News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:16PM (#30250375)
Which is just crazy. Out of all the things people could spend their times trying to improve, removing a podcaster from Spotify is very low on any rational list. Direct your energy at something important and get out of your bubble of anger at {popular to hate thing of the month}.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nextlevelwizard on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:29PM (#30250605)
I haven't really followed Rogan's show since it became Spotify exclusive, but unless stuff has really went off the rails I don't recognize the qualities people are painting on him.

I don't know if this is some 4D chess move from Spotify, but I actually had to take a look at the two "antivax" episodes and neither had antivax message. So either this is all very clever marketing from Spotify or people try to make Rogan look bad for whatever reason and they don't realize that if you out right lie about things that are easy to verify it makes everything else you push less credible.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#30250716)
It’s people reading about it from third party sources and then writing about it themselves to show Support and get their likes/shares and feel like they’re part of some Movement.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:48PM (#30250884)
Extremists (both left and right) only see black and white, if you aren't with them then you are against them. If you don't cancel Joe Rogan then you're fascist racist piece of crap in their life outlook.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by weeblewobble on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:37PM (#30250701)
“If you’re, like, 21 years old, and you say to me, ‘Should I get vaccinated?’ I’ll go ‘No,’” - Joe Rogan, 4/23/21
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nextlevelwizard on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:57PM (#30251022)
That is damning evidence if we assume people can't change, but also depends on the context around it.

For example I can say right now if you are under 30 and your only option is to get Moderna don't take it. Wait until you can get something else. Risks/reward doesn't make sense, but as a result you should keep isolating until you have your double shot.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nradov on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @04:15AM (#30256345)
There was never any valid reason for healthy people under 30 to be isolating.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by Karsteski on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#30251166)
Hmm... I got Moderna shots. Am I gonna melt into a puddle..? Real talk though, what's wrong with Moderna?
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nextlevelwizard on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:19PM (#30251337)
It increases chances of inflamation of heart muscle in young men. If you've had it already then you are fine, but Moderna is not adviced for men under 30.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by Karsteski on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:23PM (#30251400)
Thanks for the info anyways :)
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by parrellel on Monday February 07, 2022 @07:09PM (#30253365)
1/8th the chance of Covid of giving you mild myocarditis. Unlike with Covid, it tends to resolve within a couple months.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by masonic on Monday February 07, 2022 @11:22PM (#30254876)
Far less than 12.5% of the general population gets Covid symptoms at all, though.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by croon on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @08:54AM (#30258363)
They're not saying 1 out of 8 vaccinations gives symptoms, but that covid is 8 times likelier than the vaccine to cause those symptoms.

From [0]:

> They found that, during the first 12 months of the pandemic, males aged 12 to 17 were most likely to develop myocarditis within three months of catching covid-19, at a rate of about 450 cases per million infections.

> This compares with 67 cases of myocarditis per million males of the same age following their second dose of a Pfizer/BioNTech or Moderna vaccine, according to figures from the US Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. Researchers added together cases after first and second doses to reach a total rate of 77 cases per million in this male age group triggered by vaccination, a sixth that seen after infection.

That's about ~7 times likelier from covid than vaccines. No data specifically on omicron (yet) though.

[0] https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg25133462-800-myocardi...

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by weeblewobble on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:04PM (#30251125)
No idea what you're talking about, not interested in debating efficacy of vaccines on here, just pushing back on the idea that calling Joe Rogan anti-vaxx is an "outright lie"
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nextlevelwizard on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:22PM (#30251372)
As I've said multiple times I've only listened to the two new controvertial "antivax" episodes since he moved to Spotify. Maybe Rogan is antivax, but I did not get that from those two episodes.

And if you are curious you can search for Moderna in under 30 year old men.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:40PM (#30250747)
This was almost a year ago when vaccines were still new and the death/hospitalization rates of healthy 21 years olds from COVID is basically zero.

