News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:17PM (#30531550)
And yet so many modern day startups have no viable exit strategy beyond acquisition- what does that say about the state of the industry, and of founders' commitments towards building a sustainable product?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:26PM (#30531680)
> And yet so many modern day startups have no viable exit strategy beyond acquisition

Bandcamp was already profitable and has been for years. The pandemic dramatically increased their sales. They were doing fine.

Why did they need an exit?

That is the real flaw of SV thinking: that simply being a profitable, going concern is somehow inadequate. The result is monopoly accretion as small companies are repeatedly swallowed up by bigger ones.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by chris11 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:22PM (#30532534)
Did bandcamp raise a lot of money from venture capital? The last round listed on crunchbase was a series A in 2010. It looks like management were fine running it more like a lifestyle business.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:37PM (#30532741)
Yeah, as far as I can tell, they took a seed round and a series A and have been profitable since... 2014? If memory serves?

If you look at their staff growth, it's been very slow and very steady. At the time of acquisition they were sitting in the 100-150 headcount range, which is modest for a company that's almost 15 years old. Given their claim of 207M to artists last year and their touted 18% average rev share, we can guess they were generating around 50M per year gross, which is a very healthy cashflow for a company that size.

Their strategy was clearly not to take over the world, but to carve out a niche and not bother to directly compete with the streaming platforms (which helps to explain, for instance, the incredibly rudimentary mobile player app).

As for the senior management, Diamond had already previously started and sold a company. I'm sure he was doing fine. The same is true of Mark Hall, their VP of Product (who started 5-ish years ago, if I recall). The technical founders I'm less sure about, though apparently at least one of them had already moved on.

I'd absolutely describe it as a sustainable lifestyle business that had a good long-term trajectory. It was never going to be a unicorn, but who cares?

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by munificent on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:01PM (#30533813)
> a sustainable lifestyle business

A company with 100 employee isn't a lifestyle business. The term we used to use for that before VC swallowed the world and decided that anything less than a billion is chump change was simply "business". A 100-person company with millions in revenue is a successful medium-sized business.

The only reason it doesn't feel successful and stable today is because we live in a unprotected corporate environment where any of the giant behemoths may anti-competitively crush a smaller business if they so choose to and there won't be any repercussions.

I wouldn't be surprised if the main motivation for Bandcamp selling was simply the fear of being either bought out by someone worse, or crushed by them. (Likely Spotify, which is two orders of magnitude larger than them.)

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:43PM (#30534389)
Yup, excellent points all around. Well put!
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by toastal on Thursday March 03, 2022 @12:53AM (#30537657)
I love the 'rudimentary' app. It was only recently I noticed a lot of people complaining about it. It was a surprise to me. I can search and find new albums, and I can listen to album from start to finish without any issues, share a track link to a friend, and purchase + download the album for offline. Only feature I would have liked to see is the niche addition of built-in ListenBrainz support. What else was missing?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Thursday March 03, 2022 @12:04PM (#30543586)
For me the big one is playlists. I'm absolutely an album listener (call me old school), but I like to build thematic playlists of multiple albums that I listen to in rotation (for example, I have a background electronica playlist I love to use when I'm working), and the player lacks that capability.

Notably, Bandcamp absolutely encourages purchasing individual tracks, so for folks who, unlike me, tend to build mixed playlists, it's even more annoying that this feature doesn't exist.

In fact, they only very recently (as in last month!) added basic queuing support:

https://blog.bandcamp.com/2022/02/10/the-bandcamp-app-now-su...

Which is pretty incredible as I view that as a core feature of any music player.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ehnto on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:58PM (#30535716)
> more like a lifestyle business. reply

Bandcamp is 100% a bonafide operating business. I don't want to put words in your mouth, but perhaps you're seeing that they were just trying to run "Business as usual" and equating that to a lifestyle business as they weren't chasing growth.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by wly_cdgr on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @10:27PM (#30536787)
I think the most likely explanation is that the founders just got bored with the project as they got older and aged out of their own primary target demographic. You have kids, you start getting regular colonoscopies...all the trials and tribulations of teen and twentysomething indie musicians start feeling less urgent and relevant.

That, and/or they were not interested in running a company that is finally getting too large to feel like a family / tight-knit community. The kind of person who likes running a 20 person outfit is very plausibly someone who gets no joy out of running a 200 person one or even actively hates the idea.

