News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by simonh on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:18PM (#30483742)
The only people in the industry who seemed to get it were the Android team. It took Microsoft 3 years to realise they actually needed to go back to the drawing board on their mobile tech stack.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by mushyhammer on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:36PM (#30483902)

    iPhone announcement: January 2007
    Android release: October 2008
    Windows Phone 7 release: October 2010
Indeed it seems that Microsoft took their sweet time to rearchitect their OS, but these dates suggests Microsoft realized much earlier than 3 years later.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by pronlover723 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:52PM (#30484071)
Microsoft was shipping PDAs (of which iPhone is an evolution of) since the 90s. I had a Casio E-95. It's about the same size as an iphone. It has a single button below the display at the bottom (same place as the home button on the original iPhone). It's home screen has a grid of 3x4 icons for apps (similar to an iPhone's 4x5 grid). What it doesn't have, it doesn't have capacitive touchscreen, it has resistive so it used a stylus, though I used my fingernail often). It doesn't have cellular service (but plenty did before iPhone shipped). Its UX is not optimized for touch as much as iOS. But it runs an OS, Win-CE, on a PDA so I'm not sure anything needed to be rearchitected rather than just deprecate the desktop UI widgets for more touch friendly alternatives (yea I know that's easier said than done but it's a tiny part of an OS vs all the rest).

Also I'm not under any delusion that MS would have gotten it right. The same reasoning that led them to do the minimal changes from Windows -> Windows CE would have likely always been a drag on them fully embracing letting go and making the necessary changes.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by ethbr0 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:40PM (#30485459)
From early Windows CE memories, Microsoft's mobile hubris always seemed to start from "desktop Windows is the best OS." Ergo, the closer to desktop Windows they could put on mobile devices, the happier people would be.

Blackberry, Palm, and Apple all realized that given hardware and interface limitations, a better solution was to cut the Gordian knot and strike a different balance between desktop and something else.

Honestly, any of the three had a shot at being Apple. Palm had Graffiti and really slick for the time OSs. Blackberry had iMessage of their own. But Apple had a more complete package + Apple fans + iTunes.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by thrashh on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:16AM (#30485867)
I think the issue is that Microsoft only targeted enterprise users and never tried that hard to make their mobile platform for consumers.

Because I remember having a Windows Mobile device and it was fairly powerful. You could do more on it than you could on Android or iOS for many years.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by GeekyBear on Sunday February 27, 2022 @09:16AM (#30488617)
> From early Windows CE memories, Microsoft's mobile hubris always seemed to start from "desktop Windows is the best OS." Ergo, the closer to desktop Windows they could put on mobile devices, the happier people would be.

This insanity reached it's peak just before the iPhone introduction with Microsoft's "Ultra Mobile PC" handheld device initiative.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-mobile_PC

I can remember an implementation of this from ASUS that used a D-Pad to drive a mouse pointer on a handheld device running an unchanged Windows XP UI.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by gumby on Sunday February 27, 2022 @12:35PM (#30490519)
To be fair to Microsoft,* there was customer pull for “desktop everywhere”. I remember asking 20 years ago at a city council meeting why they planned to spend so much on Exchange/Outlook rather than, say, Netscape.

The answer was that the Netscape icons looked different from Microsoft’s so lack of training costs would make MS cheaper. Sounds like bullshit but back then there was enormous learned helplessness when it came to anything computerish. Walk to any desk in most companies and there would be a stack of books to explain it all.

One of the best things about the iPhone was that it jettisoned all that crap and acknowledged that people aren’t idiots. The stores still offered free “training” for the fearful.

* strange, I know, as they were rarely fair to others.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by Seanambers on Sunday February 27, 2022 @08:19AM (#30488142)
And then later on Microsoft shipped Windows 8 - which was a touch first interface on millions and millions of desktop computers. I still remember the utter despair when non pro users didn't understand what was happening with the interface.

You can't make this sh!t up!

