News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:27AM (#30415629)
>No capitalist would ever agree to the complete abolition of unemployment, to the abolition of the reserve army of unemployed, the purpose of which is to bring pressure on the labour market, to ensure a supply of cheap labour.

Marx and Adam Smith both highlighted this fundamental characteristic of capitalism, but it still rarely fails to blow Americans’ minds when I explain it to them.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mytailorisrich on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:00AM (#30415946)
In every system you need some slack otherwise the slightest hiccup brings everything to a halt.

Here the point is not to have an underclass of long-term, exploitable unemployed but to have some slack, ie. a minimum number of people available to ensure the system runs smoothly without shortages and hindrance to business growth and change.

Low unemployment is good and desirable but shortages are not.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mcv on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:42AM (#30416370)
I think the goal of no unemployment is a false one. The real goal has to be no poverty. Employment is only important because it provides people with an income that saves them from poverty (or at least should; too many jobs still pay poverty wages).

If a society had a basic income for everybody, the unemployed wouldn't be poor, and would still be available for work if the demand for extra labour was high enough.

Although ultimately, I do think that eventually automation should lead to less people having to work. Or perhaps preferably: people having to work less; we should also get rid of the 40+ hour work week, so we can divide the available work more equally, while also making sure everybody has enough time to enjoy the fruits of their labour.

And part-time work also provides the needed slack in the system without condemning anyone to poverty.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:08AM (#30416015)
The question at hand concerns who pays the price when that slack runs out.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by VictorPath on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:05AM (#30415986)
> you need some slack

The slack can be heirs forgoing the size of their profits, by boosting wages where needed, as opposed to slack in the wages if the people doing all the work and creating all the wealth.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by refurb on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:33AM (#30415680)
I mean, the US and other countries have reached “full employment” on several occasions - a level of unemployment where effectively everyone who wants a job had one (the unemployed who do exist are the small fraction you cant eliminate as people are in between jobs or seek other opportunities - employment “friction”).
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by assbuttbuttass on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:02AM (#30415960)
"full employment" is a misleading term. Unemployment only counts people who have been actively looking for a job in the last 4 weeks, and so excludes many chronically unemployed. In addition underemployment is not counted at all: in today's "gig economy" many people can't find full time employment and have to work multiple part time jobs.

"Full employment" absolutely builds in the reserve army of labor power into the definition.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by VictorPath on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:03AM (#30415970)
This is the labor force participation rate for men in the US from 1948 to now from the US bureau of labor statistics

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11300001

Was 86% or above before 1950, never above 70% over the past 5 years. The trend has been downward the whole time.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by refurb on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:54AM (#30416499)
You realize the labor participation rate accounts for the retired? A stat that might change with the aging workforce?
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by VictorPath on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:23AM (#30416837)
According to the department of labor's bureau of labor statistics, it is the opposite of what you said.

From 2000 to 2020, the labor participation for men from 20 to 44 has fallen. Labor participation for men 45 to 54 varies from flat to down. The labor participation rate for men 55 and older has risen. Working age men are less employed than they were, retirement age men are more employed than they were.

https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-particip...

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by jillesvangurp on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:57AM (#30415902)
The main issue with that notion is that the statistics simply favor excluding a lot of people from being counted as employed or unemployed. There's a rather large third group of simply not working that is problematic in the sense that these people still need taking care off financially (healthcare, housing, education, etc.).

A lot of people that are not technically unemployed are also not working fall into a few groups: those that are dependent on others to work; those that are too young or too old to work; and those that have simply given up on the whole notion of working because they are no longer able to physically or mentally (or both).

And there is of course a big problem with poverty even among those that work. So unemployment figures look great. Poverty figures, not so much. IMHO basic income would be a fair and simple way to ensure we get rid of poverty that should not break capitalism.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mensetmanusman on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:21AM (#30416153)
Unemployment may bring to mind an image of someone banging on a door crying for a job to support their children, but these are the minority of cases.

Ideally, we would have a bigger safety net so that this would never happen.

There will sprays be a certain percentage of people where work is not a good option due to physical or mental disabilities. It is society’s role to help these people, and the wealthier society becomes, the easier this should be.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by cloutchaser on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:38AM (#30415717)
If you have a social safety net so that the unemployed can live somewhere and eat, under this definition do they count as unemployed?

And a second point, in my home country the government introduced rules where to have government benefits you have to work a little, painting your community, cutting grass in public places etc.

People on the left were outraged. How dare you give work to people on a government mandate, and tie unemployment benefits to it?