I’m 27 and have my jabs, and suggest others get theirs too, but I totally understand this perspective. In fact you couldn’t even get your vaccines in the UK last April at 21.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by kashunstva on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:00PM (#30251066)
But the 18-20+ group are still nodes in a complex system that includes others who aren’t so healthy. Our friend teaches an intro to sociology course at university. She also has a child with a chronic disease and an elderly parent whom she cares for. Walking into a lecture hall packed with unvaccinated 18+ students is unnerving, not because of their risk which is negligible but because of the downstream risks that they impose on the system. It’s not unreasonable to consider the risk of others with whom one interacts in reasoning through the decision to get vaccinated or not. Now I have no idea what exactly Rogan said but a categorical “No” is not the response I’d expect from someone who has really thought about the issues. But then again the blurring lines between entertainment and information has its risks.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by nradov on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @04:19AM (#30256376)
This is irrational. I encourage everyone eligible to protect themselves by getting vaccinated, but vaccinated people also spread the virus.

https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immu...

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by weeblewobble on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:54PM (#30250966)
This is a bit of kitchen sink argument-- it was a long time ago! young people actually don't need the vaccine! he's just sharing his perspective! British people couldn't get vaccinated in April!

None of which addresses the claim in OP that people calling Joe Rogan "anti-vaxx" are "outright lying".

It is anti-vaccine to encourage young people not to get vaccinated. Simple as that.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by lamontcg on Monday February 07, 2022 @05:59PM (#30252682)
> young people actually don't need the vaccine!

SARS-CoV-2 causes much higher rates of myocarditis in kids than the vaccines do:

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7035e5.htm

Kids should still get vaccinated. They are at low risk from SARS-CoV-2, but risk of the vaccines are still even lower.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by masonic on Monday February 07, 2022 @11:25PM (#30254892)
You left out the critical qualifier: "During March 2020–January 2021, ..."
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by jorgesborges on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:37PM (#30250710)
Spotify is feeling and responding to public and internal pressure about a figure who is polarizing. I don’t think they’re directly involved in any strategy beyond damage control.

But Rogan appears to be under a coordinated attack from media institutions and governments: horse dewormer, misinformation, racism — all of which is a little absurd.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by Johnny555 on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:37PM (#30250705)
removing a podcaster from Spotify is very low on any rational list. Direct your energy at something important

If someone is really offended or disagree with what he's broadcasting, then why do you think that removing him would be low on any rational list? His podcast reaches 11 million listeners, so getting him off the air seems like it would be pretty impactful.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by wincy on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:48PM (#30250877)
It seems so stupid to try to piss off 11 million people.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:47PM (#30250870)
Let’s assume what he’s said is awful and needs to be removed because it’s dangerous. I disagree with this, but I’ll assume it’s the case.

Spotify removes him.

He goes to YouTube or something.

His fans go there.

Zero tangible impact.

This can actually go far worse - after the Trump subreddits got taken down they moved to another domain which is a clone of Reddit but only about Trump and now you have a smaller echo chamber with the same people attending but less counter-information or moderation. So it’s possible that you can make things worse this way too.

It could make an impact if he was banned from Spotify and then quit podcasts entirely, but that’s not likely because it’s so popular.

All the time we discuss this we aren’t addressing truly horrific issues like Chinese persecution of Muslim minorities or the mobilization of troops in Ukraine or other things that people will actually remember in a few months or the UK government doing all sorts of interesting things.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by Johnny555 on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:54PM (#30250977)
His fans go there.

But will they all follow him there? If 10% of his fans don't, then he's talking to a million fewer people than he used to. And, of course, if he says the same thing on Youtube, they'll start the same campaign to drop him from there too, until all that's left are niche providers where it's harder for people to find him.

Like you, I don't agree that he's said anything so bad that he deserves to be kicked off spotify or any platform, but if someone is passionate about it, doing so would reduce his reach, at least temporarily.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by bmelton on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:42AM (#30273138)
Arguably, Joe has done more for Spotify than Spotify has done for Joe (ignoring the $100 million deal)

Him moving to Youtube or somewhere that isn't paywalled likely increases his availability to those who aren't willing to pay to listen to him

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by creata on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:08PM (#30251188)
> This can actually go far worse - after the Trump subreddits got taken down they moved to another domain which is a clone of Reddit...

