News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by bwestergard on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:37AM (#30273083)
"If you’re curious why unionization has taken the journalism world by storm the last few years, you don’t have to look to politics or in-group signaling for an explanation, basic economics will get you all the way there.... You reduce quantity of labor supplied and end up with higher equilibrium wages for those who manage to get their foot in the door. Of course, this will only heighten the favoring of those who can get their foot in the $3200/mo Brooklyn rent door while dressing fashionably and using “semiotics” correctly in a sentence, but that’s neither here nor there."

This is a cute theory, and tickles some people's ideological fancy. But if the author had done more research, they would know where the CWA-NewsGuild is actually doing most of its new organizing (hint: not New York), what sorts of contract articles they bargain around hiring, and what the status quo in non-union newsrooms is.

In brief, the Guild has been organizing tons of local newspapers in small cities and rural areas, particularly those bought up by private equity firms who want to cut the newsroom to the bone. They bargain contract articles that curb the nepotistic in-group hiring practices common at non-union papers.

Source: I'm a former NewsGuild member, but at a software company, not a newspaper.

Take a gander at the NewsGuild president's twitter account and you'll see many examples of these campaigns: https://twitter.com/gaufre

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by scarface74 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:45AM (#30273168)
Don’t you think you’re just postponing the inevitable? Newspapers historically made most of their money from the classifieds when most people are using Facebook and Craigslist and the like.

Then you have the fact that “only old people buy newspapers”

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by bwestergard on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:01AM (#30273385)
In the U.S., the gutting of newsrooms has largely already happened, with disastrous consequences for democracy. There is simply too little actual investigative journalism, particularly at the local level, being done today. There are too few independent newsrooms.

Consider that this was already a plotline in the early 2000s TV show "The Wire", written by former Baltimore-Sun reporter (and NewsGuild member) David Simon.

The papers being organized are those that found a business model that works to a degree. The fight now is largely about whether their owners will continue to operate real newsrooms, which requires employing journalists at a living wage and having a fairly long time horizon for investment, or whether they will become essentially hollow brands with little original content.

But to your point: yes, the broader political question of how the fourth estate is funded in the U.S. remains unresolved for now.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by brimble on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:33PM (#30275398)
I don't think folks appreciate just how tetering-on-the-edge local corruption already was before local newspapers started to die. Expect to see a lot more crazy stories coming out when small towns and small cities go so far into private-fiefdom territory that someone outside notices. The only remaining significant bulwark to ruining-the-country levels of corruption is state auditors—and that's if they're not corrupt themselves.

Larger cities may be OK a little while longer since they usually still have some local investigative reporting.

It's one of several reasons I'm no longer sure the Web is compatible with healthy democracy.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by WesternWind on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:38PM (#30276478)
One thing I have read about though, is that, since unlike radio or tv stations there is no real regulator of who owns how many websites, conservative media networks are creating news sites for towns using a local contractor for local stories, and then having national or international stories be presented with a conservative slant.

https://www.niemanlab.org/2020/07/hundreds-of-hyperpartisan-...

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by iratewizard on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:32PM (#30281769)
There is more than one solution to the problem. As the problem gets worse, the need for a new solution will overcome the friction that was preventing that solution from taking place. Upper government ought to be proactive about helping those solutions along, so fixing the problem doesn't involve killings.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by tharne on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:27AM (#30273703)
I think a big part of the problem with funding the news is the way papers handle online payments. I would happily pay a dollar or two to have online access to the NY Times, WSJ, or even my local town paper for a day. What I absolutely do not want to do is spend $500+ on 3 or more subscriptions that I will not read, or not read much of, on most days. For papers that still have a print edition, you can buy the day's paper. I don't know why you can't do the same thing online.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by tsunamifury on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:33AM (#30273793)
You misunderstand. The subscriptions are not the key to revenue. The dollar even per article would be even less so. They are qualifiers for the ad demographic.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by wbsss4412 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:57AM (#30274167)
The NYTimes seems to be doing quite well on subscription revenue.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:18AM (#30274427)
Not sure why people are downvoting you. Here are some numbers from Feb 2021:

> Total subscription revenue in 2020 was up 10 percent, to $1.195 billion.

> Total ad revenue at The Times fell 26 percent in 2020, to $392.4 million.

> Adjusted operating profit rose 1.4 percent from the fourth quarter of 2019, to $97.7 million, and 0.9 percent over the year, to $250.6 million.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/04/business/media/new-york-t...

