I'm sure the 100M fine didn't feel great but unless it bankrupts the company I doubt that BlockFi would want to go backwards now. For the low price of 100M they now have a map of how to legally do business in the space, in a way that is now much scarier to any would be new entrants.
At its most optimistic I think crypto is trying to avoid some of these regulatory rube goldberg value extraction machines. Maybe it will in some spots, but you can see too where it may also just reinvent them.
“They now have a map”
Regulators won’t generally tell you how to comply with a rule, often because they don’t know.
So you force them to make a ruling and then have a proprietary roadmap.
What was learned in those meetings by both parties is a huge moat.
In the end, the SEC just got a hefty pay day for doing their job.
If you focus on the centralized institituions like cryptocurrency<>centralized currencies exchanges, or centralized lending platforms, then yeah, they sure get closer and closer to classical finance (except being based around decentralized platforms).
But if you look at actual cryptocurrencies, without focusing on the exchanges or any other centralized parties, they actually get further and further away from classical finance. But it requires you to read GitHub/IRC/Matrix/Forum discussions between developers, rather than following reported news.
A whole bunch of these startups have sprung up; which take up real money (USDT or even USD, INR etc.,) promising very attractive guaranteed returns without locking up customers' fund. Look at these[1] for examples. Anyone who knows anything about banking in the traditional world knows how ridiculous it is. And indeed some of these are beginning to unravel[2]. In Anchor's case there are way more lenders than borrowers so Anchor is resorting to pay those high yields from their reserves. It's cutting close to being a Ponzi scheme at the moment.
In a traditional banking world businesses take a loan either to cover for a short-term cashflow crunch (example an invoice that's delayed by their client) or for longer term investment. That money usually goes into economic activities which are expected (hoped?) to bear fruit to repay the loan.
In the crypto world however such loans are taken only to be put back into the crypto world; to be swapped into some hot new coin to be staked and what not. The music has got to stop at some point.
I'm really glad SEC has been proactive. I hope regulators in other countries do so. Because 99% of the money flowing into these are totally guidable and clueless people; they need to be protected for their own sake.
[1] https://www.pillow.fund [1] https://www.flint.money
[2] https://au.finance.yahoo.com/news/anchor-protocol-reserves-s...
Is your startup going after the consumers? If most prospective customers are clueless, and many of the remaining customers are sharks or early investors looking for suckers, that doesn't bode well for new companies in this space, even the ones that are trying to do things right.
Me and my co-founders are committing ourselves into this for the long haul (think ~10 years) so are taking it slow. We hope our deliberate, slow and steady approach will help us tide over the current short term bubble and the imminent burst.
A related problem is not even depositing but simply granting token approval to a scam app, and similar techniques may be used to warn users before they give these approvals.
The agencies played a large role enabling the mortgage bubble that popped in 2008. They were essentially selling ratings to bond issuers without any real attention to the quality of the loans underlying the bonds.
Unless regulators shut them down or expose them quite clearly as mlm/ frauds I suspect this isn’t going to stop.
It seems, based on this action that the SEC just went through with, that things like BlockFi are not "clearly MLM / fraud" as you say, as otherwise they would indeed try to get them shutdown, not just slap a tiny fine on them.
It does if they are selling securities (either as their main business or securities for their business).
The FTC does regular MLMs.
> Herbalife and Lularoe operate in broad daylight.
Herbalife was restructured to settle a pyramid-scheme lawsuit by the FTC. [0] And subsequently also settled a lawsuit from the SEC. [1]
LulaRoe has managed not to be sued by the FTC, but that seems mostly to be because that process is complaint driven and the complaints have instead either gone to state regulators or directly into private lawsuits; LulaRoe has a pile of direct- and class-action lawsuits from distributors, settled a State of Washington lawsuit for $4.75 million, has been sued by it's main supplier, etc.
[0] https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/blog/2016/07/restructured-herba...
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/lisettevoytko/2019/09/27/herbal...
> The order also finds that BlockFi made a false and misleading statement for more than two years on its website concerning the level of risk in its loan portfolio and lending activity.
> Without admitting or denying the SEC’s findings, BlockFi agreed to a cease-and-desist order prohibiting it from violating the registration and antifraud provisions of the Securities Act and the registration provisions of the Investment Company Act. BlockFi also agreed to cease offering or selling BIAs in the United States.
But I'll make a guess and say that they probably downplayed the risks in one way or another on their website, compared to statements made to the SEC. Let's say they say "It's risk-free!" on their website while in a statement to the SEC they say "There is a small risk customer lose their funds if X happens".
In other words, BlockFi failed to do the bare minimum to run a financial investment service, and are now getting punished for it. That doesn't sound like a overreach to me.
And yeah, in general, laws are usually interpreted subjectively, as laws usually give some wiggle-room to make sure it covers enough ground without having to write 1000 pages about every single edge-case.
This hugely successful company wants to exist legally and understand the laws that apply to them. This much has been obvious for a long time now.
No, they are not. The SEC's goal is to protect consumers and the general public, and like most other regulatory agencies, have been doing a good job at it.
I feel like there is a growing distrust in the government (at least in the US) and this is not a good thing. If you don't like what the SEC is doing, get involved in a democractic way (voting, organizing, etc.) and change it.
They do not value media attention. They're not politicians, and that's not how any of this works.
Page 9 of the PDF of the actual order (linked on the page under "SEC Order") explains how BlockFi made misleading claims:
> From March 2019 through August 2021, BlockFi misrepresented on its website that its institutional loans were “typically” over-collateralized, when in fact, most institutional loans were not. Accordingly, although BlockFi made other disclosures on its website concerning its risk management practices, BIA investors did not have complete and accurate information with which to evaluate the risk that, in the event of defaults by BlockFi’s institutional borrowers, BlockFi would be unable to comply with its obligation to pay BIA investors the stated interest rates or return the loaned crypto assets to investors upon demand. This false and misleading statement was in the offer and sale of BIAs, and as such was in the offer and sale of securities.
You could say more or less the same thing about Bernie Madoff's fund, at least right up until the end. I'm not saying that BlockFi is doing anything wrong here, but simply having good results for a while in a bull market doesn't make everything magically ok.
There's are too many of those in the crypto space.
"Digital currency is not legal tender, is not backed by the government, and crypto accounts held with BlockFi are not subject to FDIC or SIPC protections. Digital currency values are not static and fluctuate due to market changes."
What I think has never been clear is how they were able to manage the risk of their lending practices, in order to provide the big APYs.
> From March 2019 through August 2021, BlockFi misrepresented on its website that its institutional loans were “typically” over-collateralized, when in fact, most institutional loans were not.
When they tell you your crypto is being lent to "institutional investors" what they really mean to say is they're gambling with your crypto in defi protocols, and you can see this happening on-chain.
No mention of the fine at all, and instead framed as "first SEC registered crypto interest-bearing security" (from BlockFi's page) rather than "[BlockFi] failing to register the offers and sales of its retail crypto lending product" and "the SEC also charged BlockFi with violating the registration provisions of the Investment Company Act of 1940" (both quotes from the SEC statement).
BlockFi also doesn't mention the "false and misleading statement for more than two years on its website" part that the SEC highlights, and instead says "Both the SEC and state-level agreements contain no admission or denial of wrongdoing or liability."
Going to be interesting to see how the space develops moving forward. Hopefully companies that continue to mislead people will eventually disappear, or at least not be this popular among the masses.