Is that really a failure? I imagine that cuts out a whole bunch of people who like the convenience of Reddit, or would only have found the subreddit from the front page. And it probably fractures communities, since more than one Reddit clone gets put up to replace a banned subreddit.

> All the time we discuss this we aren’t addressing truly horrific issues

Not everyone needs to be focusing on the most important issues.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:51PM (#30250926)
Sure it will reduce his audience, but it won't change anything. These liberals who want to cancel Rogan will just move on to the next ineffectual cancellation. Joe Rogan will still have a podcast somewhere else which will be more resistant to cancellation agenda people, he's not going to stop or get cancelled lol.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by tombert on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:21PM (#30250454)
At the risk of starting a flame war, if people see something bad, even if it is {popular to hate thing of the month}, should nothing be done about it?
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by panza on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:31PM (#30250617)
There are different ways to 'do something' about it. One option could be to remove the thing that (some) people are performatively hating today.

Another option could be to release a statement like: "We understand your concern, however we are pursuing what we believe to be a greater good, etc. To help you avoid content you don't like, we will improve our labeling."

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by tombert on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:39PM (#30250731)
Taken to its logical extreme (which I realize is unfair to your point), what you are suggesting is "people should be able to post anything about anyone at any time and spotify should host it", which I think is ridiculous on its face? Should Spotify be hosting a Daily Stormer podcast? How about The Daily Shoah? [1]

I don't think they should. Let's be honest; this is corporate America. It's not about "principles", it's about money. If Spotify thinks that long-term hosting Joe Rogan is going to cost them more money, they're going to get rid of it.

[1] Do not look either of these things up. They are both outright white supremacist propaganda. You have been warned.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by panza on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:08PM (#30251177)
I could just as easily turn your argument into 'anything that draws public ire should be removed', which would be just as ridiculous on its face.

I'm not saying Spotify should do anything. I'm saying it has other ways to 'do something' about these kinds of things.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by ytNumbers on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:29PM (#30250602)
People consider misinformation to be bad. The problem with censoring it is that I can think of many important instances in my lifetime where accepted narratives were later debunked and misinformation later became accepted fact. Since our understanding of COVID-19 has shifted quite a bit over the past two years, it seems to me the proper thing to do is to let people have freedom of speech.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:30PM (#30250613)
I think it depends on so many things. In this particular case there are far worse problems in the world than Joe Rogan quoting someone and using the N word. I completely disagree with his stance on vaccinations but I also disagree that he's some sort of major source of disinformation.

In the general case, I think it's bad that the socially expected thing at the moment is to be angry at {something}. It is both bad for peoples mental health and in general and it detracts from more serious issues in the world.

Take for example the situation in Ukraine. Wouldn't it be more effective to be vocal to our politicians to say we don't want to start some catastrophic war there than to try and force a tech company to remove a podcast host? If Joe Rogan isn't removed, will people even remember this discussion in three months? Probably not, because by that time {someone} will have said {something} and everyone will be tweeting angry thoughts at them instead.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by mongol on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:09PM (#30251211)
> Wouldn't it be more effective to be vocal to our politicians to say we don't want to start some catastrophic war there

I don't have the impression that any politician (in the west) wants to do that.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by exdsq on Monday February 07, 2022 @08:27PM (#30253898)
Nationalist/populist leaders losing support love looking strong for polls. Putin is losing support internally and is trying to look strong for the polls. Two sides both playing a game of chicken is risky and would be helped by internal pressures.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by croon on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @09:06AM (#30258487)
> I completely disagree with his stance on vaccinations but I also disagree that he's some sort of major source of disinformation.

Just to play with this a bit. Joe Rogan is unvaccinated himself, and he at least has recommended young people not to get vaccinated.

In the meantime ICU beds are/have been occupied by overwhelmingly unvaccinated people (proportionally) pushing out other urgent medical care, all over the world.

I agree that we can't blame everything on something/someone specific, but JRE is the biggest podcast on the planet, so I think it's fair to say he's probably one major source (among others).

