thing. I am more fearful of the quiet wrong doers. NYT finally admits many emails in Hunter Biden laptop are authentic. NPR, others dismissed it all as a waste of time, Russian disinformation. Jack Dorsey censored anyone trying to share the NY Post article even through PMs. Joe Rogan has many different people on his show. I find it entertaining and thought provoking. I can't say the same for mainstream media; I am very saddened and worried by this more than Joe Rogan. As a matter of fact, I am happy he stirs the pot. To paraphrase the WAPO's line, "Democracy Dies in Silence".
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by thurn on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:30AM (#30721319)
You have committed the logical fallacy of 'to quoque', responding to criticism with criticism. The scrutiny (or lack thereof) for other individuals is of course irrelevant to the question.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by dekhn on Friday March 18, 2022 @11:16AM (#30723360)
In nearly no internet debate does "logical fallacy" invalidate an argument. After all, none of these arguments are truly logical, instead being deeply embedded in empiricism and intuition. While their criticism may not be useful, to imply that arguments on the internet are wrong (or to be ignored becaues they provide no value) seems like an unrealistic expectation.

I am unaware of any situation outside of pure mathematics where logic is the sole arbiter. I am curious to hear about such situations, though.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by gatlin on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:51AM (#30721529)
Other than as a substitute for bird watching I don't have much use for logical fallacies: https://maartenboudry.be/2017/06/the-fallacy-fork-why-its-ti...
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by topaz0 on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:13AM (#30722507)
I think the linked piece makes an important point, but I disagree that that point is relevant here. "Your argument pattern-matches to tu quoque" is probably an unhelpful thing to say, but what GP says is more like: "Your points about other people are not relevant to the discussion we were having out this one person, and therefore are unhelpful. This pattern of bad argument is sometimes known as tu quoque." Seems fine to me.

Edit to add: not sure if I am alone in this, but I also disagree with the author's characterization that the purpose of thinking about fallacies is to understand how people come to wrong conclusions. I think it has much more to do with the structure of an argument. It's not "you have come to this wrong conclusion by treating this fallacy as a good argument". It's more like "you believe this for whatever personal reasons you might have. You are trying to convince me to believe it as well, but you are failing to do so because your argument is not valid". I.e. it is more about the rhetoric than it is about coming to wrong beliefs in the first place.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by ithkuil on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:02AM (#30721654)
s/to/tu
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by unclebucknasty on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:08AM (#30722436)
>tired of people attacking Joe Rogan. He's a pod caster.

Rogan has millions of listeners who take advice from him and shape their worldviews around his. For many people he is more authoritative on health than public health officials like Fauci, even while not having a fraction of the experience or expertise.

>How come people don't push more on the 'experts' like Wolensky or Fauci

There's been no shortage of criticism of Fauci and others, to include character attacks, conspiracy theories and death threats.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by eggy on Sunday March 20, 2022 @12:14PM (#30743905)
So you think Rogan has more influence than the CDC's guidelines that are adopted as legistation for the most part - masking children, vaccines for 5-11 year-olds, ignoring natural immunity, not releasing data? You don't think he gets negative press or death threats? Not to mention Fauci has a direct link to COVID, and has admitted to openly lying "for your own good". Rogan has a diverse assortment on his show, and admits he is not an expert. You cannot hold him responsible for anyone's ignorance or inability to think for themselves. However, when bodies of so-called authority or expert credentials make policy you and your family will have to live by, that is more of a concern of mine, and where I turn my attention. You are free to go after Rogan. A lot of influencers have millions of listeners, and they speak in isolation without lengthy dialogues with any guests. Mainstream media does one-minute edited blurbs for you to digest like pablum. And they carry forward the status quo. Look at how much they have been collectively wrong, or misleading, sometimes intentionally.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by unclebucknasty on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @10:41PM (#30785909)
>So you think Rogan has more influence than the CDC's guidelines

That's not really the point but, for some, yes, he does have more influence. That "some" apparently includes you.

>You don't think he gets negative press or death threats?

Again, not the point. You asked why Fauci and others weren't challenged. My response was that, not only is he challenged, but he's also been the target of personal attacks, conspiracy theories, and death threats.

