News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by DanielBMarkham on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:25PM (#3027112)
A news article where both the scientists and the reporter understate the claims, publish the data, and ask other teams to please prove them wrong.

I like this. Most of the time the reporters overstate the research, the scientists keep the data secret, and the general public is left scratching their heads.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by zeratul on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:23PM (#3027865)
This seems to be solid work. First, the group proved that the neutrino speed can be accurately measured in OPERA:

http://arxiv.org/abs/1106.2822 http://iopscience.iop.org/1367-2630/13/5/053051

Second, they compared the neutrino results with light results. Third, they ask to replicate the results in some other environment. This is a normal scientific procedure.

Please also note the number and variety of authors on this work. They will make sure that there is no overstate, understate, secrets, or head scratching.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by hartror on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:53PM (#3028140)
Phil Plait the Bad Astronomer goes into some of the technical challenges the scientists have to overcome in this experiment in laymen's terms.

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2011/09/22/fa...

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Groxx on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:51AM (#3028872)
Wow, and he's extremely reserved about the whole thing - usually he's like a cold shower, raining on the press's parade. I like the SN1987A counter-example, though - it does raise a few questions. Not even remotely conclusive, but it makes it more puzzling.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by hartror on Friday September 23, 2011 @07:40PM (#3032018)
Well normally the press or the PR people representing the scientists blow things all out of proportion. In this case it seems everyone is being pretty reserved and the claims, while extraordinary are already heavily couched in caveats.

I am expecting one of two things to happen:

a. A systemic error in the measurements, which is most likely IMO. b. a modification of physics similar to how relativity was a modification of Newtonian physics.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by beloch on Thursday September 22, 2011 @10:25PM (#3028603)
Scientists generally do not keep data secret. They try to publish as much as they can actually! This is how you get nice things like funding and tenure!

Most of the time reporters misunderstand the research and then oversell it in order to get their story read. The general public is usually left scratching their heads because of this bizarre layer of clueless journalists between them and the scientists. Yes, some scientists are hard to understand, but there's no hope in trying to understand particle physics filtered through the soft spongy grey matter of a liberal arts major! Scientists are quite often educators who are used to speaking to a wide range of audiences. Journalists would do far far better to introduce the subject and then let the scientist explain it in their own words. I have no idea why this is not done more.

As for the FTL neutrinos at CERN... I'd hold on to skepticism for now. The reason they're asking for help finding the glitch instead of proudly proclaiming that they've found tachyons (FTL particles) is because this would be a truly bizarre result that would upend a century of physics that has, to date, proved remarkably accurate in its predictions. If this discovery proved true it would literally force us to rewrite physics from ~1900 onwards. Physicists are not afraid of this. Quite the contrary! It would touch off a bonanza of research! There would be so much work to do that the field would literally explode. It's just a lot more probable that there really is a glitch somewhere and we simply haven't found it yet.

This actually would not be the first time that tachyons were "found". A group in the 70's found statistically significant evidence for them preceding cosmic showers. They were so sure of their results that they published. Then, a year or two later, they discovered that it was just a glitch in their electronics! These guys were small fry compared to CERN, but CERN's accelerator is so complex that glitches could be very hard to find. The scientists at CERN are clearly out of ideas and mean just what they say: They don't believe their results and they want help finding the glitch that's probably causing them. It's extremely irresponsible to report this story as if FTL particles have really been found before CERN has had a chance to consult with outside scientists and other facilities have had a chance to try reproducing their results.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by gmac on Friday September 23, 2011 @07:01PM (#3031915)
Scientists generally do not keep data secret. They try to publish as much as they can actually!

Publish != tell the media. Publish != share raw data.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by beloch on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:39AM (#3033104)
When we publish papers, we usually include sample raw data as part of an online supplement or appendix whenever the journal permits it (most people never look at these). Not all journals do permit this, and storage constraints sometimes make it difficult to provide a worthwhile sample anyways. We do supply raw data to anyone who asks for it. If that counts as keeping our data secret, then so be it.

I have yet to find encounter a group in my field that refused to share raw data when asked for it. They're usually happy to have another set of eyes look for a meaning they didn't publish (This could lead to another paper they might not have to work very hard for!). Again, is it really secret if all you have to do is ask for it? Corresponding author email addresses are on papers for a reason!