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:52PM (#30250948)
The only thing they should do is click on something else and stop being sticks in the mud.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by pcan77 on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:27PM (#30250552)
Pretty sure racist remarks on the podcast and use of n-word casually isn't {popular to hate thing of the month}, so I respectfully disagree heavily with you here.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:55PM (#30250986)
If you listened to them in context they weren't racist. I listened to at least 5 of them in context, and they weren't racist and mostly portraying the opposite, so I'm satisfied he's not racist and this is a made up out of context attack as is typical of extremists. They post sound bites without context to enrage weak-minded people who won't seek out clarity on the situation. It's a tactic as old as propaganda.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by tombert on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:31PM (#30250627)
I don't think we actually disagree here; I totally think that racist remarks and casual use of the N-word is pretty bad, more than just a cringy thing to hate in a month.

I was trying to say that, using the parent comment's framework, even if it was the {popular thing to hate of the month} (which it isn't), if it is sufficiently bad, something should be done about it regardless.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by furgooswft13 on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:36PM (#30250687)
> Direct your energy at something important

Like paying musicians reasonable amounts of money per stream? People have been complaining about this since the very beginning of Spotify. But as usual woke nonsense takes up all the air in the room because it's fiscally irrelevant.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by gkoberger on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:21PM (#30250468)
Right or wrong (I think right, personally), a lot of people have a lot of time on their hands because they're sitting at home due to a pandemic (while loved ones are getting sick). This is different than normal "cancelling" over a bad joke; it's about being tired of misinformation being spread that is elongating this virus and causing countless deaths.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by LoveGracePeace on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:26PM (#30250543)
Not a big fan of Rogan but he isn't spreading misinformation, he's speaking his mind, voicing his opinion. There was a time only a few years ago when this was a time honored concept called Freedom of Speech.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:58PM (#30251030)
I agree. I think he has some dumb takes on things, but I actually signed UP for spotify as a result. Before I was just using a combination of adblockers to block 90% of spotify's ads.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by redisman on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:32PM (#30251536)
It’s pretty crazy how anyone talking outside of the party line is now a racist and a anti-vaxxer and god knows what. You can’t stop people from thinking differently from you unless you’re willing to instate a China-level state
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by dgfitz on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:26PM (#30250536)
> sitting at home due to a pandemic

People are still sitting at home? That is not my experience even a little bit.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by agilob on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:32PM (#30250636)
>People are still sitting at home? That is not my experience even a little bit.

In a company I work for not a single person came back to our local office, in fact, many people decided to move further away from the city and we said publicly that forced coming back to the office will mean changing jobs for us. That's coming from ~150 developers and testers. Even my neighbour who works in a call centre works 4 of 5 days from home... Like is anyone coming back to your fancy cubicles or dirty openspaces?

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by dgfitz on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:57PM (#30251900)
I wasn’t specifically talking about work. Where I live feels as close to pre-pandemic as it ever has.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:56PM (#30251011)
Yeah since I got vaccinated I've been going out every weekend, most people ignoring the mask mandates and local pols have given up on speaking about or trying to enforce them lol.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by dkjaudyeqooe on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:20PM (#30250443)
Arguably targeting the highest profile spreaders of misinformation and disinformation has the greatest impact, independent of the specific information.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by jimmyjazz14 on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:28PM (#30250583)
I don't know if that's true, attempts to censor information tends to lend credibility to those being censored.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by redisman on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:39PM (#30250732)
What impact? He’ll literally peace out with his $100M back to YouTube and free aggregators like Apple with much larger reach. He’s also the most popular podcast! So he wont have any problems finding a new network if need be. These people are delusional if they think they can change anything
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by ComradePhil on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:24PM (#30250503)
Experts in any field disagree. Why are opinions of some experts "misinformation" and "disinformation", specially when it is about something that we definitely don't know enough about?
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by alkonaut on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:30PM (#30250610)
That’s why you’d only label the absolutely worse horseshit as “misinformation”. It’s not simply a name for the minority position whereever where there isn’t consensus.

