News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by redthrowaway on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:21PM (#3044557)
This seems like a really ill-conceived play on bethsoft's part. A month before the release of their biggest title in years, and they want to piss off gamers by suing someone universally loved by them? Why? What possible good could come of this for them? I would have thought the initial reaction to the story would have caused them to rethink their strategy, but they don't seem to care.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by radu_floricica on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @04:53PM (#3045191)
There is no such thing as bad publicity. And this one is really cheap. How else would I find out on HN that they're launching next month?
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by redthrowaway on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @05:50PM (#3045401)
Bethesda doesn't need this kind of publicity; they're one of the biggest and most successful studios this side of EA or Activision. Skyrim has been hotly anticipated (and its release date announced) for about a year, now. I can see this having a minor effect on Skyrim sales, but I certainly can't see it having a positive one.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Zimahl on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:20PM (#3044549)
Remember, this isn't just about Mojang naming their game 'Scrolls', this is about them doing that AND applying for a trademark on the name 'Scrolls' for video games.

If this was just about the name of a game then it wouldn't be much of an issue, Bethesda could just cover their TM by licensing it to them for how little or much they wanted to. But Mojang wants their own TM (to subjugate others) and that's where the lawyers are getting huffy.

Frankly, I think he should just change the name of his game. Life is too short to deal with the headache and pay a bunch of lawyers to argue over this junk. 'Scrolls' doesn't seem like a great name anyways.

Disclaimer: I love Minecraft and play it regularly, but I'm not interested in card-type strategy games. Therefore I won't probably even try a demo of 'Scrolls' (or whatever it ends up being called).

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Zodiakos on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @03:23PM (#3044806)
>But Mojang wants their own TM (to subjugate others)

I'm not sure that the parenthetical remark is really warranted, since there are many other reasons to want a trademark, nearly all of them more useful than 'subjugating others'. Such as to prevent someone making sure that someone doesn't make a game called 'Scrolls: The Elders' - Basically, to prevent someone riding on the coattails of your success by riding your product brand name or dragging your brand into the mud with an inferior but confusingly similarly named product. The name Scrolls is neither of those things, which is why Bethesda is in the wrong here - both ethically, and most likely legally. I guess we'll see.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by joebadmo on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:49AM (#3043784)
I guess the Quake 3 match fell through. Too bad.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2895491

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by andrewingram on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:51AM (#3043802)
Forgive me if I've misunderstood trademarks. But aren't Bethesda, as trademark holders, required to defend that trademark or risk losing it?

I don't agree that a trademark on Elder Scrolls should cover just Scrolls, but it might just be a case of a legal department going through the motions.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Pyrodogg on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:20PM (#3043967)
Yes, Bethesda is required to defend their trademark but suing the other party to completely change course isn't the only option available.

See Trademark Coexistance http://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2006/06/article_0007.ht...

SparkFun vs SPARC International http://www.sparkfun.com/news/344

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by withad on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:09PM (#3043901)
Notch apparently hoped that it was just "lawyers being lawyers" early on, but I doubt it would have gone this far without important people at Bethesda/ZeniMax noticing and (presumably) supporting it.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Dylan16807 on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:02PM (#3043860)
They have to defend the trademark itself, yes. But not things that aren't all that similar.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by cube13 on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:18PM (#3043949)
From what I've heard, Scrolls is a fantasy... something(could be turn based strategy, role playing, or something completely else) game currently in development by Mojang. The Elder Scrolls is a series of fantasy role playing games developed by Bathesda.

Bathesda's lawyers probably felt that the two titles are similar enough in either gameplay style or genre that it could be infringement. Unfortunately, there isn't any other way of resolving this than suing the people you believe are infringing on your trademark.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by uxp on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @01:58PM (#3044432)
The unfortunate side effect is that Scrolls (the parchment containing objects) are a deprecated technology. The only time We get to use them anymore is in a fantasy setting.