>Rogan has a diverse assortment on his show, and admits he is not an expert

Yet, he continuously pushes a counter-mainstream narrative that you seem to be repeating here.

>However, when bodies of so-called authority or expert credentials make policy you and your family will have to live by

To each his/her own, but I think those credentials are meaningful. We've had expert public health guidance for decades brought to us by the "so-called experts" and it's generally served us well, as evidenced by the fact that you've probably never had polio, measles, diphtheria, whooping cough, tetanus, etc. And, you're also not likely to die from a case of diarrhea.

>You are free to go after Rogan.

Yes. I know. But, I wasn't going after him, as much as pointing out the reality that people (seemingly yourself included) respect his opinions over those of public health officials.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by Graffur on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:09AM (#30722458)
Joe brings on guests that are informative and interesting. He didn't come up with a scheme to hype up Ivermectin or any other treatment. Do you think otherwise?

I believe he has had on: Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Dr. Michael Osterholm and and Dr. Peter Hotez. That doesn't look to be cherry-picking experts to push an absurd position.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by coldtea on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:38AM (#30720883)
>If you cherry-pick your experts enough, you’ll be able to find one that agrees with you, no matter how absurd your position.

So? Some experts are more experts than others?

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:23AM (#30721265)
Interesting you are downvoted, this is precisely what is happening. The contradicting experts are quickly labelled as quacks and loonies, yet we have a long history of the early critical voices being eventually proved right (cholesterol, sugar, cigarettes, asbestos, Oxycodone, bio-labs, roundup, DDT, radium, etc). It's a long list and yet we behave the same every single time.

This time I'm sure the consensus/"the science" has got it right though.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by odonnellryan on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:49AM (#30721509)
I don't really like this fallacy as I think it is really dangerous. Because you're wrong about something (or even everything) doesn't mean you're wrong about another thing.

Because there are examples of the medical community getting it wrong (btw they did not get it wrong when it came to opiates - everyone knew opiates were addictive) doesn't mean they are always wrong.

Also there is no way for you to figure out who the quacks are (of course they exist, there are MDs suggesting insane things all the time) and who the correct but contrarians are.

So, by default you assume if the opinion is not mainstream it must have validity.

Now, I'm not saying the opposite is true. I'm saying it is just as bad (or maybe even worse statistically) to form an opinion because it isn't mainstream as it is to form an opinion just because it IS mainstream.

You're not a critical thinker because you dismiss the mainstream because it is mainstream. Just the opposite.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by Jtype on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:39AM (#30722080)
I believe that you're misinterpreting the point. It's not dismissing the mainstream because it's mainstream, but ignoring the mainstream that completely dismisses and mislabels contradicting views and evidence as "misinformation." Relying solely on the judgement of mainstream media is putting all your faith in science not in science itself but on reporters(and activists) choosing what is "science."

This recent trend of treating science as an unquestionable reminds me much more of religion than of science. At this point in the covid game where quite a bit of the accepted science has changed, it seems that only people's egos are keeping them from seeing this.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:58AM (#30721600)
That wasn't quite my point. The point is not to immediately devalue experts critical of the consensus, but keep informed and considered. To dismiss either side whole-handedly is ignorant.

What is happening especially now is precisely that, this whole 'misinformation' drive is to encourage the dismissal of critical opinion (on more and more topics it seems). This is a bad road to go down.

And you make a good example of the overall point: there should not be this 'mainstream' vs 'not-mainstream' and we just pick a side. We should all be mature enough not to fall for that silly manipulation and instead try to fully inform ourselves from a range of sources and challenge ourselves.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by odonnellryan on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:06AM (#30721696)
There wasn't any real evidence for the use of Ivermectin. Some public policies were not perfect or misguided (lockdowns) some were inconsistent with both messaging and implementation (masks) some were really good and people are against them for no logical reason (vaccines, though maybe requirements are totalitarian in cases).

I think the reality is that because there are holes in the response to covid, people dismiss the whole.

Also, there's no real way for us to know what would have happened if we did nothing. Maybe another 1-2m dead - or maybe we'd be just where we are today.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#30721968)
All of your points have no certainty. I'm not sure what you're attempting to show here?

