News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by typeofhuman on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:46PM (#30604082)
I don't engage on Twitter out of fear.

I sometimes see posts that I like and want to retweet but I don't because it means I'm endorsing everything the author has ever said or ever will say. It's not worth the risk.

People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink. So it's best for me to avoid it entirely.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by jamesfe on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:57PM (#30604394)
This exactly. I once tried the twitter game, I thought it was important to have a big following or say clever things, whatever.

I was lightly burned by a tweet (of my own authoring) once, and I thought "I make $XYZ per year, twitter pays me nothing, this joke tweet caused me a lot of stress, the odds that being on twitter will get me cancelled will cost me $XYZ are non-zero and I don't control them"

Then I deleted all my tweets and my twitter account (8 years ago) and life has been really nice without it!

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by vasco on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:05PM (#30604598)
Exact same story except recently I created an empty account with private lists that I follow (so not even the people I "follow" is public), and I can still keep up with some topics from a source of information that generally is on the bleeding edge. Usually I find things in twitter / discord first, then they hit Reddit, then mainstream media. If you only follow reddit you have a slight delay currently, and for some of my interests, fresh information is helpful.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by alphabetting on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:06PM (#30604613)
This is the way
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604739)
Twitter is a massively multiplayer video game that is culturally overvalued and entrenched because journalism and other influential fields got sucked in. It is absolutely insane that it is taken so seriously. It's also super weird that everyone is so addicted to this game they play it out in public.

To illustrate this: imagine your ideal day. It could be on vacation, or hanging out at home, anywhere really. The key: imagine you are happy, or at least content. Now, do your imaginings ever have you reading angry tweets by people you hardly know for longer than you'd like?

I'd guess not.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by saiya-jin on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:24PM (#30605061)
Never joined the game, never will, see absolutely 0 reason. I don't care what he and she and he said, I guess you can say I am way more impressed by deeds than endless blabbing. Anytime I open it due to being embedded in news articles and wanting to see detailed photo being shown, I see basically news/youtube/whatever shallow and pathetic comment section. Echo chambers. Weird dynamics which don't happen in real life.

Why would you do this to yourself? I mean if you are a balanced adult who knows what they want in life and are not affected by massive mood swings and insecurities for whatever reason.

It is of course not black and white, it seems that ie right now Ukrainian defenders have a very good platform to inform whole world, no need to have BBC/CNN guys embedded in the heart of bombed city. That's cool and all. I just really don't like the rest of the whole society evolved around it.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @04:03PM (#30606909)
> if you are a[n]...adult who knows what they want in life

Twitter feeds directly into the modern impulse to define oneself. It becomes sticky by coupling that with social validation. Say the right thing and you get a few Internet Points. Do it enough and people may follow you, which gives you a different type of Internet Points. Get enough of those, and you might get a blue checkmark, denoting you as a Very Important Person.

It is much easier to lean on externally mediated processes of identity formation (like Twitter) than it is to go at it alone. I almost don't blame people, except for the fact that I don't believe this outsourcing of identity even works on an individual level. It's as if everyone present is playing along with a game that they don't fully believe in, but the game goes on despite that.

It's quite modern and tragicomic in a way.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by MattGaiser on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:24PM (#30605056)
I saw a post once for a journalism job with local media here. 4-6 articles a day.

Not sure how you could do that job without Twitter.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by Ekaros on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:31PM (#30605218)
Sing up for all the companies that provide press releases? Not sure if that is enough though...
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by colechristensen on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:13PM (#30604804)
I post publicly on forums with my real name and don’t endorse everything I have said.

Just evict such absolutist moral nonsense people from your life and don’t allow them to control you. When you see them do it to others, block them.

It’s exactly the same thing as when it was a certain sort of church people controlling much of society with fear of “canceling” which was just done by different people with different means in the past, fundamentally nothing changed when people left religion because they thought religion was the source of this kind of toxicity.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by scintill76 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:30PM (#30605204)
When you get “canceled”, it doesn’t matter who you’ve personally “evicted” or not. If people with power over you either agree with the absolutists or are afraid of offending them, you’re going to have a bad time.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by KerrAvon on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:32PM (#30605246)
I think you're failing to account for the specifically viral nature of Twitter. Even a forum like reddit is a relatively isolated space for opprobrium by comparison.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by happytoexplain on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:53PM (#30604291)
>People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink.