I really don't understand how they can reasonably expect to own the trademark on a word that is only a portion of their actual product line and describes an object that has been known to exist for thousands of years. Microsoft was denied the trademark for "Windows", but they were given trademarks for the phrases "Windows XP Operating System", etc.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by cube13 on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @06:17PM (#3045494)
The trademark doesn't prevent you from having in-game objects called "Scrolls". I can only(if Bathesda wins the suit, which I think is unlikely) prevent you from creating a fantasy video game called "Scrolls".

Also, MS does have a registered trademark for "Windows"(http://www.microsoft.com/about/legal/en/us/IntellectualPrope...), but this is only for computer operating systems, not for physical building windows.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Tichy on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:52AM (#3043812)
Legal departments going through the motions are a big problem, though.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Shenglong on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:35PM (#3044036)
I was going to write a satirical comment pointing out how ridiculous this is, but I can't come up with anything that even semi-serious. Bethesda needs a PR team.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by markokocic on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:10AM (#3043555)
Given the attention this case got in some communities, it is worth every cent they are going to spend in court, regardless of the winner.

This particular case seems like good PR for both parties.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by gte910h on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:19AM (#3043610)
While people love ES games, they don't particularly have love for Bethesda (hell, they're the people who made the horse armor which is the standard example of stupid DLC).

On the other hand, people love Notch and Mojang...

I could see this pushing people on the fence away from buying skyrim (as it is for me; I'd probably not have time to play anyhow, but it's also supporting a bit too much in the way of crazy here).

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by falcolas on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:19AM (#3043609)
Good PR in the sense of brand awareness, but I can't imagine this is garnering good will for Bethesda.

It's hard to say whether good will really matters, though, as capricious as gamers can be.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by parfe on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:57AM (#3043829)
Worst case Mojang changes the name of an unreleased game (that I hadn't heard about until now).

Bethseda on the other hand looks to be trying to beat up on the little guy. After Oblivian's "Too bad you leveled wrong. No stat points for you." character system, the next elder scrolls already lacked appeal. This case certainly won't help.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by dkersten on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:17PM (#3043940)
"Too bad you leveled wrong. No stat points for you."

Meh, leveling was pointless anyway because when you leveled up, so did the enemy. I hear the next game is keeping this mechanic, so its lost its appeal to me too.

Regarding this case: I have never ever heard of the elder scrolls games referred to as scrolls. Its either The Elder Scrolls or its Oblivion or Morrowind or whatever.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by parfe on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:20PM (#3044553)
>Meh, leveling was pointless anyway because when you leveled up, so did the enemy.

Yes, but if you didn't also increase other skills you would only get +2 or +3s for your stats rather than the max of +5s to three stat groups.

So the enemy hits lvl 20 just like you do, but you are much weaker as you've inefficiency leveled.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by eavc on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @04:13PM (#3045003)
Which meant that unless you optimized your progress, leveling was counter-productive.

Enter the difficulty slider. Both mechanics made the game silly to me in later stages, and I never finished.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by TheCapn on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:58PM (#3044150)
"Worst case Mojang changes the name of an unreleased game (that I hadn't heard about until now)."

I disagree. Worst case is both companies are out $X because legal departments collect their fees post-court for a no good reason.

Mojang is essentially playing a game of chicken at this point. They're calling Bethseda's bluff that they're not serious about pursuing the case but the longer it goes like this the more they risk losing in lawyer fees.

I see Mojang backing down last minute because after-all, your statement really is true in the sense that they might have to alter an unreleased game's name... s/scrolls/$something_else/g

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by dustingetz on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:21PM (#3044559)
i'm sure the suit is ridiculous and all, but why exactly does the Scrolls team think that defending this suit is in their business interests?
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by nknight on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:27PM (#3044587)
I'd find a lawsuit over "Minecraft" at least as plausible as this nonsense. That the ActiLizzard has managed to keep its lawyers caged does not reflect well on Bethesda.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by jakelear on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @11:55AM (#3043823)
I can definitely understand how the masses would side with Mojang on this one. Big media corp vs small indie self-made studio, etc.

However, not knowing all that much about "Scrolls," I feel like Bethesda (Zenimax) has a good argument here. The only artwork I've seen from scrolls depicts Fantasy-style characters in leather and metal armor. From what I understand, it's some sort of card game, but that's not obvious from the at-a-glance view, and I think there could be some confusion among those unfamiliar with the two games in question.

