Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by basisword on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:45PM
(#30546724)
Surprised but not surprised to see people using the standard free speech/censorship arguments in this thread. Surely people can differentiate between standard speech and state sponsored propaganda??? More speech is often the solution to “bad” speech - but I think it would be quite obvious this doesn’t apply to propaganda.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by JakeAl on Thursday March 03, 2022 @05:40PM
(#30548020)
Many non-state actors produce content for RT, including academics and celebrities, and almost all MSM outlets here in the US produce content sponsored/paid for by the US government. It's only propaganda when it's crafted by The State, otherwise it's just the marketing of ideas. The issue at hand is who is filtering/controlling what ideas people are allowed to have access to.
I recommend everyone read Neil Postman's "Amusing Ourselves to Death," and "How to Watch TV News."
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by Barrin92 on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:29PM
(#30546517)
Two straightforward things. It stops Russian propaganda from being broadcast, secondly it destroys their revenue. I think you need to be masochistic to have an enemy broadcast lies to your country and make money in the process.
RT is such a blatant tool of the Russian state it should have been shut down five years ago.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by flipbrad on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:39PM
(#30546636)
Your first "thing" is begging the question. What is that blatant propaganda (your words) really going to achieve at this point ?
One of the West's key marks of distinction has always been freedom of the press. By allowing our governments to decide what's a lie / propaganda that's not allowed to be published, I feel we set ourselves well on the path to becoming exactly what we're criticising here.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by long_time_gone on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:07PM
(#30547000)
> By allowing our governments to decide what's a lie / propaganda that's not allowed to be published
The headline "RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies block the network" tells us that private companies blocked the network, not the government.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by Barrin92 on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:04PM
(#30546968)
Freedom of the press like any other freedom has limits and only makes sense if the entity in question actually has any interest in doing free and genuine journalistic work rather than being a glorified arm of a foreign government.
We also value freedom of movement, or commerce or the right to bear arms, doesn't mean we let foreign spies sell weapons to domestic insurgents or let them roam across the border. Democratic freedoms are a contract with a democratic population, or democratic partners, not autocratic adversaries who will use them to undermine the very foundation they're built on.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by labrador on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:44PM
(#30546709)
Peter Thiel was born and spent the first 12 years of his life in Germany. A lot of people worry about Thiel's intentions, but none more so than Germans
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by pastor_bob on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:23PM
(#30546437)
I really don't understand the defense against censorship of state controlled propaganda news from people like Glenn Greenwald. That idea that it operates in the normal realm of media is extremely questionable. This is not a slippery slope but clearly delineated line imo.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by dukeofdoom on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:38PM
(#30546625)
Knowing the other sides best arguments is a benefit. Censorship is stupid. The pro government media would have love your oppressor. This is so bad in Canada where all the TV stations just parrot the current liberal government's narratives. If it wasn't for US coverage, most Canadians would even know about protesters getting trampled by horses or that trucker that had his ribs broken from repeated police kicks to the chest while he was down. A guy who literally escaped from a communist Romania.
They're talking about banning Fox news here. Because they had some pro protestor coverage.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by I-M-S on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:08PM
(#30547018)
Thank you. The Globe and Mail did mention the trampling incident and Ottawa Citizen is definitely not an US source. I only know of Adam Vaughn from his stances on housing which have discredited him in my eyes.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by archagon on Thursday March 03, 2022 @02:59PM
(#30546010)
If you needed another reminder that Thiel delights in and financially backs despotic authoritarianism, here it is. His vision for our country's future is Russia today.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by atlantas on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:27PM
(#30546483)
How is backing a permissive free speech focused video hosting site authoritarianism? Authoritarians lock down and control speech. You have it completely backwards.
Putin, for example, does not support anything remotely like Rumble. It's the opposite of what he supports.
Re:RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies...
by etangent on Thursday March 03, 2022 @07:36PM
(#30549023)
Well, neither am I, considering that the Western governments have been using the term "democracy" to launder a specific flavor of apparatchik authoritarianism.
I recommend everyone read Neil Postman's "Amusing Ourselves to Death," and "How to Watch TV News."
Centralized : Dailymotion, Bitchute, Rumble, DTube, Vimeo, Vidlii, DLive, Triller
Decentralized : Odysee(LBRY), Peertube
RT is such a blatant tool of the Russian state it should have been shut down five years ago.
The headline "RT turns to Peter Thiel's Rumble after Big Tech companies block the network" tells us that private companies blocked the network, not the government.
We also value freedom of movement, or commerce or the right to bear arms, doesn't mean we let foreign spies sell weapons to domestic insurgents or let them roam across the border. Democratic freedoms are a contract with a democratic population, or democratic partners, not autocratic adversaries who will use them to undermine the very foundation they're built on.
Also Peter Thiel doesn’t manage or control Rumble but is an investor.
An investor is just another word for owner. He owns part of Rumble. He has more say than any employee in the company ( including the CEO ).
Who is Peter Thiel? | ZDF Magazin Royale https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SKY5pOcEn4U
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50mAT12ZpJM
Police kicking
https://rumble.com/vvmpxi-ottawa-police-arrest-and-violently...
No charges for OPS officer after takedown that broke man's ribs
https://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/no-charges-for-ops...
Former Liberal MP wants to ban Fox News in Canada
https://tnc.news/2022/03/02/former-liberal-mp-wants-to-ban-f...
Putin, for example, does not support anything remotely like Rumble. It's the opposite of what he supports.
While I agree, I have to say it takes some skill to end such a dark and realistic assessment with a pun!