I will say that it is unusual for a group of scientists as prominent as the ones at CERN are to go to the media before publishing, but they are clearly very unsure of their results and would rather have a lot of eyes looking for bugs before they commit to publishing their results. This, of course, won't accomplish much if they try to keep secrets, as you are suggesting.

In fact, here's a challenge for you. Go ask CERN for their FTL neutrino data. I bet they'll be happy to give you a copy. They'll probably even have a grad-student to spare to explain some of it to you, although his or her time will probably be at a premium for the next few weeks!

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by gmac on Sunday September 25, 2011 @03:27PM (#3036527)
That's a fair point, and my comment was a bit lazy. All I wanted to say was that publishing findings, publicising findings, and sharing the raw data aren't exactly the same thing and don't necessarily go together.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by trocker on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:01AM (#3028785)
Yes,the mankind would literally need to rewrite physics! It will be so exciting to be a part of it!

About the 70's group, can you share the link to the article?

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by azulum on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:24AM (#3028820)
am i the only one that has come to love the scientific method simply because it creates more questions than it answers. there is just so much that we do not and cannot understand. the more we learn, the less we know. fantastic.

on the flipside, i would be certain that certainty is a particular kind of hell, if having such knowledge didn't condemn me to it. excuse me while i proceed to consume my tail http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by trocker on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:22PM (#3031003)
+1 here! Questions are fun. I didn't learn my name till people around me bugged me thousands of times a day with the questions -- 'what is your name, you cute little thing?'.

I so so digg your 'the more we learn, the less we know' dialogue.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by samstave on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:10AM (#3028906)
The Scientific Method could be boiled down to:

10: Question Reality

20: Verify Results

30: GOTO 10

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Radim on Friday September 23, 2011 @03:26AM (#3029170)
let's try without GOTO:

    while anyone_cares:
        improve_model()
    
        if theory_of_everything_appears or strong_ai_appears:
            raise Exception("rethink loop")
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by InclinedPlane on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:39AM (#3029095)
10: Question (the currently accepted model of) Reality

20: Verify Results

30: GOTO 10

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by amorphid on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:27AM (#3029068)
Line numbers. Awww yeah!
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by TheAmazingIdiot on Friday September 23, 2011 @09:35PM (#3032219)
This is generally the reason in the esoteric studies one does not question a master.

In scientific studies, a question is made and an answer is given. That answer then leads to newer questions further probing the ultimate. One can approach, but never completely know.

In the Occult, one accepts a maxim or answer as an answer. Questioning hinders or derails to what is desired. I am speaking of the ultimate goal of the study of the esoteric: understanding of self.

(You mentioned an occult icon, thereby opening this line of commentary)

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by beloch on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:18AM (#3028808)
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v248/n5443/abs/248028a0...

I forget the source, but they later tested their setup with random input and found it predicted tachyons from that as well.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by lutorm on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:22PM (#3027390)
Most of the time ... the scientists keep the data secret

Um, no. There are plenty of data being released, and in even more cases the scientists are happy to give you the data if you ask. It's very dependent on discipline, though. In astronomy, pretty much all data obtained with publicly funded facilities (e.g. including all large space instruments) are accessible by anyone after a proprietary period of 1 year.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by maercsrats on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:26PM (#3027650)
There is also releases and updates on genomic data. It stays pretty current as far as I know: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_HapMap_Project
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by bestes on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:43PM (#3027474)
Maybe not secret then, but to be released at a later date. Or released in one of those journals that most of cannot access.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by lutorm on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:58PM (#3027526)
No one releases data in journals, at least not in astronomy. There are dedicated sites for this, e.g. http://archive.stsci.edu/

About the later date: I think it's reasonable that those that put together the proposal and thought up the project have a chance at getting their results out first. Otherwise, why would you go through the effort of planning and executing observations if you could just poach someone else's data as it comes down the pipe? Think of it as a 1-year patent on the research project.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by tingletech on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:53AM (#3028875)
The data cite people http://datacite.org/ are trying to figure out how to create "data papers" and "data journals" that would let publishing data get a "peer-review" status that would help people advance towards tenure.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by lutorm on Friday September 23, 2011 @10:46AM (#3030142)
Yeah, this would probably be an important incentive.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by arcdrag on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:24PM (#3027868)
There's often cases of the data literally being measured in tera or peta bytes. Releasing the raw data isn't always feasible.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by aperiodic on Thursday September 22, 2011 @07:26PM (#3028220)
The mother of one of my friends works with the Zooniverse[1] project, a citizen science effort. She was saying that one of their biggest problems is how to distribute their data to the public. I naïvely suggested BitTorrent, figuring the sets were in the 10s of gigabytes at most. She laughed and said that that wasn't a great way to distribute terabytes of data every few weeks.