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by spoonjim on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:46AM (#30485999)
The feature parity minimizes how much better the iPhone was, even at launch when it was clearly rough around the edges. It’s like comparing a 1988 Hyundai with a Tesla Model S. The features are all the same: 4 doors, 4 seats, steering wheel, brake and gas pedals. But the experiences couldn’t be more different.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by xorcist on Sunday February 27, 2022 @06:23AM (#30487283)
One thing Apple had was the political ability to iterate on the design. Remember that the original iphone had no apps, and no mobile data.

That made it look like an odd duck in the sea of computerphones, but what it had was a slick user interface completely designed around the capabilities of capacitive screens, and that took many years for the competition to even get close to.

Good user interfaces are truly hard, and Apple has always put it front and center, so it must have made sense for them.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by jaclaz on Sunday February 27, 2022 @12:52PM (#30490655)
Also, besides the form factor (pda/phone) there was - before the Win-CE - the mis-known Windows for Pen Computing (essentially Windows 3.11), I used to have a Compaq "laptop" that was actually a tablet (with detachable keyboard), the Compaq Concerto that was actually quite usable with the specific pen, whether that is to be seen as a precursor of the iPad/tablet or of the Microsoft Surface or similar, it came well before anything else (and lasted only a very brief time):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compaq_Concerto

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by agumonkey on Sunday February 27, 2022 @07:25AM (#30487721)
I can't find traces of E-95 models, was part of Cassiopeia line ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casio_Cassiopeia
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by modeless on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:23AM (#30485902)
The Windows Phone 7 "tech stack" was based on the Windows CE kernel and, speaking as someone who worked on it briefly, it was a dumpster fire. It wasn't until Windows Phone 8 in 2012 that Microsoft put a real OS kernel on their phones the way Apple put Darwin on iPhones. Devices could not upgrade from 7 to 8 because they were essentially different operating systems.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by Joeri on Sunday February 27, 2022 @03:52AM (#30486521)
For the customer though the difference was not that dramatic. My wife had a WP7 device and I liked it enough that I replaced my android phone with a WP8, and while it was clearly better than 7, it was not dramatically better. At the time the lack of backwards compatibility was baffling for the WP7 buyers I knew, and all of them switched to iphone or android after that because of being burned by that transition.

I had a similar experience when they went to WP10. While WP8 was a fast, stable and highly usable OS, WP10 was a dumpster fire (for me as a user, cannot talk about underpinnings). Constant crashes, slow, terrible battery life. This was a widely shared experience among WP10 users as far as I know. And on top of that there was another software transition that all but guaranteed no apps properly jumped to the new platform. Looking back on it I think jumping to WP10 instead of carefully incrementing WP8 was the big mistake, and rolling out WP8 without a way to make the transition easier on existing WP7 buyers was the lesser one.

I don’t think a perfect execution would have saved microsoft though: they would have always been third and it is pretty clear developers cannot support more than two mobile platforms properly. The app situation would have always been bad, and without all of the popular apps a smartphone is dead in the water.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by jkestner on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:53PM (#30484092)
I might say that Microsoft didn’t really rearchitect the mobile OS until Windows Phone 8 in November 2012, which was based on Windows NT. Windows 7 was, well a new skin on Windows CE is reductive, but CE was the kernel.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by wolpoli on Sunday February 27, 2022 @03:00AM (#30486318)
As if the 2.5 years delay to market wasn't enough, Microsoft also decided to invent a whole new UI paradigm for Windows Phone 7. I really want to know what went on when they made that decision.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by omegabravo on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:59AM (#30487153)
The new UI paradigm was fantastic for users. That was never the problem with the Windows Phone. I'm not sure if you ever used one, but I loved it. It's problem was always the ecosystem. The device was fast even on low end hardware, yet felt fresh and productive. It got out of the way. I always felt the tabs were a couple of points too large. I never wrote an app for it so suspect it sucked.

On the phone, peoples social media was all integrated into one hub and while great for the user, it reduced the platforms to a transport layer - which did not appeal to them. Youtube was a big deal at the time, and didn't want their app on the new competitors platform. Microsoft wrote some, and they were taking offline. On the Windows phone, it would have been a few steps away from a storage platform.

