It is just wild to me that this is where society landed. Imagine you are a business owner. Wouldn't employees who are loyal and happy to come to work be the exact people you want to keep long term? These are people who know your industry, your business, your customers, and your product. They are your institutional knowledge. They are drastically more valuable than a new hire who has to spend years learning this all. But instead of rewarding that loyalty, we use it to squeeze out an extra few dollars of profit regardless of the consequences. It is bizarre.
I think it is simply short term profit maximalization. Why give an employee a dollar more than you have to give them? Whether giving them an extra dollar now might generate an extra two dollars down the road is rarely even considered.
You do, but you can achieve this by one of 2 ways: frequently adjusting salaries to match market rates, or rely on momentum, and hide information from them by strongly discouraging salary discussions among employees[1]. The latter approach results in more profits.
1. but sharing this information with fellow employers behind paywalls, like the work number.
My colleague was an immigrant who had moved up the ranks from a call center agent to a senior technical role.
I found out when fixing a technical problem that she made $25k, while I made $65k. Basically, they gave her a 25% raise from a call center supervisor to be a Unix SA, and in lieu of raises “gave” her comp time for 24x7 on-call.
> Recent decades have witnessed a growing focus on two distinct income patterns: persistent pay inequity, particularly a gender pay gap, and growing pay inequality. Pay transparency is widely advanced as a remedy for both. Yet we know little about the systemic influence of this policy on the evolution of pay practices within organizations. To address this void, we assemble a dataset combining detailed performance, demographic and salary data for approximately 100,000 US academics between 1997 and 2017. We then exploit staggered shocks to wage transparency to explore how this change reshapes pay practices. We find evidence that pay transparency causes significant increases in both the equity and equality of pay, and significant and sizeable reductions in the link between pay and individually measured performance.
If this is true, why aren't large employers already publishing salary data? i.e. why do they have to be forced to do it by law?
I spent most of my career as a public employee, most years salary are searchable on the internet. It’s nice because it eliminates a lot of drama about salary, who has what formal title, etc.
When I was in sales, the smart salespeople were following their peer/competitors performance. The notion that “professionals” are above such things as compensation is just stupid.
Understanding job markets requires leg work and is definitely part of the competitive advantage of many businesses.
Also with all the talk of racism and sexism in the work place , especially by the Big Tech companies, they should have done this long ago.
Well they would have if they had truly cared about minorities versus creating a bigger labor pool to drop pay rates or create faux PR for their companies and industries.
Data could be sorted by years of experience, education levels, race, gender and so on.
Still is incorrect though, b/c those sites are biased against older consistent data vs new data.
Example: Look at averages for FAANG engineers that are poached from other companies, vs ones with years at that company. If you just looked at the average then it wouldn't work since you're a new applicant you should probably ask for 20-30% more than if you currently worked there.
Also saying Google/Levels is good enough puts aside the problem of what market rate is for smaller companies. How much should a well funded web3 company pay you? What about companies outside of tech where salary sharing is less common?
All of the info available to the candidate on Google also pales in comparison to the asymmetry of one person versus an entire department of people who make these deals for a living, and have actual research on what's going on with the market instead of randomly reported crowdsourced data.
We used to call dealing with these kinds of situations "being an adult."
If you were forced to trade stocks for a living but had only second-hand access to price information ("My cousin bought some TSLA at $200/share last year") while all the brokerages share order flows in real time, would you say you're getting hosed? Or that it's a fair market?
Since you're not, the rest doesn't follow.
For example, I played poker when I was younger. I routinely did much worse than mathematically expected. I suspect I was being cheated by the other players, but I wasn't savvy enough to know how they were cheating me. My solution was to stop playing poker.
I know that when I trade stocks, I'm getting chiseled. So I don't day trade. I buy and hold, and rarely make a trade. Hence, the chiseling doesn't amount to much.
It's an analogy. "Trading stocks" is an analogy for "negotiating salary". Nearly everyone has to negotiate salary.
> I wasn't savvy enough to know how they were cheating me. My solution was to stop playing poker.
So you're saying people's options are to a) be cheated on salary or b) not work in paid employment? I respect that you have an opinion, but it's not an opinion that I have any respect for.
> Hence, the chiseling doesn't amount to much
Because we have open price sharing today and it's not possible to cheat you too much. You're benefiting from this even though you don't day trade. If we didn't have that, you and every other buy-and-holder would be shafted severely.
Sidenote: I notice in many of your posts that you're a big proponent of free markets (which I mostly agree with). How do you square that belief with this one where one party, by design, has far less market information than the other? I'm genuinely curious about this, because it seems contradictory.
(And yes, you might say "Companies choosing to share/not share salary is actually them competing on a free market", but that's an awfully limited viewpoint when we have other markets where prices are required to be open - such as real estate, and securities - without there being any suggestion that they aren't free markets)
Negotiating is not "forced". Forced is the word you used. It is inapplicable and so your analogy simply doesn't follow.
> So you're saying
No, I'm not. I was pretty clear on what I said. You don't need to invent positions.
> every other buy-and-holder would be shafted severely.