I don't use Twitter or pretty much say anything publicly for the same reason, but note that this is definitely a risk for people of all demographics.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by analyst74 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:30PM (#30605205)
Totally agree, being attacked for your viewpoint used to be just a problem for minority viewpoints/identities. But now even those who were previously safe are seeing increasing risk in backlashes.

We have gone from silencing the minority to silencing the majority, this is terrible, but silver lining is that now maybe more people are invested in solving the problem.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by RobertRoberts on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:55PM (#30604341)
It is far more risk for some than others.

If you have a minority viewpoint, you get attacked far more easily.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by Ekaros on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:00PM (#30604482)
I would even say viewpoint of not the vocal minority. That is even near majority viewpoint, but if it is one not popular on twitter it is risky...
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by aksss on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:05PM (#30604589)
Isn't the whole dynamic of twitter that it can make a highly vocal minority viewpoint seem like an oppressive majority viewpoint, where reality is that it's like a heckler's veto on amphetamines with a megaphone?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by Sebb767 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:22PM (#30605017)
> but if it is one not popular on twitter it is risky...

Right now or at any point in the future. People have been canceled for things they said many years and opinion changes ago.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by ryandrake on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:33PM (#30605312)
That’s the minefield of posting online. People measure your comments from 20 years ago with today’s sensitivity yardstick. I know I made wisecrack jokes decades ago that would get me fired today. Who knows whether some innocuous thing you say today will be horrendously taboo 20 years from now?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by whathappenedto on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:36PM (#30605365)
Maybe instead of demographic, it's about people whose public image is part of their job. Like startup executives, academics, athletes, politicians (even "low-level" politicians like city councilman), product managers, or venture capitalists. That's a lot of people who are juicier targets than someone earlier in their career, like a student, an associate, or entry-level software developer.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by bob1029 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:01PM (#30604498)
I don't think this is a healthy way to live. There was another conversation thread started about an hour ago that dives into this really well:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30602611

I would reiterate my comment on that thread, verbatim:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30603008

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by blowski on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:06PM (#30604609)
On the contrary, this seems to me a very healthy way to live. Until the last 15 years, very few people had their views expressed beyond a narrow circle. Standing on a public stage and shouting your every thought would have seemed crazy.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cpach on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:13PM (#30604779)
Without hesitation I dare say there is prior art in this question. I’m thinking of the Speakers’ Corner in Hyde Park.

https://www.bbc.com/news/in-pictures-32703071

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by blowski on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:00PM (#30605936)
I don't think Speakers' Corner is remotely comparable to how social media works today.

Very few people spoke there, and very little of what they said was distributed beyond Hyde Park or recorded for posterity. I'm lucky enough to have seen a couple of people speak there, and they were both rather... eccentric. And even they didn't stand there all day, every day giving their opinions on everything that happened.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cpach on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:19PM (#30604951)
I think that’s great.

I don’t believe in living in fear of how people might react.

Of course I choose my battles; and I don’t walk up to strangers and tell them their baby is ugly. But that’s not being suppressed, IMHO.

And I don’t keep narrow-minded people among my close friends.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by fantod on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:24PM (#30605071)
You can get the best of both worlds. Stop worrying too much about what you think and say, like you mentioned; and also stop engaging on Twitter.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by massysett on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:09PM (#30604688)
I’m so afraid of Twitter that I even created a distinct account with a default username—“user12345” or something of that nature. My old account had my photo and maybe my name.

I can’t even risk having people see who I follow, and on Twitter who you follow is public.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by Clubber on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:14PM (#30604833)
>I don't engage on Twitter out of fear.

It seems in their effort to ban people for wrong think, they banned the wrong group. They should have been banning the cancellers. "I don't engage on Twitter out of fear," is not a good sign for retention or growth numbers. Twitter seems to be killing itself by allowing this cancer to grow.

