News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by mind-blight on Saturday February 12, 2022 @05:18PM (#30317034)
I wish the author gave examples for why he thinks "manipulation" and "gaslighting" are arbitrary and flexible. I think the definitions are actually very clear: manipulation is intentionally using deception, dishonesty, or withheld information to alter someone's behavior or beliefs. It's essentially persuading in bad faith.

It's fair to say that it's extremely difficult to prove manipulation, which makes it seem arbitrary. But, there's plenty of legal standards that require proving intent, not just action. That's a high bar, but it's not unreasonable or arbitrary

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by slibhb on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:57PM (#30317633)
I think the author is right that those terms are flexible (maybe arbitrary is too strong). They depend on value judgements or the ability to know someone else's mental state. "Bad faith" is a great example. It's easy to label someone "bad faith" just because you disagree with them and I find that's common.

Whether this flexibility is a problem or a virtue is another question. When the author calls for us to eliminate these flexible laws/norms, he's trying to formalize something quite vague. Even if that's possible I'm not sure it's desirable. Perhaps when it comes to millions of people living together in harmony, vagueness is a good thing.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:22PM (#30317382)
> I think the definitions are actually very clear: manipulation is intentionally using deception, dishonesty, or withheld information to alter someone's behavior or beliefs. It's essentially persuading in bad faith.

If that is what charges of "manipulation" actually corresponded to in practice, then one could just punish the actual instances of deception, dishonesty, or withheld information (DD&WI). But, in fact, it's rather rare for people to object to DD&WI when it is used to support a position they agree with, and in these situations they essentially never call it "manipulation". (If your friend Bob withheld information to convince someone of a political position you strongly agreed with, can you imagine yourself saying "Bob manipulated him"? Of course not, because "manipulation" is understood to mean "...for something bad".) In other words, "manipulation" is only used as an additional charge, beyond DD&WI, for things we disagree with.

(One could argue that we correctly have laws that punish actions based on the action's impact, like attempted vs. completed murder, and that "manipulation" could be for when DD&WI is deployed effectively. But again, no one ever calls this "manipulation" when it's for something they agree with, and they never claim that effective DD&WI of this type should be punished more harshly than ineffective DD&WI.)

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by hutzlibu on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:08PM (#30317691)
"But again, no one ever calls this "manipulation" when it's for something they agree with"

I might be an alien, but I do call this manipulation and I do so openly and loud enough to in fact did receive a lot of "counter attacks", just for insisting on truth and facts, which is indeed not normally welcome by any side in tribal wars.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:43PM (#30317919)
Did you actually use the word "manipulation", or did you just criticize deception/dishonesty? (Would be interested in a link if you have one.) I think the valence behind the word "manipulation" is so clear in real-world usage that it would be incorrect, from a linguistic descriptivist perspective, to use it this way. It would be like using the word "miserly" for thrifty behavior that you endorsed.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by hutzlibu on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:57AM (#30320374)
I am not a native english speaker, but I do not really see a big difference between manipulation and deception and dishonesty.

And I rarely call this behavior out in those words in those situations.

Example? Vaccination. I am in the "political" camp of people, who think as much people as possible should get vaccinated against covid.

Still, when I see posts written that go: "there is no reason to not get vaccinated, they are totally safe" (meant especially to covid, but also in a general sense) and I respond, that "no, they are not total safe, there have been incidents of contaminated production batches for example and it is not 100% clear, that for young people there is individually more benefit than potential harm and no doctor ever advised of taking just any vaccination (there are many vaccinations with actual higher risks, only benefiting, when visiting certain areas)" than I have to word it very, very careful or face a shitstorm even here. As in their perception I fight then against their political cause - overcoming the pandemic with more vaccinations. While in my perception they try to reach their goals with lies, which I do not agree with, despite agreeing to the goal.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by todorus on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:17AM (#30329134)
There's a difference between reasonable and pedantic. To say "going through that neighborhood is perfectly safe", doesn't mean you're not aware of there ever being crimes there.

So yeah, if you would try something like that within the context of a very contested issue, I would definitely assume you're clandestinely trying to sabotage the discussion.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by hutzlibu on Monday February 14, 2022 @03:27AM (#30329617)
Yeah, I know.

People mean different things, when they say they want to have a discussion guided by facts.

I mean it literal.

"there is no reason to not get vaccinated, they are totally safe"

And since this is factual wrong, I think it is very weird to assume that I would want to sabotage a discussion, when relativating absolutistic statements, that bring no benefit to any discussion. They only enforce groupthink. But this this rather the cultural default, which I am quite aware of.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by lazide on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:44PM (#30317535)
That doesn’t stop it from being manipulation - it’s just calling out how most people are hypocrites?
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:58PM (#30317638)
Well, it's certainly true that the post is about hypocrisy:

> Most laws are defined in relatively objective ways, so that society can truthfully say “no one is above the law”. Those who violate the law can be found guilty and punished, while others remain free....But most societies have also included a few less objective and more “flexible” offenses, flexible enough to let the powerful more arbitrarily punishment disliked parties.