[1]: http://www.zooniverse.org/

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by noilly on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:16PM (#3028038)
I also assumed that the storage/bandwidth/computational costs of particle accelerator data sets would make open access practically useless
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by nl on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:20AM (#3028935)
Most journals can be accessed by those working professionally in the field.

Some argue this isn't good enough (and I have some sympathy for those arguments). But it's very different to a deliberate action to hide or obscure information.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by grammaton on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:12PM (#3030968)
I can see why people might not like this, but personally I would tend to think this is actually a good thing. Just imagine if climate deniers or intelligent design proponents had open access to every scientific paper they might want - imagine the howling din of useless distraction that would result. More generally, and less politically charged, I think it cuts down on the amount of aimless speculating and ill informed inquiry that an actual expert has to deal with.

That said, it's very true that this is worlds different from maliciously withholding data.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by archgoon on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:24AM (#3028941)
>Or released in one of those journals that most of cannot access

Go down to your local university library. Go over to one of the computers (or hop on the wifi). Read the article. Email it to yourself. Not that hard now was it?

This is not ideal, but it's not that you _cannot_ access it, it's just not convenient.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by batpad on Sunday September 25, 2011 @10:40AM (#3035858)
uh.. and what if you're in India? uhh .. apply for a Visa at your local consulate, hop onto a plane, go down to the library ... not very convenient, innit? I'm sorry, but academic data walled up in closed journals (im sorry you live in a coccoon where you think everyone has a local university library) is malicious withholding of information - i dont imply that malice exists on the part of the scientist publication, but of the larger system - smug statements that data available only to experts will save the 'wise ones' from useless questions and let them do work or so, are, i think, retarded. any-how, just my personal opinion.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by archgoon on Monday September 26, 2011 @01:12AM (#3037738)
Interlibrary Loan. There are places in the world that don't have internet either you know.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by ErrantX on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:19PM (#3027379)
Indeed. Compare that with the other article about this currently on the first page of HN: http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_BREAKING_LIGHT_SPE...

Which is less cautious and more of the standard fare of not-very-well-reported science.

sigh

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by quux on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:06PM (#3027550)
At least they didn't use the phrase "perverse and often baffling" in this one.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by phil on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:30PM (#3028072)
You've got to admit that, if confirmed, these results would raise new and troubling questions...
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by broot on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:20PM (#3027631)
Haha, I can't be the only one that got that.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by mhb on Thursday September 22, 2011 @09:51PM (#3028535)
Ah, Gladwell.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by AgentConundrum on Thursday September 22, 2011 @08:47PM (#3028387)
That's the article that's at the top of reddit right now. I came to Hacker News to see if there was a better article here since the reddit one didn't seem particularly well written.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by forsaken on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:18AM (#3028807)
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by olihb on Thursday September 22, 2011 @03:33PM (#3027442)
Scientist rarely keep the data secret. It's the basis of peer review. There's a reason why open access journals (PLoS One) are getting so popular, scientists want to be known and publish. In my experience, ego is a currency much more valuable than money in academic circles.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Maro on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:05PM (#3027547)
In Physics, published raw data is not the basis of peer review. We're not there yet.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by tjic on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:24PM (#3027642)
> Scientist rarely keep the data secret. It's the basis of peer review.

In a better world, that would be true.

In this world, it's not.

Most of the climate science data that Phil Jones and others have worked with, and most of their models are secret.

It is THIS that makes me keep at least one ear open for the "anti-" side in the climate debate. Real science SHOULD be conducted out in the open.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by chrisb on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:05PM (#3028000)
IPCC AR4 models all listed with lots of information and links (although some now dead): http://www-pcmdi.llnl.gov/ipcc/model_documentation/ipcc_mode...