Have you ever been on a pretty great message board / forum and a bunch of spittle people join and makes the board suck to converse on? Eventually that board is nothing but spittle people, then the board dies. Twitters seems like it is going this way.

FWIW, I cancelled all my social media accounts after the Snowden revelations in 2013. I'm just an outside observer, but I'm certainly glad I'm not inside.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by echelon on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:26PM (#30605095)
> I don't engage on Twitter out of fear.

> it means I'm endorsing everything the author has ever said or ever will say.

> People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink.

I totally get that this is the zeitgeist now (and I'm starting to behave this way now on HN since I don't really do other social media), but this is a horrible place we've worked ourselves into.

People taking pop shots and then getting algorithmically amplified has reduced the surface area for having safe dialogue and has led to increasing tensions and polarization.

In an ideal world, people talk about and discuss things they disagree about frequently and are at least respectful in dealing with those they don't see eye to eye with. We all have a different frame of reference, and that's not something to fight against.

I think the pandemic increased stresses for a lot of people (myself included), but these trends really took hold with algorithmic amplification. It isn't just a passing fad, sadly. And it isn't just rooted in just the technology. There are real needs and causes for social angst that need to be met.

Imagine if we also amplified inspiring and hopeful things. Nourished ourselves with stories of hope and overcoming difficulties. Science and technology, opportunity, a look to the future. (Especially for kids!) I know life isn't all sunshine and roses, but this would give us balance and perspective and wouldn't chip away at a person's inner drive and passion by replacing it with skepticism and dissatisfaction.

I think we can swing back. People are noticing this and feeling displeasure.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by paulpauper on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:32PM (#30605274)
Unless u have a lot of followers, there is a 99.9% chance no one will even see your tweet. Almost all twitter engagement is just bot engagement. there are entire industries devoted to getting social media posts seen by humans. it isn't easy.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604727)
The golden rule of using Twitter is: everything said is said to everyone, in public.

Turns out, there's a lot of stuff people just probably shouldn't broadcast.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by rvz on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:16PM (#30607975)
> So it's best for me to avoid it entirely.

Good decision.

To win the social media game it is to not play it at all.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:14PM (#30604822)
Is it accurate to label that fear, or simply a modicome of intelligence.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by jquery on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:05PM (#30604591)
You’re getting cancelled for your views? Which views are those, exactly?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604748)
“If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him.” - Cardinal Armand Jean du Plessis

It doesn't matter what their views are. If someone decides they don't like them and that person have enough followers, they will find something.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by typeofhuman on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604745)
The point I was making was the risk exists. Consider the scenario: Author says something interesting; I retweet; Author later says something awful which I don't even know about; My retweet is still present and can make me guilty by association.

This is very common on Twitter. It's not a place I can haphazardly navigate. I can't stay up to date on the latest outrage or who has fallen from glory.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by TechBro8615 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:30PM (#30605196)
Your comment implies that surely any cancellation of someone for their views must be justifiable.

That's an insane premise, but even if we presume it to be true, it still doesn't cover the case of _future_ cancellation when someone finds your tweets 10 years later and decides they aged like milk.

There are many comments I would have made 5-10 years ago, that I wouldn't make today. Sure, that's mostly due to maturity, but I've also adjusted my self-filter to account for a changing environment and audience.

At this point, I write all political comments under pseudonyms. It's not because I'm scared of getting cancelled — on the contrary, I wish I could argue my positions from my real name. But there is a lot of risk, for little benefit – I'm not a "journalist" or blogger or anyone with a career that depends on my political viewpoints. So why bother?

In general, online political comments gain me nothing, and there is no way to predict how those comments might look in a week, month, or even years from now. I do still write plenty of them, under pseudonyms (like this one), but it's more of a hobby to practice my writing. But I'm also not ashamed of anything I've written under any of the accounts – I would gladly defend all my opinions in person (to those close to me, who already know my feelings, and – btw, because they're sane – have never "cancelled" me).

