News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by firekvz on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:31PM (#30654139)
Comming from a country where nucler power is nowhere near the radar, what is the case against nuclear power? it seems such a nobrainer for me to use
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by crote on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:01PM (#30654395)
- Time. This one took over a decade and a half to build, and that's pretty normal

- Cost. Literally billions of dollars, all upfront. This one was budgeted at $3B and ended up costing $10B+.

- Inflexibility. Almost all of the cost is in building one, so if you aren't running it basically 100% of the time at 100% capacity you are losing money.

When it comes to $/MWh, nuclear simply can't compete with fossil or renewable when demand is low. And you can't run it to pick up high demand because it gets even more expensive. The private market is simply not interested in them, unless they get a government guarantee that forces their production to be bought at a fixed price.

And there's of course the whole safety and waste argument, but I consider that to be secondary. All in all, nuclear is a could-have-been and mostly a side-effect of nuclear arms development. Neat technology, but there are way better options.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by fsflover on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:34PM (#30654662)
All these arguments are moot, see the research:

https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html

https://whatisnuclear.com/fukushima.html

...etc.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by threeseed on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:35PM (#30655102)
No the arguments are still the same.

We have to build lots of bigger, standardised reactors which will then reduce the cost due to experience and economies of scale. But then of course someone has to subsidise the tens/hundreds of billions in upfront investment to get to that point.

Where as with renewables this was all done decades ago. And we are now at the point where it is orders of magnitude cheaper than nuclear. And getting cheaper by the day.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by ncmncm on Saturday March 12, 2022 @06:15PM (#30655966)
Renewable+storage is not an order of magnitude cheaper yet, thus far it is just "a lot" cheaper. But that is a predictable outcome, because nobody is predicting when those costs will bottom out. (They will have to, at some point, as incidental cost becomes an increasing fraction of the total. But we are not close to that point yet, except on residential rooftops.)
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by freemint on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:48PM (#30654753)
See this nuclear positive website that doesn't have an imprint (I can find on mobile). I wouldn't bcall it research either. Summary would probably be fair.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Sunday March 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#30662425)
> See this nuclear positive website that doesn't have an imprint

You mean an "Impressum"? That's just some weird thing that AFAIK (almost?) only German Web sites have, because they're required to by German law. The vast majority of sites on the World Wide Web get by just fine without it; it's not like that's some kind of minimum requirement for a reputable site.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by freemint on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:13PM (#30677634)
I want to see who is behind an advocacy group. If it is a letterbox address and if so what other letter boxes are at this address.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:21AM (#30683218)
Many, probably most, Web sites the world over have "About Us" or "Contact" pages. It's just that they're not universally called "Impressum" ("Imprint"); that's a Germany-only thing.

So saying "a Web site without an imprint" as if that in itself somehow showed the site were somehow bad is, if it's about a non-German site, just stupid. HTH.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by fsflover on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:27PM (#30655038)
It contains links to the research.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Krasnol on Saturday March 12, 2022 @05:25PM (#30655551)
Yeah but only where it fits the narrative which in the question of cost for example leads to this:

1) If markets valued the low-CO2 nature of nuclear, they’d be doing better

2) Multiple hypothetical approaches to reduce nuclear costs are ongoing. No one knows for sure if any of them will work, or which one will work best

3) Factory-produced large reactors on floating platforms is a surprisingly intriguing idea to make reactors cheap

or: 1) make everything else more expensive so we look better

2) let me consult the magic orb because I have nothing in my hands

3) I have a nice idea

Meanwhile we have HERE just another example of hilariously expensive reactor. Actual facts. Waved away with theories like "we don't have the people with experience anymore" which leaves you with the thought: should inexperienced people build nuclear reactors at all?