Microsoft had a brand reputation problem at the time. Windows is what your parents used for work. Apple had an emotional connection of being fresh and hip. They had the iPod and people dancing in silhouette.

iTunes was available on Mac. You could run it on Windows, if you shut everything else down - the thing was a massive resource hog. I'm so scarred by it that even owning a Mac now I never user it.

The Zune app was a joy to use in comparison. I used Zune app for years without even owning a Zune. You had to use iTunes to sync your iPod. The older portable MP3 players were storage devices that you just copied files onto the device.

The end user experience was not the problem.

edit: some of this might be slightly inaccurate since I'm going from memory here. Happy to be corrected by someone who remembers better than I.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by wolpoli on Monday February 28, 2022 @02:24AM (#30497260)
I had an iPhone at that point. I remember playing with Windows Phone 7 at a store and my gut feeling wasn't great about it.

Perhaps it was a combination of that text based tab control or it was the black & white + flat + text design they adopted for live tile and for the UI controls.

It's been a while, so it's possible that it wasn't as bad as I remember it.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by philistine on Sunday February 27, 2022 @09:59AM (#30489019)
You’re so scarred by iTunes you didn’t even realize they got rid of it years ago.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by olliej on Saturday February 26, 2022 @07:55PM (#30484104)
As I understand it the android team had to complete redesign the user facing aspect of the platform after the iPhone was announced
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by randomifcpfan on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:03PM (#30484594)
Not really. The “I guess we’re not shipping that phone” quote was about not shipping the Blackberry-clone Sooner device, but the full-screen touch-first “dream” prototype was already on the drawing board.

Android source code is publicly available, with time stamps. You can read it and see how little had to change to make it a touch first ux.

Android had to add multi-touch events, make the default controls bigger, and add inertial scrolling to the list views. They didn’t even have to add a soft keyboard, because the first few gens of phones had physical keyboards.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by WoodenChair on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:19PM (#30485048)
> Android source code is publicly available, with time stamps. You can read it and see how little had to change to make it a touch first ux.

> Android had to add multi-touch events, make the default controls bigger, and add inertial scrolling to the list views. They didn’t even have to add a soft keyboard, because the first few gens of phones had physical keyboards.

Whether or not it was a lot of code, multi-touch was a revolutionary new UI paradigm and a beautiful symbiosis between well tuned hardware and software. I don’t think its importance should be trivialized and the iPhone was undoubtedly the catalyst that brought Fingerworks’s invention to the masses.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by ksec on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:53PM (#30485257)
This. The genius of iPhone UI was that it was so obvious once you saw it. There were plenty of so called Smartphones then, with or without Keyboard. But none of the touch screen phone interface were user friendly. Zero.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by Joeri on Sunday February 27, 2022 @04:00AM (#30486551)
There was a full touch screen phone that predated the iphone, the LG prada, but if you look at the demo you can see in some places they arrived at a similar design (the dialer), in others they had a laughably bad design (T9 text message entry on the touch screen) and overall it was very unresponsive. The iphone didn’t just have the right touch ui concepts, it executed them really well.

LG prada phone demo from 15 years ago: https://youtu.be/5mo7Ab6ZcJ4

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by ksec on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:30AM (#30486992)
Yes I even had one, the LG Prada. Along with other Smartphone like Sony Ericsson P800, or O2 XDA which was similar to LG Prada but way earlier, I think it was 2002. They were based on Windows Mobile. And some other PDAs before that. The O2 XDA were built by HTC ,at the time they were like Foxconn doing ODM before it became a consumer brand.

There were lots and lots of other small details that Apple got it right. And I said it the first time I saw the iPhone, what sets them apart was Apple was trying to make an iPhone like an Appliance. While all other Smartphones was trying to cramp a computer inside a Phone factor. The day I saw iPhone I knew that was it. The Smartphone I have been looking for. Strange it is 15 years already.

