News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by hit8run on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:03PM (#30460240)
Then go to your office and sit there parked as an employee spending your life in a cubicle. But don’t expect people who value their life outside to show up.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by actusual on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:09PM (#30460320)
Sometimes I want to work in an office, therefore I don't value my "life outside" (whatever that means). What an odd conclusion to jump to...
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by Apocryphon on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:48PM (#30460783)
For starters, having to commute and stay in the office for the full day cuts into one's WLB.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by Unbeliever69 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @06:06PM (#30461585)
This is obviously a "to each his own" issue. Work where you perform the best and for the best of the team. For my small startup WFH has been a blessing. Outside of physical face-to-face interaction there have been no downside because we have adjusted our process and technologies accordingly. We also work very comfortable in video chat all day. We occasionally meet and have lunch. I can honestly say I will never go back to working in an office and most of my co-workers feel the same. The few that wouldn't mind working in an office occasionally are those that have distractions at home (family that don't respect boundaries, usually with young children).
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by closeparen on Friday February 25, 2022 @12:23AM (#30463985)
Having nowhere to be, ever, cuts into one’s sanity. It is all the stress of working combined with the listlessness of retirement. I hate it so much.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by jayd16 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @06:51PM (#30462004)
This is probably unpopular but...

Commute time is a choice against other expenses. I live 10 minutes from the office because I didn't want to commute. I don't begrudge you for living further but I will say it was a WLB choice the employee made, not the employer.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 24, 2022 @06:58PM (#30462060)
I begrudge people who demand their colleagues come into the office which governs their living arrangements if a commute is required.

Remote is absolutely possible if your job doesn't require meatspace/atom manipulation as part of your work product, and to say that it isn't possible 3 years into a global pandemic demonstrating sustained levels of productivity while remote across various sectors is simply laziness and stated in bad faith. I understand that we are just randos throwing opinions back and forth, and that the only recourse available in countries where remote work isn't mandated by law as an option is to hope for remote orgs to continue to cannibalize non-remote/less-remote orgs for top talent, until non-remote orgs concede on their physical presence demands.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by jayd16 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:16PM (#30462183)
Not really weighing in on any of that. I just find it disingenuous to claim its a work life balance thing when the balance was the choice of the employee to begin with.

I understand the desire to have a cake and eat it but the job was to show up and put in the time. To go back and argue that showing up is now a WLB violation for previously existing jobs is just not defensible.

That said, sure, more jobs should just be WFH. If you want that, find it.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by ryandrake on Thursday February 24, 2022 @09:50PM (#30463207)
It's not entirely a free choice. At least in the Bay Area, your ability to live close to work depends to a great degree on your compensation. I'd love to live on the Peninsula right next to work, but there's no way I could afford the rent or a mortgage there. I'd gladly walk to work and work-from-office every day if I was paid what our division's VP was paid. I think the normal-paid people who are within an acceptable commute to work are either willing to live in a shoebox-sized apartment or single and willing to live with many roommates. I guess that's technically a choice, but not a great one.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by Apocryphon on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:37PM (#30473728)
Those previously existing jobs with inordinately long commutes were always WLB violations, some workers just were willing to put up with them, even when they were very suboptimal.

Extreme example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15942945

> If you want that, find it.

And create it, if possible. By putting market pressure in favor of WFH so that employers are forced to adjust to worker demands.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:25PM (#30462253)
> I understand the desire to have a cake and eat it but the job was to show up and put in the time. To go back and argue that showing up is now a WLB violation for previously existing jobs is just not defensible.

Based on your reply, I don't think you truly understand the situation. The work arrangement is always negotiable, and demanding remote when it's proven it can be done at a reasonable productively level is entirely reasonable from an employee perspective. One does not need to put up with unreasonable employer demands in the current job market, and showing up on site five days a week is arguably unreasonable. The job expectations are to deliver results, not warm a chair with colleagues. Of course, if your job performance was based on warming the chair versus delivering, of course, measure that instead of results.

If you want to work on site, wonderful, go for it. That does not appear to be the direction the market is going based on available data.

https://www.dallasnews.com/business/jobs/2022/02/24/why-remo... (Why remote jobs are changing work for good — if you’re working in the right place; Over 40% of employees say they would look for a new job if required to go to a worksite five days a week.)

https://www.hcamag.com/us/specialization/recruitment/west-co... (West Coast tech firms increase hiring throughout U.S.)

https://www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/economic_b... (Are Firms Using Remote Work to Recruit and Retain Workers?)

https://slate.com/human-interest/2021/07/workers-quitting-ov... (The People Who’d Rather Quit Than Give Up Remote Work)

https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2022/02/16/covid-1... (excerpts from this link below)

> Working from home is a relatively new experience for a majority of workers with jobs that can be done remotely – 57% say they rarely or never worked from home prior to the coronavirus outbreak. For those who have made the switch to telework, their work lives have changed in some significant ways. On the plus side, most (64%) of those who are now working from home at least some of the time but rarely or never did before the pandemic say it’s easier now for them to balance work with their personal life. And many (44%) say working from home has made it easier for them to get their work done and meet deadlines, while very few (10%) say it’s been harder to do this. At the same time, 60% say they feel less connected to their co-workers now. Most (72%) say working from home hasn’t affected their ability to advance in their job.