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by iso1631 on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:51PM (#30654315)
Extreme cost (money and time) to get it built

Difficulties in managing waste

20 years ago I was all for nuclear, then I looked at terrible projects in Europe, like in the Finland and the UK, and realised that it's too little too late. Europe can't build nuclear, so rather than trying to fight a losing battle for another 20 years, Europe should be massively investing in what it can do (offshore wind, tidal, solar, pumped hydro)

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by hackerfromthefu on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:26PM (#30654597)
Plus proliferation of material for nuclear weapons.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by fsflover on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:31PM (#30654639)
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Ekaros on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:12PM (#30654919)
I'm thinking proliferation as positive. Just think of countries recently in war had nuclear deterrent. They might not have been invaded in first place. Everyone having nuclear weapons would make world much more peaceful and safer place.

That is unless we sanction all nations that have nuclear weapons and blockade them from international trade until they get rid of them and subject themselves to being open to inspections for couple centuries.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rhn_mk1 on Saturday March 12, 2022 @05:17PM (#30655490)
> Everyone having nuclear weapons would make world much more peaceful and safer place.

That's the happy path.

The failure path with an unhinged dictator causing global destruction also gets much more likely.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by iso1631 on Sunday March 13, 2022 @07:29AM (#30660307)
The chance of losing a nuclear weapon out of the control of said dictators increases too
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Ekaros on Saturday March 12, 2022 @05:33PM (#30655626)
Then again the so called "rational" actors would be less likely do bad things. Just imagine how much better place world would be if in response to drone strike by Obama or Biden the NYC or Washington DC was hit by nuclear weapon. That would surely put end to those antics.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rhn_mk1 on Sunday March 13, 2022 @01:40AM (#30658581)
If you think the near-certainty of getting wiped out entirely at some point is the right price for avoiding wars, then sure. I'm not sure most people share that preference.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by stavros on Saturday March 12, 2022 @07:07PM (#30656442)
This is like saying there's no gun crime in the US because there are lots of guns there.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by stevenwoo on Saturday March 12, 2022 @07:46PM (#30656699)
AFAIK Finland is the only country in the world that has managed to build a long term (they're planning for something like 100000 years) nuclear waste storage facility.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by londons_explore on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:37PM (#30654192)
* Plants are very expensive to build. Due to massive upfront costs, it cannot beat wind/solar today unless you use very unusual financial models. (ie. assume interest rates are zero for 50 years). If nuclear plants were built more frequently, cost would come down a lot - it turns out making everything bespoke is hugely expensive.

* Lots of public opposition due to the public being scared of nuclear waste, nuclear accidents, etc. The public far prefers taking on invisible risk (like the lung cancer risk from coal/oil/gas emissions) than the huge event risk of a nuclear meltdown, even if the overall harm to human lives is higher.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by cipher_system on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:52PM (#30654334)
Keep in mind that Finland is on the same latitudes as Alaska so solar doesn't work that great when needed the most.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:35PM (#30654170)
It usually goes like this:

Chernobyl! Fukushima! Radiation! Waste! Death! Death!! DEATH TO ALL HUMANITY!!!

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Aachen on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:00PM (#30654394)
And if you manage to convince someone this is an airplane crash type of problem, they start about the finances.

And they're right about it not being the cheapest option, so what can you say? They win the argument.

Next time you meet the person is at a protest where they don't want a solar farm where there is now a nice forest or pasture, no 24/7 moving shadows from huge wind turbine blades and that's after they pushed for a law to require more space between the edge of town and the nearest turbine, protesting for fish rights when hydro is being proposed (if that's possible in their area in the first place)...

People also love to gloss over that electricity is 10% of the problem. Whenever you see a headline about Germany having run on 90% renewable power last month or whatever, mentally replace that with 9% because energy used in transportation, building heating, etc. don't count towards this. And then we haven't even touched upon the problem of cement/steel/plastic yet, we're going to need breakthrough materials or negative emissions with capturing plants that, you guessed it, also require electricity.

It's apparently very hard to understand that we need to work on all fronts, not pick a partial solution and wait until that's exhaustively implemented (all reasonably available space occupied) 15 years down the road, then wonder why emissions are at record highs (see 2021).

