This same argument be made to justify any erosion of personal privacy. With the level of technical sophistication western society has now, just about any invasion of privacy is too cheap to meter. Take IoT for instance. Just because it's possible for large corporations to infringe upon the privacy of individuals for pennies doesn't mean that we should just go ahead and accept it.
Also, if people riot, there is no way to be sure that a positive thing will happen. We can clearly see this from Arab Spring. Many people thought there would be liberation, but what we got in return? Dictators got removed, just to be replaced by another dictator. In fact, it backfired and now autocrats have more power than past. Those days are gone where we ended horrific things like slavery and liberated the world with democracy. We have become too greedy with the capitalist society, as indicated by covid scenario. Sorry, for digressing.
Bruning down building is more of a bug than a feature.
We have certain freedoms (e.g., speech) combined with a (relatively) free market. This opens opportunities for capitalists to monetize data they collect.
Even without monetization, some data is made public that some would prefer to keep private (e.g., a journalist can publish a photo of a politician on a boat with his mistress).
I don't see how we can put the genie back in the bottle so long as we have free speech and free markets. I think the PRC could, for example, restrict distribution of DNA data if it wanted to. I would prefer not to live under such an authoritarian regime.
I am asking if executing people to get more privacy is a desired outcome over adapting to a world where things we formerly thought of as private are just well known.
I hope for their sake that the capitalists realize this before it’s too late for everyone.
Would the owner of a security camera have requirements on how they handle their data?
I am interested in how free speech and free markets enable the interesting effects we are now seeing. Maybe the answer is that there should be stricter controls on everything. That does not seem very likely to me.
That's a grey area. I think it should be illegal if the goal of the photos is to track a person, and legal if the goal is to document a scene. And yes, that's a classification that we can do. We can apply the same rule to the people buying the photos, so it's illegal to go around buying photos about the movement of somebody even if no photographer did anything illegal.
> Would Google Analytics become illegal?
If they sell personal data? Without a doubt. Currently, AFAIK, they don't.
> Would the owner of a security camera have requirements on how they handle their data?
Yes, he can't sell it.
> If they sell personal data? Without a doubt. Currently, AFAIK, they don't.
Google can obviously construct a dossier on a person from his analytics cookie. It’s okay for Google to have this data so long as they do not sell it, just sell access to it to advertisers or release it to governments?
I am trying to imagine the state capable of enforcing such a law. I don’t think that is where anyone wants to live.
That still doesn't imply that DNA will be shared freely. On the contrary, it is important that we ensure that people retain control over their own genetic information.
Filming porn is going to be so cheap it's going to happen to everyone anyway
Now your new employer obviously doesn't have access to your DNA, but he has an active subscription to "NaturalCheck(tm)whatever" which does have access to most people's DNAs.
Sorry, we can't hire you, your NaturalCheck came back as red.
You call NaturalCheck, after getting tossed through 2-3 support staff you finally learn your dna has some markers for some kind of cancer. Welcome to a new world.
P.S. If you think this is unrealistic: Credit check? Credit score? I see people have no problem with this stuff...
Potential employers also have photos of me that indicate my skin color. We have laws against discrimination over some attributes.
Technically illegal and enforcably illegal are not the same. People with pregnancies or disabilities get fired all the time; as long as they're not putting "we're firing you for getting prengant" in writing somewhere, chances are they get away with it.
Same here, they will say they care about equal rights, but in reality they oust pregnant ladies, old peoples etc..
They should be forbidden from doing so. Not forbidden from using it for discrimination; forbidden from obtaining or posessing or sequencing an employee's DNA without their express consent, even via a third party.
> I am arguing that DNA is not the most "sensitive" personal data.
"The most" is debatable, and to some extent a matter of opinion. "One of the most" is hard to argue. It's highly personal information.
>They should be forbidden from doing so. Not forbidden from using it for discrimination; forbidden from obtaining or posessing or sequencing an employee's DNA without their express consent, even via a third party.
I am imagining that sequencing will be so cheap and ubiquitous that it will be like Facebook glasses (or whatever they are called now). Restaurants will sequence food to ensure provenance and quality. Environments will be sampling the air looking for viruses. Toilets will sequence whatever goes into them to find pathogens, both at the service of their owners and their users. I am not saying this is good. I am saying it is inevitable. Not tomorrow, but it's coming. Given that, I consider the personal data I have choice over to be more sensitive.
>"The most" is debatable, and to some extent a matter of opinion. "One of the most" is hard to argue. It's highly personal information.
