News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by mind-blight on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:31PM (#30324198)
Yep, I disagree with Hanson's assertion that "manipulation" is outcome dependent. I think he's conflating the way that it's used in popular discourse (which is often outcome dependent), with what I think is a fairly clear definition.

He's then calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining a person's intent. I actually think that's counter-productive and leaves you vulnerable to (for want of a better word) manipulation.

A person's intent matters and effects how you should interpret and respond to information they deliver. If I'm debating with someone, I want to know whether their intent is to 1) figure out the truth or try to reach consensus, 2) prove themselves right, or 3) just prove me wrong. 1 is fun, 2 is normal, and 3 is a troll. Whether they agree with me or not isn't relevant - their intentions very much are.

Re:Brainwashing is sorcery by jessriedel on Monday February 14, 2022 @04:22PM (#30338538)
> I think he's conflating the way that it's used in popular discourse (which is often outcome dependent), with what I think is a fairly clear definition.

He's not conflating, he's just taking a different stance than you to linguistic prescriptivism vs. descriptivism.

> He's then calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining a person's intent. I actually think that's counter-productive and leaves you vulnerable to (for want of a better word) manipulation.

No, he's not. He never mentions intent in the post. He is calling for a measure that can be used objectively without ascertaining the actions outcome.