News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by fbn79 on Saturday March 05, 2022 @09:03AM (#30567684)
You could create a QR based on the last block of BITCOIN blockchain. These way you do not rely on a private key and onyone can check and trust it.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by can16358p on Saturday March 05, 2022 @09:35AM (#30567923)
Remimds me of Vitalik Buterin holding a paper with a new block's hash and posting his photo when there were rumors about him being dead a few years ago.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by thamer on Saturday March 05, 2022 @05:46PM (#30572738)
I hadn't heard of this, this is a pretty cool way to provide this proof.

Back story: https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2017/06/26/proof-of-life-vi...

The block in question (open "Click to see more" and look for the "Hash" field): https://etherscan.io/block/3930000

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by avnigo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @09:54AM (#30568060)
That reminds me something like the OpenTimestamps project:

https://opentimestamps.org/

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by amelius on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:35AM (#30568923)
Have these stamps already been tested in a court of law?
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by rosndo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:53AM (#30569148)
This question doesn’t make any sense, there’s nothing to “test”.

An irrefutable cryptographic timestamp is just that, irrefutable.

Sometimes courts make mistakes, but you can’t expect any useful precedent over something like this.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by ohyeshedid on Saturday March 05, 2022 @03:37PM (#30571621)
> An irrefutable cryptographic timestamp is just that, irrefutable.

In math, sure, but he specifically asked about a court of law. Irrefutable in math doesn't mean admissible in court. Then there's the 1, 6, 12, or however many random people that decide the case; they likely need the math explained to them, and two sides get turns convincing them the other is wrong.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by rosndo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @04:29PM (#30572097)
So uh, it’s like literally everything else in court? What’s the point here? This feels like such a strange line of thinking.

> Irrefutable in math doesn't mean admissible in court

What is that even supposed to mean? Why would (relevant) math not be admissible in court? Do you even know what these words mean?

If cryptographic timestamps are relevant and not against the rules of evidence, obviously they are admissible.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by emmelaich on Saturday March 05, 2022 @09:24PM (#30574421)
There was a case in Australia 10 or so years back, where MD5 sums were added to police speed camera photos. This was before MD5 vulnerabilities were well known.

The defence successfully argued that MD5 was not totally reliable -- even though the chance of it being faked was absolutely tiny.

The real irony was that without the MD5, the photos would probably have been accepted just on the police assertion of chain of custody.

(I've been looking for this news story but unfortunately I can't find it at the moment)

[edit- found it] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2005/08/the_md5_defen...

In fact the MD5 was known to be vulnerable - maybe. But it's still the case that adding MD5 made it less trustworthy!

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by miunau on Saturday March 05, 2022 @10:03PM (#30574634)
Thanks for the link- exactly the sort of thing that I was looking for in feedback. I'm aware it's conjecture, but do you think this sort of precedence would be useful in airing doubts about the trustworthiness of an Ed25519 signature in court? Do you think the wording on the site is problematic in regards to this, or would you have any thoughts on how concerns about this would be best communicated?
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by amelius on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:57AM (#30569200)
Most of cryptography can in theory always be brute-forced or simply guessed. There is no absolute guarantee, though you can get very very close. And there are other ways around it, such as keys getting leaked.

Also, because of lack of expertise courts may simply not want to deal with this kind of proof and thus not acknowledge it.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by rosndo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:03PM (#30569289)
> Also, because of lack of expertise courts may simply not want to deal with this kind of proof and thus not acknowledge it.

Courts lack expertise on almost every subject, I don’t think this logic can actually hold up.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by amelius on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:09PM (#30569347)
Perhaps, but the other points I brought up might.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by rosndo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @01:16PM (#30570181)
No, not really. Opentimestamps addresses all of them.

Opentimestamps cannot be bruteforced, and there are no keys that could leak.

Bruteforcing would require for you to permanently take over the entire bitcoin network.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by miunau on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:34PM (#30569679)
I believe at that point it's up to the lawyers to argue. It's up to persons with people skills to convince other people that something is not fake, using tools like these as assistance, not as clinchers.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by slaymaker1907 on Saturday March 05, 2022 @06:35PM (#30573131)
You could probably make it work, but it would likely involve some expensive expert witnesses.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by jeroenhd on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:07PM (#30569331)
But what would that solve? The blocks on the blockchain are public, so anyone can fake a timestamp by grabbing an old block and generating a QR code.