For example, the three models developed by NASA: http://data.giss.nasa.gov/modelE/ar4/

Direct links to each model + code + datasets:

http://www.giss.nasa.gov/tools/modelE/ - with nightly code snapshots here: http://simplex.giss.nasa.gov/snapshots/

http://aom.giss.nasa.gov/ - with direct access to code here: http://aom.giss.nasa.gov/code.html and here: http://aom.giss.nasa.gov/code4x3.html

http://www.giss.nasa.gov/tools/modelii/ - seemingly work on this has now been merged with the ModelE simulation.

Lots of other code and data is available if you take the time to find it ... and then considerably more time to understand it.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Tycho on Thursday September 22, 2011 @05:13PM (#3027818)
The models are secret... wait, seriously??
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Retric on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:01PM (#3027990)
Short answer is no, long answer is sort of. The way in which data / code is released is a complex issue. However, if your willing to wait a reasonable amount of time AND pay for the costs involved you can get just about everything produced.

Still, in the larger context validating someone's data is basically worthless activity. It's far more important to go out and collect new data, build a new model, run a new simulation, and report those results than it is to try and shortcut the process. The data deluge is making it way to easy for people to validate bad science using the same bad data / model as someone else. Fundamental assumptions in statistics break down when you use the same 10 coin flips to substitute for the 10 million coin flips that cost more than your willing to pay for.

PS: The failure to collect significant quantity's of new data is a hallmark of fringe / bad science. If you really think global warming is a joke or you can be more healthy by eating coco puffs then go collect that data and do your analysis and see if someone can poke holes in your process.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Tycho on Friday September 23, 2011 @05:30AM (#3029381)
Well the model is the thing that tells us what effect a rise in temperature/CO2 would actually have, no? Seems common sense to me that this should be open so that people can judge it. You could program a model to say anything regardless of the data.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by Retric on Friday September 23, 2011 @04:09PM (#3031408)
When it comes to global worming you have two models one of which is what happens after a fraction of a second when you have various levels of CO2 in a column of air over in daylight or darkness. That's a well understood thermodynamics problem and rarely debated, but you will have little trouble finding out the specific details on this issue.

The larger model is based around how that the extra heat maintained gets distributed around the world and everyone knows this is far less accurate. The people building this are well aware it's highly limited but by trying to balance the errors in both direction they hope to create a good estimate. The problem is when you start tweaking the heat distribution equations it's easy to find errors in every direction because they are greatly simplified so it's easy for someone to introduce systematic errors by only correcting issues in one direction.

Which is why you provide a high level description but when you release your source code you open yourself up to a lot of fruitless debate. Sort of like someone saying based on your methodology the rocks are really 1/1,000,000th a year older which means your science is a joke and less valid than my consistent theory that god created the world 8 weeks ago. But, if you actually build a model from scratch under similar assumptions it's going to have similar outputs and error bars or look really biased.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by jfoutz on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:02PM (#3027996)
After about 20 million requests for their data and models by people who were motivated by god to disprove climate science, they got a little less open.

I don't think they're "secret" i think they assume anyone they haven't heard of who is asking for the info is a troll.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by grammaton on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:52PM (#3030900)
And it's unfounded statements like this that contribute to ignorance and useless "debate." They do not keep their models "secret," it's just difficult for them to release homebrew software not written by software engineers to the general public and get much use from the exercise without a lot of handholding. Difficult != secret.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by logjam on Thursday September 22, 2011 @06:05PM (#3028001)
No. In this world, it is true that scientists rarely keep the data secret, more often than not, silly conspiracy theorist views notwithstanding.

Business-sponsored science is very often secret, but please don't attempt to paint, as the parent commenter disingenuously attempts to do, that scientists are the root of data secrecy.

There have been now six separate inquiries into the misguided, corporation driven, politically-motivated and frankly dumb charges that climate science data is faulty or is associated with some kind of scientific misconduct. All six separate inquiries indicated it was not:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_co...

Moreover, scientific organizations are overwhelmingly making changes that makes their data even more accessible:

http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Data+without+the+doubts%3A+the...