I still dont know why the Visual Voicemail patents had not expired. It really should be the standard on all network.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by colinthompson on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:38AM (#30485963)
I purchased the fingerworks gesture keyboard insert for my TiBook. It was amazing. I remember thinking it was the future of all laptop input devices. While I'm glad it resurfaced as the iOS input device, I am super bummed I still don't have that keyboard on my MacBook. That thing was incredible.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by GeekyBear on Sunday February 27, 2022 @09:41AM (#30488863)
> Not really

Yes, really.

>[Google] had been working with proto­types for six months and had planned a launch by the end of the year . . . until Jobs took the stage to unveil the iPhone.

Chris DeSalvo’s reaction to the iPhone was immediate and visceral. “As a consumer I was blown away. I wanted one immediately. But as a Google engineer, I thought ‘We’re going to have to start over.’”

“What we had suddenly looked just so . . . nineties,” DeSalvo said. “It’s just one of those things that are obvious when you see it.”

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/12/the-d...

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by exsf0859 on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @02:09AM (#30524620)
Those quotes are entirely compatible with "not really".

Chris is talking about the Sooner: https://www.androidcentral.com/look-back-google-sooner-first.... It was called Sooner because it was going to come to market "sooner" than the other, more advanced, Dream prototype. After the iPhone announcement Sooner was canceled, in favor of the "Dream" prototype, which eventually shipped in a modified form as the G1.

The _software_ difference between non-touch Sooner and the touch-capable G1 were relatively minor. Same OS, same view system, same application framework.

As I recall, Chris's role at the time was as a UX focused engineer, so perhaps from his POV it was a massive redesign. But if you consider Android as a whole, relatively little changed. I recall the apps being pretty easy to port over to support touch. (Moving to a bigger screen helped offset the problem of having to make the buttons way larger.)

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by 8note on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:09PM (#30485341)
There was a really similar mp3 player that had been out for a while. It was too expensive for me to buy one, so I don't remember the name
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by bradleyankrom on Sunday February 27, 2022 @08:52AM (#30488416)
Zune?
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by cpuguy83 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:10PM (#30484227)
Android didn't do anything (in the ballpark) for several years either.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by avl999 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:32PM (#30485133)
Android had been working on their phone long before that. There is a story by Richard Hipp the creator of Sqlite who was flown in by Android to help with their sqlite deployements on their phones long before it was public knowledge. He also had been working with Nokia/Ericsson who reigned supreme in cell phone market at that time and according to him what he saw by Android blew him away and knew that other companies were doomed. This was well before the Iphone days, I forget the exact date he mentioned but it was circa mid-2000s. It is clear that Apple and Android had been working on a similar product, apple just got to market first.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by cpuguy83 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:16PM (#30485366)
This is not how history went.

Android being worked on is very different from Android being anything at all like what it ended up being.

It literally took years before Android was in the same league.

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by JimDabell on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:52AM (#30486029)
It wasn’t several years. The G1 was released just over a year after the first iPhone, not long after the iPhone 3G, and it was roughly equivalent to the 3G.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by cpuguy83 on Sunday February 27, 2022 @03:24AM (#30486419)
Here's the G1: https://www.androidpolice.com/2021/09/23/the-first-android-p...

Here's cnet's review (literally just the first link I pulled from Google).

"But still, the G1 doesn't quite offer the mass appeal and ease of use as the iPhone, so it won't be a good fit for someone making the jump from a regular mobile to their first smartphone." https://www.cnet.com/reviews/t-mobile-g1-review/

Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by JimDabell on Sunday February 27, 2022 @08:27AM (#30488198)
I don’t need to read a review. I owned one when they were launched, while I was working as an iPhoneOS developer. I would spend eight hours a day using an iPhone 3G and the rest of the time using my G1. They were roughly equivalent. The iPhone did some things better, the G1 did some things better. It didn’t take “several years” for Google to be in the same ballpark, they were in the same ballpark from launch, which was fifteen months after the original iPhone launch.
Re:On the Origin of the iPhone by sangnoir on Sunday February 27, 2022 @11:54PM (#30496558)
I remember Android had a much better notification experience out of the gate, and IIRC, shipped copy-and-paste first. Same ballpark sound about right