> I think the reality is that because there are holes in the response to covid, people dismiss the whole

I think a more salient point is perhaps that because so much effort was put into covering the 'holes' (not to mention the coining and dissemination of the label 'misinformation') rather than be honest about them, distrust was created. It is sensible to question when any groups make concerted efforts to dismiss and censor alternative views, regardless of the merits. Evidence and transparency on the side of the reason/truth should not need such measures.

The authorities and press infantalised the population on the assumption people are too stupid to process information and make their own informed choices. This is bad precedent.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by dTal on Friday March 18, 2022 @11:04AM (#30723199)
"But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown." -- Carl Sagan

Point is we also have a long history of genuine quacks and loonies, and they outnumber the genuine Cassandras to such an extent as to invalidate your heuristic. Statistically, if someone disagrees with the mainstream scientific consensus, they aren't a brave voice fighting the tide of darkness - just wrong.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by civilized on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:03AM (#30722365)
You can make a long list of times outsiders were right and the establishment was wrong. You can also make a long list of times outsiders were wrong and the establishment was right.

Why would you mention only one list and not the other?

Why would you want to enlist as a soldier in one side of a cause where neither side is reliable, neither side has your best interests in mind?

You're playing yourself for a fool.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:13AM (#30722513)
No. It's not about sides. It's about listening to a range of views. I'm talking about 'only' one list because that was the topic.

People gotta stop with this whole "you're either with the science or against it" rubbish. Be adults, inform yourself and make decisions. Don't just let media, politicians or fringe dwellers define your 'label' for you.

Complex issues need complex thought, but it's easy to just fall for paternalism and externalise your responsibility.

You're playing yourself the fool by thinking this is just a game of being on the winning team.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by civilized on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:27AM (#30722687)
The topic is cherry-picking experts (outsider experts in Rogan's case). The person you replied to said it can be justified because some experts are better than others, implying that outsider experts are better in this case. You supported that by saying there's a long list of cases where outsider experts are right and establishment experts are wrong.

In this topic, it's clearly relevant that this is far from universally the case. The establishment is often correct as well. That's why you don't want to cherry pick all your experts from one side. Especially if you yourself lack the ability to tell which experts are more expert, which is definitely true in Rogan's case.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Saturday March 19, 2022 @07:27AM (#30732939)
The person I replied to was quite obviously being sarcastic I thought, and if not then I misread, apologies.

As in my other responses, I agree and my view is not to just dismiss a view just because of which 'side' it is on.

We must keep reprosecuting the evidence, data and opinions over time to try to maintain objectivity while avoiding being swayed by manipulation, fraud and/or populist consensus.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by nostoc on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:34AM (#30722017)
Going down the "Some quacks were right, therefore all quacks are right" path will not lead you to a healthy place.

Yes, there is inertia in the scientific community, and sometimes the dissenting voices have a hard time being heard. That much is true.

But that is true because most of the time, the dissenting voices are wrong, if not outright lunatics.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:05AM (#30722391)
That's not my point. My point is don't dismiss all alternative views just because someone told you to. Consider a range of views and make your own informed decisions. This should not be about being on teams, but acting like adults.

The 'misinformation' label has made it really easy to just ignore a range of views through not wanting to be in 'that group.'

> But that is true because most of the time, the dissenting voices are wrong, if not outright lunatics

That's an incredibly broad generalisation, you're going to have to back that up with evidence. Does that also include those over-enthusiastically pushing the 'right' science that is in fact later proved wrong? Or are they not lunatics, just 'the science changed' on them?

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by coldtea on Saturday March 19, 2022 @11:30AM (#30734551)
>Going down the "Some quacks were right, therefore all quacks are right" path will not lead you to a healthy place.