So they sold to someone they liked well enough, or in any case someone they distrust less than others to have the expertise and values to scale the business in a way that doesn't COMPLETELY destroy what made it special

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ballenf on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:34PM (#30532714)
I think it's more so the result of cheap money than some way of thinking. Higher interest rates will curtail a lot of this activity. Might even see a wave of divestitures or spinoffs as companies have to look harder for sources of capital.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:54PM (#30532984)
The need to "exit" and the obsession with "growth" that occupies the minds of SV founders significantly pre-dates the low rate environment that's dominated since 2008. The only difference is the path: IPO vs acquisition.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by airstrike on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:15PM (#30533274)
> Why did they need an exit?

Because the people who like to start new companies and take lots of risks generally tend to not like running stable businesses and dealing with FP&A managers, lawyers, compliance and tax experts

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:34PM (#30533502)
> Because the people who like to start new companies and take lots of risks generally tend to not like running stable businesses and dealing with FP&A managers, lawyers, compliance and tax experts

... in SV/the tech industry.

That's kinda my entire point.

Stealing someone else's analogy: If you went to a bank to get a small business loan to open up a coffee shop, and you told them "Yeah, I'm hoping to take a bunch of your money, open a coffee shop, never return a profit, and then sell it to Starbucks", you'd get laughed out of the room.

In SV that's a business model.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by charcircuit on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:43PM (#30533605)
You won't get much money selling a small coffee shop which is why it won't work. There is a small upper bound to what you can possibly be worth.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Talanes on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:30PM (#30535492)
The more accurate to life version of that sale is "I'm going to open a small regional coffee chain and then sell it to JAB Holding Company"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JAB_Holding_Company

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by airstrike on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @06:19PM (#30534845)
Coffee shops don't grow at the speed software does because they are limited by the physical world.

There aren't many "startup industrial companies"

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Invictus0 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:46PM (#30531961)
SV is not a homogeneous thought-entity. Maybe the founders were tired of running it or wanted to move on to do something else. Businesses get bought and sold all the time and don't need to be a lifetime commitment for the founder (it would still get sold or shutdown at that point anyway).
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by pketh on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:18PM (#30532491)
You make a good point, but I wonder what the real world business equivalent of this is? Is it the destiny of every successful café to become acquired by Starbucks one day? (assuming there's not a better comparison I should be thinking of)
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ribosometronome on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:24PM (#30532576)
Successful restaurants, bars, etc do change owners from time to time as owners retire or simply want a change of pace. I imagine the difference is the amount of money involved. It's possible for an individual to save up several hundred thousand to a million to buy an existing, profitable small business. Less so the hundreds of millions to billion+ a business like this might go for.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by bigiain on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:10PM (#30533917)
Around me in Sydney, there is a major “hospitality group” that’s spent the last 10+ years buying up bars and pubs.

There’s a few smaller operations doing it as well.

The big one, Merivale, seems to have practically unlimited money to throw at interesting or struggling venues. While I really don’t like the changes they eventually make to most places they buy, I have a grudging respect for the business acumen of Justin Hemmes the owner.

He seems to have an uncanny knack for having bought a good sized venue a year or two before, in every area that becomes cool and popular. Often they’ll barely change for a few years, while the demographics around them shift, then one day they’ve suddenly been renovated and there’s a queue of b-grade celebrities all dressed up and lined up around the block waiting to get in every weekend for a month or two.

I totally get that my demographic spends less over the bar than the crowd he’s so good at attracting, but he’s ruined two of my local ex-favourite pubs in the last few years, and over decades he’s turned some of my favourite music venues in things like trashy Mexican restaurant/bars.

But yeah, even as successful as he is in his field, I doubt it’ll get him into the three comma club.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by heleninboodler on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:16PM (#30536311)
The goal of every venture-backed tech startup is to reach an exit. That's the whole explanation of "why." You can go back in time and ask them "why did you have to take VC money" in 2008 and that might be an interesting question. But once they did, there's no surprise whatsoever that they went for the exit today.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Talanes on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:33PM (#30535520)
>Is it the destiny of every successful café to become acquired by Starbucks one day?

Almost, but it's these guys:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JAB_Holding_Company

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by antihero on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:34PM (#30531789)
Why do things need an exit strategy, why can they not simply exist and do good work and pay people fairly? Does everything have to exist purely to maximise profit?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:03PM (#30532242)
>Does everything have to exist purely to maximise profit?

No, everyone is free to start a bandcamp alternative that does not sell out. But the probability of people wanting to "cash out" or trade equity for other things they want is pretty high. And so that is the world that we see, because it is a reflection of what people want.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Swenrekcah on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:48PM (#30532895)
Sure, but what people want as individuals and makes sense for them to individually do can nevertheless be harmful to society. That is what people are complaining about generally.