More importantly it’s those areas where there is a time critical aspect to the misinformation or disinformation. Something that makes the idea of “hearing all opinions” not viable.

Things that come to mind include “polls won’t open until tomorrow” (on Election Day). Or, in this case, medical information.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by aksss on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:13PM (#30251261)
There's always a convenient excuse for censorship. Who defines "worse horseshit" today? Tomorrow? Show me the information and I'll find an excuse.

A better standard is whether the communication rises to criminal offense or civil matter that caused harm (e.g. voter/election fraud, some sort of willful disregard/negligence). In other words, there's a standard/mechanism for redress already (there's an app for that).

If opinion doesn't violate a law or expose someone to a likely successful civil suit, you should be free to express it. Hard for me to imagine scenarios where this doesn't satisfy requirements. If you're concerned about timeliness, keep in mind that censorship doesn't happen quickly enough to stop the election fraud example you gave, unless you are advocating a 'ministry of information' scenario where conversations need to pre-approval to be aired - I would assume you would not advocate for such a thing, in principle.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by alkonaut on Monday February 07, 2022 @05:04PM (#30251985)
> If opinion doesn't violate a law or expose someone to a likely successful civil suit, you should be free to express

Absolutely. I don’t think we are arguing freedom of speech here.

> If you're concerned about timeliness, keep in mind that censorship doesn't happen quickly enough to stop the election fraud example you gave

Is the fact that it’s futile a good reason to say that obvious fraud should not be removed on sight?

> A better standard is whether the communication rises to criminal offense or civil matter that caused harm (e.g. voter/election fraud, some sort of willful disregard/negligence). In other words, there's a standard/mechanism for redress already (there's an app for that).

That’s the bar for the law. Obviously the bar for anyone such as a broadcaster can be set at that point or lower. A company has to follow the law obviously but here the question is probably what to employees, prospective employees, customers, investors etc feel. The company adds up the numbers and decides who to include in their platform. Because it’s important to keep in mind that companies promote a select few voices on a platform. They don’t censor away an uncomfortable voice. They chose not to be the megaphone.

I’m not sure what the alternative is to the situation we are seeing? Forcing platforms to give everyone a voice?

There will always be arbitrary moderation and association in free media. Because it’s part of what free media is. We can’t have a free press without self-censorship.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by aksss on Monday February 07, 2022 @08:46PM (#30254000)
> I don't think we're arguing free speech

"Free speech" is being progressively constrained to prevent "offense" and attacked with the murky dog whistle of "misinformation" or disloyalty (most commonly Russian agency), causing a national debate in the process.

> should not be removed on sight?

I just meant that 'on sight' is often too late to be any more effective than legal action for the Election Day example you gave. The prospective "damage" we risk in most cases that we hear stories about today is highly debatable (next point).

> Alternative to the situation we're seeing

We would need to agree on the situation "we" are seeing before focusing too much on solutions. I see outsized and misplaced risk intolerance. Indeed, intolerance for open dialogue and skeptical challenge generally if it contrasts with the government/institutional positions. The rapidity with which (ex-CIA now state department) spokesman Ned Price started accusing AP reporter Matt Lee of disloyalty a few days ago is pretty shocking and gross. But that's our reality right now.

> We can't have a free press without self-censorship

I think I very much disagree with this, but may not be understanding the statement. When you say "self" censorship, does that mean you and I showing restraint (systemically unreliable), or (industry collaboration with) a centralized institution (as in the royal "We") which would not be 'self-censorship' by definition? I think you can have free press without institutional censorship as long as we aren't speaking in complete absolutes and are acknowledging a place for the rule of law. Why? We've been modeling it pretty well for a while, and while everyone imagines the times they are living in are unprecedented, this country has faced far worse crises and managed to hold on to some bedrock principles unique to its model of government (delegated powers and inalienable rights of the people). What's really changed that requires a new call for censorship? I know of a few reporters making the case that we can never compete with China unless we become effectively more 'totalitarian' ourselves. I dismiss the reasoning out of hand entirely. I've heard some other reasons revolving around danger and offense but very wooly and inarticulate definitions/constraints that makes me think risk outweighs reward by a large margin.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by alkonaut on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @03:11AM (#30256015)
> When you say "self" censorship, does that mean?