Neither would some that disagreed were quasks so all who disagree with the mainstream are quacks, which is how they are treated.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by cudgy on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:44AM (#30721445)
The same thought came to mind regarding how easily manipulated the US population is regarding wars. They keep falling for the same fallacy of making conclusions without enough evidence.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by gadders on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:43AM (#30722122)
Not to mention Frances Oldham Kelsey and thalidomide. She'd be slated as anti-science on CNN etc today for sure.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by dekhn on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:33AM (#30722763)
Thalidomide is still used as a drug, it's very successful. Parts of the narrative around the FDA and Kelsey make it sound more heroic than it really was.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by headsoup on Friday March 18, 2022 @10:08AM (#30722439)
And more-so, have any of the scientists and politicians that supported and promoted thalidomide early on been pilloried since? Are they now whackos supporting pseudo/incorrect science?
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by xadhominemx on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:06AM (#30721698)
Yes, that is correct
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by spaetzleesser on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#30721840)
When the pandemic started I got some of the best information on Rogan. He had some immunologists on that predicted exactly how it would turn out. While a lot of people still believed that this could be stopped these guys predicted that it would run through the population. Which it did.

I don’t really like this need for people to hear only what they want to hear and get angry when people say something they don’t like. Rogan lets people on and lets them talk. Sometimes it’s interesting , sometimes it’s not, sometimes it’s right, sometimes very wrong. I much prefer Rogan over all the people on big news that constantly spin things one way or the other to get more viewers. The mainstream news has lost the ability to give straight news.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday March 18, 2022 @11:06AM (#30723240)
I would be highly suspicious that in this post, the msm is tasked with the standard of giving “straight news” but Joe Rogan is apparently no more quality with “sometimes it’s right, sometimes very wrong”. Why would you actively prefer one mediocre source of news over another mediocre source of news? They both seem mediocre and neither seem worth listening to.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by spaetzleesser on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:31PM (#30725054)
Rogan is not a news program and doesn't claim to be one . His thing is conversations with interesting people.H It can be serious scientists, questionable scientists, flat earthers, UFO people, Alex Jones and many others. He lets them talk and it's up to you do with it whatever you want. I personally find it very interesting to listen to political extremists, conspiracy guys, COVID deniers or flat earthers and learn what they are thinking. I don't need or want to be protected from wrong information. Actually it's very important to know where people you are disagreeing with are coming from. It's very unhealthy to only hear what you think is true.

If people want to get protected from wrong information a good start would be advertising. Maybe the woke people at Spotify should start there.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday March 18, 2022 @05:08PM (#30727548)
All I’m saying is that I don’t get why Joe Rogan and MSM are even comparable if they’re being held to totally different standards. You can critique them both without comparing them. They can both spout misinformation and bias differently because they are fundamentally different products. And they can critique each other’s biases and failures because, wel, they’re different things??
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by spaetzleesser on Friday March 18, 2022 @05:42PM (#30727916)
I just don't see a point in criticizing Rogan. He does exactly what he claims he does and I don't want him to get cancelled. His show is useful.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by nradov on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:13AM (#30721185)
Do you mean licensed doctors like Peter Attia or Michael Osterholm? As guests on Joe Rogan's podcast, both of them repeatedly recommended that people get vaccinated, and said that there wasn't reliable evidence for ivermectin.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/5DuxGhOJSa7X0AKvJGwwta?si=P...

https://open.spotify.com/episode/5VSukFrMYGae1ILd0e4HuR?si=B...

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by gadders on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:40AM (#30722081)
If you cherry pick your experts enough you end up believing that the Wuhan Lab Leak theory is hate-speech and that Hunter Biden's laptop is a Russian disinformation campaign.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by leereeves on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:38AM (#30720875)
Serious question: What media doesn't choose their guests to fit their opinions or their political stance? I'd like to watch that one.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by chefandy on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:50AM (#30721522)
Honestly— PBS News Hour.

You’re just as likely to see current or former GOP talking heads like Mitch McConnell, Newt Gingrich, or Pat Buchanan as some DNC talking head. In fact, scrolling down their page just now, McConnell is the only actual politician I saw interviewed, though they did have a Biden speech clip.

Keep in mind that inviting Political opponents into your show can advance your political message if you lampoon them — but PBS News Hour has about the same ratio of push to pull interviewing politicians, never ever interrupts, and doesn’t ask cheap shot gotcha questions.

They are more likely to choose topics from a loosely mainstream democrat perspective — you’d be more likely to see a story about the ACLU releasing a statement about immigration than a law enforcement agency doing the same, but that sheriff or whatever is going to get equal respect and air time in that segment… and it’s not that extreme of a shift compared to mainstream outlets.