I don’t know how to combat the shift to a single monopoly/duopoly in every market though, but it’s definitely going to make our lives worse. Especially with the erosion of private ownership for us plebeians.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by heleninboodler on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:46PM (#30531958)
The employees who traded compensation for equity probably don't agree. Bandcamp's success is built partially on this trade and at some point it needs to pay off for them. I suppose they could stay private forever and give out profit-sharing bonuses, but I think people go into this expecting an exit.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:57PM (#30532146)
Did Bandcamp offer employee equity?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hamburglar on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:33PM (#30535527)
Yes, they did.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by heleninboodler on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:41PM (#30532801)
Would they have ever managed to hire anyone if they didn't?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:05PM (#30533141)
Some people just want to work at a decent company for reasonable pay, and aren't looking to get filthy rich busting their asses for a FAANG.

Bandcamp is absolutely a company I would've considered working for. I'm long past the point in my career where I care about a lottery ticket. They were profitable, big enough to be sustainable, but small enough to be nimble. The management seemed to make all the right noises regarding their values and motivations.

I'll take that over a massive tech company or a tiny startup any day of the week.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by heleninboodler on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:15AM (#30538889)
I didn't think it needed clarification, but "they wouldn't be able to hire anyone" does not literally mean they would have zero candidates. It's expressing the fact that they would be severely limiting their talent pool by offering 0 equity in this industry, where equity is one of the reasons people are willing to take a risk on a startup.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Thursday March 03, 2022 @11:01AM (#30542676)
> where equity is one of the reasons people are willing to take a risk on a startup.

They're not a startup. They're a profitable, mature, 15 year old company of 100-150 people. Working there isn't "taking a risk", so there's no need to entice people with hazard pay.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hamburglar on Thursday March 03, 2022 @01:04PM (#30544399)
And yet those early employees who joined before they were profitable took a risk, and likely below-market rates, and got equity. Because that’s one proven strategy a startup can use to try to find people who can get them to not-a-startup.

I never thought I’d see the day where hacker news, of all places, forgot how this works.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by BaseballPhysics on Thursday March 03, 2022 @02:28PM (#30545549)
> And yet those early employees who joined before they were profitable took a risk, and likely below-market rates, and got equity. Because that’s one proven strategy a startup can use to try to find people who can get them to not-a-startup.

I was interpreting the original comment that kicked this off ("Would they have ever managed to hire anyone if they didn't?") as referring to their hiring practices now, not 15 years ago when they were first starting up. Granted I may have misinterpreted the nature of their remark.

Obviously back then, yeah, folks would probably have been given an equity stake.

So we're arguing different points.

What I personally don't know is if they were continuing to give out options to new hires to this day. Based on my own experience in a startup-now-going-concern, my bet is "no", given that it would no longer be strictly necessary to entice folks to join the company, but I could be wrong.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hamburglar on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:33PM (#30546568)
I definitely interpreted it the other way, owing to the "would they have ever" part. The original subthread is about their motivation for an exit. The existence of early key employees that got (potentially a lot of) equity is quite relevant to that topic, and the sentiment that it would have been harder to hire people in this industry without offering equity at a startup is not wrong.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Thursday March 03, 2022 @02:34PM (#30545627)
Your critique appears to assume that every tech company or startup begins by offering below market rates. That's not universal, and who knows, maybe they had a seed round and were able to pay people appropriately. They were also founded in 2008, it was a different time in the market anyway.

Looking at Crunchbase's list of articles, the earliest news story from May '08 mentions that it was a four-man startup that was completely virtual. Don't know how that lasted, but not having an office certainly frees up the budget to pay people.

https://gigaom.com/2008/05/07/bandcamp-clubwiki/

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hamburglar on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:38PM (#30546623)
My critique assumes no such thing, it just claims it's likely. That's why I used the word "likely."

I certainly hope it's not controversial to suggest that VC-backed startups, especially thrifty ones like bandcamp allegedly is, very commonly offer lower salaries to extend runway and make up for it in the form of equity options. My last startup offer actually gave me a window of salary ranges and let me choose my salary based on how much equity I wanted. The more salary, the less equity.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:43PM (#30532832)
Who's to say they didn't? As mentioned elsewhere (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30532741), they were always focused on slow and steady growth and seemed to be more lifestyle business than wannabe unicorn. Not the shop to join if you wanted lottery ticket options. Maybe they didn't.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by munificent on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:02PM (#30533831)
Because in our current corporate environment where there is essentially no anti-trust enforcement, any small or medium-sized company is vulnerable to being destroyed by one of the giants.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by feoren on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:54PM (#30532087)
The very term "exit strategy" answers your own question: if you're committed to building a sustainable product, with long-term sustainable profits, caring for your employees and your customers, without any explicit plans to sell off your company to random megacorp, where it will be scrapped for parts, then you're a dumb loser trying to build a lifestyle business and you deserve to be shamed out of Silicon Valley! How dare you waste our precious venture capitalist time with that crap!?