I mean that a publisher, as a corporate entity will do what it needs to operate as a business and that might mean, for example, choosing to not to do business with people/companies/countries/whatever that might have any form of negative impact on the business but isn't illegal.

> I think you can have free press without institutional censorship

Not sure what institution you refer to here.

> this country

Not sure which country you refer to here. Spotify is a Swedish but global company, Rogan is from New Jersey... This story is pretty universal I think.

> What's really changed that requires a new call for censorship?

I'm not "calling" for censorship. I'm just stating the obvious: that companies and people doing self-censorship isn't something you can be for or against, "call for", protest against, or ban. You can argue that it's unfortunate when the "landscape of acceptable opinions" shrinks. This is a pendulum that will always, and has always, swung both ways (And is very different between different countries of course).

> intolerance for open dialogue and skeptical challenge generally if it contrasts with the government/institutional positions

Whenever something even gets near authorities and public instutitutions, we are in a whole different area. That's where actual free speech comes into play. The limit set by authorities on what you can and cannot say. The topic at hand here though is only when a privately owned company chooses to not do business with another company or person.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by tablespoon on Monday February 07, 2022 @05:47PM (#30252494)
> That’s why you’d only label the absolutely worse horseshit as “misinformation”. It’s not simply a name for the minority position whereever where there isn’t consensus.

I think there's a gray area: minority scientific position that's being hyped by a faction for political reasons (e.g. a faction that's cherry picking outlier studies for the sole reason that they support their pre-existing policy preferences).

Now some might argue that "both sides" do that, and to a degree they might be right. However, I think there's another heuristic that helps avoid paralysis due to that: if both sides aren't trying to solve the problem in good faith, pick the one that is, and reject the one that's just reacting against proposed solutions.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by ComradePhil on Monday February 07, 2022 @06:03PM (#30252722)
> That’s why you’d only label the absolutely worse horseshit as “misinformation”.

Joe Rogan is primarily being attacked for bringing in Dr. Peter McCallaugh. Name one thing that he has said that is "misinformation".

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by okl on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#30250722)
> Experts in any field disagree. Why are opinions of some experts "misinformation" and "disinformation"

Find out if/why the experts are justified to hold their respective opinion, evaluate the facts and come to a conclusion. Just because someone says something does not make it true. Regardless if that person is an expert or not.

Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by aksss on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:58PM (#30251041)
I agree with your approach if it's us as individuals making the evaluation, but if it's some centralized authority (even the private/public censorship arrangement as we have now) "clearing" allowable conversation in the public sphere, then would completely disagree. Free and open dialog is a hill to die on. One of those political principles that is, for me, more important than any 'safety' or conformity benefit claimed from censorship. I confess to being a bit gobsmacked that this is even a debate in the U.S., for as many times as it's been had and litigated in the past.
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by okl on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#30251174)
Oh sure, I don't support that. I would love to see people reward quality information instead of sentational infotainment with their "clicks" but alas that's not the world we're living in. -- What to do?
Re:Spotify’s CEO apologizes to employees over Joe Rogan cont... by aksss on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:50PM (#30250904)
Does that include governments? Or is there no objective standard -- the mis/disinformation is whatever the (local/state/federal) government is not currently supporting?

It's obviously a slippery slope approaching censorship this way.

Mis/disinformation should not be conceived of as skeptical questioning that may lead to dumb people making bad choices. That's a level of second-guessing and faux-benign concern that cannot guide policies of censorship. Skeptical questioning, dialog, and debate is more beneficial for society than it is dangerous to dumb people (who are high-risk even without overhearing the speculative conversations of others). There is some level of acceptable risk, whether it's vehicular traffic, or allowing people to speak their mind.

Think about the societal product of ten years living where skepticism of government is effectively outlawed vs a government routinely subjected to open skepticism. I think the latter is a stronger society.