Any major trademark holder has to actively protect their copyright/trademark and I feel like this, though perhaps unfortunate, is a pretty standard legal practice.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by cbs on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:28PM (#3044006)
>I think there could be some confusion among those unfamiliar with the two games in question.

Probably has nothing to do with the name; both scrolls (the objects) and Fantasy-style characters in leather and metal armor are incredibly common video game tropes.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by cdmckay on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:32PM (#3044018)
I don't know, shouldn't their trade-mark only protect "The Elder Scrolls"? Otherwise, this would be an incentive for companies to trade-mark longer trade-marks, as they would receive protection for every word in the mark. For example, "The Elder Fantasy Knight Chronicle Scrolls".
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by dangero on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:12PM (#3044506)
Mojang has money, so no matter what this won't hurt him, but unless he's doing this for the publicity, he's making the wrong choice. Change the name of your unreleased game. Not that big a deal, and you'll save a lot of lawyer fees. Pick your battles. Of course, that is if he isn't attempting to use this as a publicity stunt. As some people mentioned, Mojang's project wasn't that well known prior to this incident.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by rkalla on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:14PM (#3043923)
I understand that it is cool to root for the little guy, but with $20 million in the bank[1] and something like 20 employees (I am trying to remember from the docu about them), Markus isn't a guy sitting in his dorm room trying to hack his way to future success, and as andrewingram pointed out, if Bethesda doesn't defend their claim on the "Elder Scrolls" name, they can lose it.

I would not find it that unreasonable to think that ES fans likely refer to the game as "Scrolls" and not "Elder" when discussing it online, nor that in RPG groups if a year ago you said "Have you played Scrolls?" most people would realize you were talking about ES.

This seems reasonable to me... like if I created a new game called "Warcraft" that let you build siege weapons and launch attacks against castles filled with orcs. I would fully expect Blizzard to come after me.

It isn't like they named the game "Frostraven Scrolls" or something clearly different.

Just my 2 cents. Just communicating the fact that I am not weeping in agony for Mojang and their poor plight.

[1] http://www.warriorforum.com/main-internet-marketing-discussi...

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by sharpneli on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:18PM (#3043946)
I have a strong hunch that the response to "Have you played Scrolls?" would be "What?" "You know, Oblivion/Morrowind/Daggerfall" (choose the right one) "Oh yeah I've played that, maybe bit too much."
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by rkalla on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:22PM (#3043982)
That's a good point... maybe my prompting question was wrong. "Are you familiar with Scrolls lore" or "Scrolls style of play?" or "Do you like the Scrolls games?" maybe better options so they are grouped.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by redthrowaway on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @02:18PM (#3044538)
As others have said, nobody ever refers to them like that. They might say, "did you like Oblivion", or, if they're gamers hanging out in a gaming-specific forum, "are you a fan of TES?" Never, ever, have I heard anyone refer to the games as "Scrolls". It's simple not done. In the same vein, you would never refer to gcc as "collection".
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by Natsu on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @03:36PM (#3044864)
Same here. Calling it just "scrolls" sounds horribly wrong and I've done a lot of gaming. I can't imagine being confused by this.

I think this is a total waste of money and wish they'd taken Mojang up on that offer to play a game for it.

Can anyone point to any comment, prior to this lawsuit nonsense, where someone actually referred to any game or the series as just "scrolls"? In all the comments over this, not one person has done that. And it's a huge internet, so someone, somewhere has probably done that. But everyone I know will say Elder Scrolls or ES or TES or Morrowind or what have you.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by shabble on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:35PM (#3044034)
I've only ever heard it referred to in the plural sense as 'elder scrolls' series, across quite a wide variety of people. This is from casual players, console version players, d&d geeks, as well as the hardcore modding communities. In almost all cases someone refers to a specific game by its subtitle though, and noted above.

