News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by yanmaani on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @03:39PM (#30352363)
I think I want to disagree with the central point of the article here: As a payment mechanism, Bitcoin is final. As a store of value, it isn't unseizable. But from a technical PoV, they still had to make a new transaction in order to reverse the effects of the old one.

I want to clarify that this isn't just a technical point: if I have $100 in account A, and I use a card processor to move it to account B, and then the holder of that account withdraws it, then the card processor can still reverse the transaction, leading B with a debt of $100.

(This is actually a common scam: you send someone $1000 with a 'soft' payment method, like a check, then you have them buy gift cards and send the codes. Once the check bounces, you split.)

If I do the same thing in Bitcoin, that's not possible. If Bitfinex hackers had used Bitcoin qua payment processor to move $70MM, then exchanged the Bitcoin into something else, the Bitcoin transaction could never have been reversed. Only the custody, which is a different thing.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by lxgr on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @03:48PM (#30352475)
The distinction is certainly one worth making (reversibility within the ledger vs. "meta-reversibility" in the context of the social/legal system that ledger is embedded), and not just at an academic level as underlined by your example.

In my view, both matter when trying to understand a payment system.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by yanmaani on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:06PM (#30352729)
I don't understand - how is the custody even part of the payment system, though?

For example, if I keep all my money in the bank, then cash is only as reversible as my bank account is solid. But "cash as a payment method is reversible, if you store the proceeds in a bank account" is not a statement that tells you anything about cash, it's a statement about my bank account.

It would be a solid article if it attempted to argue the point it proves, which is that "there is no such thing as unseizable". But it doesn't, so it isn't.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by gojomo on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:54PM (#30353308)
Indeed, ~patio11 has glossed over the distinction between ‘definitely reversible’ & ‘possibly recoverable’ here - which can be a salient difference.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by wewtyflakes on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @05:31PM (#30353780)
I think the sentiment of the article was that all of these technical details and nuances are ultimately irrelevant to governments that control armies. Those government can even legislate ridiculous things (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nix_v._Hedden).
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by EdwardDiego on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @09:30PM (#30355691)
Huh, they legally enforced the old saying "intelligence is knowing that a tomato is a fruit, wisdom is not putting tomato in a fruit salad".
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by olalonde on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @06:06PM (#30354149)
> it isn't unseizable

It can be, with a memorized seed phrase and some willpower. I'm still amazed that the technically inclined Bitfinex hackers managed to get their wallet seized.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by noah_buddy on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @11:56PM (#30356507)
What's the xkcd... Something something, $15 dollar wrench? The application here is this:

We (the US govt) know you (the hackers) did it. Cough up the cash and go to prison for a long time or don't and go for much much longer.

Suddenly, the money is seized.

That said, there are arguments to be made about that money as a bargaining chip if you keep the wallets 'unseizable' (until you cough it up for an offer).

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by olalonde on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @02:28AM (#30357257)
I specifically included "some willpower" because I knew someone would bring that up. Technically, if you stand your ground and go to prison for a long time (or are going to prison for a long time regardless), the money won't be seized. Similarly, if you forget your passphrase or die, the money won't be seized. Or if you have a multisig wallet setup and your accomplices don't get caught, the money won't be seized. I believe there are multiple actual instances of the FBI not being able to seize rather large Bitcoin wallets.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by wpietri on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:07PM (#30352734)
You're right about the technical distinction, but I think you're incorrect that Bitcoin is truly final. Bitcoin may not have reversed a transaction yet, but it's technically feasible. Note that Ethereum did it: https://futurism.com/the-dao-heist-undone-97-of-eth-holders-...

Bitcoin mining is very concentrated, so if one or more of the major miners is robbed, it's entirely plausible that similarly situated entities would collaborate and just undo the transaction.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by olalonde on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:45PM (#30353205)
Actually the transaction wasn't reversed, a distinct cryptocurrency was created (a "fork") which reversed the transaction. The new cryptocurrency adopted the name Ethereum and it became way more popular than the original, so the original had to rebrand to "Ethereum Classic" to avoid confusion. The new cryptocurrency was successful largely thanks to Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin endorsing it. Similar "attacks" were attempted on Bitcoin multiple times (e.g. Bitcoin Cash) but they never quite succeeded and are unlikely to succeed thanks to Bitcoin lacking some sort of active founder/leader. For a Bitcoin hard fork to succeed, there would need to be a large consensus not only among miners, but among users, merchants, exchanges, etc.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by wpietri on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:58PM (#30353376)
So it sounds like we agree: It's unlikely but impossible, and so patio11 is correct to say that finality does not exist, and that it's just a probability distribution for each channel.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by olalonde on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @05:36PM (#30353817)
I disagree that the Ethereum fork confirms the idea that the transaction wasn't final. It was final and still is.

That being said, I do think patio11 is technically correct, given his unconventionally strict definition of "finality".