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by llbeansandrice on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:16PM (#30275169)
Just because the NYT was successful doesn't mean that model translates at all to local independent newsrooms. It doesn't even necessarily translate to other large national news papers.

The resulting problem is exactly why people complain about too many streaming services. You could easily have to juggle national, state, and various local-level subscriptions. Maybe multiples at every level. Plus any other publications specific to other hobbies or interests you might have.

Just because it works once, doesn't mean it will work for everyone.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by wbsss4412 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:35PM (#30275421)
I mean, the ad model doesn’t seem to be working all that well for local news rooms either.

My point was simply to show a counter example that news must survive off of ad revenue.

The old model of subscriptions covering cost of production + ads delivering the profits is just dead.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by llbeansandrice on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:50PM (#30275632)
I see your point, but I don't think it's a good counter-example. News needs a new paradigm entirely most-likely. The NYT isn't "the news" and the only options seem to be subscriptions and/or ads. For smaller operations, the problem gets a lot harder a lot faster since there's an upper-bound on the number of people they serve.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by wbsss4412 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:01PM (#30275827)
> The NYT isn't "the news"

I’m not sure what you mean by this.

At the end of the day, I think the answer is that local news rooms just aren’t going to be viable, by and large. This is a consequence of a century long trend to begin with.

The way I see it, either you have a broad enough reach, or you have to niche yourself into the broader content generation ecosystem. Local news publishing that just reprints of AP stories or talking about some new pop health study of the week isn’t going to survive. To the degree that local investigative journalism is valuable, it’s going to have to find an entirely new model to sustain itself.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by marmadukester39 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:48PM (#30278284)
Or, more likely, simply die, and take fair local government with it.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by foolinaround on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @05:29PM (#30279484)
Is 'fair local government' correlated to the presence of robust local media? Seems like a sad state of affairs if that is indeed the case..
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @07:33PM (#30280889)
corruption is an endless feature of human communities. one way to keep it somewhat under control is to publicize it to the broader community rather than allow it to remain secret. the corruption doesn't need to be extreme enough to warrant legal action (though it might); it could just be "bad for most people, good for a few".

stupidity has most of the same properties.

the main feature of those human communities that we've used for a few hundred years to try to accomplish that control is called "a free press".

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by eastWestMath on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:18PM (#30277886)
I feel like the NYTimes could take more papers under its subscription - e.g. give subscribers the option to bundle in a state and municipal paper, that the NYTimes essentially vets as a local affiliate (I’m guessing this would probably lead to substantial overhead on their end, though).
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:32PM (#30275383)
I absolutely agree. I've had some conversations with my local paper, the Santa Fe New Mexican about this, since their subscription cost seems sort of absurd for the value. They point out (correctly, IMO) that the really small upper bound on their potential subscriber base really forces their hand a lot, a problem that the NYT does not face and likely never will (given its national and international reach).
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by autokad on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:28PM (#30275342)
1/3 of their revenue from ads is a lot. especially since the ads are probably high margin
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by filmgirlcw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:24AM (#30274514)
The New York Times is the only legacy media company to successfully pivot into digital, and pivot properly at that. In 2014, an internal innovation report [1] laid out the challenges the Times faced and what it needed to do to be successful. To the Times’ immense credit, it succeeded and then some. I worked at a digital publication that was cutting edge on the types of digital and audience engagement work the the Times was trying to chase and used to say that “we are trying to become the New York Times before the Times becomes us.” And in 2016, we had layoffs and the company “pivoted to video,” and as I said to some colleagues the night of the layoffs (I was spared but many other were not), the Times won. (The pivot didn’t work and the company would sell for 1/5 of its valuation 18 months later. But at this point I’d just left media for tech.)

The Times is the exception. It’s the Apple amidst a sea of Commodores and Ataris and DECs. The Times is the exception and is exceptional as a business reinvention story, but it is the outlier, not the norm.

(The Journal has always had a paywall (even in the mid 1990s when it sold digital editions over dial-up), tho its porousness has ebbed and flowed, and as such, has never had the same degree of challenges that faced local papers or the national papers like the New York Times, WaPo, and the LA Times)

[1]: https://www.scribd.com/doc/224608514/The-Full-New-York-Times...

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by Veen on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:38AM (#30274706)
> The New York Times is the only legacy media company to successfully pivot into digital, and pivot properly at that.