Who knows, maybe one day I'll even tweet my pseudonym usernames so I can show everyone how right I was five years ago.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by colordrops on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:10PM (#30604719)
Supporting free speech and support equal hiring practices will get you cancelled these days, or at least bucketed with right wing extremists.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by ggm on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:18PM (#30604914)
or supporting radical feminism. or socialism. it's easy to be in an out-group very quickly
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @01:58PM (#30604439)
It's really easy to not be "canceled", just be a good person. What genuinely OK opinion are people being canceled for?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by thinkingemote on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:03PM (#30604552)
Define "good" and "ok" first.

A good person who doesn't use Twitter (someone who might fix cars, or works on a fishing vessel for example) who is having this little discussion about what is "good" and "ok" might very easily use the wrong words and offend someone.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:05PM (#30604584)
Really? This is easy, don't hurt other people.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by voakbasda on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604751)
That’s not possible. People take offense at everything. Or they will tomorrow.

That’s the real problem: the standards of “good” and “decent” shift from time to time. What is fine today may get you canceled tomorrow.

Thus, it is not safe to put your opinions out there in any form that could come back to bite you. If you want to take that risk, fine. But do not pretend that it is safe.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:16PM (#30604866)
It really isn't changing that much though. Maybe if you think someone might be offended by what you say in 10 years, maybe don't say it now. It's probably offensive now
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by brimble on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:35PM (#30606476)
Has it slowed down? The change over the last 10 years, and over the 10 before that, was fast. Just watching mass media from the early parts of those two spans should make that clear.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:31PM (#30605222)
Are there any of your own beliefs which you don't express because they might be considered offensive in the future?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:54PM (#30605805)
I don't think i hold offensive beliefs (controversial maybe, as we see here, but no ones getting their feelings hurt), if I did and learned about I'd change them. It seems easy to not be offensive though, what kind of beliefs are people having trouble with?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:24PM (#30606346)
There are some issues where it seems impossible to hold a non-offensive belief. You can't support abortion or oppose abortion or claim abortion is unimportant without genuinely hurting a lot of people's feelings. (I wouldn't deny that you can avoid being offensive by simply avoiding all controversial issues, and in some contexts that's a perfectly reasonable approach.)
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by panzagl on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604744)
You're literally talking down to someone right now- that's not hurting other people?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by thinkingemote on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:14PM (#30604809)
Now define "hurt".

It's not easy as "hurt" is not objective, is relative to others and no longer connected to intention.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:17PM (#30604882)
This isn't some clover got you, if someone tell you your offended them then that's it, you offended them. You don't get to redefine it
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by mtizim on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:39PM (#30605444)
Your comment offends my intelligence, therefore you've hurt a person, therefore you're not a "good person" anymore.

But you might not care about that. You might say that I'm arguing in bad faith, or that your words couldn't possibly have offended me. But you don't get to redefine it.

Obviously, you might just not care that you've just offended me. That's what bad people do. You aren't a bad person, right? Could you please apologize?

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cgriswald on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:45PM (#30605565)
That's an unreasonable standard. If I chose to see your use of the phrase 'clover got you' as some slur against Irish people and was offended, would you have offended me?

This is an unfair question, not because it's not a reasonable one given your argument, but because if you say 'yes' I can't take you seriously.

Of course, that's not really the issue. The issue is what the response is when people are offended. I can certainly modify my language and behavior to reduce the chances of offending someone. I can even apologize when I've accidentally put my foot in my mouth.