Probability is at the core of Bitcoin's proof of work security mechanism. There is a non zero probability that I could rewrite the whole Bitcoin transaction history in the next 15 minutes, if my miner gets really, really, really lucky. The chances of that happening are of course abysmally small and not worth considering. For all practical purposes, Bitcoin transactions are final past a few confirmations.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by wpietri on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:27PM (#30354872)
I think you are using a very technical definition of "final". Both the purpose and the real-world effect of the fork was to make an apparently final transaction no longer final. That it is still "final" in at best a distraction to the general-audience meaning of "final".

I estimate the probability of a similar Bitcoin action to be small, but much larger than the "miner gets really, really, really lucky" scenario you propose. Do you disagree?

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by olalonde on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @03:00AM (#30357437)
I wouldn't say it's just technical. The Ethereum Classic chain, where the transaction lives on, still exists and is now worth ~3x more than it was at the time of the hack. If the hacker kept their ETC (not sure if they did) they would still have 118M$ USD today. And regardless, the probability that any one transaction will be reversed by a fork of the Bitcoin blockchain are vastly smaller. There have been tons of hacks in Bitcoin's history already and no transactions were reversed. Bitcoin doesn't have a clear head.

> I estimate the probability of a similar Bitcoin action to be small, but much larger than the "miner gets really, really, really lucky" scenario you propose. Do you disagree?

Of course, I agree. That being said, I'd still put the probability in the vanishingly small category, especially for any individual transaction that isn't an exploit, and not worth considering in the context of "finality", as the term is commonly used (and not as patio11 defines it).

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by opportune on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:27PM (#30352977)
But as the article notes this was actually a hard fork off the chain known up to that time at Ethereum. It’s really just semantics that the old chain became known as Ethereum Classic and the hard-forked chain maintained the name of “Ethereum” due to the active developers and most of the community choosing to use the hard fork.

The payment was still never actually reversed on Ethereum Classic. And that blockchain exists to this day. Sure, the amount of the not-actually-reversed transaction has lost value in $ at mark-to-market but it’s still the same amount of ether on the same blockchain as it’s always been.

In that sense a better term is that the payment was rejected by the community, or routed around, rather than reversed IMO.

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by mLuby on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:39PM (#30353145)
That Ethereum Classic never reversed is true but largely meaningless; what matters, as you say, is that "the not-actually-reversed transaction has lost value in $ at mark-to-market." That loss in value represents the reversal. If that hadn't happened, the original and fork could be double-spent.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by opportune on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @05:29PM (#30353755)
The difference in value of ETH classic and ETH grew over time though. It hasn’t always been so stark. I don’t care enough about the specifics of the “bad” txs to check when/if the funds were sent out of the receiving wallets but they might have recovered the same or similar amount of value in $.

Anyway, I just find this a really bad example in general because it’s 1 an exceptional case, most other hard forks haven’t been done just for transactions 2 it required almost the entire community to choose to follow the hard fork (which is the only thing that actually destroys value). Yes, it does show that you can do something like a payment reversal in crypto but it’s very hard and unlikely. In this case the exception proves the rule

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by yanmaani on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:30PM (#30353005)
I don't think it's possible to draw any conclusions about what would happen to Bitcoin, you're running into the fundamental limits of the problem of induction here.

In particular, Bitcoin mining is concentrated into a small number of pools, but the amount of actual power they hold is very questionable. Because nobody censors transactions, we can't know if miners would flee or not if they began to.

English banknotes are printed by De La Rue plc, but it's not like they have a stranglehold on the English economy. If they began to act up, their 'power' would dry up very quickly.

Also, even with 100% of miners cooperating, reversing a two week old transaction would still take two weeks. There are some technical issues with this, since new transaction would grind to a halt and it would generally be a mess.

Note how Ethereum wasn't miners collaborating (soft fork), it was a hard fork, which required no miner cooperation at all.

A hard fork of Bitcoin in this way is indeed possible, but would require the consent of a lot of entities. Ethereum is much more 'socially' centralized in terms of its governance process, and it was very obvious that if they didn't go along with it, then the big, centralized entity that held all the proceeds from the ICO would stop paying the developers, and the PR goons, and and and...

I'm not going to draw any conclusions about the future based on this, but we can observe that big players (Binance) have lost money, publicly considered 51% attacks, then backed down. We can also observe the fate of Marathon's OFAC pool - he didn't fly so good, who wants to try next?

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by wpietri on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @05:00PM (#30353396)
I didn't make any claims about what would happen. Just that patio11 is correct that no transaction is truly final, because a Bitcoin transaction reversal is unlikely but not impossible.
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by beaned on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:27PM (#30352971)
Is it that concentrated? People used to criticize that it was concentrated in China, and then that changed basically overnight when mining was shut down the. Now people still say this but how much is it true?
Re:Finality does not exist in payments by kayamon on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @06:17PM (#30354266)
Transactions have already been reversed on Bitcoin via successful hard-forks:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=823.0

Re:Finality does not exist in payments by yanmaani on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @06:43PM (#30354517)
That's not a hard fork. A hard fork makes a previously invalid transaction valid; this made a previously valid transaction invalid, e.g. a soft fork. Bitcoin has had many soft forks.