I get it: venture capitalists are interested in the most efficient possible way to loot the economy, and funding non-viable startups until they're so overhyped that some other idiot buys the over-inflated toxic asset from them before it blows is a great way to do that.

Of course speaking out against VC and startup culture on Hacker News is going to get me downvoted to oblivion, so go ahead and mash that down arrow. Don't forget to dislike and unsubscribe!

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:16PM (#30532441)
HN is a lot more jaded towards startups and founders’ games these days. Back in late 2019 there was this thread about a Garry Tan video where the tone of the discussion was fiercely against working for startups, saying it was better to join FAANG or start your own company instead:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21865065

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by cgrealy on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:11PM (#30532351)
I completely agree, but this isn't just a VC problem. The entire current economic system incentivises this.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hedora on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:41PM (#30532805)
Yeah. They also could have IPOed, but either way the fundamental issue is that people looking for long term investments are willing to pay 10x forward earnings. How do you compete with that without getting employees to make major personal sacrifices?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by andai on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:19PM (#30531581)
Doesn't exiting necessarily imply a change in leadership?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:21PM (#30531602)
IPOs are the alternative form of exit and they certainly don't.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by dundarious on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:31PM (#30531759)
Where does the drive for an "exit" come from? It's a jargon term not used in the entrepreneurial side of most other industries.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ska on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:08PM (#30532310)
> It's a jargon term not used in the entrepreneurial side of most other industries.

That's because in most of the industries you are thinking of, you can get traditional financing.

The need for an exit of some sort follows from the financial structure.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by dundarious on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:06PM (#30533866)
I don't think elsewhere it's called an "exit strategy" to seek financing, be that IPO, Shark Tank, or the much more common and mundane options. I'm not even naively proposing that it's somehow bad to sell a profitable business in this way. I know selling a piece of your business involves diluting your control, but it is nearly always contractually required to not involve an "exit" (in terms of involvement) outside of tech. (Selling it wholesale does in any industry)

I'm just confused by two interlinked things. The terminology of "exit" and the implicit need for an "exit".

To me, the focus on "exit" does imply moving away from involvement with the business (in how the phrase sounds, and most importantly, in how it seems to be most often used). Which to me signifies a culture built around starting businesses and ultimately around becoming a VC yourself. Doing this is not notable, but presuming it is.

So either "exit" is any kind of large financing, and it doesn't involve "exit" in terms of involvement, in which case the term "exit" is strange to me.

Or "exit" is selling control and does imply "exit" in terms of involvement, in which case it's interesting that this is presumed to be the goal of starting a profitable business.

It seems in practice to be just jargon that covers both, but more the latter.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ska on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:01PM (#30535273)
> I don't think elsewhere it's called an "exit strategy" to seek financing

I don't think that's how it is used in this context either.

A lot of early stage money in tech startups is there for the short(ish) term, and they definitely want to get their money out (i.e. "exit") at some point, not build a business over decades.

It's their usage of "exit", and the need to have a strategy for it, which drives the usage more broadly, I think. Agree it can be a bit confusing by confounding the above needs.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by dundarious on Thursday March 03, 2022 @09:24AM (#30541382)
Right, it's the focus on "exit" also for founders (who also run the business) that puzzles me.

As for the "exit=financing" association, I made that based on your comment:

> > It's a jargon term not used in the entrepreneurial side of most other industries.

> That's because in most of the industries you are thinking of, you can get traditional financing.

> The need for an exit of some sort follows from the financial structure.

But I think I misunderstood and you were saying something more like that the lack of traditional financing leads to a form of financing that necessitates selling the business wholesale.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ska on Thursday March 03, 2022 @01:02PM (#30544368)
> But I think I misunderstood

Yes I should have been clearer.

Re founders there is a tension: They often want to both maintain control (i.e. equity) and realize some $$ from building the company. A liquidity event of some sort is often seen as the best way to do this, especially if they've been lean on salary for a decade at that point, which is often the case.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by projectazorian on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:50PM (#30532025)
Many people are attracted to this industry by the stories of Google/FB/etc early employees walking away with 8 figure sums and retiring after a few years of work. Thus the exit obsession.