I'm more familiar with the UK media market, where quite a few legacy media publications have pivoted into digital successfully. Whatever you think of the Daily Mail/Mail Online, it's very successful. The Guardian is doing well without a paywall (although it has a large endowment to sustain it). Smaller publications such as the Spectator (which is about legacy as it gets) are doing well with a digital subscription model. And then there's The Economist, of course.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by filmgirlcw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:05PM (#30275894)
I think the Daily Mail is a good example and this is a reminder to never speak in absolutes.

That said, I don’t think any of those other examples pivoted the way the Times pivoted. The Times didn’t just digitize the newspaper or combine the newsrooms. It started to do real digital first and product first investments. The Cooking app, the Games vertical, the investment into audio and video, the tremendous investment in data tools for its journalists for multimedia storytelling (consider the impact of Snow Fall, even a decade later).

The Daily Mail may have successfully managed profitability, but I wouldn’t put it on par with the transformation that happened at The Times. The Times looked at the innovation happening at BuzzFeed and Mashable (where I worked for many years) and Vice and Vox and has not just been able to compete with them, I would argue that it has largely vested them. Whatever else you think of their journalism, that alone, is nothing short of remarkable. And I cannot think of another legacy media company that has transformed itself the same way.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by native_samples on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:27AM (#30284434)
Well, success in this context means digital+profits. There's nothing particularly digital about the Guardian's work - it's just ordinary text - and they are incredibly unprofitable. They really shouldn't count.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by rjsw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:12PM (#30275118)
> The New York Times is the only legacy media company to successfully pivot into digital, and pivot properly at that.

How about the Financial Times or The Economist?

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by filmgirlcw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:57PM (#30275763)
The Economist is so small (staff of 75 writers, not sure how large the whole organization is but it’s still very small) that I don’t think it counts the same way something like the Times counts. That isn’t to take anything away from The Economist, but a magazine isn’t the same scope, to me. Especially since the magazine has changed hands a few times. And if I’m going to be brutally honest, The New Yorker is actually the magazine that has adapted to digital the best and if it were its own business and not one of the things propping up Condé Nast, I’d list it alongside the Times.

(Thinking about it more, The Atlantic is close to successfully pivoting but I don’t know if I can say it has done it quite yet. And again, it had to sell itself)

FT is a fantastic newspaper but I think it’s much more akin to WSJ, where its paywall and subscriber base insulated it from the challenges than a lot of other papers. But that’s a good call-out as a paper that has done its part to pivot like the Times has. (It has also been sold, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing but is worth noting).

The Times, to me, is unique in that it’s investment in its tech has been as significant as it has. And not just for the apps like Cooking and Games, but the commitment to the full stack within its storytelling, its video, its audio. It is really remarkable from a product perspective, as much as from a journalism perspective. The core product it offers is still news, but it has managed to really change the medium and packaging of its offerings in a very demonstrable way.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by stephenhuey on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:52AM (#30274878)
I’m glad they were able to figure that out, and now the question that arises in my mind is whether there is any hope for finding a model that props up local investigative journalism. Even if all those local news organizations became non-profits and had access to a very effective digital media platform that made it effortless to produce online content (including mobile-friendly functionality), and maybe even charge micro-payments for some of the individual articles, would it be enough? Or would it not work? Can they only survive if they do real news while selling other stuff?
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by julienb_sea on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:55PM (#30275726)
WSJ has also pivoted quite successfully and maintains pretty much the same operating model as NYT.

I realize these are basically the two highest profile legacy news products, so broadly your point stands.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by filmgirlcw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:10PM (#30275958)
Totally, and WSJ never had the same challenges because it never took down its paywall/had a different subscriber profile/etc. But yes, those are the two that have managed to stay successful and that’s a testament to both of their teams.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by Master_Odin on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:14AM (#30274373)
The NYT has subscribers across the country (and beyond) as it covers broad US and world events. I doubt a local paper that principally covers local/state news will have that same reach.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ghaff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:40AM (#30274722)
The NYT, WSJ, FT, The Economist, and maybe a few others have a national and international (to greater or lesser degrees) audience who are willing to pay $100/year or so for a subscription. That's a much tougher sale when your audience is almost entirely just, say, Philadelphia.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by wbsss4412 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:39PM (#30275491)
And for the same reason, local papers are going to have paltry ad sales.

