Also I'm not under any delusion that MS would have gotten it right. The same reasoning that led them to do the minimal changes from Windows -> Windows CE would have likely always been a drag on them fully embracing letting go and making the necessary changes.
Blackberry, Palm, and Apple all realized that given hardware and interface limitations, a better solution was to cut the Gordian knot and strike a different balance between desktop and something else.
Honestly, any of the three had a shot at being Apple. Palm had Graffiti and really slick for the time OSs. Blackberry had iMessage of their own. But Apple had a more complete package + Apple fans + iTunes.
Because I remember having a Windows Mobile device and it was fairly powerful. You could do more on it than you could on Android or iOS for many years.
This insanity reached it's peak just before the iPhone introduction with Microsoft's "Ultra Mobile PC" handheld device initiative.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-mobile_PC
I can remember an implementation of this from ASUS that used a D-Pad to drive a mouse pointer on a handheld device running an unchanged Windows XP UI.
The answer was that the Netscape icons looked different from Microsoft’s so lack of training costs would make MS cheaper. Sounds like bullshit but back then there was enormous learned helplessness when it came to anything computerish. Walk to any desk in most companies and there would be a stack of books to explain it all.
One of the best things about the iPhone was that it jettisoned all that crap and acknowledged that people aren’t idiots. The stores still offered free “training” for the fearful.
* strange, I know, as they were rarely fair to others.
You can't make this sh!t up!
That made it look like an odd duck in the sea of computerphones, but what it had was a slick user interface completely designed around the capabilities of capacitive screens, and that took many years for the competition to even get close to.
Good user interfaces are truly hard, and Apple has always put it front and center, so it must have made sense for them.
I had a similar experience when they went to WP10. While WP8 was a fast, stable and highly usable OS, WP10 was a dumpster fire (for me as a user, cannot talk about underpinnings). Constant crashes, slow, terrible battery life. This was a widely shared experience among WP10 users as far as I know. And on top of that there was another software transition that all but guaranteed no apps properly jumped to the new platform. Looking back on it I think jumping to WP10 instead of carefully incrementing WP8 was the big mistake, and rolling out WP8 without a way to make the transition easier on existing WP7 buyers was the lesser one.
I don’t think a perfect execution would have saved microsoft though: they would have always been third and it is pretty clear developers cannot support more than two mobile platforms properly. The app situation would have always been bad, and without all of the popular apps a smartphone is dead in the water.
On the phone, peoples social media was all integrated into one hub and while great for the user, it reduced the platforms to a transport layer - which did not appeal to them. Youtube was a big deal at the time, and didn't want their app on the new competitors platform. Microsoft wrote some, and they were taking offline. On the Windows phone, it would have been a few steps away from a storage platform.
Microsoft had a brand reputation problem at the time. Windows is what your parents used for work. Apple had an emotional connection of being fresh and hip. They had the iPod and people dancing in silhouette.
iTunes was available on Mac. You could run it on Windows, if you shut everything else down - the thing was a massive resource hog. I'm so scarred by it that even owning a Mac now I never user it.
The Zune app was a joy to use in comparison. I used Zune app for years without even owning a Zune. You had to use iTunes to sync your iPod. The older portable MP3 players were storage devices that you just copied files onto the device.
The end user experience was not the problem.
edit: some of this might be slightly inaccurate since I'm going from memory here. Happy to be corrected by someone who remembers better than I.
Perhaps it was a combination of that text based tab control or it was the black & white + flat + text design they adopted for live tile and for the UI controls.
It's been a while, so it's possible that it wasn't as bad as I remember it.