Twitter lacks the tolerance and nuance for either of those scenarios, though. If something 'not ok' is said, what was intended or meant doesn't matter (and any nuanced is typically ignored). An apology isn't seen as an apology for a mistake, but as an admission of guilt of being a terrible person who doesn't deserve oxygen.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by MrPatan on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:48PM (#30605633)
I find your words offensive, please stop posting in HN forever.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tdrgabi on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:36PM (#30605362)
You offended me.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by recursive on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:12PM (#30604773)
You can't physically hurt people on twitter, as it's all information. So whether or not you hurt someone is (at least partly) dependent on how people react. That can be hard to predict.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by PeterisP on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:52PM (#30605755)
It's definitely not sufficient, we've seen people being cancelled who did not do anything bad.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by blockmarker on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:07PM (#30604633)
It's really easy to not be burned at the stake, just don't be a witch.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:10PM (#30604709)
Being canceled isn't even a real thing. It's just a phrase people use because they have to have consequences when they show their true selves. Some group of people don't agree with you? Show me an example of being canceled then
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cgriswald on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:28PM (#30605145)
You've already made up your mind, so if you're not interested in actually understanding why cancelling both exists and is a problem, you can probably sit this conversation out. You want an example, fine.

In many scenarios canceling is completely arbitrary, based on misquotes, lack of context, or total fabrication simply because someone, somewhere was offended and can get other people to act on their behalf.

In the best case scenario, the person being canceled is actually a shitty human being. I know such a person. He said some really stupid stuff online, was called out on it, doubled down on it, was doxxed and canceled. He's not the type of person who considers the consequences of his actions in any scenario. He's also actually stupid and not a friend of mine. I think he's as close to hot garbage as a human being can get without actually abusing or murdering other people.

However, this person still did not deserve death threats for the words he wrote. This person did not deserve people calling his employer threatening to burn down their building. The employer certainly didn't deserve that. His coworkers didn't deserve it. This person did not deserve his house to be vandalized; nor did the actual owner of the house. His roommates didn't deserve to live in fear and to have to deal with angry people maybe thinking they were him.

These behaviors are not justifiable. They are, in fact, less justifiable than someone saying awful things online. Writing them off as "consequences" is simply twisted.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by recursive on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:16PM (#30604851)
If you really think it's not a thing, here's an early cancellation. Pretty much everyone involved lost their jobs, and it was all over social media for a cycle.

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/03/how-dongle-jokes...

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by shankr on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:38PM (#30605420)
My earliest memory of getting "cancelled" predates twitter where Dixie Chicks were "cancelled" by their own fans because they criticized the Iraq war.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dixie_Chicks_controversy

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cgriswald on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:49PM (#30605662)
The show Soap was (literally) canceled for positive representations of homosexuals by people complaining to employers, issuing death threats, and etc.

https://tvseriesfinale.com/tv-show/soap/

> Though the show’s ratings were still good in season four, ABC cancelled the series because of continued pressure from the so-called “moral majority.” By the end of the series, Vlasic pickles was the only advertiser interested in advertising on the series. In They’ll Never Put That on the Air, executive producer Paul Junger Witt said, “We weren’t killed by a fearful network. The network had been incredibly supportive. We had been doing this long enough to understand that they were in a business, and they sat down and showed us — dollar for dollar — why they couldn’t afford to do it anymore.”

The people who are part of cancel culture now are literally using the same scare tactics that were used to suppress and oppress homosexuals and other minority groups.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by shankr on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:29PM (#30608147)
> The people who are part of cancel culture now are literally using the same scare tactics that were used to suppress and oppress homosexuals and other minority groups.

More like people who complain about being victim of the cancel culture are the ones who were oblivious to it until they became the victim. Currently the cancel culture is being associated as some kind of PC culture outcome but it originated way before. The push back or critisim against it seems to be only happening now.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by cgriswald on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:49PM (#30609028)
I don’t think so. Abhorrent behavior has always been abhorrent. The people using these tactics even often acknowledge it’s ugly behavior but feel vindicated (and even righteous). Some people are hypocrites. This is all just quite a bit easier and more visible than in the past. If anything has changed beyond scale and politics, it’s that people arguing against it are more easily heard.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by aksss on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:08PM (#30604648)
ha, beat me to it! :D
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by theshrike79 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:03PM (#30604531)
People change. Your "edgy" tweets and shitty jokes from when you were young and stupid can still haunt you in your adult life.