At the end of the day, none of this looks good for local news, but that doesn’t been that subscription sales aren’t a viable business model to some degree.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by chaostheory on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:30AM (#30274594)
The “qualifiers” are way too high for anyone who isn’t from the boomer generation. I can afford it, but I cannot justify it.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ekanes on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:02PM (#30275832)
Agreed, micropayments would be clutch here.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by philwelch on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:01AM (#30274218)
The heyday of the newspaper also had disastrous consequences for democracy, such as the Spanish-American War.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by seanicus on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:48PM (#30275606)
Lest we forget NYT being used as a mouthpiece for Dick Cheney and forming the foundation of the invasion of Iraq. I'll stump for the importance of journalism at any level (esp. the local level) but the willingness of major outlets to accept and regurgitate anything from cops/3-letter orgs is absolutely confounding.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by modo_mario on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:10AM (#30285057)
Reminds me of when every US newspaper basically plainly copied what the gov said about the strikes against Kata'ib Hezbollah being in response to a hit and run toyota-rocket attack of theirs on a US base.

Not a soul that took note of the fact that Kata'ib had denied any involvement or that this happened very far away from where they held power and deep in territory with an enemy local group that had instantly claimed the attack.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by throwaway2037 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:21AM (#30274463)
Thank you to post about this important issue. The demise of diversity in news sources is that local politics will lose its Fourth Estate (media) that acts as a check-and-balance. National politics will continue to be closely monitored by national papers. To all readers of any nationality: This issue will affect any democracy that sees a sharp decline in local news sources.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by mcculley on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:39PM (#30275494)
I would love to buy a subscription to a newspaper. As far as I can tell, nobody wants to sell me one without ads and trackers. It does not appear there is a big enough market for a publication that serves the interests of subscribers.

I canceled all of my subscriptions after asking politely that they do something about the third party tracking.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by WesternWind on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:02PM (#30275848)
There's also been a huge rise of non profit journalism.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by scarface74 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:29AM (#30273718)
“Journalism” has never been good when it comes to covering anything that didn’t effect the White middle class.

Journalist reflexively took the word of the police department and prosecutors and didn’t believe minorities when they complained about police misconduct. It was only when everyone could film the police that it became apparent.

On the other side, the rise of Trumpian populism came about because everyone ignored rural White America including journalist.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by bnralt on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:36AM (#30274678)
I think Walter Lippmann covered this pretty well 100 years ago in his book Public Opinion (an excellent book by the way, I highly recommend it). Newspapers get money from the public through a hidden commodity tax by way of advertisements. In order to get this to work, they need to sell their circulation, and the value of the circulation depends on the buying power of those in it. As such, the goal of a newspaper has to be to keep it's target audience happy by giving them what they want:

> Circulation is, therefore, the means to an end. It becomes an asset only when it can be sold to the advertiser, who buys it with revenues secured through indirect taxation of the reader. The kind of circulation which the advertiser will buy depends on what he has to sell. It may be "quality" or "mass." On the whole there is no sharp dividing line, for in respect to most commodities sold by advertising, the customers are neither the small class of the very rich nor the very poor. They are the people with enough surplus over bare necessities to exercise discretion in their buying. The paper, therefore, which goes into the homes of the fairly prosperous is by and large the one which offers most to the advertiser. It may also go into the homes of the poor, but except for certain lines of goods, an analytical advertising agent does not rate that circulation as a great asset, unless, as seems to be the case with certain of Mr. Hearst's properties, the circulation is enormous.

> A newspaper which angers those whom it pays best to reach through advertisements is a bad medium for an advertiser. And since no one ever claimed that advertising was philanthropy, advertisers buy space in those publications which are fairly certain to reach their future customers. One need not spend much time worrying about the unreported scandals of the dry-goods merchants. They represent nothing really significant, and incidents of this sort are less common than many critics of the press suppose. The real problem is that the readers of a newspaper, unaccustomed to paying the cost of newsgathering, can be capitalized only by turning them into circulation that can be sold to manufacturers and merchants. And those whom it is most important to capitalize are those who have the most money to spend. Such a press is bound to respect the point of view of the buying public. It is for this buying public that newspapers are edited and published, for without that support the newspaper cannot live. A newspaper can flout an advertiser, it can attack a powerful banking or traction interest, but if it alienates the buying public, it loses the one indispensable asset of its existence.

Especially relevant today, with the number of advertisement driven companies.

Also from the book, how newspapers will often let erroneous stories die rather than correcting them and angering passionate readers:

> The more passionately involved he becomes, the more he will tend to resent not only a different view, but a disturbing bit of news. That is why many a newspaper finds that, having honestly evoked the partisanship of its readers, it can not easily, supposing the editor believes the facts warrant it, change position. If a change is necessary, the transition has to be managed with the utmost skill and delicacy. Usually a newspaper will not attempt so hazardous a performance. It is easier and safer to have the news of that subject taper off and disappear, thus putting out the fire by starving it.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by webdoodle on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:57AM (#30274938)
> But to your point: yes, the broader political question of how the fourth estate is funded in the U.S. remains unresolved for now.