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by thow-58d4e8b on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:57PM (#30654812)
As a rule of thumb, greenhouse gas emissions are roughly equally split between electricity production, transportation, heating, agriculture and industry, about 20% each. Transportation is electrifying rather quickly in Europe, heating at a bit slower pace. So it's a bit better than "10% of the problem" - it's about 20% now, becoming ~40% in 10-15 years, eventually lowering total emissions by ~60% probably some time around 2050

Agriculture and industry are tough nuts to crack. With electricity, transport and heating, it's a problem of scaling out. With agriculture and industry - we don't even have a blueprint yet

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Aachen on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:47PM (#30655217)
Fair enough. My figures are from 2013 and even then it was better than 10% (namely 12.7% in the Netherlands where I'm from; that's the latest info Wikipedia has). I'll use 20% as a rule of thumb going forwards because that's indeed more future-proof.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by qkls on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:29PM (#30678601)
The solution for agriculture is to stop eating meat.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by manquer on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:17PM (#30654520)
It is less about being cheap and more about being predictable.

Getting consistent funding for new projects is hard when every other project in history has over run both costs and time widely.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Aachen on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:30PM (#30654625)
If mere cost/time predictability were the problem we could double any worst-case projection. Even at that price point it's something I think we should pursue alongside the more renewable sources. That electricity has been dirt(y) cheap in the past decades was great, but that's just not sustainable.

But yeah if we argue for another five years before getting started on at least the legislation/planning stages (after which we could still declare it a sunk cost, based on how the situation looks in 2027), we might as well forget about it.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by manquer on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:32PM (#30677093)
Just double the worst-case project ?

Firstly, the plant above has costed more than 3x projected time or money, so doubling is not going to solve anything.

Secondly, forget civic planning, could you or I go to our companies and say just double by budget because we don't know how to plan well ? What is the guarantee our plan is at least 50% accurate ? i.e. only 2x is enough ?

Poor planning cannot be solved by increasing budget (time or money), even in non public projects, work has tendency to get expanded to meet the budget, basically if Norway had thought 2x the $3B and actually budgeted $6B, they would likely have spent $20B in the end.

All this is only for operational life of the plant, it does not even include long term costs of waste storage because no one can even model that well enough or budget for it today.

I am not saying we shouldn't do nuclear, we really should, but truly commercial plans are meaningless unless we can handle costs better, We should invest more on that, there is encouraging work in SMRs(Small Modular Reactors) that could potentially address these concerns, until then most plants are experimental high risk projects from a public plan perspective.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rectang on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:44PM (#30654254)
You left out proliferation of dual-use technologies. The fewer countries with advanced nuclear capabilities, the more thinly spread the expertise necessary to build nuclear weapons.

If Russia didn't have nukes, its imperialistic ambitious would be curtailed. The ability to shield conventional assaults behind a nuclear threat is destabilizing for the rules-based world order.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by qwytw on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:08PM (#30654453)
Is this also sarcasm? So you're saying that building this plant has increase the chance Finland will try to acquire Nuclear weapons? And Russia has nukes purely due to political and military reasons, they'd still have more than enough of them if they mostly started closing/stopped building new plants after Chernobyl.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by jrockway on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:24PM (#30654586)
I don't think it's sarcasm. Maybe North Korea is a better example. It would probably just be "Korea" if they didn't have nukes, but you can't exactly go in and overthrow the government when they can just wipe out all human life on the peninsula in an instant.

(People get upset at the implication that one country would take over another country, but the people of North Korea would probably not be worse off if that happened. Instead they suffer greatly because nobody can help them.)

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by RobertMiller on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:32PM (#30654642)
> It would probably just be "Korea" if they didn't have nukes

Their first nuclear test was in 2006. Even their production of refined uranium and plutonium only began in the 80s, decades after the war came to a standstill.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by jrockway on Saturday March 12, 2022 @07:18PM (#30656517)
Kind of a case of ignoring geopolitical debt, I guess. Anybody who wants to fix the problem today has an impossible task that was once possible.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Sunday March 13, 2022 @12:10PM (#30662576)
Seems to indicate that the general rule of thumb should be to fix shit like that ASAP, so it won't over time get impossible to fix.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Sunday March 13, 2022 @12:08PM (#30662556)
> People get upset at the implication that one country would take over another country

If anyone is upset that the people of the German "Democratic" Republic got to join the rest of "We, the people" in a free Federal Republic, they're cordially invited to go fuck themselves.