I'm not sure many people would realise what you meant if you asked "Do you like the Scrolls games?", whereas s/Scrolls/Elder Scrolls/ and you'd have much higher recognition. I might try asking a few people and seeing how it actually works out, but IMO the names are sufficiently distinct as to not cause confusion.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by rkalla on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:40PM (#3044058)
Hmm, then I retract my assumption that "Scrolls" was clear, I was under the impression that to some extent it was similar in clarity to saying "Warcraft" and people generally knowing what you mean, or saying "Warhammer".

Thanks for the clarification.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by alnayyir on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:42PM (#3044079)
None of those things have ever been said. Cf. my other comment.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by masterzora on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @01:24PM (#3044277)
This seems reasonable to me... like if I created a new game called "Warcraft" that let you build siege weapons and launch attacks against castles filled with orcs. I would fully expect Blizzard to come after me.

Yes, if you create a game with the exact same name as Blizzard's and with very similar gameplay, expect to see a trademark dispute. This, however, is not the guess with The Elder Scrolls series and Scrolls.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by ramidarigaz on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:40PM (#3044061)
Just to echo the other commenters here, I've only ever heard the series referred to as the "Elder Scrolls" games.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by InclinedPlane on Wednesday September 28, 2011 @04:30AM (#3047004)
Firstly, nobody refers to either any Elder Scrolls game or the series as "scrolls", it just doesn't happen. Secondly, the Elder Scrolls part of the name tends to be subordinate to whatever the name of the current game is. These both make it extremely, extremely unlikely that anyone would ever seriously confuse Scrolls as being a Bethesda game within the Elder Scrolls series. Thirdly, the games are nothing alike: Elder Scrolls games are first person single player RPGs, it's similar to Fallout 3, Red Dead Redemption, and Grand Theft Auto, except in a medieval fantasy setting; Scrolls is a multiplayer trading card game with "tactical" elements, it's similar to Magic: The Gathering, Culdcept Saga, or Yu-Gi-Oh, nobody could possibly confuse the two even if they only managed to see 10 milliseconds of game play.

The only people who could conceivably be confused into accidentally buying Scrolls when they meant to buy Skyrim would either have so little idea of what Skyrim was or so little grasp on reality that they would be equally likely to buy Halo or a bag of M&Ms.

This lawsuit is like if Blizzard were to sue the company that makes "Raft Wars" because it was infringing on the "Warcraft" trademark.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by alnayyir on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:42PM (#3044068)
>"Have you played Scrolls?" most people would realize you were talking about ES.

False beyond imagination. You're clearly not a gamer or a fan of the series, I've been playing it and involved in the community for the ES games since Daggerfall (1996).

Not once, in any forum post, usenet post, or BBS have I ever seen someone refer to the series or an individual game from Bethesda as "Scrolls", nor has it ever been part of their marketing or branding.

This is like Microsoft claiming you can't use the word "soft" in your product because someone might once have referred to their brand as "Soft" without the "Micro".

Just ridiculous.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by rkalla on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @12:51PM (#3044120)
Chris, your point was strong enough without the bile.
Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by alnayyir on Tuesday September 27, 2011 @03:57PM (#3044955)
The bile makes people think twice before making assertions about things they know nothing about.

Truth and how it gets publicly propagated is more important than either of our egos.

Spend some time on Wikipedia, and you'll see what happens when ego wins over truth.

Re:Mojang vs. Bethesda Scrolls Case Heads to Court by wnight on Wednesday September 28, 2011 @01:21AM (#3046594)
> if Bethesda doesn't defend their claim on the "Elder Scrolls" name, they can lose it.

Only if there's a chance of the usage being misleading. Otherwise the usages are supposed to co-exist.

Anyways, the scrolls they refer to are actual scroll objects. They aren't using it in the slightest bit creatively.

A trademark on a game called 'The Sword of the Kingslayer' might conflict with another game called 'Spell for the Kingslayer', as they both follow the pattern '_ of/for the kingslayer' and kingslayer is a relatively unique word. Sword and spell are not.

> if I created a new game called "Warcraft"

Did Mojang create a game called TES: Oblivion? No.

So the appropriate analogy would be you creating a game called 'War', a generic thing not invented by Blizzard and not in any way exclusively associated with their games.