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by ellyagg on Thursday September 22, 2011 @10:33PM (#3028612)
I don't know about scienctists in general, but at least in climate science it is not true that scientists rarely keep the data secret. You can review untold number of cases of this on climateaudit.org and the justifications by the stonewallers are extremely poor. Given the high profile and sweeping consequences of their work, this attitude is giving science a black eye.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by bermanoid on Friday September 23, 2011 @12:42PM (#3030605)
Given the high profile and sweeping consequences of their work, this attitude is giving science a black eye.

First of all, "climate science" != "science as a whole".

Second, if any scientific field ends up in the crosshairs of a well-funded politically motivated movement working against it at any cost, then it will become hostile towards skeptics and eventually start stonewalling them. This happened in biology re: critics of evolution (in the anti-evolution camps there are tons of complaints about censorship, refusal to address criticisms, provide data, share models and code, etc.), and whereas it's always possible to address criticisms, the other side is always willing to spend more money to poke new "holes" in the theory, and you'll just never win.

"Skeptics" like to portray the ultimate goal of science as if it's to continually try to poke holes in existing theories, because progress is made when theories are disproven. But that's not science. Science is when you mix a desire to poke holes in theories with a reasonable threshold of acceptance, a willingness to step back and say "Okay, we've spent a lot of energy coming up with arguments as to why this is wrong, and they've been addressed satisfactorily, so this is probably right, let's see if this takes us anywhere new rather than getting stuck arguing the point".

Climate skeptics lack the willingness, even in theory, to accept that enough is enough - I don't believe for one moment that there is, even in principle, any piece of evidence that would lessen the amount of criticism against AGW. I don't believe they would give in because we've already seen that no amount of evidence reduced the amount of anti-evolution noise, and it's by and large the same sources of funding and political motivation that's behind both movements.

Now, it very well may be the case that climate scientists also lack the willingness to admit that they're wrong (actually, I think this is pretty likely), in which case they're not doing science, either, and that's bad. I'm totally in agreement there.

But they're taking exactly the approach to the skeptics that they would (and arguably, should) be taking if they were doing proper science. So the way they deal with skeptics is not a point of evidence either for or against the honesty of their scientific investigations, it's merely an inevitable result of the politicization of their field.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by 3am on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:00AM (#3029018)
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by mseebach on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:35AM (#3029759)
> He is the proprietor of the Climate Audit blog (or, more accurately, "Climate Fraudit")

If you can't make an argument without resorting to name calling in the first line, please excuse me while I disregard anything at all you have to say. kthxbye.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by grammaton on Friday September 23, 2011 @02:17PM (#3030991)
Maybe they do that because of the number of mistakes and basic misunderstandings of the science involved? If you don't like the name calling just look at the actions of the man, as outlined in the article. He is not a credible commentator.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by xbryanx on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:16PM (#3027605)
The vast majority of the world's petroleum geologists keep their data secret.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by cpeterso on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:54PM (#3027761)
But are they "doing science" or just doing a job?
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by lutorm on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:18PM (#3027624)
Presumably, they are in private employment?
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by nl on Friday September 23, 2011 @01:18AM (#3028928)
In related news most gold prospectors keep their gold strikes secret until they lodge the claim....
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by gnosis on Thursday September 22, 2011 @04:33PM (#3027668)
Are they concerned with the possibility of data falsification?

This has happened in other fields.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by lambda on Thursday September 22, 2011 @10:23PM (#3028598)
Well, it is one of the most surprising results in the past century. It's not like this is an "x cures cancer/AIDS/the common cold/obesity" which reporters love to overstate, and which can easily be overstated because of how vague things like "obesity" and "cures" can be.

In this case, it's "this fact that we've believed to be completely fundamental to physics for the past century appears to be wrong," and if you stated that without asking for people to check your work carefully because you are puzzled too, people are going to laugh at you if it turns out that you were wrong somehow. I'm not sure how you really could report this without downplaying it; it's just too incredible a claim for people to believe if you did anything close to overstating it.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by dewiz on Thursday September 22, 2011 @07:00PM (#3028163)
It's called impartial news, possible only as a public service
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by derleth on Thursday September 22, 2011 @11:50PM (#3028755)
> impartial news

Inherently impossible, a troubling myth that is made all the more troubling by the fact people believe it.