The same would go ten times over for anyone feeling that way about the much more oppressed North Koreans.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rectang on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:18PM (#30654529)
No, it's not sarcasm — I would appreciate it if you would be a little more generous when interpreting my remark. The proliferation problem is exacerbated incrementally by every additional plant in every additional country — including this one. The issue is not Finland in particular developing nuclear weapons, but any country developing nuclear weapons — especially a country governed by an autocracy. Or a country that might be governed by an autocracy in the future — the last few years have raised the urgency of the problem of democratic backsliding, which we need to figure out how to avert.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by yakubin on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:05PM (#30654875)
The countries which are least trustworthy wrt nuclear weapons are the ones that aren't going to ask the public's permission. An autocracy doesn't need to power itself by nuclear plants in order to have nuclear weapons. On the other hand having a sustainable, clean source of power not tied to autocratic regimes lowers the leverage those regimes hold over democratic countries.

In my particular country, a major chunk of the public budget goes towards paying fines to EU for use of coal, all while our government periodically passes bills allowing it to borrow more money from the central bank, increasing inflation. Negotiations with neighbouring autocratic countries can be pretty tough, when they can threaten us and rest of Europe, which is going to put pressure, with stopping energy transmission. Energy shortages in some parts of the country were a regular occurrence for decades, even before the current political problems.

Lack of nuclear plants does nothing to prevent a nuclear war, while it harms us on many very tangible levels.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rectang on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:38PM (#30655127)
See https://whatisnuclear.com/non-proliferation.html#how-is-nucl... for one of the mechanisms whereby dual-use technology presents issues: obtaining fissile material is difficult, and while nuclear power plants are not a prerequisite, they make it easier.

I agree that dependence on geopolitically and environmentally problematic fossil fuel sources is a pressing concern.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Sunday March 13, 2022 @12:04PM (#30662495)
> In my particular country...

But yet [your country] is not lost?

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by yakubin on Sunday March 13, 2022 @02:27PM (#30664262)
What do you mean by "lost"?
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by CRConrad on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:12AM (#30670945)
Just a guess at what country you were talking about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poland_Is_Not_Yet_Lost . OK, so not Poland, then. :-)
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by pfdietz on Sunday March 13, 2022 @08:44AM (#30660754)
An interesting example is Japan. Japan has a large reactor grade plutonium stockpile. This was ostensibly for their fast reactor program, but that's dead now. So, the plutonium just sits there. It's not ideal for weapons (being reactor not weapons grade) but it can be made to work, so Japan has the potential capability to make thousands of warheads if they need to.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by fsflover on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:31PM (#30654637)
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:43PM (#30654717)
Russia imperialistic ambitions would be far more modest if Europe and US wouldn't fill Putin's coffers with hundreds of billions of dollars and euros in exchange for oil and gas. You know, the things they use instead of Nuclear energy.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by rectang on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:04PM (#30654865)
Indeed, we are left with (from my perspective) all bad choices in the short-to-medium term. In the US, we made a least-bad calculation when choosing the environmental cost of fracking over the geopolitical costs of depending on dictator oil. Now Europe gets to make similar calculations.

I'd sure like it if less inherently dangerous technologies were further along. But every year they are gaining.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by Tepix on Sunday March 13, 2022 @06:26AM (#30659943)
Insane cost overruns.

Takes decades to build, will be too late for climate change.

Uranium is also a finite resource

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by chabes on Saturday March 12, 2022 @10:05PM (#30657502)
Look at the situation in Ukraine. A huge problem almost nobody is talking about is the largest nuclear plant in Europe was just captured by an invading military force just over a week ago. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zaporizhzhia_Nuclear_Power_P...
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by theshrike79 on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:37PM (#30654190)
Fear based on feeling, not on facts. That's it.

By any objective metric, nuclear is by far the best choice for stable base power generation.

"But what if it explodes" - and there goes all rationality.