Case in point: James Gunn ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Gunn#Firing_from_Disney_... )

This is why I rarely interact on Twitter and I have a script that deletes all my tweets that are over X days old. If I say something truely insightful, I'll just make a blog post out of it.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tstrimple on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:16PM (#30606209)
> "Firing from Disney *and reinstatement*"

Yep, he's super cancelled. Great example.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by colordrops on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:12PM (#30604757)
Got attacked by dozens of people and eventually a twitter account ban for suggesting that free-speech is important and Chappelle's latest special shouldn't be removed from Netflix.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:50PM (#30605683)
If you got banned by Twitter, it was probably more than merely "suggesting" that free speech was important.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by colordrops on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:40PM (#30606538)
No, this is exactly what happened. My tweet suggested nearly verbatim what I said above, and in response I got verbally abused and insulted by literally dozens of people from the trans community. They scrubbed through my tweet history, replying to old tweets and reporting anything they could. They reported a very old tweet where I promoted pacifism (I'm a pacifist), but it was sarcastic, stating that if we are gonna punch Nazis, we might as well punch mujahideen, ISIS, pro-lifers, Zionists, etc. They took advantage of the fact that sarcasm can be read both ways, and I was banned for promoting violence. Nevertheless I was cancelled due to my comments on free speech.

Choose to believe it or not, that's your business, but this is exactly what happened.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:48PM (#30606689)
>Choose to believe it or not, that's your business, but this is exactly what happened.

(I do believe you. By comment was in response to your original one, which lacked a lot of the context you just provided.)

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by causi on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:08PM (#30604674)
The problem is that you can have a not-ok opinion and still be a good person who has a positive effect on the world, but we have no tolerance for that. We demand public perfection.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:14PM (#30604834)
Here is a good example:

"You just used 'OK' in your comment, only white supremacists use 'OK'."

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:49PM (#30605664)
I mean, it's an example...
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:49PM (#30606698)
I would ask you to think back to 2019 when a large majority on Twitter and from the mainstream media took a picture of some high school boys in Washington DC and brandied them about as the face of racism in America.

"He has a racist smirk"

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @04:04PM (#30606932)
Do you have a link to this? I Googled the quote at the end and just found this weirdo tweeting under the hashtag #RealNiggas4Romney.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:15PM (#30607972)
Here is a medium article that preserved a bunch of the tweets and a wiki article.

I remember(maybe mis-) some reddit comments at the time about the kid's smirk. There was also a buch of comments about "punchable face"

https://medium.com/@RevolutionaryId/twitter-democratizing-mo... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_2019_Lincoln_Memorial_...

>In the wake of the publication of the longer video, CNN Business reporter Donie O'Sullivan described the twitter video uploaded by "2020fight" as the one that "helped frame the news cycle" of the previous days, and characterized the video as a "deliberate attempt" to mislead and "manipulate the public conversation on Twitter"—a violation of Twitter rules.[76] According to Molly McKew, an information warfare researcher, the tweet had been boosted by a network of anonymous Twitter accounts to amplify the story.

To add to my point of 'OK': On January 22, shortly after tweeting it, comedian Kathy Griffin deleted a Twitter message in which she accused Covington basketball players making an OK gesture of "throwing up the new nazi sign".

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:33PM (#30608865)
Boy oh boy wowee.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by jstream67 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:20PM (#30608034)
https://nypost.com/2020/07/24/washington-post-settles-250m-s...

heres one link. search term is covington kid.

basically just another case of left aligned news stations casually labelling everyone they don't like as 'racist'

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by themaninthedark on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @06:07PM (#30608589)
I think it goes beyond that, sure the traditional media did not help things but this started on Twitter.

Someone edited down a video of what happened and shared it. It was boosted either by bots or by unsuspecting people but it set off what can only be described as a witch hunt. This is of course not the first time this has happened, we have had things like Donglegate(https://arstechnica.com/staff/2013/03/donglegate-is-classic-...) and Shirtgate(https://time.com/3589392/comet-shirt-storm/). But the events seem to be getting bigger in magnitude, i.e. drawing in international media(https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-46935701) and more numerous(sorry no stats, only my attention).

You can not run a society on mobs. I am not sure if it is Twitters design, the speed of information, the need to feel like part of the in group and/or a combination of all and more that is leading to the formation of mobs but it is not healthy.