If we all agree on the facts of how the word "manipulation" is used in practice, then mind-blight's first paragraph is at most asking that Hanson would be clearer that he is a linguistic descriptivist rather than a linguistic prescriptivist. That would be fair enough, but then mind-blight's second paragraph wouldn't make sense: Hanson's objection isn't that "manipulation" is hard to prove, it's that it's used exclusively in an outcome-dependent (i.e. hypocritical) way.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by mind-blight on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:31PM (#30324198)
Yep, I disagree with Hanson's assertion that "manipulation" is outcome dependent. I think he's conflating the way that it's used in popular discourse (which is often outcome dependent), with what I think is a fairly clear definition.

He's then calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining a person's intent. I actually think that's counter-productive and leaves you vulnerable to (for want of a better word) manipulation.

A person's intent matters and effects how you should interpret and respond to information they deliver. If I'm debating with someone, I want to know whether their intent is to 1) figure out the truth or try to reach consensus, 2) prove themselves right, or 3) just prove me wrong. 1 is fun, 2 is normal, and 3 is a troll. Whether they agree with me or not isn't relevant - their intentions very much are.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Monday February 14, 2022 @04:22PM (#30338538)
> I think he's conflating the way that it's used in popular discourse (which is often outcome dependent), with what I think is a fairly clear definition.

He's not conflating, he's just taking a different stance than you to linguistic prescriptivism vs. descriptivism.

> He's then calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining a person's intent. I actually think that's counter-productive and leaves you vulnerable to (for want of a better word) manipulation.

No, he's not. He never mentions intent in the post. He is calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining the actions outcome.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by dataflow on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:34PM (#30317845)
> If your friend Bob used withheld information to convince someone of a political position you strongly agreed with, can you imagine yourself saying "Bob manipulated him"? Of course not, because "manipulation" is understood to mean "...for something bad".

I think this depends on both the position and the actual arguments that were used (or withheld).

To give a hypothetical example for Democrats in the U.S.:

- If Bernie Sanders were to information about the negative budgetary repercussions of his Medicare-for-all plan (I'm not claiming he has or hasn't; I'm just giving an example), many Democrats probably wouldn't consider that "manipulation" of the public.

- But if he were to withhold information about how Medicare-for-all would actually somehow benefit corporate interests/profits at the cost of taxpayers (again, I'm not claiming this; I'm just giving a hypothetical example), a lot of the same Democrats probably would consider that "manipulation" of the public.

Of course there are people who would behave the same way in both situations too, but my point is that there are lots that would behave differently.

And obviously this isn't to claim people have zero bias here, but I don't think that's particularly specific to "manipulation". People just have a bias against criticizing people whose conclusions they agree with in general, whether the accusation is one of manipulation, corruption, or something else.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:49PM (#30317943)
> But if he were to withhold information about how Medicare-for-all would actually somehow benefit corporate interests/profits at the cost of taxpayers..., a lot of the same Democrats probably would consider that "manipulation" of the public.

I assert that Democrats who supported his plan would not use the word "manipulation" for this. Instead, the Democrats who criticized Sanders for this would only say he was deceptive or withheld info.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by dataflow on Saturday February 12, 2022 @08:31PM (#30318224)
Maybe? To be honest I'm having a hard time analyzing whether the reluctance to call it manipulation (i.e. actually using that word in speech/writing) would be mostly attributable to him being Democrat, or mostly to the word "manipulation" not being all that common in daily speech in general. I feel like people are just far less willing to use that word in a public interview with a journalist than on, say, an English exam.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by randrews on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:18PM (#30317367)
Shifting the definition of manipulation and gaslighting is itself a kind of manipulative gaslighting...
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by abecedarius on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:39PM (#30317882)
Their definition of manipulation would forbid any negotiation move other than laying all of your cards on the table. ("Withheld information to alter someone's behavior or beliefs.") So yeah.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by User23 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @08:02PM (#30318026)
Tangentially, when negotiating I’ve had pretty good luck with just straight up asking what the other party’s best offer is. Usually I have to iterate a couple rounds of course. Rarely is the first response actually their best offer. Since I really am willing to walk away, it’s worked well for both professional and personal relationships. Obviously the framing and presentation is different between a job interview and a first date, but in the end it’s basically the same principles at work.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by abecedarius on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:47AM (#30323079)
Yeah, I actually lean towards openness too (though I once had to give up on an exciting job offer because I naively anchored the salary discussion with my previous government-salary-band-for-a-high-school-dropout, instead of just not answering). But it's gotta be a free choice; someone demanding it of you, as a supposed norm, is being pushy.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by d110af5ccf on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:59AM (#30320643)
Would their definition forbid it, or would it just label such behavior as "manipulative" and you happen to have a negative association with that word? I do personally view many (but not all) "aggressive" negotiations as manipulative. And yes, withholding pertinent information is deceitful as far as I'm concerned.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by abecedarius on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:36AM (#30322964)
But I didn't bring up aggressive negotiations at all: I said that withholding any information about my private, personal valuation of a prospective trade constitutes "manipulation" according to the definition given.