Agreed. I am arguing with the statement as written in the article.
> This seems a bogus assertion to me. I can imagine many diagnostic health test results that would be more sensitive to leak than DNA (e.g., STD and drug tests).
> DNA sequencing is eventually going to be so cheap and ubiquitous that it will happen to everyone anyway.
> Having published my own results (https://enki.org/2017/10/17/publishing-my-genome/), I really don’t buy into the idea that DNA is the most personal data that can be leaked.
> (Nevertheless, there should be more obvious warnings to customers about how their data will be monetized.)
> In the article there is a quote, “There is no personal data more sensitive than our DNA.“
> This seems a bogus assertion to me. I can imagine many diagnostic health test results that would be more sensitive to leak than DNA (e.g., STD and drug tests).
It's still PHI, and in this case subject to at least the Data Protection Act. The walk-in centers at Gatwick and Heathrow may have tested non-UK citizens. If so, they may run into compliance issues with GDPR or other privacy regs. Not sure how that plays out.
Guess I'll have to wait for the investigation results....
> Having published my own results (https://enki.org/2017/10/17/publishing-my-genome/), I really don’t buy into the idea that DNA is the most personal data that can be leaked.
Being as (at least in the US) DNA is used as evidence to conclusively identify (or exclude) those accused of crime (i.e. rape kits, etc) I'd say that a court of law would consider it to be essentially personal info.
Even if that is true, societies should still take extra care to protect the interests of minorities, since they typically suffer disproportionate consequences from human rights abuses.
To give a hypothetical example, if someone had Jewish ancestry and also a diagnosis that they had diabetes, I would guess that they'd want the first piece of information to have more protection than the second.
Of course the situation may be different in different countries and for different people (who I am not qualified to speak on behalf of), but I'm just cautioning against seeing DNA as being somehow "neutral".
I think that's a reasonable framing. Would you perhaps also accept the claim that "DNA is the most personal data that can be known about someone"?
It's true in the reductive sense that a person is made of cells and the information content of those cells is their DNA, but it's also true in the more nuanced sense that millions of people might share the same diagnosis as you (or even the same shameful secret), but no one who has ever lived, or will ever live, shares your DNA (unless you have an identical twin, or get cloned).
I am intrigued that someone might genuinely think otherwise. Would anyone rather have their browser history published over their DNA?
One way to look at it is that someone's choices (and the pages they've visited) are things in their past, and even a medical diagnosis could be old news if they've since been cured. Their unique DNA signature, on the other hand, has been with them since before they were born, and will remain with them, largely unchanged, for the rest of their life, and even some time beyond. (Their DNA may also have a big effect on when they die, and the sort of life they live while they are alive too).
That's why DNA feels to me like it's an intrinsic part of someone's personhood, in a way that "They visited Hacker News yesterday" doesn't.
That said, I am not sure how this can be prevented either. We leave traces of our DNA everywhere.
For some people, a tiny amount of peanuts is deadly. The rest of us can gorge on them without any ill effects whatsoever.
Perhaps there many other such substances that cause a runaway reaction in a tiny minority of people. We do not know.
Photography is so cheap and ubiquitous that it happens to everyone anyway. That still doesn't mean it's OK for you to sell photos of me in a private setting without my permission.
It's nice that you've chosen to publish your own genome but I bet you'd feel a little different if someone else had published it without your consent.
ADDED: For those disagreeing: In general, I'll generally respect your wishes if you don't want your photo taken. But (in the US) if you're in a public place, you have no legal recourse (outside of some specific commercial uses). And that's how things are and will continue to be.
Secondly, there is a lot of hand waving on that page. The bottom line is that if I take a picture of you in a public space like a park and publish it without a misleading caption on my blog, you have no real recourse (although the reality is that if it was just there for no particular purpose and you asked me to take it down after the fact I probably would).
This seems a bogus assertion to me. I can imagine many diagnostic health test results that would be more sensitive to leak than DNA (e.g., STD and drug tests).
DNA sequencing is eventually going to be so cheap and ubiquitous that it will happen to everyone anyway.
Having published my own results (https://enki.org/2017/10/17/publishing-my-genome/), I really don’t buy into the idea that DNA is the most personal data that can be leaked.
(Nevertheless, there should be more obvious warnings to customers about how their data will be monetized.)
Edit: I think I failed to make clear that while I agree that DNA is "personal" data, I don't think it is the most "sensitive" personal data. If I had an identical twin and he released his DNA, I would not care. If I had syphilis and my test results were leaked, I would be upset about that.