> Looking to the future, 60% of workers with jobs that can be done from home say when the coronavirus outbreak is over, if they have the choice, they’d like to work from home all or most of the time. This is up from 54% who said the same in 2020. Among those who are currently working from home all or most of the time, 78% say they’d like to continue to do so after the pandemic, up from 64% in 2020.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by jayd16 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:35PM (#30462332)
No I fully understand. I just want to be honest that it's simply a contract negotiation, not some moral force.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by hlbjhblbljib on Thursday February 24, 2022 @07:28PM (#30462280)
You're right, that is a horrible thing to force employees to do. To manage their entire lives and where they lived for their employer. Glad we're seeing an end to this.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by blub on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:22AM (#30465280)
Working from the office is the default; you likely have this in your contract (I do) and you did that most of your life. Now if your life in the office was reduced to being parked in a cubicle, then no wonder you hate it, but don't project that on everyone.

Who has to show up is decided by the company and to a lesser extent by the market: if your contract says you have to show up, then you get fired if you don't. And frankly this is what I expect to happen to many of those which discovered working from home during the pandemic and now behave like extremists and want to force companies and their colleagues to change for their sake.

By all means, argue for hybrid or home office, but don't pretend this is normal and anyone that's against it is some barbarian.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by marcellus23 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:32PM (#30460599)
idk about you, but whether I WFH or not, I still have to spend the same amount of time inside, in front of a computer screen.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by taylodl on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:54PM (#30460830)
You need to find a spot where you can work outside. I have an outdoor office along with an indoor office. In nice weather it's great to go outside and work. You don't have to work all day outside, either. Even spending an hour or two outside will really boost your mood.

I'd like to know where people are working that they used to work with people in an office. I've been developing software for 35 years - a lot of start ups even - and have always worked with an engineering team that's geographically distributed - either in different countries or in different locales. Yeah, most of us went to an office to work, but we were working with maybe 1 or 2 people in the office. About the only thing I got out of working in an office was soul-destroying gossip. For some reason WFH has cut that crap out by at least 75%.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by bluefirebrand on Thursday February 24, 2022 @11:41PM (#30463788)
Less time in a car or on a bus though.

That's substantial. For many people it adds up to hours per day.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by closeparen on Friday February 25, 2022 @12:21AM (#30463976)
Don’t expect people who show up to include you in conversations, and we’re fine.

Really. I have no problem with people executing tasks from wherever. But Zoom is vile.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by mschuetz on Thursday February 24, 2022 @04:09PM (#30460314)
That is fine, but don't expect us to want to work with people who are not present and can only be contacted via mail/chat/video conferencing. Just as you expect others to respect your wish not to show up, you'll have to respect other peoples wish to work with people who do show up.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by tsunamifury on Thursday February 24, 2022 @06:38PM (#30461874)
So wasting 1-2 hours a day being non productive is your bar for a valuable employee.

I’d suggest your view comes from a bias towards red queen races being arbitrators of value rather than… you know… productivity.

A few years ago the bar was wearing a suit to work every day with sock suspenders. Look up IBMs uniform dress code. Now we all accept that as antiquated, distracting waste.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by closeparen on Friday February 25, 2022 @12:52AM (#30464089)
Ah, yes, the famously productive Zoom meeting. Barking dogs, construction, echo cancellation artifacts, lag, “no you go ahead,” endless monologues, creepy pseudo-ASMR from people’s giant gamer headsets, Bluetooth glitches, “let me try turning off my video” for 6 hours a day. So much fucking value generation. It’s just palpable, isn’t it?

You know, you’re right. It probably is the most efficient way to work, to continuously subject employees to this torture. The problem is I’m a fucking human being and there’s only so much abuse I’m going to take from you. And by being a remote worker you are, necessarily, subjecting your coworkers to this abuse every second they have to work with you. It is inherent to the notion of video calling with consumer-grade hardware on a packet switched network.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by tsunamifury on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:55AM (#30464379)
Dude. Get a new workplace or coworkers then. This sounds awful. Nothing like this where I work. Generally just awesome.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by closeparen on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:02AM (#30464755)
Really, none of your coworkers have flaky internet or noisy surroundings? None of them are using Bluetooth or onboard microphones or speakers? Is this a company full of audio engineers working from their personal broadcast studios?
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by KronisLV on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:00AM (#30465925)
> Really, none of your coworkers have flaky internet or noisy surroundings?