It's true that withholding of information can be manipulative. Either this definition left out how we are to judge this (and so failed to establish that it's "actually very clear") or you think you have a right to the private contents of my mind and 100% of the gains from trade.

> Would their definition forbid it

Our context is a discussion of good or bad norms. Technically you could want to live under bad norms.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by mind-blight on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:45PM (#30324923)
That's a great critique of my definition. I don't think people are manipulative by withholding private or personal information. Withholding relevant information isn't manipulative in certain contexts either: i.e. those where all parties agree that there is no expectation of transparency. So, we could either argue that 1) deception implies that there is a reasonable expectation of disclosure, or 2) update the definition to explicitly say "...withheld information when there is a reasonable expectation of disclosure..."

For example, if I invest in a publicly traded company, I expect the company to be honest on their quarterly filings, but I don't expect to have access to all of their financials. If a company withholds pertinent information because they don't want to impact the stock price, that is manipulation. If they withhold the same information honestly believing it isn't significant to the stock price, that's not manipulation (though it may be incompetence).

Another example: If I target financially illiterate people with predatory loans, that is often manipulative. I'm deliberately targeting people who I wouldn't expect to be able to analyze repercussions of the loan, and I'm lying when I say it will be positive.

If I target financially illiterate people and give them credit cards that I believe are within their means, then I'm not being manipulative - even if some of those folks default or their lives are made worse by the loan.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by abecedarius on Sunday February 20, 2022 @11:35PM (#30412019)
(Sorry for the late reply.)

Yeah, I think this is reasonable. IANAL but I have the impression that manipulations like these would go under "fraud" -- most debatably the last couple. The OP was about pressures to establish laws and norms that are more open to interpretations:

> we also seem to include some more flexible offenses, such as “brainwashing”, “propaganda”, “manipulation”, “deception”, “misinformation”, “harassment”, and “gaslighting”. Again the key is that these tend to be defined less in terms of what exactly was done wrong, and more in terms of a disliked result.

so I just wanted to object to a claim in this context that "manipulation" actually is open-and-shut. If I'm right that your last couple of examples are where "manipulation" leaves more discretion to enforcement than the "fraud" standard, then I don't think you're disagreeing much with the OP on this point (though probably you are on whether this discretion is excessive).

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by wisty on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:43PM (#30317916)
What does "persuading in bad faith" mean?

Is this bad faith in the techniques of the persuasion, or that the persuasion is being used in a malicious way?

For example, if I say something misleading (or omit a few facts) to encourage people to vote for an objectively good candidate, is that bad faith? The persuasion is using a dark pattern, but I've got good intentions.

On the other hand, maybe I have some objectively bad belief, and I openly and candidly try to persuade people of it. Is that bad faith?

I'd lean towards the former being "bad faith". I believe that free and candid discussion is the best mechanism to move society forward, and I think that more progress would be great. But there are people who would disagree, because it took a lot of work to get our society to its current state, and they want to prioritise conserving what we've already got.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by d110af5ccf on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:07AM (#30320669)
Yes, your first example is correct (by definition). Bad faith is misrepresenting your motivations or the relevant facts in some way, including by omission.

> But there are people who would disagree, because <reasons>

That is an example of mental gymnastics to avoid classifying the thing they want to do as bad in their own view. They want to do something but they don't want to think of themselves as behaving in bad faith because they're a good person doing the right thing.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by mistermann on Saturday February 12, 2022 @08:00PM (#30318017)
I think people who use the term bad faith (and similar phrases) use it with the best of intentions, but the ambiguous nature of it combined with the imprecise way most people speak and think results in it causing more problems not less.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by ajdv on Saturday February 12, 2022 @06:30PM (#30317437)
At a basic hardware level its not hard to understand. Our chimp brain has 200 billion neurons with about 1 trillion connections. There is nothing static about that network structure or the info flowing through it at any given moment. If there are 6-7 billion of these networks then connected up with each other in various other ever changing networks with different ever changing info flowing through, what the fuck hope is there of keeping all that hardware in sync for very long.

The energy requirememts for consistent sync are massive.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by tartoran on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:10PM (#30317700)
We’re constantly updating and synching with peers and community. If these are giving us bad signals it’s sort of downward spiral.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by kiba on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:07PM (#30317681)
OK? Discussion are often highly complex with shifting terrain. At some point 'manipulation' became a judgement call.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by User23 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:56PM (#30317990)
Effective rhetoric can use truth at least as easily as falsehood.