Yet that is precisely what Stalin just argued for there. A government can create full employment by creating jobs and forcing people to work. Why don't modern socialists support that?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by CapitalistCartr on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:50AM (#30415832)
During the Great Depression, the USA had the Civilian Conservation Corps, which made jobs for people, and got a lot of good stuff done.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by zokier on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:45AM (#30415775)
If you need to work to get money, it is no more benefit, it is employment. And with employment should come all the benefits of employment, meaning vacation days, insurances, proper wage (>minimum wage), etc.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by Sankozi on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:13AM (#30416061)
"you have to work a little"

It can easily be benefit for example if you work 1/8 time for 1/2 of pay.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by VictorPath on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:54AM (#30417229)
> People on the left were outraged. How dare you give work to people on a government mandate

The heirs who expropriate surplus labor time from those of us who work and create wealth are the ones who not work. Their wealth is from government mandate - the government was created by them to do this and enforce it. When are they to work?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by ARandumGuy on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:54AM (#30415865)
First off, Stalin is not the be all end all of socialist thought. In fact a lot (most?) people who call themselves socialist these days don't even like Stalin. Even if he was well liked, one can support someone's broader ideas without supporting every single individual position. It's not a contradiction to say "I like [person]'s ideas, except [specific idea], which is dumb."

Secondly, tying unemployment benefits to community service is a blunt tool, that can directly hurt those trying to get unemployment. Some people need more time to find a job or improve their own skills, and spending time mowing the lawn may be counterproductive to that. Some people can work, but they may have disabilities that prevent them from doing whatever community service jobs are available. And finally, some people just can't work at all, and they shouldn't have to go through hoops to prove that to receive the benefits they need to live.

Finally, many on the left (including myself) reject the notion that living necessities should be tied to employment at all. Everyone should have access to food, shelter, clothing, and healthcare, regardless of their employment status. This includes people who can work, but choose not to. Work should not be a requirement to live a comfortable life.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by yazantapuz on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:20AM (#30416137)
> Work should not be a requirement to live a comfortable life.

_Someone else_ will we working to give you a comfortable life.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mcv on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:47AM (#30416422)
> _Someone else_ will we working to give you a comfortable life.

Robots, preferably.

We're not there yet, but it would be a nice goal. And certainly a lot better than having robots do all the work but the fruits of their work going only to the rich who own them.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by CodeGlitch on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:59AM (#30416556)
Yes this is why anything to do with ai should be open source. It can be too powerful in the hands of bad actors.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by cloutchaser on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:29AM (#30417622)
> Yes this is why anything to do with ai should be open source. It can be too powerful in the hands of bad actors

Maybe read your sentence again. Carefully...

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by CodeGlitch on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:34AM (#30417681)
By being open source = democratising

Bad actors start using ai to do bad things. Good actors use ai to counter bad actors.

Or is that not what you meant?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mensetmanusman on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:23AM (#30416170)
This will be true for all of us at some point in our lives (usually at the extremities). We should embrace the notion of paying it forward.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mcv on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:45AM (#30416407)
> In fact a lot (most?) people who call themselves socialist these days don't even like Stalin.

That could also be because he was a murderous dictator, and not necessarily have anything to do with his economic ideas. (Although some of his economic ideas, and they way they were implemented in particular, lead to lots of death too.)

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mantas on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:46AM (#30415793)
... and it was illegal to not work in USSR.... The modern socialists who expect to have plenty of time for themselves in their dream regime would be so disappointed.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by refurb on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:53AM (#30415857)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitism_(social_offense)

In the Soviet Union, which declared itself a workers' state, every adult able-bodied person was expected to work until official retirement. Thus unemployment was officially and theoretically eliminated. Those who refused to work, study or serve in another way risked being criminally charged with social parasitism

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:05AM (#30415989)
In other words, rent-seekers in the USSR were called what they are (parasites) and they received the same treatment that the US gives to it’s unemployed and homeless, except the US maintains an economic system that guarantees an unemployed and homeless population.

If you think you’re making the USSR appear less reasonable than the US, maybe think again.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mantas on Monday February 21, 2022 @11:08AM (#30417374)
In USSR you couldn't own much, thus rent-seeking was not possible.

House ownership was limited per-square-meter (varies on exact period and location). Most rooms/apartments were technically state property and you just rented them. Building „cooperative“ apartments where one would own it was a rather late development. And even then I believe limits of apartments-to-own were in place.