The point of this website is that the server signs the timestamp. It's more than just a QR code with a time and date, it has some actual verification code.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday March 05, 2022 @02:33PM (#30571060)
You can always "hold up an old newspaper". Nothing prevents you from storing and reusing an old signature.

It always only proves that it wasn't taken before a certain date.

You can then also prove "not after" by timestamping the picture (having it signed by a RFC3161 timestamping authority or putting a hash on the blockchain).

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by IanCal on Saturday March 05, 2022 @02:05PM (#30570768)
The server verifying just adds a security hole - the makers of this site can fake a qr code for any time & date.

Using info from the the block is safer as you don't need to trust the host of the system.

The point (like showing a newspaper) is to prove the image / video was taken no earlier than that time.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by neilv on Saturday March 05, 2022 @04:10PM (#30571898)
Good point. And the people who decide what the newspaper front page will display for a given day are constrained to some degree by newsworthy events on that day.

That thought does does cast an additional possible funny interpretation on a photo I took of the adjacent street newspaper vending boxes of the two major Boston papers one day. The Boston Globe main headline was of a serious major news event. The Boston Globe above the fold was mostly filled with a photo of some political or sports figure, and a lowbrow muckraking headline about them. A funny (highly implausible) theory is that the Herald editor/publisher had needed to determine the front page for a paper issue, days or more into the future, such as for faking proof-of-life on/after a date, and then had to run that front page. :)

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by innocenat on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:20PM (#30569501)
And you can take screenshot today and use it tomorrow, too.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by oauea on Saturday March 05, 2022 @01:24PM (#30570279)
> But what would that solve?

Nothing, which is amusing irony.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by itake on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:19PM (#30569486)
you wouldn't need to use their website and the service would be completely decentralized.

the website has the exact same problem that you pointed out for the blockchain: you can screen capture a QR code and re-use it later.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by ricardobeat on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:27PM (#30569582)
No, you can’t. It’s one of the main features, explained right there in the page.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by itake on Saturday March 05, 2022 @01:35PM (#30570444)
> It does not work against the past (taking snapshots of the code and using them later)

Right on the page, it says this.

Maybe I am not understanding your point. Both the website and the blockchain strategy make it impossible for you to record video content and claim it happened in the future, but neither of them defend against recording after the timestamp happened.

The blockchain strategy does not require a centralized service, while the QR code requires the website to be up forever.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by miunau on Saturday March 05, 2022 @01:42PM (#30570527)
You can always use the published public key to verify the signature.

There's also a way to generate the codes offline using a certificate chain and a fingerprint (https://github.com/qrdate/qrdate#static-qr-date-v1-spec) which does not require a website, just a key store. It needs more specifying to be viable for real world use but it should be possible. Help is very welcome.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by itake on Sunday March 06, 2022 @03:40PM (#30581051)
If you print out a piece of paper with the latest block, hold up the NYT's, or use your service, you still only prove that the content was created after a certain date.

AFAIK, signing off a timestamp and offering a public key to prove the timestamp was signed then doesn't seem to add value other than unnecessary complexity. I guess if there is a specific time you're trying to prove the event happened after, this system would offer higher fidelity than others, but not all.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by miunau on Saturday March 05, 2022 @10:03AM (#30568132)
This is certainly a possible implementation and good if you would want to base it on the chain, doable via a minimal node. It would not work offline though, which would make it harder to use in frontline reporting, so I think the spec itself should not specify such a requirement.
Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by 3np on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:07AM (#30568646)
Qrdate involves server-side signing and does not work offline either?

If the signature involves a hash of a bitcoin block we don't have to trust the site owner to not sign future timestamps.

Re:QR Date – signed timestamps inside for verifying dates by miunau on Saturday March 05, 2022 @11:54AM (#30569157)
There's two proposed ways specified. The web way (called "Dynamic") and a fingerprint-based implementation that can work offline ("Static"), for example in approved apps for some organisations: https://github.com/qrdate/qrdate#static-qr-date-v1-spec

It is still a concept as there's no implementation of it besides the tests in the repo, so it would require further refining for production apps. For example with specifying key exchange formats, which we are looking at right now. Anyone with expertise in this field wanting to contribute is welcome!