It's been funded by for profit organizations, that have a vested interest in controlling what is newsworthy and what is ignored, and who gets discredited and maligned. Unbiased news died with Operation Mockingbird in the 60's and it's corpse has been dancing along like Weekend at Bernie's.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by mchanson on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:54AM (#30273281)
Everyone is always delaying the inevitable. It is the only thing anyone can do. None of us (or our companies) are getting out of this alive.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by throwaway2037 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:25AM (#30274520)
I had a similar reaction when I read the grandparent post. Could we not say the same about most retail shops and people who work at them? "Bah, why bother? In the long run, you will all be replaced with robot pickers in an Amazon warehouse." And yet, the retail "experience" continues to innovate / find / create experiences that people cannot have with pure online shopping.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by scarface74 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:11PM (#30275105)
Would you invest in either a bookstore or a big retail shop in a mall today?
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by scarface74 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:56AM (#30273311)
The difference is that millions of people aren’t going to wake up one morning and say they want to start buying physical newspapers.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by dv_dt on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:30AM (#30273742)
The only hyper local paper in my region that seems have worked out a stable model, delivers to everyone free and is the only outlet that covers local events.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by Taylor_OD on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:41PM (#30275521)
> Newspapers historically made most of their money from the classifieds when most people are using Facebook and Craigslist and the like.

Really? I didnt know that. I assumed ad sales were how newspapers made money.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by scarface74 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:24PM (#30276200)
https://www.minnpost.com/business/2014/02/how-craigslist-kil...

I was off when I said “most”

> Newspaper classified advertising peaked in 2000 at $19.6 billion. In 2012, the most recent year for which data are available from the Newspaper Association of America, classified advertising was $4.6 billion — a drop of about 77 percent in barely more than a decade.

> In 2000, classified ads accounted for about 40 percent of newspaper industry ad revenue. In 2012, classifieds made up about 18 percent of the ad revenue in an industry that was barely half the size it had been a decade earlier.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ekanes on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:05PM (#30275887)
Please ignore if this takes us off-topic, but is this a case for micropayments, done via cryptocurrency? Because I think a successful implementation of micropayments might solve for this.

I don't want to subscribe to any regular news, but I'd be happy to click a button that gives $.25 to the author/site.

That doesn't work with CC fees, but if micropayments done via crypto (there are many with low/no transaction costs).

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by agentdrtran on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:41PM (#30277401)
This has been trialed several places before and never taken off, the type of people willing to engage in micropayments at all, but who will never subscribe at any price point, seems to be quite small.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by nonameiguess on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:49PM (#30278297)
Not entirely true. There are a few porn sites that have had success moving away from "all scenes access" subscription models to load up an account and purchase individual scenes from the pool models. And, of course, services like Clips4Sale have always worked this way. I suspect it would work well enough for any kind of cross platform video on demand service, not just adult, but no such thing exists right now because streaming providers largely don't work with each other the way porn providers do, preferring to own both the content and the platform.

Another part of this is I guess the payments aren't really "micro" in the video case, as filmed scenes are more expensive to produce and more valuable to consume than most written articles, so they can charge more per scene than anyone would ever pay per article.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by khalladay on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:19PM (#30276109)
I could be misremembering, but this seems like an idea that's been tried (and failed before). I have a memory of a service whose pitch was that you'd load funds into an account (a 1 time large transaction to get past the CC fees), and then individual sites could request micropayments from that account balance. No crypto then of course, but I'm not sure adding crypto makes this idea functionally different from how it looks without it.

I could be totally off my rocker, but I'm pretty sure I remember this from sometime around the early 2010's ?

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ryandrake on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:30PM (#30276327)
I think the point is that nobody wants to make some account, then pre-load that account with money, and then wonder what the balance is, etc. etc. etc. Yuck! If this problem is going to be properly solved, someone has to solve the [evidently very hard] problem of being able to send $0.25 over the Internet without all these accounts and without getting overwhelmed with fees from the banking establishment.

If we had a magic wand, and there were no technical, business, or security constraints, what would the ideal micropayment system look like? A button on the web page that, when I press it, sends $0.25 from my bank account to the web site. Isn't something like that the holy grail? No need to "have an account" at the web site, and "have an account" with the payment processor or pre-load things with funds or any of that garbage. I already have a bank account, why do I need a handful of other accounts all over the place?