Then the market wouldn't exist, and the market makers would either have to be more transparent about the price or find another business to be in.
> How do you square that belief with this one where one party, by design, has far less market information than the other?
People often have the notion that a functioning free market requires perfect information. I don't know where this notion comes from. But it is clearly false. One never has perfect information. In the marketplace, this lack of information is called "risk". The amount of risk is always factored into the price.
That's why, for example, you'll pay more for a car from a dealer than from a private party. You're paying more for less of a risk. If you're investing, you expect higher returns for riskier investments, and lower returns for "safer" investments.
Me (and you) will negotiate for a higher salary for a riskier job, and would accept a lower salary for a more reliable job. A company will offer a lower salary for a riskier employee.
Again, lack of information is called "risk" and is part of the price of everything you buy and sell.
Other than starting their own business (which most people don't or can't do), how else do you propose people earn livelihoods?
> People often have the notion that a functioning free market requires perfect information
I didn't say "perfect information". Institutional investors have access to snap quotes accurate to a few milliseconds. Retail investors get delayed information. Information asymmetry is a spectrum. The stock market is on one end, and the job market is close to the other end (I can only think of healthcare pricing in the US that's worse than that).
Risk only matters when comparing two otherwise-similar employees. Otherwise supply and demand are the dominant factors in pricing. Hiring someone to make sandwiches is very low risk (you can easily verify that they make good sandwiches) compared to hiring a software developer (any interview process gives imperfect signal). And yet the sandwich artist gets paid less than the developer.
I ask you again: would you participate in a real estate market where you could only find out prices by asking friends and family, while the other side (let's say all institutional sellers) can share lots of information with each other? Would you invest in a stock market like that? Would it be good for you? Would you think it's fair? What if it was the only way to obtain housing (short of building your own house)?
It's really weird that you're against legislation requiring market participants to receive more information. Perfect information isn't possible, but why is more information bad?
Anyway, that's all I'll say on the topic.
If I am an adult agreeing to go to work in a sweatshop, why is the government stopping me? Because the government recognizes that I am only agreeing because the power imbalance my employer has over me is a form of coercion.
The only real difference is the million dollar ones give notice, and the min wage workers just stop showing up.
This is a statement totally disconnected from reality for most Americans. Over half of Americans live paycheck to paycheck. Over half of Americans get their medical insurance through their employer. These two facts mean that most Americans do not have the financial security to quit a job without having another one already lined up.
And they don't have access to accurate information on what value you can generate, either. It's a crapshoot for both parties.
Calling it a crapshoot on both sides is a pretty empty statement. When it comes specifically to compensation, the applicant is David and the company is Goliath.
For example, if you pay Bob $10 to go to the store and buy a lottery ticket for you, and you win the $1m jackpot, do you owe anything more to Bob than $10 worth of value he provided? Let's say the ticket was a dud. Do you therefore owe Bob less than the $10 you promised him?
There are multiple definitions of the word value. The value of something in a free market is what someone is willing to freely pay for it.
Not having that information means you will ascribe the wrong value, which means society is not allocating resources properly.
Labor prices stagnating relative to equity owners’ gains has to do with supply of labor vastly increasing due to globalization, and simultaneously, automation reducing demand for many types of labor.
Having transparent prices will help better inform labor sellers which labor markets have excess supply and which need more labor, in a timely fashion.
The reality is that there is tons of nuance that goes into pricing a job / candidate effectively. Each candidate has unique skills even if two candidates have the same title, level, etc. That's why it's almost never a fixed number and often a range.
Also they have the money to buy information from various information aggregation companies which collect salary information from more reliable sources. They do not have to rely on (inherently unreliable) self reported figures from glassdoor etc.
That has nothing to do with the topic at hand, which is the candidate doing some research to get a feel for salary ranges.
> They do not have to rely on (inherently unreliable) self reported figures from glassdoor etc.
Salary figures are inherently inaccurate, just like googling for the market price of your car can never be accurate, because the price you actually get is dependent on the individual characteristics of your car, and how much the other party needs to buy it, and how much you need to sell it.
The fact is, if you're going in blind to deal for a car, or a job, you're shooting yourself in the foot. Information isn't hard to come by for either. You don't need the government to hold your hand.
> Salary figures are inherently inaccurate, just like googling for the market price of your car can never be accurate,
I don't think this has got anything to do with the topic under discussion.
> Information isn't hard to come by for either.
I disagree. IMO it is harder to come by for individuals than large companies. I have explained why in my previous response.
I don't understand how you can have a labor market where only one side has information on what the salaries are for an industry through a team that does market research. It depresses wages, mostly for internal employees who aren't paying attention bc they're content with their jobs.
Price transparency leads to more efficient markets, no reason the labor market is any different. A company hiring an employee under market rate, because the employee doesn't know what market rate is, is a failure.
EDIT: Wanted to add that this hits closer to home for me b/c I've personally experienced this.
Went out and jumped companies and got a 300% raise b/c I was underpaid at the prev, only know that thanks to levels.fyi. New hires at my level were making almost double what I was.
When other engineers at my current company talk about salary, or total comp more generally, they vastly underestimate the state of the market.