So I firmly believe that they fit the criteria for your specific question. Truthfully I think most people just don’t want that.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by spaetzleesser on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:25AM (#30721915)
Agreed. News Hour is definitely left leaning but they let people talk and seem to make a genuine effort to provide information. Which is something most other news programs have stopped doing. They just want to produce outrage and conflict. You can listen to CNN, MSNBC or Fox for hours and the only thing you have learned is what you should be angry about. You will have learned nothing about the actual topic.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by dekhn on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:33PM (#30724333)
I agree; for COVID news, none of those three are even remotely reliable. What disappoints me the most is CNN, they really have no reason to be as useless as they are while also riling up emotions.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by spaetzleesser on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:32PM (#30725062)
CNN is just terrible. They have turned into the left wing Fox News. They report mainly on opinion, not news.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by dekhn on Friday March 18, 2022 @01:52PM (#30725321)
I think of HuffPo as the left wing Fox News. CNN is just some sort of thing that evolved from the mentality of TV talk shows.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by HL33tibCe7 on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:44AM (#30720927)
The coronavirus experts that the mainstream media platformed are far more representative of the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community than the experts Joe Rogan platformed.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by azangru on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:53AM (#30720997)
> are far more representative of the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community

But that isn't the answer to the question asked in the parent comment. The parent was wondering which media would choose guests that have a differing view from theirs. The mainstream media happened to align with the people representing the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community, and were rarely inviting Robert Malone, Peter McCullough, or Jay Bhattacharia, who had different views.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by willcipriano on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:53AM (#30721000)
The media manufactures opinion so that isn't surprising, the same can be said for the Hunter Biden laptop story, or WMD in Iraq.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by leereeves on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:47AM (#30720946)
Yes, as the evidence comes in, it seems probable that the mainstream media got Invermectin right. They've gotten other things wrong.

Whether they ultimately turn out to be right or wrong about any particular topic, the problem occurs much earlier: they choose their position before conclusive evidence is available, often, as in this case, based mostly on politics, then skew their coverage to fit.

I'd prefer to hear the arguments and evidence from an impartial source, not a political position.

[dead]
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by HL33tibCe7 on Friday March 18, 2022 @07:46AM (#30720940)
I have never said that he _only_ platforms experts that agree with him. I’m saying the skew is enormous.

So (say) 99% of the relevant scientific and medical community realise ivermectin is bogus and the vaccines work. But he’ll invite on (say) a 75/25 split for/against ivermectin.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by wozniacki on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:21AM (#30721248)
Youre trying to appear too clever. If you had not meant that you should have said as much. You were stopping just short of implying Joe Rogan invites quacks without actually using those words.

This ship for this sort of gaslighting has long sailed. Please do not do this. People have had enough of this disinfo-in-all-but-name only for the past two years. You will seem duplicitous if you do this sort of stuff.

[dead]
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by HL33tibCe7 on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:08AM (#30721149)
You need to go back and re-read my comment. He is skewing by cherry-picking. The two aren’t mutually incompatible.
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by edmcnulty101 on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:20AM (#30721236)
It's skew to you because the world is binary to you. My opinions vs The bad guys.

Joe Rogan has people with all kinds of differing opinions to create a rich marketplace of ideas where the idea wins on merit not censorship.

As I said, there's no reason to have more than one main stream person repeating the same thing repeated on every network.

When Labotomies won the Nobel Prize you would have possibly been upset that anyone would be questioning the science.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by bena on Friday March 18, 2022 @09:34AM (#30722015)
> create a rich marketplace of ideas where the idea wins on merit not censorship.

This is demonstrably false. Ideas on Joe Rogan do not win on merit. Unless merit is based on quantity of bullshit.

Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by edmcnulty101 on Friday March 18, 2022 @12:34PM (#30724342)
Not with that attitude!
Re:Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Lar... by maxerickson on Friday March 18, 2022 @08:29AM (#30721311)
Why isn't it fair to criticize his use of his platform?

There's enough people with MDs that are willing to do more or less anything for money that checking for a license isn't really much in the way of diligence.