I also think there is some cultural values at play as well, where the number of Twitter followers, being an influencer, or just being self centered is seen as a positive thing.

Part of me thinks that it might be related to the gamification of everything, if I post more more(of the right thing) I get more likes, followers, retweets by celebrity. Rather than if I post clear concise or well thought out things. Quality over quantity as it were.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by Manuel_D on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:16PM (#30607978)
There was massive coverage over this incident: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_2019_Lincoln_Memorial_...
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by bena on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:39PM (#30605443)
While I don't think most of the people engaging with you are doing so completely in good faith, I don't think you understand the "fickleness" of the tweeting masses either.

Just like you're getting downvotes and a lot of blowback for your opinion on this matter here, it's way worse on twitter.

I've heard someone say that twitter is a game where the goal is not to be the main character of the day. And that kind of holds. Twitter is a bit geared for outrage. Small snippets with no context. Say you don't like The Batman and you could find yourself under a barrage of hate and vitriol. It's not a left thing or a right thing, they both have their mobs on twitter, in addition to all the other random mobs floating about. Hell, say something shitty about the wrong product will have that mob after you.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:51PM (#30605719)
are people using cancel to refer to the pile on mobs or what they consider unfair escalation in consequences? i mentioned in another post, im on the receiving end on a pile on I think, but i wouldn't say i'm being canceled.

if you say internet communities have an issue with pile on mobs and harassment, id agree but i think that's different then canceling, which i don't think happens to the average person or they even need to worry about

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by bena on Wednesday March 09, 2022 @09:03AM (#30614473)
"Cancel" is a nebulous term, it means almost whatever the person using it wants to mean.

Is banning cancelling? What about HN's rate limiting? Being harrassed off of a platform?

All these things have been called "cancelling" by someone. And fair play by others. I think, in this context, we do have to consider the mobs as a part of "cancelling" because this is a thread about an article about people who don't engage in social media. Partly due to the fear of the amount of negative engagement.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by nickstinemates on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:04PM (#30604562)
Who's the arbiter of an OK opinion?
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:13PM (#30604787)
I used to think this way. Saw too many legitimately-good people get brigaded to believe it anymore.

There's enough pile-on mobs on Twitter now with enough disagreement on what's acceptable that you can trip over any of them.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by tayo42 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:24PM (#30605057)
I wouldn't consider canceling and pile on mobs to be the same thing. I'm getting piled on here, I wouldn't say I'm getting canceled lol
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by AussieWog93 on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:10PM (#30606109)
>It's really easy to not be "canceled", just be a good person.

I think you've really highlighted here why there's so much backlash against the latest wave of political correctness.

To many people, myself included, a "good person" is someone who can be counted on to help a friend in need, goes out of their way to make the day of the people they interact with that little bit more special (this is something I need to work on), and works hard to provide for their family in whatever way they can.

In my experience at least, a lot of the people who say the right words and hold the right opinions will flake on a friend in their hour of need, or avoid speaking with certain kinds of people lest they say the wrong thing. On the contrary, I can name several people who have dark senses of humour or right-wing beliefs, but will always go above and beyond to help out their community and the people they care about (yes, LGBT people and ethnic minorities too!).

I'm not saying that PC people are worse than non-PC people (if anything, it's probably uncorrelated), but the fact that you've binned people into "good" and "bad" based on how PC their opinions are is just, at least in my opinion, completely out of step with the view of general society.

Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by namelessoracle on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:25PM (#30605076)
A good person does not use Twitter. If you use Twitter therefore you are a bad person and deserve to be cancelled.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by recursive on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:11PM (#30604737)
What's "good"? I think it's at least OK to suggest that covid vaccines are generally good, and most people who are eligible should get them. But it's a social media shit-storm. I'm not interested.
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by aksss on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @02:07PM (#30604635)
just believe in our gods and you won't get burned at the stake, how hard is that, people? I mean really? /s
Re:The new silent majority: People who don't tweet by candlemas on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @03:06PM (#30606045)
Good people are boring.