Humans will take constant death from coal power plants rather than a minuscule chance of a larger catastrophe in a nuclear plant.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by ljf on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:53PM (#30654343)
As soon as private industry is funding and running nuclear power including the decommissioning costs, plus selling their energy at market rates (in the UK we have guaranteed the new nuclear plants rates that are higher than the next most expensive generators costs) then I'll believe that.

The only way these are remotely economical is when they are funded by the tax payer before the are built, while they run, and after they close down.

Any examples that goes against that? I'd be very interested to learn about them. I think as a way to ensure energy independence and remove fossil fuels they are good, but we cannot pretend they don't come with massive costs, and don't yet pay their own way.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by p_l on Saturday March 12, 2022 @04:56PM (#30655300)
The problem is that markets are supremely bad at building a stable electricity grid. So on one hand wind and solar are getting cheaper per MW, but it doesn't include the effect they have on destabilising both the grid and electricity markets - in fact, solar getting cheaper is probably going to cause a stop on buildout in some places, because the price of solar MW is going to be too low to deal with all the time you're not producing - either due to lack of sun, or due to curtailment.

And we do not really have any storage available - the only systems that are 1) not experimental 2) usable for anything other than frequency stabilisation; are the pumped hydro - and those are geographically limited. At least when it's windy, you can use wind turbines as sinks for stability. Intermittent nature of solar and wind is too intermittent for most industrial sinks.

Meanwhile unpredictable nature of generation from wind and solar push the grid to buildout LNG/petroleum powered gas turbines, due to their very short delay on ramping up/down (IIRC, second only to hydro). So you end up in situation where market approach to electricity is going to prevent decarbonisation, unless you hugely upend what is being bought on the market.

Personally I've been thinking of electricity market paying only for predictable (aka "dispatchable") low-carbon power plants, or at least with huge priority. Solar and Wind could still compete on such market by being paired with storage systems into Virtual Power Plants (something that already exists), and the rest of the generation would be sold on spot market during peaks, or preferably to dedicated sinks like green hydrogen production.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by danhor on Saturday March 12, 2022 @08:01PM (#30656796)
The issue is, that in a traditional electrical system, you need both base load and dispatchable power plants. And while nuclear power plants work as base load, they're really bad for dispatchable power, both economically and in how they work.

So if you want to base an electrical grid solely on nuclear power without additional fossil fuel plants, you need either a lot of often unused (and thus very, very expensive) nuclear capacity or some kind of .. storage. It's similar to renewables in that regard, although much more predictable and reliable (with exceptions, such as france this winter).

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by p_l on Saturday March 12, 2022 @10:16PM (#30657566)
That's why I'd rather see a variable sink like electrolysers producing green hydrogen for non-electricity related purposes or disconnected operations. A mix of renewable and nuclear that, instead of curtailment, uses excess renewable production for other purposes.
Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by ncmncm on Saturday March 12, 2022 @06:35PM (#30656147)
We do not have storage yet just because it is not built out yet.

Thus far, a renewable euro has been just overwhelmingly better used to build out generating capacity, even where intermittent. The only problems in storage are picking which will be cheapest or otherwise most valuable -- e.g. hydrogen, ammonia, and liquid air are entirely the latter -- and that by waiting, you get more for your euro. Storage cost is plummeting much faster even than solar, and solar is already so cheap that building 2x, 3x, 6x overcapacity is in easy reach.

The cheapest, most efficient present storage is pumped hydro, which can be used in very many places where native hydro generation cannot be, i.e. almost anyplace with hills. But iron-air battery factories are under construction, for very cheap and safe storage, and that will compete with many other alternatives. Each has strengths for certain places, all work, and operating cost is in all cases very small, so building "the wrong one" just means you spent more up front than you maybe had to.

Trotting out the "ooh, storage" argument only demonstrates you don't have one.

Re:Finland starts much-delayed nuclear plant, brings respite... by pfdietz on Saturday March 12, 2022 @05:18PM (#30655496)
"But what if it explodes" is actually a valid question for fast reactors, since they can potentially go prompt fast supercritical in a serious accident. Edward Teller was famously suspicious (in 1967) of fast reactors for this reason.