News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by ajxs on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:24AM (#30384850)
> DNA sequencing is eventually going to be so cheap and ubiquitous that it will happen to everyone anyway.

This same argument be made to justify any erosion of personal privacy. With the level of technical sophistication western society has now, just about any invasion of privacy is too cheap to meter. Take IoT for instance. Just because it's possible for large corporations to infringe upon the privacy of individuals for pennies doesn't mean that we should just go ahead and accept it.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:35AM (#30384950)
It does not matter how we feel about it. Every license plate scanner, every Ring doorbell, every security camera I walk by is potentially selling data.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by ClumsyPilot on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:40AM (#30385000)
It does, if people actually cared they'd be rioting in the streets, maybe burn down some corporate headquarters
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by cute_boi on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:31AM (#30385458)
People do care about privacy. But, they don't have any power. Many people have to go to work, and they don't have time to fiddle in rioting etc. And, there is high chance that these people will be called terrorist for rioting such things. In fact some will even claim they are destroying property, and they should be incarcerated. And, there can be cases like rats in the group are taking advantage of protest. We can see this with BLM where few people deceived entire world by committing shenanigans in name of doing deeds.

Also, if people riot, there is no way to be sure that a positive thing will happen. We can clearly see this from Arab Spring. Many people thought there would be liberation, but what we got in return? Dictators got removed, just to be replaced by another dictator. In fact, it backfired and now autocrats have more power than past. Those days are gone where we ended horrific things like slavery and liberated the world with democracy. We have become too greedy with the capitalist society, as indicated by covid scenario. Sorry, for digressing.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:42AM (#30385016)
Would burning down a building make it illegal to sell photos taken in public places?
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by ClumsyPilot on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:24AM (#30385373)
Well getting millions of people out to protest should, otherwise do we have a democracy?

Bruning down building is more of a bug than a feature.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by gilrain on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:50AM (#30385091)
That’s what the French aristocracy thought about their masses too. The masses then executed the French aristocracy.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:52AM (#30385105)
Would such executions lead to laws prohibiting the sale of photos taken in public? Would that be a better outcome?
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by gilrain on Friday February 18, 2022 @07:57AM (#30385146)
This question is entirely irrelevant, yet you seem fixated on it.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:14AM (#30385281)
Maybe I am not spelling it out enough.

We have certain freedoms (e.g., speech) combined with a (relatively) free market. This opens opportunities for capitalists to monetize data they collect.

Even without monetization, some data is made public that some would prefer to keep private (e.g., a journalist can publish a photo of a politician on a boat with his mistress).

I don't see how we can put the genie back in the bottle so long as we have free speech and free markets. I think the PRC could, for example, restrict distribution of DNA data if it wanted to. I would prefer not to live under such an authoritarian regime.

I am asking if executing people to get more privacy is a desired outcome over adapting to a world where things we formerly thought of as private are just well known.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by gilrain on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:30AM (#30385445)
Also, sure, one can debate whether the masses were right to execute the aristocracy… but surely we can all agree that the aristocracy were lethally wrong that the masses didn’t matter.

I hope for their sake that the capitalists realize this before it’s too late for everyone.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by gilrain on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:27AM (#30385412)
It’s not so much the loss of privacy, as the inevitable, violent exploitation of the weak that it does, will, and is meant to enable.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @08:46AM (#30385582)
I think we are in agreement that corporations, governments, religions, etc. will use personal data to harm people. I am less convinced that DNA is the most "sensitive" personal data.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by marcosdumay on Friday February 18, 2022 @10:23AM (#30386862)
That's why selling it should be heavily punished.
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @10:56AM (#30387337)
I am interested in how you would punish such vendors. What would make a piece of data illegal?
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by postsantum on Friday February 18, 2022 @01:12PM (#30389097)
Same that makes some drugs illegal?
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Friday February 18, 2022 @04:16PM (#30391231)
I am looking for specifics. Would photographers no longer be able to take photos of people in public and sell them? Would it be illegal for one to sell web server log files? Would Google Analytics become illegal?

Would the owner of a security camera have requirements on how they handle their data?

I am interested in how free speech and free markets enable the interesting effects we are now seeing. Maybe the answer is that there should be stricter controls on everything. That does not seem very likely to me.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by marcosdumay on Friday February 18, 2022 @04:59PM (#30391670)
> Would photographers no longer be able to take photos of people in public and sell them?

That's a grey area. I think it should be illegal if the goal of the photos is to track a person, and legal if the goal is to document a scene. And yes, that's a classification that we can do. We can apply the same rule to the people buying the photos, so it's illegal to go around buying photos about the movement of somebody even if no photographer did anything illegal.

> Would Google Analytics become illegal?

If they sell personal data? Without a doubt. Currently, AFAIK, they don't.

> Would the owner of a security camera have requirements on how they handle their data?

Yes, he can't sell it.

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Saturday February 19, 2022 @08:11AM (#30396893)
> > Would Google Analytics become illegal?

> If they sell personal data? Without a doubt. Currently, AFAIK, they don't.

Google can obviously construct a dossier on a person from his analytics cookie. It’s okay for Google to have this data so long as they do not sell it, just sell access to it to advertisers or release it to governments?

Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by postsantum on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:35PM (#30401986)
Is it legal to own heroin, not sell it to anyone, but have guests over and offer them some (for a payment)?
Re:Covid testing firm ‘selling swabs carrying customers’ DNA... by mcculley on Saturday February 19, 2022 @08:08AM (#30396878)
> We can apply the same rule to the people buying the photos, so it's illegal to go around buying photos about the movement of somebody even if no photographer did anything illegal.

I am trying to imagine the state capable of enforcing such a law. I don’t think that is where anyone wants to live.