Impartiality is gone the moment the camera is aimed over here as opposed to over there.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by kul on Thursday September 22, 2011 @07:47PM (#3028266)
The beauty of state-funded news, no?
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by derleth on Thursday September 22, 2011 @11:49PM (#3028751)
> The beauty of state-funded news, no?

Until it steps on the state's toes.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by weavejester on Friday September 23, 2011 @08:32AM (#3029753)
The BBC is indirectly funded, but not controlled by the UK government. It's possible that the government could threaten to cut the BBC's budget by reducing the cost of the TV license, or not raising it along with inflation, unless it changed its news coverage. However, a tactic like this would go over about as well as a proposition to repeal the first amendment would in the United States.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by derleth on Friday September 23, 2011 @06:04PM (#3031751)
> The BBC is indirectly funded, but not controlled by the UK government.

I doubt funding can ever be divorced from control, even if it is indirect. The BBC knows where its next meal comes from.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by weavejester on Saturday September 24, 2011 @08:23AM (#3033082)
So if you were the UK government, and you knew the BBC was going to publish something you didn't want them to, how exactly would you get them to stop?
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by majika on Saturday September 24, 2011 @10:52AM (#3033343)
I'm Australian, and we have the ABC. So, assuming you're British, we're coming from the same page.

That said, the GP does have a point. The only thing preventing the possibility of closed-door deals going on between the BBC and political parties is good faith. Ergo, if it's not already happening or hasn't already happened, which is unlikely, there's no reason it can't happen in future.

Note: despite Australia's high exposure to UK content, I don't know much about the British media landscape. I haven't read the BBC's charter (nor the ABC's, for that matter).

Edit:

It's a tradeoff of different goals. On one hand, you get a news agency which can focus on news - not entertainment as would be dictated by a comittment to profit. On the other hand, that news agency is more susceptible to decisions by government. Consider: what determined the BBC's spending cuts?

I think publicly-owned news organisations are a great idea. The ABC, BBC, and NPR usually provide great news coverage. They have no need to sensationalize content, and that services the public to no end.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by weavejester on Monday September 26, 2011 @05:36AM (#3038202)
> The only thing preventing the possibility of closed-door deals going on between the BBC and political parties is good faith. Ergo, if it's not already happening or hasn't already happened, which is unlikely, there's no reason it can't happen in future.

Political parties could equally make backroom deals with private media companies as well. It would also be considerably less risky, because they wouldn't have to violate the Royal Charter.

The problem with backroom deals concerning the license fee is that they have to be remain secret, yet affect how the news is reported without drawing suspicion. Any control would have to be very subtle.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by derleth on Sunday September 25, 2011 @06:36PM (#3036915)
Ensure a reduction in TV license fees, perhaps, or schedule a big, expensive inquiry into whether the BBC is systematically biased in its reporting. After all, the people pay for it so the people have a right to know, regardless of how many millions of pounds it costs the BBC.
Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by weavejester on Monday September 26, 2011 @05:40AM (#3038208)
Reducing the TV license fee at the same time the BBC is going to report something unfavourable to the current government might seem just a little suspicious, don't you think?

An government inquiry into the BBC's reporting would be even worse, as it would be a clear violation of the BBC's independence.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by derleth on Monday September 26, 2011 @02:05PM (#3040034)
> Reducing the TV license fee at the same time the BBC is going to report something unfavourable to the current government might seem just a little suspicious, don't you think?

That's why you don't reduce it right away. You threaten to reduce it if they're impolitic enough to pursue certain courses. You make this fairly clear to them. The actual decisions come from the BBC's own leadership, acting on such knowledge.

> An government inquiry into the BBC's reporting would be even worse, as it would be a clear violation of the BBC's independence.

Freedom's just another word for nothing left to lose. The only independence the BBC can have under its funding model is if it decided to risk going downhill and no longer being able to do the good things it's doing now. A reduction in license fees would accomplish that, meaning if you can wave that stick around the BBC will waive its independence and allow investigations.

Re:Speed-of-light experiments yield baffling result at LHC by weavejester on Monday September 26, 2011 @10:09PM (#3041519)
> You threaten to reduce it if they're impolitic enough to pursue certain courses. You make this fairly clear to them.

And the next day there's a headlining report on government corruption.

I'm not quite seeing how the government can threaten the BBC, when they have so much to lose if those threats become public.