There's the UX. I think it would be successful. But nobody has managed to build it yet.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by meetups323 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:16PM (#30277080)
This is what Web3 is supposed to be. "Want to store some data? Just pay the market rate for data storage!" Of course they chose the most expensive and unwieldy data storage mechanism imaginable.

Inb4 "but X chain is so cheap!", all chains are cheap until they're popular. Make a chain that gets faster&cheaper to commit on as the amount of compute on it increases (as you would expect... pretty much any CS thing to work) and you've solved web3. Oh but then the asset is inherently inflationary and people care more about getting in on the next big hockey stick than sound financial instruments. So... there you have it.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by thebean11 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#30278152)
The blockchains you are thinking of were never meant to be data storage layers. The proof-of-storage chains (at least, the ones that store "real" data) are much more reasonable, check out prices for storage on FileCoin.

The distinction here is that nodes publish proof that they have data stored on chain, rather than publishing the data itself on chain.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by meetups323 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @04:36PM (#30278882)
Yep, proof of storage is the only way forward as far as I'm concerned. At least of the currently available options. But they aren't great for representing a ledger. Some sort of hybrid is needed.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ghaff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:25PM (#30277189)
Back in the dot-com era (and maybe since), there were some startups in the micropayments space.

>If we had a magic wand, and there were no technical, business, or security constraints, what would the ideal micropayment system look like? A button on the web page that, when I press it, sends $0.25 from my bank account to the web site.

That sounds like exposing my bank account quite a bit too freely. The obvious approach is that you have an account with someone who collects the money and distributes it--and yes it would probably be prepaid.

In any case, if there were a demand the technical and UX problems can be overcome. The bigger issue, other than establishing the network, are getting people to actually pay per article--given that we've mostly moved to all you can eat subscriptions for other media--at an amount that would actually pay the bills. And in light of the fact that a lot of people don't want mental transaction costs to decide if reading an article is worth it every time they want to read something. (Which Clay Shirky brought up 20 years ago.)

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by itronitron on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @04:17PM (#30278606)
As long as the reader needs 'an account' this will never take off. There should be some way to load money into my computer and then drag a quarter or half dollar coin onto an article that I want to read.

The only information that needs to transfer is the coin's value. There is absolutely no need for any account information to propagate off of my computer. But the current state of the internet basically guarantees that the most syphilitic tech whore lead is going to shout from the mountain tops who paid what to view which article and then carve it into stone which is subsequently dumped into a landfill.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by rasz on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:52PM (#30281523)
> what would the ideal micropayment system look like? A button on the web page that, when I press it, sends $0.25 from my bank account to the web site.

Now imagine someone making that button 1x1px, same color as background, in the footer, and js clicking it regularly every seconds you spend on some random spam site.

Similar technology is actually already deployed in the real world. All you need is a phone number of a person browsing your website to automagically subscribe them into monthly mobile charges.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by tbrownaw on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @04:56PM (#30279116)
> I think the point is that nobody wants to make some account, then pre-load that account with money, and then wonder what the balance is, etc. etc. etc. Yuck!

Those free-to-play phone games seem to survive ok while making players pre-load a balance before they can buy their in-game advantage items with it.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by webmaven on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:46PM (#30282538)
> Those free-to-play phone games seem to survive ok while making players pre-load a balance before they can buy their in-game advantage items with it.

Those games largely depend on addicting people to intermittent rewards and harvesting a disproportionate amount of their revenue from relatively few 'whales'.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by marmadukester39 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @03:45PM (#30278238)
See Iota - the only zero fee crypto with realistic ambitions for supporting smart contracts.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ephbit on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @06:13PM (#30280073)
Sounds like flattr.com would have worked for you.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by fragmede on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:29PM (#30276306)
The failure in the 2010s, is due to (lack of) network effects (from lack of participation), among other things. Crypto doesn't necessarily solve this but things like the Solana cryptocurrency enable solutions built on top of it.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by azza2110 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:47PM (#30277470)
I think you are talking about Blendle which up until a few years ago let you pay by the article for many major newspapers and magazines.

I miss it.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ptman on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @04:12PM (#30278548)
https://webmonetization.org/ the transactions need to batched, e.g. once per month
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by nemothekid on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:39PM (#30276500)
If you have a paywall, a subscription works a lot better. If you don't, ads have a better CPM than donations.