While one shouldn't discount those that are stuck in circumstances like that, no, we don't. And when their surroundings are noisy, they can just mute their microphones until they'd like to say something, which is just basic etiquette for communicating online. Or you can even pic up a microphone with a polar pattern that doesn't pick up much background noise for about 20$, which is what i did.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by weq on Thursday February 24, 2022 @10:11PM (#30463324)
The world has moved on. We came to cities looking for work. Now the internet is availible ANYWHERE, people can LIVE ANYWHERE.

If your business wants to demand in-person, then you know what kind of people who you will get: - people with kids who dont have a good grasp on what work life balance is (maybe because of extended debt) - people who are single or otherwise unhappy at home, looking for companionship - people who cant feel good about themselves without chit-chat - people looking to increase their social circle - people who will think they can use social engineering to forward their career

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by citizenpaul on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:28AM (#30464256)
There are millions of do nothing middle managers whoms only job was taking roll call. Those pointless jobs are being threatned by WFH.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by mschuetz on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:29AM (#30464912)
My view comes from my dislike of communicating via mail or video conferencing, and that I just don't want my home to be a place of work. Communicating online is wildly inefficient and lacks the nuance of doing things directly in person. It's so much easier to explain/teach things in person, and also get things thought in return. One of the best experiences I've had was an internship that involved so many hands-on experiences that would never have been possible remotely.

> So wasting 1-2 hours a day being non productive

Wasting in what way? Commuting? I love my commute, it's a nice 25 minute morning stroll on the cycle and provides the necessary motivation/pressure to get out of the house. I'm fine with people wanting to work remotely, I'm just not okay with working together with them (unless they're here at least 2-3 times a week) as it's wildly inefficient, and also not okay with people demanding that any company must offer full 5 days WFH as if it's a god given right.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by jakupovic on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:10AM (#30465997)
>I'm just not okay with working together with them (unless they're here at least 2-3 times a week)

Good for you as you can always vote with your feet. If others don't want to come in and work with you, then you must find a new job. But don't expect anyone else to conform to your idea of how work should be. If for nothing else but for the same reasons you are using, personal preference.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by mschuetz on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:14AM (#30466021)
> Good for you as you can always vote with your feet. If others don't want to come in and work with you, then you must find a new job

Sure, that's fine. It's why I'd never apply for remote positions. Luckily, where I work people still come into office.

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by thebean11 on Thursday February 24, 2022 @08:11PM (#30462576)
Comparing dress code to working in person is pretty ridiculous. Is your claim that there is literally zero value to seeing your coworkers in person? Also not everyone has a long and/or unproductive commute.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by malermeister on Thursday February 24, 2022 @09:54PM (#30463234)
I'd go one further and say there is often negative value to seeing coworkers in person. Distractions and idle chit-chat that can't be turned off as easily as a Slack notification can decrease productivity.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by bravetraveler on Thursday February 24, 2022 @11:34PM (#30463752)
I've actually timed it, any time I would go into the office almost half of the day would be filled with idle distractions and the like.

Which wouldn't be so bad if, you know, I found the experience relaxing or had the slightest inclination to get to know these people [beyond how they can help solve a given problem].

Maybe I just see work differently from everyone... but we're here to do the thing and get paid. I'm not putting in anything more than what's required.

[ edit: if Bob won't do $thing because we don't have enough social points, that's between him and our employer ]

'Team building' through things like these idle pleasantries and bombastic 'collaborative' seat-filling meetings are draining for people like me.

Put it on my calendar, if I think I can help or have an interest - I'll stop by the call... I'm already on your side if we're trying to make things better.

I really like to exercise my salary benefits of finishing my work and doing something else. Seeing the meatbags breaks asynchronous work

Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by thebean11 on Friday February 25, 2022 @09:26AM (#30467613)
I believe you that that's your specific personal experience. I don't think it's universal.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by malermeister on Friday February 25, 2022 @11:42AM (#30469175)
I agree, which is why I've qualified it with "often".
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by whimsicalism on Thursday February 24, 2022 @06:03PM (#30461561)
I am not sure there is a majority who agrees with your views. I want to go in maybe 2 days/week. But I certainly don't want to fire people working fully remote. Firing those people isn't merely "respecting" someone's wishes.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by mschuetz on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:23AM (#30464876)
I'm fine with people coming in maybe 3 instead of 5 days a week. I'm not fine working together with people who are not here at all. It's wildly inefficient and communication via video conferencing is horrible.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by jakupovic on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:15AM (#30466027)
Nobody cares about individual preferences as in the end we vote with our feet. So you not wanting to work by yourself should have no bearing on what others in the same group do. Once you start mandating what others should do based on your needs, people will either not listen, leave or you will leave.
Re:Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future by mschuetz on Friday February 25, 2022 @09:38AM (#30467715)
True, I do vote with my feet. Which is why I won't apply for jobs with remote teams, and which is why I'm sticking with my current job.