On the other hand, room-renting was tolerated in two cases. Resorts (no enough spots in hotels) and university towns (no enough places in dormitories). In resorts locals would move to, for example, garages to make money from renting their own apartments to holiday goers. Students renting was usually old lady business where after your kids are gone and husband dies you rent spare rooms.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by yazantapuz on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:18AM (#30416112)
> rent-seekers in the USSR were called what they are (parasites)

So, if I plan to live from rents that i earn from my past work i am a parasite?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:30AM (#30416236)
Rent is attained by controlling access to capital that you own, according to the state.

Wages are attained by selling your labor to someone else.

Which is it?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by yazantapuz on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:36AM (#30416304)
I have earned a certain capital selling my labour. That capital is now working for me (some rent, bounds, etc). Why you think that someone doing these is a parasite?
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:05AM (#30416618)
Capital doesn’t “work”. People work. These are just objective English language definitions. What you’re saying is simply nonsensical. Can you try explaining again?

Wrt “earning capital,” you may have purchased capital, but you sold your labor for wages.

Compensation paid as stock options are an exception, and are a result of New Deal reforms to get more working people bought into the capitalist system, which has been successful, so far. But owning stocks is not the same as owning capital because you still do not control the capital and therefore cannot collect rents. Realize capitalists never directly trade the capital for the labor to operate that capital, unless forced. Historically, only communists have ever forced such a thing.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by mensetmanusman on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:26AM (#30416199)
As strange as it may seem, the us also has a system that respects the rights of people who want to be homeless nomads.

If people want to be homeless due to mental health issues, there is no easy way out if the government is allowed to overrule someone who says ‘No! Don’t help me!’

Very difficult ethical issues all around.

In our area, we have shelter beds open and people sleeping in the cold outside of the building…

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:03AM (#30416591)
How do you explain the astronomical numbers of homeless people in the US, for example, compared with so many other wealthy nations?

Are you seriously suggesting that so many millions of Americans just happen to love being homeless? Is this a joke?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by seneca on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:06AM (#30416629)
> Are you seriously suggesting that so many millions of Americans just happen to love being homeless? Is this a joke?

The person you're replying to didn't say any such things. Your replies on this post have followed a pattern of lazy swipes, and degrade the quality of discussion here.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:42AM (#30417079)
My replies have followed a pattern of logical deduction and clarifying inquiry. Can you answer my questions?
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by thodin on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:13AM (#30416067)
It was difficult to be rentier in USSR because it was officially forbidden to "own" even 2 apartments at the same time.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:44AM (#30417094)
Sounds like a great law.
Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by refurb on Monday February 21, 2022 @08:49PM (#30423169)
Those are some impressive mental gymnastics.

Regardless, the USSR was heavy on the “you don’t carry the water, you don’t drink”.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by Shin-- on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:05AM (#30415992)
A collectivistic society expects everyone to do their part to reach a good standard of living for everyone. 8 hours/day, as was common, to rebuild destroyed countries and economy is less than countless people in capitalist nations have to work today. The biggest difference is, is that this amount of labour is necessary for their own survival, that there is no collective sense, without authorities trying to reward them in some ways to keep them happy, or even showing any appreciation for the work they do.

Socialists don't say that socialism would suddenly lead to less work for everyone, a revolution and rebuilding after a revolution is a lot of hard work, but the work is done for the collective good, not to make a few even richer. It shall have meaning and be valued by society. And yes, eventually - even Marx talked about it already - work that is not necessary and labour that can be automated will become more free time for everyone.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by yucky on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:40AM (#30417043)
>a revolution is a lot of hard work, but the work is done for the collective good, not to make a few even richer.

Does this ever happen in reality though?

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by krapp on Monday February 21, 2022 @01:48PM (#30419239)
No. I think every revolution serves the interests of the elites.

Even the American Revolution was essentially a tax evasion scheme by the wealthy merchant class.

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by nopenopenopeno on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:12AM (#30416047)
> A government can create full employment by creating jobs and forcing people to work. Why don't modern socialists support that?

I am myself a politically active Marxist and we do say this, but we also understand that this isn’t going to happen. Keynesianism was not a sustainable solution. It only bought time. Ultimately states in capitalist societies are in service of capital. In the US, realize the 1970s financial overhaul, including the Bretton Woods System, was the capitalist response to the New Deal giving workers too much power. 1960s inflation hit the ruling class and they responded by brutalizing the economy. See: https://wtfhappenedin1971.com

Re:Marxism vs. Liberalism: An Interview Between J.V. Stalin ... by dW4XWxH5Rxsh5rC on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:43AM (#30416385)
>Marx and Adam Smith both highlighted this fundamental characteristic of capitalism

In what part of his works does Adam Smith says something like that?